So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Simper, what does that have to do with the stranger who talked to her in the elevator ?

Oh I thought the stranger was Dawkins? Ive got things completely and embarrassingly wrong if that was not the case.
 
Last edited:
Is this still going on? I'll bet RW is having multiple orgasms just from knowing we are talking about her for this long.
 
Perhaps what I was talking about has been lost in all the misunderstandings and misrepresentations, but I wasn't talking about EG at all. I'm talking about general judgments and how there are bad names for both incompetent and competent men, so being or becoming competent does not mean that people aren't going to hate you. This is analogous to a similar behavior toward women.

I am sorry if I keep misunderstanding you. I am not trying to be dishonest about your argument. I think I just see a particular opinion and want to confront it, then, after so long, I start seeing statement that, at best, might remotely resemble the opinion I disagree with, only if I stretch reality, and I end up treating it as though it's what you clearly stated. Before I know it, I am arguing but not entirely sure why. With that said, I don't disagree with anything you stated above.

I don't have a problem with that, and that's my view is well. I have been mostly sympathetic with Watson, but I am getting less so. However, this bruhaha has gone way beyond the initial event and Watson herself, and that indicates to me that it has touched off a huge number of issues that need to be talked about. It's as if the initial incident was a spark, but it touched of a powderkeg. Now the powderkeg matters.

I can understand no longer following her POV, if she's said something after the fact that just doesn't sit well, with you. To be honest, I have kept my focus on the original incident, the initial replies, and her Priviledge blog. I stopped following after that, mainly because I feel it's the original event that deserves attention. At this point, it seems like it's all purely emotional responses and personal attacks. Regardless, I don't feel that it changes anything about the original set of circumstances. That's a general statement, not accusing you, personally of doing such.

Apart from the very specific (that Watson, upon being approached by someone she reported to have said a certain thing in an elevator at 4 AM in a "foreign country", felt "sexualized" and therefore uncomfortable), everything else said requires some degree of generalization. These may indicate issues, and they may need to be addressed.

Again, I agree.
 
You talked about body language, without actual conversation. Boy, you are all over the place, now.

You made that claim, now it's on you to support it. What you originally quoted me saying was this...

Um, body language? That's why talk before the proposition can help avoid sounding creepy.

If you need to twist what I've said, that's your deal but my main point has been opening up with "...come back to my room." Go ahead, read back. I'll wait...
 
Please don't objectify / sexualize women by implying one of them may be multiply-orgasmic. Sexist pig.

I don't think that's an objectifying statement. I think an objectifying statement would be more like "RW helps me achieve multiple orgasms when I tape a picture of her to the back of a prostitute's head."
 
If anyone else is seeking to sexualise Rebecca you might find a tip or two here.

I can tell you from experience that the contents of a "horny skepchick" include at least four whiskeys.

Ah, but if it's the drink you're talking about, I recommend this:

The Horny Skepchick
3/4 oz Creme de Cacao
3/4 oz Godiva liqueur
3/4 oz Kahlua
1/2 oz Butterscotch schnapps
Milk to fill

Of course, you'll need to blend it. I recommend using some tool which will mix the ingredients using a strong vibration. I might have a few lying about, let me grab one . . .
Note: Whiskey is Irish so try taking her to Dublin.......
 
You made that claim, now it's on you to support it.

Claim, what claim ?

If you need to twist what I've said, that's your deal but my main point has been opening up with "...come back to my room." Go ahead, read back. I'll wait...

No problem:

How would you know if both parties were not willing, if you didn't ask?

That was sadhatter's question. How can you tell if you don't ask ? You said "body language", and this is what I was responding to. The rest is irrelevant to the question.
 
<snip>

How can you tell if you don't ask ?

<snip>

Easy. The new social expectation should be for women to clearly and explicitly proposition men for sex.

Up to that point men, particularly those who are shy, socially awkward and not much to look at, should treat all women they encounter as though they are totally disinterested in having sex (or any other personal interaction) with them, which far more often than not is the case anyway.
 
Easy. The new social expectation should be for women to clearly and explicitly proposition men for sex.

Up to that point men, particularly those who are shy, socially awkward and not much to look at, should treat all women they encounter as though they are totally disinterested in having sex (or any other personal interaction) with them, which far more often than not is the case anyway.

I assume there's some amount of sarcasm in that, but do people really have this much trouble getting laid?
 
I assume there's some amount of sarcasm in that, but do people really have this much trouble getting laid?

Well I'm totally uninteresting to the vast majority of women, and those who do find me slightly entertaining don't want to have sex with me. I'm pretty sure if I hadn't paid a woman for sex I'd still be a virgin at the age of 33. So yes, some of us have a lot of trouble getting laid.

More to the point, what Watson clearly doesn't get is that telling shy, socially awkward men not to proposition women in quiet, private places is that these are the places such men are most likely to feel comfortable asking a woman out for a date.

So the take home message for such men is to not talk to women at all because they will be thought of as "creepy" for being in an environment where they do have enough courage to express interest in a woman.
 
@Ivor

Buried somewhere in this thread, I described a situation where I don't think anyone would complain about someone using an approach in an elevator. It goes a little something like this:

- Guy spots / hears girl he is interested to know better, while at a convention.
- Guy is a bit shy, but takes the time to say 'hello' and introduce himself in a 'typical' setting. Like in a bar. Or when the speaker is doing a meet & greet after her stage time.
- Guy isn't really a conversationalist, but in the context of a convention setting, he remains engaged in the conversation with this woman by hanging out as part of a larger group where she is 'holding court'.
- Later on, when the woman retires, he reintroduces himself, offering perhaps a business card, and suggests a meeting at a later time. Suggest at first a casual first meeting - coffee (at a coffee shop), or lunch.

If that happened to occur in an elevator, without any pretence of a sexual come-on, or with physical intimidation (such as standing in someone's personal space, or leering / failing to make eye contact) - then I doubt very much someone could feel 'creeped out' by it.

So if I were in your shoes, don't be a victim about all this - just realize that you may want to examine your strategy so you don't end up making the same errors EG did.

No big deal.
 
Well I'm totally uninteresting to the vast majority of women, and those who do find me slightly entertaining don't want to have sex with me. I'm pretty sure if I hadn't paid a woman for sex I'd still be a virgin at the age of 33. So yes, some of us have a lot of trouble getting laid.

More to the point, what Watson clearly doesn't get is that telling shy, socially awkward men not to proposition women in quiet, private places is that these are the places such men are most likely to feel comfortable asking a woman out for a date.

So the take home message for such men is to not talk to women at all because they will be thought of as "creepy" for being in an environment where they do have enough courage to express interest in a woman.

Well, clearly there's a lot of personal stuff going on here, so I will tread more lightly.

The issue is not the concept of asking a woman on a date when the two of you are alone, it's propositioning someone with no prior contact when they are in an enclosed space with no exit.

For some reason a lot of the discussion over the previous pages involving the concept of "consent" has focused on its applicability in a legal environment. This, obviously, is only relevant to issues of rape and other sexual contact.

Consent, however, should have a much broader application to interpersonal relationships. If you are unable to be alone with a woman absent means of obviating her consent to that arrangement, this should be a strong sign that the reaction to your proposition will not be a positive one.

Even within a public place, like a bar, interested people will have no difficulty finding a way to talk one on one. Talking to women is not like hunting bears, you don't need to lay a trap.

The remedy for social awkwardness and shyness is not to make the other party feel just as uncomfortable, or even worse, scare them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom