So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh sorry, my bad. I'm reading backwards from the end and keep getting caught in the morass. (As it would be totally rude and inappropriate to pun that final word in light of Senex' post, I am not going to do that.)

The elevator guy has been objectified. He is no longer a human being but rather a deaf, aspie, shy dork who skips the headline speaker at a atheist conference in favor of laying in wait until 4 AM to stalk woman, follow them into the elevator and refrain, just barely, from raping them.

The reason he is getting such an outpouring of sympathy and empathy from one side is because he was, after all merely looking to hook up with a woman he found attractive and there shouldn't be anything wrong with that. Hooking up, having casual sex or even just flirting with strangers is normal, natural and harmless fun that many people enjoy.

As this tired saga drags on, a new element appears - Watson is a tease! A hussy! A flirt! Here is an example from this forum:


There are many other examples across many other sites and a few have their own twist but basically they are saying that Watson has given up the right to respect and empathy because she has hooked up, had casual sex or flirted with strangers.

But if EG is getting let off the hook, if the cries for understanding are based on the idea that casual sex and flirting are healthy wonderful activities, why should Watson be penalized for having done so in the past?

Well - my point about EG throughout has been consistent that we don't really KNOW the full context about what happened. We could suspect any number of scenarios. All that we have is Rebecca's evidence, from an encounter at 0400h, where alcohol may have been a factor. I don't mean that in a disparaging sense - perhaps she is very lucid at 0400h and maybe she didn't have anything to drink.

As skeptics, we're pretty big on the 'evidence' department - usually. Not so sure about this instance.
 
Yes - fine.

So what? Richard has made an error. A hollow argument. What next? Do we take away his 'atheist' card? Make him issue some sort of apology before we'll talk to him again? I mean really - just because he's smart doesn't mean he can't make a mistake. Is it really that important to hear someone say 'mea culpa'?

This really is verging into some sort of unintellectual witch hunt.

Hey, wait a second - it was his decision to inject his own self into this debate, not mine...or even Rebecca Watson's. I'm discussing his contributions to the whole mess because they were part and parcel of the discussion when I arrived in this here already-developed thread. It's just like responding to a post made by anyone here.

I'm decidedly not a fan of Dawkins; my advice to anyone would be not to waste time asking him to apologize about anything. And I don't follow Rebecca or use her website, either, so whether she is or should demand an apology isn't none of mine. If there's some kind of turf battle going on, it's not in my posts. I'm just point-counterpointing things people say that I disagree with. If the subject happens to be something Richard Dawkins said, that's just the way the bones roll.
 
Well - my point about EG throughout has been consistent that we don't really KNOW the full context about what happened. We could suspect any number of scenarios. All that we have is Rebecca's evidence, from an encounter at 0400h, where alcohol may have been a factor. I don't mean that in a disparaging sense - perhaps she is very lucid at 0400h and maybe she didn't have anything to drink.

As skeptics, we're pretty big on the 'evidence' department - usually. Not so sure about this instance.

That's all 100% true. For my own part, I'm discussing the situation as if Watson's description of events is accurate, because no one else who was present has come forward with an alternative description. The conversation could've gone any one of a million other ways; but without a point of reference to judge which ways are more likely than others, we can call the situation "hypothetical" and use the description we have so far as an accurate transcript.
 
I think its worse than that ... it was sexual harassment of a minor. IMHO, Senex should have had the opportunity to at least get to the age of 18 years without undergoing this.

It doesn't matter that as an adult Senex decided that he liked having his ass grabbed by upper management. He had the right to mature in an environment appropriate for a minor.

Yes, you are absolutely right.

I've been trying to tone down any dramatic language. In this case, that was a mistake and a disservice to Senex.
 
Of course; but the proper criteria for judging whether a complaint is justified or not, is not "whether there are worse things that happen elsewhere in the world to the same demographic".

It is when the 'event' itself is so mundane no one would bother to ask for evidence because who could make up anything much sillier to complain about?

Just so I have this straight:

4 AM, Dublin, convention, after bar time.

Guy gets on elevator with banned poster.

He says something to the effect of 'don't take this the wrong way, but I think you're interesting, why don't you come to my room for coffee?'

She demurs, presumably the whole encounter lasted all of about 45 seconds?

I'm assuming there's still alarms in elevators in Ireland, as well as hotel staff?

So it would be a really stupid place to actually try something if the object was not to get caught, kinda trapped and everything?

This 'event' somehow makes the net viral newsreel and a grumpy old man tells her to 'get over herself' at a blog run by Professor Flaccid Package.

Rants, raves and letter-writing campaigns are started.

5 days later there's 1500 posts about it here.

It has become a 'teaching moment' for those who took the interdisciplinary liberal arts classes where these skills are learned.




What if the 'lesson' is this is a damn fool thing to get worked up about?'
 
It is when the 'event' itself is so mundane no one would bother to ask for evidence because who could make up anything much sillier to complain about?

Did this not start as an offhand comment in someone's personal video blog? The whole point of video blogs is to give people an outlet for griping about things that aren't worth an article in the local paper.
 
That's all 100% true. For my own part, I'm discussing the situation as if Watson's description of events is accurate, because no one else who was present has come forward with an alternative description. The conversation could've gone any one of a million other ways; but without a point of reference to judge which ways are more likely than others, we can call the situation "hypothetical" and use the description we have so far as an accurate transcript.

Yeah, I'm not really sure what "arguing the anecdote" accomplishes in this discussion. The whole thing started with Watson saying that most people seem to get it, but here's an example of someone who didn't, and guys, please don't do that. A lot of different arguments have been made, but I struggle to see how speculation that "it didn't really happen that way" is relevant to any of them.

If you believe that EG's behavior as described by Watson was perfectly fine, then it shouldn't matter to you if the description was inaccurate.

If you believe that EG's behavior as described by Watson was inappropriate but is an isolated incident and not worth bringing up or "making a big deal of," then again, your argument stands or falls irrespective of what really happened.

The only kind of argument to which I can imagine it making a difference is to say "EG's behavior as described by Watson was inappropriate, but nobody at a skeptical conference would behave that way." That seems a dubious proposition in light of how many people have come forward to say that they think this is perfectly acceptable behavior and that they have done it in the past and may do so in the future even if only to make a point, or a joke, or whatever.

If EG was some known person, then of course it would matter because it affects his reputation.
 
I for one don't see the RD letter as intending to say...

Rather it seems to me that he was trying to... accentuate....

...not meaning what some people have chosen to see.
He committed the same error that Elevator Creep did: failing to predict a pretty obvious and easily predictable reaction that his audience would have.

Sometimes being a good person means not only not doing/saying bad things to people, but also not giving them reason to THINK you are/will/would/might.
 
I hope Evan's pet issue gets discussed for a half hour on next week's show.

I happen to know that he is a vehement opponent of the designated hitter rule. Baseball is a game about fielding the best team of NINE! What's next? Are we going to allow basketball teams to keep a center on both sides of the court, one specializing in scoring and one for defense?

We as skeptics should recognize that and work together towards solving this important scientific issue.
 
Last edited:
FYI: The JREF has now released a "Code of Conduct" for TAM which includes the following:

"... respect your fellow attendees... by not making uninvited sexual comments..."

Spot the paradox.

I think this'll be the TAM where everyone's too afraid to come on to everyone else.

Hey, some of us wouldn't notice the difference anyway, so... :cool:
 
I understand your point. I feel, at least I have maintained that his question was ambiguous. The most I can say is that RW took it to be a sexual proposition. I have not labeled him as anything.

Perhaps what I was talking about has been lost in all the misunderstandings and misrepresentations, but I wasn't talking about EG at all. I'm talking about general judgments and how there are bad names for both incompetent and competent men, so being or becoming competent does not mean that people aren't going to hate you. This is analogous to a similar behavior toward women.

I have done my best to argue specifically from RW's perspective; She goes to a convention and tries to address a topic. Among her topic are discussing emails where she is threatened to be raped. She goes to a bar afterwards and continues to participate in a discussion. She, supposedly tells her companions that getting hit on at conventions makes her uncomfortable. She announces that she is tired and going to bed. Upon entering the elevator, she meets a man who, at least alludes to being interested in what she's saying, then proceeds to invite her to his room. She said this makes her uncomfortable, don't do that. Having absolutely nothing to do with the guy, his intentions or lack thereof, Rebecca, as an individual A) is justified in feeling a little creeped out by the situation and B) has every right to say she doesn't want that.

I don't have a problem with that, and that's my view is well. I have been mostly sympathetic with Watson, but I am getting less so. However, this bruhaha has gone way beyond the initial event and Watson herself, and that indicates to me that it has touched off a huge number of issues that need to be talked about. It's as if the initial incident was a spark, but it touched of a powderkeg. Now the powderkeg matters.

This is irrelevant if the guy was honestly asking for coffee. None of it changes the fact that his request, whether innocent or not, creeped RW out.

Apart from the very specific (that Watson, upon being approached by someone she reported to have said a certain thing in an elevator at 4 AM in a "foreign country", felt "sexualized" and therefore uncomfortable), everything else said requires some degree of generalization. These may indicate issues, and they may need to be addressed.
 
Well - my point about EG throughout has been consistent that we don't really KNOW the full context about what happened. We could suspect any number of scenarios. All that we have is Rebecca's evidence, from an encounter at 0400h, where alcohol may have been a factor. I don't mean that in a disparaging sense - perhaps she is very lucid at 0400h and maybe she didn't have anything to drink.

As skeptics, we're pretty big on the 'evidence' department - usually. Not so sure about this instance.

RW said in the SGU podcast that she was drinking. I can't recall whether she said she was tipsy, but over such a period of time, I'd bet she was. Not only may she have completely misinterpreted EG, she may well have misheard (or dare I say, imagined) him. I wish he would show up say what happened from his perspective.
 
Of course; but the proper criteria for judging whether a complaint is justified or not, is not "whether there are worse things that happen elsewhere in the world to the same demographic".

But that's not the only way to take RD's comments.

If it's not as bad as this, it isn't bad enough to complain. [This version is making a false dichotomy of RD's comments.]

OR

It wasn't that big of a deal, this is a big deal. [This version accepts RD was using an example to show how minor the EG event was and saying RW was making a mountain out of a molehill.]
 
I for one don't see the RD letter as intending to say that American women shouldn't complain about anything because there are women who have it so much worse.

Rather it seems to me that he was trying to use the horrible experiences of other women to accentuate just how petty he found the event in the elevator.

Laying it on heavy, in that obnoxious way he can do; but not meaning what some people have chosen to see.
Bingo. And I swear I wrote the above post before seeing yours.
 
Haha, I read about this on Phil Plaits blog.

He's all a-twitter about the "potential sexual assualt" that occured.

There was no assault, potential or otherwise! End of story.

That's where I read it too...Rebecca needs to get over herself, and Phil...well, I don't understand his reaction...all I can say is that I don't agree with him.
 
And that is the problem. And what irks me about fringe feminists.

" We are powerful, we are independent we can do whatever a man can do. We are woman , hear us ROAR!"

" Having to say no to someone in an elevator EEEEK what do i do, i am scared, this man is evil EEEK!"

The fringe feminist reaction to being politely asked for sex ( again, as someone who likes men and women, i have been asked in the same manner, by both sexes, and a good portion of the time, it is people i turn down. No harm no foul, and i have to say, i have had worse attempts than she is describing. ) , seems to be way too similar to the reaction of a stereotypical female circa 1950 or so to a mouse.

The irony astounds me.

I hear you, but I don't find it ironic.

The former position is an attempt to increase women's power, by getting them access to forms of power traditionally held by men.

The latter position is an attempt to maintain women's power, by keeping their access to forms of power traditionally held by men.

Trying to do both, of course, is contradictory to most people and has harmed feminism (such as with the self-destruction of the inaccurately numbered "second wave feminism" some time during the 1990s and a few years when young women avoided feminism like the plague). However, feminists don't usually seem to find a contradiction.

Very few feminists adhere closely to either the former or the latter. Examples are Betty Friedan (former) and Mary Daly (latter). Of course, Friedan was known as an Uncle Tom in feminism precisely for those reasons, and even Daly was a bit kooky for most feminists. Most feminists are somewhat in the middle and swap off in an ad hoc manner.

There are, of course, many women who adhere to the former (whom you'll find in progressive and humanist circles) and many who adhere to the latter (whom you'll find in conservative religious circles). Neither has a tendency to adopt the label "feminist."
 
[some people believe] he committed the same error that [some people believe] elevator [guy] creep did: Failing to predict a pretty obvious and easily predictable reaction [according to some people's views] that his audience would have.

Sometimes being a good person means not only not doing/saying bad things to people, but also not giving them reason to think you are/will/would/might.
ftfy
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom