So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
...
The issue is not the concept of asking a woman on a date when the two of you are alone, it's propositioning someone with no prior contact when they are in an enclosed space with no exit.....
No exit? What, because you have to push a button to open the door?
 
@Ivor

Buried somewhere in this thread, I described a situation where I don't think anyone would complain about someone using an approach in an elevator. It goes a little something like this:

- Guy spots / hears girl he is interested to know better, while at a convention.
- Guy is a bit shy, but takes the time to say 'hello' and introduce himself in a 'typical' setting. Like in a bar. Or when the speaker is doing a meet & greet after her stage time.
- Guy isn't really a conversationalist, but in the context of a convention setting, he remains engaged in the conversation with this woman by hanging out as part of a larger group where she is 'holding court'.
- Later on, when the woman retires, he reintroduces himself, offering perhaps a business card, and suggests a meeting at a later time. Suggest at first a casual first meeting - coffee (at a coffee shop), or lunch.

If that happened to occur in an elevator, without any pretence of a sexual come-on, or with physical intimidation (such as standing in someone's personal space, or leering / failing to make eye contact) - then I doubt very much someone could feel 'creeped out' by it.

So if I were in your shoes, don't be a victim about all this - just realize that you may want to examine your strategy so you don't end up making the same errors EG did.

No big deal.

Great advice. Nothing about this scenario would freak me out at all. Even in an elevator. Bonus: During the larger conversation, I would work in the fact that I am married. This would save anyone who might be interested from being shot down.
 
I assume there's some amount of sarcasm in that, but do people really have this much trouble getting laid?

Yes. I've got friends of both sexes who are awesome - smart, funny, and well within the cute range who have had dry spells lasting for years. If I were to post a brief biography & pictures of them, nobody would believe me.
 
I thought I was pretty clear, but perhaps I should spell it out. You are exaggerating.

If someone was trying ruin your clothes by marking them with a permanent marker and you were doing your best to avoid them, rank the following areas in order from easiest setting to elude the ruining blemish to hardest:

1) a hallway
2) the playing field of Yankee Stadium
3) the inside of a sarcophagus
4) an elevator

Is your point that when the doors open there's a way out? That certainly changes everything, why, I'm sure any potential threat would gladly stand out of the way, let you hit the button, and kindly wait for the elevator to stop at a floor, let the doors open, then move away from the small exit to let you get away. They would then say, "time in," as they chased their target down the hallway.

No, it's an environment that doesn't restrict movement at all.
 
Last edited:
Yes. I've got friends of both sexes who are awesome - smart, funny, and well within the cute range who have had dry spells lasting for years. If I were to post a brief biography & pictures of them, nobody would believe me.
If only, if only there were some way to communicate our desires to each other in a direct manner, perhaps by modulating air pressure or something.

:D
 
Claim, what claim ?



No problem:



That was sadhatter's question. How can you tell if you don't ask ? You said "body language", and this is what I was responding to. The rest is irrelevant to the question.

Way to cut out the second part of my statement, you know, the part where I said TALK before the propsition. Hey, if that's how you need to justify it, that's fine.

I will put it in simpler terms. When you interact with people (as in carry out a conversation) each party puts out signals, while they are talking. You do not need mind reading skills to pick up on, yawning, lack of eye contact, little if any feedback, as being uninterested. The opposite is also true. If someone is making eye contact, facing their body towards you, making an attempt to keep the conversation going, they appear interested in the conversation, you are getting somewhere. That's called body language. If you find yourself in a situation where there is no option for that conversation, feel free to jump past all the formalities and go right to the, "come to my room," request, but there is a chance that the individual you are addressing is not going to receive it well.
 
If someone was trying ruin your clothes by marking them with a permanent marker and you were doing your best to avoid them, rank the following areas in order from easiest setting to elude the ruining blemish to hardest:

1) a hallway
2) the playing field of Yankee Stadium
3) the inside of a sarcophagus
4) an elevator

Is your point that when the doors open there's a way out? That certainly changes everything, why, I'm sure any potential threat would gladly stand out of the way, let you hit the button, and kindly wait for the elevator to stop at a floor, let the doors open, then move away from the small exit to let you get away. They would then say, "time in," as they chased their target down the hallway.

No, it's an environment that doesn't restrict movement at all.

Indeed. On this I agree with you. There isn't a sure, quick exit from a moving elevator.
 
Way to cut out the second part of my statement, you know, the part where I said TALK before the propsition. Hey, if that's how you need to justify it, that's fine.

The reason why I cut it is because, as I've already said, it's irrelevant to the question asked by Starthinker.

I will put it in simpler terms. When you interact with people (as in carry out a conversation) each party puts out signals, while they are talking.

The signals can be misleading, misinterpreted or flat-out invented. Better ask.
 
Great advice. Nothing about this scenario would freak me out at all. Even in an elevator.

So what this ridiculously enormous thread is really about is differences between idiosyncratic feelings of creepiness at being in the situation described by Ms. Watson.

I'm sure there are people who would be freaked out by any approach in an elevator. Shouldn't we accommodate them by simply condemning all interaction between men and women in elevators and similarly confined spaces, just in case?

Bonus: During the larger conversation, I would work in the fact that I am married. This would save anyone who might be interested from being shot down.

Why? Plenty of married people have extra-marital sex while alone at conferences.
 
Last edited:
There is a demand here that she be treated as the spokeswoman for all women in general.

Hope she's not holding here breath over that...:)

Told my Wife about this whole "mess"...she can't understand what the fuss is all about...to quote her, "but nothing happened", which are my sentiments exactly.

Guess that's why we've been married "almost" 36 years...we tend to agree on most everything.
 
So what this ridiculously enormous thread is really about is differences between idiosyncratic feelings of creepiness at being in the situation described by Ms. Watson.

I'm sure there are people who would be freaked out by any approach in an elevator. Shouldn't we accommodate them by simply condemning all interaction between men and women in elevators and similarly confined spaces, just in case?



Why? Plenty of married people have extra-marital sex while alone at conferences.

Yes, they do. And they tend to say "I'm married but..." (We have an understanding; we're happily non-monogamous; we're in a bit of a rough patch; or what have you.) People who are happy in a monogamous marriage tend to say "I'm married and..." (it's been 20 years!; They're my best friend; I wish they could be here; or what have you.)
 
Last edited:
The reason why I cut it is because, as I've already said, it's irrelevant to the question asked by Starthinker.



The signals can be misleading, misinterpreted or flat-out invented. Better ask.

*minor nitpick - you quoted me from Sadhatter, not Starthinker

To cut it out because of it's relevance is one thing, fine, call me out on that. However, to cut it out and then accuse me of not saying it:
You talked about body language, without actual conversation. Boy, you are all over the place, now.
is flat out dishonest. If you want to talk relevance, though, that's fine.
 
Last edited:
So what this ridiculously enormous thread is really about is differences between idiosyncratic feelings of creepiness at being in the situation described by Ms. Watson.

Not really idiosyncratic.

I'm sure there are people who would be freaked out by any approach in an elevator. Shouldn't we accommodate them by simply condemning all interaction between men and women in elevators and similarly confined spaces, just in case?

How about we just condemn cold propositions with no prior contact when a woman is alone in an elevator?

Obviously accomodating everyone's unique perspective on a situation can sometimes be impossible. For example, we cannot accomodate the Islamic rules concerning women's attire and behavior with those women's individual rights. There's a conflict, we have to make a decision.

There is no such conflict, here. The cost of listening to women and respecting their perception of the world is that we lose the ability to rush into an elevator and ask them back to our rooms when we've never communicated before. If that concession is considered burdensome...I just really don't know what to say at that point.

I don't know anyone nor have I ever heard of anyone who would be unable to have sex without the ability to corner women in elevators, "Yeah, I was getting laid all the time until goddamn Rebecca Watson made up this new rule about elevators..."
 
I don't know anyone nor have I ever heard of anyone who would be unable to have sex without the ability to corner women in elevators, "Yeah, I was getting laid all the time until goddamn Rebecca Watson made up this new rule about elevators..."

Rebecca doesn't make the rules.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom