So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
It wasn't that big of a deal, this is a big deal. [This version accepts RD was using an example to show how minor the EG event was and saying RW was making a mountain out of a molehill.]

I would say the dramatic and inflammatory language Dawkins' used in his initial reply to Watson's video, considering the casual and passing manner in which she relayed the episode, kind of cancels out his credibility if his complaint was that Watson was exaggerating the importance of some minor thing. Who was the one in fact making a mountain out of the molehill?
 
I would say the dramatic and inflammatory language Dawkins' used in his initial reply to Watson's video, considering the casual and passing manner in which she relayed the episode, kind of cancels out his credibility if his complaint was that Watson was exaggerating the importance of some minor thing. Who was the one in fact making a mountain out of the molehill?

I don't see it that way at all.

RD was replying to PZs blog..

Anywhoot.. PZ has a new one up today. I think he did a better job of filling in the blanks this time around. Will see if Phil follows the trend :)
 
I'm pretty sure Richard was drawn into the debate not because of the gravity of the commentary, but the fact that the blog frenzy was well underway. There had been hundreds of responses on Skepchick & Pharyngula before he decided to chime in. Speculation on my part of course, but the rhetoric and crazy comments were already in full swing before Richard got involved. They just switched course, away from the 'Rebecca was wrong to call out the student' or 'Rebecca was fully entitled to call out the student' to 'OMG Richard said something mean!'
 
By the way, perhaps I could offer a little advice of my own for the EG's of the world. I'm still of the opinion that he was intentionally trolling; but let's assume for the moment he wasn't. Here's where he made the crucial mistake:

"Don't take this the wrong way, but..."

FREEZE! I call this a preemptive conversational disclaimer and it comes in many forms:

"All due respect, but..."

"I'm not saying I don't trust you, but..."

"I'm not a racist, but..."

Okay, everyone: if you're going to say something, and you find yourself about to start off with a phrase like one of these, STOP, CLOSE YOUR TEETH, AND THINK OF SOMETHING ELSE TO SAY. If you are cognizant of the fact that you're about to say something that is so likely to look bad that you feel compelled to disclaim it before you even actually say it, pick a different line. Everybody knows that when somebody starts a conversation with "all due respect", you're about to be insulted in some way. Everybody knows that when somebody starts off with "not that I don't trust you, but...", they're about demonstrate vividly that they do not, in fact, trust you at all; and when was the last time you saw someone who wasn't a flaming racist begin a sentence with "I'm not a racist, but..."? Be honest.

"Don't take this the wrong way" is the same thing. When you say that, you key your audience into the fact that you're about to say something that might be taken offensively, and their minds will be fixated on finding that meaning first and foremost, with the side effect of making that interpretation the most unavoidably obvious interpretation...and if it is offensive enough to their sensibilities, their first response is going to be to get angry, not to look for a possible unoffensive interpretation. What this says to them is, "I'm about to offend you, I know I'm about to offend you, and I want to be able to weasel out of accountability for what I'm about to say". Whether that's your intention or not, that's what they will hear.

Just throwing that out there for you all.
 
I don't see it that way at all.

RD was replying to PZs blog..

Anywhoot.. PZ has a new one up today. I think he did a better job of filling in the blanks this time around. Will see if Phil follows the trend :)

How nice that PZ has decided its time to calm the **** down about this, considering he is definitely accountable for a lot of the hype. At least he had the decency to include one sentence to chill the hell out about RD. He could've stopped writing after this:

Let's stop the shouting that Richard Dawkins is some kind of raving misogynist. What's happened here is that he is at some remove from all of the details, and this issue got blown up by lunatics who felt their manhood threatened and who exaggerated the situation to an absurd degree. I think he is wrong, but what he was arguing against was a cartoon of feminism which far too many people have been peddling on the blogs.
 
Last edited:
By the way, perhaps I could offer a little advice of my own for the EG's of the world. I'm still of the opinion that he was intentionally trolling; but let's assume for the moment he wasn't. Here's where he made the crucial mistake:

"Don't take this the wrong way, but..."

FREEZE! I call this a preemptive conversational disclaimer and it comes in many forms:

"All due respect, but..."

"I'm not saying I don't trust you, but..."

"I'm not a racist, but..."

Okay, everyone: if you're going to say something, and you find yourself about to start off with a phrase like one of these, STOP, CLOSE YOUR TEETH, AND THINK OF SOMETHING ELSE TO SAY. If you are cognizant of the fact that you're about to say something that is so likely to look bad that you feel compelled to disclaim it before you even actually say it, pick a different line. Everybody knows that when somebody starts a conversation with "all due respect", you're about to be insulted in some way. Everybody knows that when somebody starts off with "not that I don't trust you, but...", they're about demonstrate vividly that they do not, in fact, trust you at all; and when was the last time you saw someone who wasn't a flaming racist begin a sentence with "I'm not a racist, but..."? Be honest.

"Don't take this the wrong way" is the same thing. When you say that, you key your audience into the fact that you're about to say something that might be taken offensively, and their minds will be fixated on finding that meaning first and foremost, with the side effect of making that interpretation the most unavoidably obvious interpretation...and if it is offensive enough to their sensibilities, their first response is going to be to get angry, not to look for a possible unoffensive interpretation. What this says to them is, "I'm about to offend you, I know I'm about to offend you, and I want to be able to weasel out of accountability for what I'm about to say". Whether that's your intention or not, that's what they will hear.

Just throwing that out there for you all.

I'm not going to tell you how to conduct yourself, but... ;)
 
I would say the dramatic and inflammatory language Dawkins' used in his initial reply to Watson's video, considering the casual and passing manner in which she relayed the episode, kind of cancels out his credibility if his complaint was that Watson was exaggerating the importance of some minor thing. Who was the one in fact making a mountain out of the molehill?

Because Dawkins was saying that the RESPONSE TO THE VIDEO, with everyone screaming, "OMG, POTENTIAL RAPE" was the overreaction. PZ Myers writing on the issue was an overreaction. Phil Plait writing on the issue was an overreaction. The fact that this was ever anything OTHER THAN THE WORDS REBECCA HERSELF SAID IN THE VIDEO was an overreaction. And now? Well, now I can't side with Rebecca at all because she is BASKING in the overreaction. It is easy now to say that Rebecca was afraid, but she didn't actually say that. It is easy now to claim that Dawkins was belittling the plight of actual rape victims, but he didn't actually say that.

NO ONE SAID ANY OF THE THINGS EVERYONE IS ARGUING ABOUT.

This is a huge friggin' facepalm for everybody.
 
How nice that PZ has decided its time to calm the **** down about this, considering he is definitely accountable for a lot of the hype. At least he had the decency to include one sentence to chill the hell out about RD. He could've stopped writing after this:

yeah, actually, i do wish he would have just ended it a bit earlier, but oh well.. Its PZ
 
^^this wins.
This was a particularly tasty morsel ...

17.30 The Winners of the James Randi 1 Million Dollar Challenge will be presented their prize. The 1 million will be divided evenly between the 500 individuals on the Pharyngula and Skepchick mesageboards for their demonstration perfect psychic abilities, mind reading exactly what was going on in the head of Elevator Guy.
About time someone actually won that prize, :cool:
 
Because Dawkins was saying that the RESPONSE TO THE VIDEO, with everyone screaming, "OMG, POTENTIAL RAPE" was the overreaction. PZ Myers writing on the issue was an overreaction. Phil Plait writing on the issue was an overreaction. The fact that this was ever anything OTHER THAN THE WORDS REBECCA HERSELF SAID IN THE VIDEO was an overreaction. And now? Well, now I can't side with Rebecca at all because she is BASKING in the overreaction. It is easy now to say that Rebecca was afraid, but she didn't actually say that. It is easy now to claim that Dawkins was belittling the plight of actual rape victims, but he didn't actually say that.

NO ONE SAID ANY OF THE THINGS EVERYONE IS ARGUING ABOUT.

This is a huge friggin' facepalm for everybody.

Truth.
 
By the way, perhaps I could offer a little advice of my own for the EG's of the world. I'm still of the opinion that he was intentionally trolling; but let's assume for the moment he wasn't. Here's where he made the crucial mistake:

"Don't take this the wrong way, but..."

FREEZE! I call this a preemptive conversational disclaimer and it comes in many forms:

"All due respect, but..."

"I'm not saying I don't trust you, but..."

"I'm not a racist, but..."

Okay, everyone: if you're going to say something, and you find yourself about to start off with a phrase like one of these, STOP, CLOSE YOUR TEETH, AND THINK OF SOMETHING ELSE TO SAY. If you are cognizant of the fact that you're about to say something that is so likely to look bad that you feel compelled to disclaim it before you even actually say it, pick a different line. Everybody knows that when somebody starts a conversation with "all due respect", you're about to be insulted in some way. Everybody knows that when somebody starts off with "not that I don't trust you, but...", they're about demonstrate vividly that they do not, in fact, trust you at all; and when was the last time you saw someone who wasn't a flaming racist begin a sentence with "I'm not a racist, but..."? Be honest.

"Don't take this the wrong way" is the same thing. When you say that, you key your audience into the fact that you're about to say something that might be taken offensively, and their minds will be fixated on finding that meaning first and foremost, with the side effect of making that interpretation the most unavoidably obvious interpretation...and if it is offensive enough to their sensibilities, their first response is going to be to get angry, not to look for a possible unoffensive interpretation. What this says to them is, "I'm about to offend you, I know I'm about to offend you, and I want to be able to weasel out of accountability for what I'm about to say". Whether that's your intention or not, that's what they will hear.

Just throwing that out there for you all.


Awesomeness, with wide general application as well.
 
Holy unwarranted generalization, Batman.

Just because you, an individual, enjoyed it, that doesn't make it generally right or acceptable.

True, but my point is that men and women are different and women are more vulnerable, such as in an elevator, than men are. The drunkest most sexually aggressive woman in the world poses no threat to me at 4AM in an elevator. I smile and say call me tomorrow if you feel the same way when you are sober. Drunk men on the other hand can be dangerous to women. It's a double standard, but it exists. I posted another example of a double standard just as I did with the South Park link.

So someone who knew you well enough to know that you would like to have your ass grabbed, grabbed your ass and all was well. Then other people extended the ass-grab to a skirt flip that you enjoyed well enough to build a fetish around and all was good. It was unorthodox but everyone was having a good time. At no time did you say "Never do that again." Had you said it, even once, it would have stopped.

(ETA: I, personally, think it's a little gross and completely disrespectful to do this to a 16 year old boy. Especially if you're a 25 year old who has more worldly experience and it is a power trip. )

Then you made the ass-grab on someone. You did it to make a point, knowing that it was not welcome. They didn't like. They said "Never do that again." Nobody was having a good time.

You did not do it again but that's when you started complaining.

The difference is not can/can not grab ass, it's does/does not want ass grabbed. She grabbed your ass because she knew that you would like it. It was friendly. You grabbed her ass because you knew that she wouldn't. It was aggressive.

In this case, I don't blame you at all. A 17 year old kid who has been constantly ass-grabbed will grab back. But that doesn't mean that it was right and it doesn't make for a very comprehensive description of ass grabbing in general.

[/QUOTE]

Well, when you say it like that you take all the romance out of my serial groping story . In my defense hope springs eternal and when I grabbed her bottom I did hope she would lead me to the laundry room to take my virginity giving me a story I could top all my friends stories with.
 
Drinking at a bar is not the same context as attending a conference regardless of where you were earlier that day.
 
So a woman can wear a mini skirt and low cut top on a date expecting the man not to take it wrong without actually saying "don't take it wrong," but a man who starts with "don't take it wrong" should just shut up.
 
True, but my point is that men and women are different and women are more vulnerable, such as in an elevator, than men are. The drunkest most sexually aggressive woman in the world poses no threat to me at 4AM in an elevator. I smile and say call me tomorrow if you feel the same way when you are sober. Drunk men on the other hand can be dangerous to women. It's a double standard, but it exists. I posted another example of a double standard just as I did with the South Park link.

Well,

1) A drunk, aggressive man is going to oppose a threat no matter what he says.

2) You obviously haven't been around some of the drunk, aggressive female Rugby players I have.

3) The kind of man who gets aggressive when drunk is probably not going to pay much attention to what Rebecca Watson asks him not to do, let alone remember it while drunk.

4) (ETA) I bet that a man the size of Penn Jillette could probably whoop your butt.

What Rebecca Watson said in the first place (she may have changed her mind later; I find hard to keep track) was quite simple and moderated and reasonable (if possibly futile). She said nothing about being afraid, nothing about fearing violence, nothing about being worried if she turned him down (which she did), and nothing even about being "objectified." She just said that she felt uncomfortable about being "sexualized." The rest (which is most of what is being discussed) consists of projections onto her.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom