So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
True, but my point is that men and women are different and women are more vulnerable, such as in an elevator, than men are. The drunkest most sexually aggressive woman in the world poses no threat to me at 4AM in an elevator. I smile and say call me tomorrow if you feel the same way when you are sober. Drunk men on the other hand can be dangerous to women. It's a double standard, but it exists. I posted another example of a double standard just as I did with the South Park link. ...
Did you consider how many men have been robbed in elevators?
 
“Don’t take this the wrong way, but I find you very interesting, and I would like to talk more; would you like to come to my hotel room for coffee?”

That depends. Would it be safe coffee?

I can certainly see why she would feel uncomfortable and threatened. But Rebecca's reaction: "Guys, don't do that" -- suggests she was (understandably) stressed, but not that she felt like she was going to be raped or assaulted. If she did she wouldn't have advised men in the audience in general to "not do that".
 
What Rebecca Watson said in the first place (she may have changed her mind later; I find hard to keep track) was quite simple and moderated and reasonable (if possibly futile). She said nothing about being afraid, nothing about fearing violence, nothing about being worried if she turned him down (which she did), and nothing even about being "objectified." She just said that she felt uncomfortable about being "sexualized." The rest (which is most of what is being discussed) consists of projections onto her.

She shoudnt have gone public. Dawkins made an advance, she refused, end of story. If Dawkins didnt react in the way he did I would be completely on his side.
 
It boggles my mind how many men don't understand why being propositioned by a strange man at 4am in a hotel elevator might make a woman feel uncomfortable.

I'd have been thinking "hell, am I in danger?" and putting my keys between my fingers just in case. The guy's a stranger - I don't know what his intentions are. I'm 5' and chances are he could overpower me if he wanted to. I'd be stupid not to be wary.

EDIT: I wouldn't feel that way if propositioned in a crowded bar. Again, it boggles my mind how anyone can struggle to grasp the difference between 'approached while alone in an elevator in the middle of the night' and 'approached in a crowded bar'.
 
Last edited:
I'd have been thinking "hell, am I in danger?" and putting my keys between my fingers just in case. The guy's a stranger - I don't know what his intentions are.

If he just propositioned you, I would think you'd have a fairly good idea of what his intentions were.
 
It boggles my mind how many men don't understand why being propositioned by a strange man at 4am in a hotel elevator might make a woman feel uncomfortable.

I'd have been thinking "hell, am I in danger?" and putting my keys between my fingers just in case. The guy's a stranger - I don't know what his intentions are. I'm 5' and chances are he could overpower me if he wanted to. I'd be stupid not to be wary.

EDIT: I wouldn't feel that way if propositioned in a crowded bar. Again, it boggles my mind how anyone can struggle to grasp the difference between 'approached while alone in an elevator in the middle of the night' and 'approached in a crowded bar'.

Watson had just appeared on a discussion panel in which she told Dawkins that his voice was her ringtone. I dont think she can regard him as a stranger even if his actions were misguided.
 
Last edited:
But Rebecca never claimed or implied that it was supposed to be an example of what 'women' complain about...

I see a lot of 'me' and 'I' in there; nothing claiming or implying that any of it applies to women in general. Richard Dawkins was the first one to make it about women's rights by comparing her personal experience to the plight of other women. He essentially built a strawman and proceeded to make a bad argument against it.

That is not relevant. Richard Dawkins wasn't responding to her video. Richard was responding to PZ Myers' blog, which had already made it about women and men generally, and he was responding to the comment war which was already well under way (his is response #75).

Linda
 
It boggles my mind how many men don't understand why being propositioned by a strange man at 4am in a hotel elevator might make a woman feel uncomfortable.


Nobody's saying, to my knowledge, that it can't make a woman uncomfortable. All I've read is:

1) You can't expect people to not talk to you based on their ignorance of whether or not you want to talk to them.

2) Labeling this guy as mysoginistic or anti-woman based on the available evidence is ridiculous.

3) Dawkins' comments on the matter were insensitive.

4) Rebecca is basking in the controversy and liking it.
 
IMHO, Checkmite is correct if we take into account context and connotation. FLS is correct if we don't take into account context and connotation, and only regard what happened literally and as if it had occurred at noon in a wide open space just a few feet away from many people.

I agree that the connotations are different in our two scenarios, but it isn't that mine is context-free and her/his isn't. The two differ in context. And that difference illustrates the differences in the claims which are being made.

Rebecca's incident has been taken up as an example of clear, if mild, objectification and misogyny. Richard is saying, wait a minute, is this even a mild example of objectification and misogyny? I (and others) asked the same thing. What about this incident makes it sexualization/objectification vs. sexual attraction? And what about this incident reflects hatred towards women?

If Checkmite's examples were actually analogous, there wouldn't have been a storm. Those were all cases of definite concern which people on the same side of an issue wouldn't argue about. Since when do gay rights advocates exclude visiting your partner in a hospital from normal spousal rights, or science advocates include Christian stories in their classes, or those fighting racism embrace derogatory name-calling?

No. It's a storm in a teacup because we have reached the limits of what it means for something to be "sexism" and what it means for something to be "annoying and happens to take place in a setting with sexual overtones", just like the examples I gave were at the limits of discrimination on the basis of intolerance. And nobody in the "definite sexism" camp is really explaining where those limits lie (admittedly, I haven't plowed through the comments on the various blog posts to see if someone has). Instead, they alter it into a definite example of sexism and misogyny by making this about the fear of rape (OH NOES!!! HOW CAN YOU FAIL TO SEE HOW SCARY THIS IS???!!!).

Regardless of whether one believes that or not, and regardless of what one believes actually happened in the RW/EG case -- this blogwar has obviously resonated with many people. At this point, many people have shown support for the idea that people shouldn't have to deal with being propositioned for casual sex by strangers completely out of the blue when they've done absolutely nothing to show that they wanted it.

But there are lots of incidents that I'd rather not have to deal with. I shouldn't have to deal with door-to-door salespeople or telemarketers, I shouldn't have to be accosted by the religious proselytizer on the street corner, I shouldn't have to be assailed by strong perfumes in a movie theatre, I shouldn't have someone chew gum in my ear. It's not sexism and misogyny just because, in this case, the "shouldn't have to deal with" involves a man and a women.

Linda
 
Last edited:
By the way, perhaps I could offer a little advice of my own for the EG's of the world. I'm still of the opinion that he was intentionally trolling; but let's assume for the moment he wasn't. Here's where he made the crucial mistake:

"Don't take this the wrong way, but..."

FREEZE! I call this a preemptive conversational disclaimer and it comes in many forms:

"All due respect, but..."

"I'm not saying I don't trust you, but..."

"I'm not a racist, but..."

Okay, everyone: if you're going to say something, and you find yourself about to start off with a phrase like one of these, STOP, CLOSE YOUR TEETH, AND THINK OF SOMETHING ELSE TO SAY. If you are cognizant of the fact that you're about to say something that is so likely to look bad that you feel compelled to disclaim it before you even actually say it, pick a different line. Everybody knows that when somebody starts a conversation with "all due respect", you're about to be insulted in some way. Everybody knows that when somebody starts off with "not that I don't trust you, but...", they're about demonstrate vividly that they do not, in fact, trust you at all; and when was the last time you saw someone who wasn't a flaming racist begin a sentence with "I'm not a racist, but..."? Be honest.

"Don't take this the wrong way" is the same thing. When you say that, you key your audience into the fact that you're about to say something that might be taken offensively, and their minds will be fixated on finding that meaning first and foremost, with the side effect of making that interpretation the most unavoidably obvious interpretation...and if it is offensive enough to their sensibilities, their first response is going to be to get angry, not to look for a possible unoffensive interpretation. What this says to them is, "I'm about to offend you, I know I'm about to offend you, and I want to be able to weasel out of accountability for what I'm about to say". Whether that's your intention or not, that's what they will hear.

Just throwing that out there for you all.



I disagree entirely.

It don't think 'don't take this the wrong way' is anything close to 'I'm not racists, but...'


Don't take this the wrong way can actually mean "I'm about to say something that has two possible connotations, I would like you to consider which one I mean before flying off the handle."


Basically, 'Don't take this the wrong way' can mean exactly what it says. It's occasionally a useful phrase when the speaker realises that what they're about to say may be taken in one of two ways.
 
I disagree entirely.

It don't think 'don't take this the wrong way' is anything close to 'I'm not racists, but...'


Don't take this the wrong way can actually mean "I'm about to say something that has two possible connotations, I would like you to consider which one I mean before flying off the handle."


Basically, 'Don't take this the wrong way' can mean exactly what it says. It's occasionally a useful phrase when the speaker realises that what they're about to say may be taken in one of two ways.

I'm certain everyone who uses the phrase is thinking exactly that. But you have missed both of the points of my post, which are

1. It almost never works as intended in practical application (QED the current discussion), and

2. If you're aware that you're going to say something that can be taken the wrong way, then you have an opportunity to rephrase it such that it can't, and it is strongly suggested that you do so.
 
I'm certain everyone who uses the phrase is thinking exactly that. But you have missed both of the points of my post, which are

1. It almost never works as intended in practical application (QED the current discussion), and

2. If you're aware that you're going to say something that can be taken the wrong way, then you have an opportunity to rephrase it such that it can't, and it is strongly suggested that you do so.



I'll agree with 1.


I think in the case of 2. it can genuinely mean 'I have no other way I can think of to put this, so I'll put it like this...'


I suspect that my interpretation is more accurate between friends ('Don't take this the wrong way, but I really doni't think you should wear that outfit to this event')

I only bring it up because I really don't think it's as bad as the others you mention at all. I actually think it has a non slimy use. Unlike 'I'm not a racist, but...' which is just plain slimy.

Sorry for the derail.
 
It's quite simple guys:

1) Shape your behaviour by rounding the proportion of women you know don't want to have sex with you up from 99.5% to 100%.

2a) Wait for women to explicitly ask to have sex with you.

2b) If forever is too long, pay a prostitute when you want (and can afford) to have sex.

3) Find an intellectually absorbing hobby.
 
I disagree entirely.

It don't think 'don't take this the wrong way' is anything close to 'I'm not racists, but...'


Don't take this the wrong way can actually mean "I'm about to say something that has two possible connotations, I would like you to consider which one I mean before flying off the handle."


Basically, 'Don't take this the wrong way' can mean exactly what it says. It's occasionally a useful phrase when the speaker realises that what they're about to say may be taken in one of two ways.

I have a female friend who's an amateur naturalist. She phoned me up and said "Don't take this the wrong way, but do you fancy going out and doing some beaver photography?"

Turns out she really didn't want me to take it the wrong way. :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom