Its a shame when someone you admire & respect reveals himself to have some controversial ideas. Don't get me wrong - I like RD, read his books, watch his stuff. But he's just showing he's human.
At least he hasn't been caught Emailing sexy photos of himself or anything truly apology-worthy.
FWIW, I don't know enough about RD to have an opinion of him as a whole. I do have some opinions on some aspects of him. I've read some of what he has to say about evolution; the mechanics of how vision and sonar work; and his book,
The God Delusion.
If someone were to ask me to recommend an author for the first two items, I would recommend RD hands down.
If someone were to ask me to recommend a author for the topics of atheism, agnosticism, and monotheism, I would recommend RD with reservations. He often writes logically and thoughtfully in those areas, but at other times his arrogance shows. Arrogance isn't rational and sometimes his rebuttal only amounts to: I think that argument is stupid, therefore it is stupid. Not impressive. (FWIW, in the interest of full disclosure, I'm agnostic. )
Since I had already thought his arrogance sometimes defeats his ability to reason -- his "Muslima" comment didn't surprise me.
And I'd rather know what someone really thinks than read a false apology.
FWIW, if RD were to get "caught" e-mailing sexy photos of himself, I couldn't care less (unless of course it was to a minor or it could reasonably be construed as sexual harassment of someone who had made it clear that they didn't want those kind of attentions from him). I might feel differently if he had the kind of responsibilities where the ability to be discreet was of national importance, e.g., if he were a politician or spy.
Someone in one of these threads said that the underlying theme in elevatorgate is respect.
The matter of sex isn't viewed uniformly by many people, and obviously many people do have strong personal feelings about it. That being the case, it's a matter of respect to take a few moments out to determine if someone, including a stranger, is interested in having casual sex with oneself. It's a matter of respect to not to be so dismissive of someone's opinion and dismiss them with sarcasm, especially publicly.
The issue of respect is important to me. So sure, I'd rather have RD on my side of the line in this discussion about what I think ultimately is about the topic of respect. But I'm not interested in having anyone say something just because they think I want to hear it.
Also, FWIW, I know that we don't agree entirely about some of these issues -- I think our posts make it clear that I'm more conservative in some areas than you are. However, I think we're on the same page when it comes to respect, and I believe that's whats really important.