So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Since there has been some confusion/speculation/discussion about the degree of interaction EG may or may not have had with RW prior to the elevator, I'm bringing over a comment by Rebecca Watson from her Skepchick post*:

Of course, I'm sure someone will still manage to spin this into RW "leading him on" in some way.

*-- I don't know how (or if it's possible) to direct link to the specific comment on that thread; you'll have to scroll down a lot to find it

Except that we watched the video of her talk and it wasn't about "I do not want to be hit on". It would be useful if there was someone who could give us a less conflicted account of what message anyone in the crowd was likely to have heard.

However, if he did hear that message, it would make sense for him to say (and mean) "don't take this the wrong way" in order to indicate that he wasn't hitting on her.

Linda
 
My bolding.

I believe this is a non-sequitur.

Obviously "reasonable" is subjective, but I do not think it follows that because she found his proposal off putting, it is reasonable to think (based solely on this) that he is one that feels she should be raped. It maybe reasonable to think he isn't remarkably polished, but nothing here suggests he wished her harm.

If you accept this premise, then it is apparent that he would have been just as "threatening" as if he had said nothing.

He could have been silent and threatening but in this story he actually approached her and propositioned her, in the elevator. Saying that any other situation could have been threatening is distracting from the situation that we are actually addressing.
 
BS. You can't just look at someone and tell. You just don't want to have to say it.

This reminds me of our supervisor, who thinks we should guess how he wants projects to be develloped, without having to tell us. And it's not hyperbole. He actually told me so.

What part of "That's why talk before the proposition can help avoid sounding creepy...." did you mistake for playing a game of guess what's on my mind?
 
Its a shame when someone you admire & respect reveals himself to have some controversial ideas. Don't get me wrong - I like RD, read his books, watch his stuff. But he's just showing he's human.

At least he hasn't been caught Emailing sexy photos of himself or anything truly apology-worthy.

FWIW, I don't know enough about RD to have an opinion of him as a whole. I do have some opinions on some aspects of him. I've read some of what he has to say about evolution; the mechanics of how vision and sonar work; and his book, The God Delusion.

If someone were to ask me to recommend an author for the first two items, I would recommend RD hands down.

If someone were to ask me to recommend a author for the topics of atheism, agnosticism, and monotheism, I would recommend RD with reservations. He often writes logically and thoughtfully in those areas, but at other times his arrogance shows. Arrogance isn't rational and sometimes his rebuttal only amounts to: I think that argument is stupid, therefore it is stupid. Not impressive. (FWIW, in the interest of full disclosure, I'm agnostic. )

Since I had already thought his arrogance sometimes defeats his ability to reason -- his "Muslima" comment didn't surprise me.

And I'd rather know what someone really thinks than read a false apology.

FWIW, if RD were to get "caught" e-mailing sexy photos of himself, I couldn't care less (unless of course it was to a minor or it could reasonably be construed as sexual harassment of someone who had made it clear that they didn't want those kind of attentions from him). I might feel differently if he had the kind of responsibilities where the ability to be discreet was of national importance, e.g., if he were a politician or spy.

Someone in one of these threads said that the underlying theme in elevatorgate is respect.

The matter of sex isn't viewed uniformly by many people, and obviously many people do have strong personal feelings about it. That being the case, it's a matter of respect to take a few moments out to determine if someone, including a stranger, is interested in having casual sex with oneself. It's a matter of respect to not to be so dismissive of someone's opinion and dismiss them with sarcasm, especially publicly.

The issue of respect is important to me. So sure, I'd rather have RD on my side of the line in this discussion about what I think ultimately is about the topic of respect. But I'm not interested in having anyone say something just because they think I want to hear it.

Also, FWIW, I know that we don't agree entirely about some of these issues -- I think our posts make it clear that I'm more conservative in some areas than you are. However, I think we're on the same page when it comes to respect, and I believe that's whats really important.
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry my post didn't meet your standards. Here are some quotes from Skepchick:

Perhaps 'groped' was not the right word. Maybe I should have used 'inappropriate touching' or I could have said 'inappropriate propositions'. Forgive me. I was trying to convey a general idea of the picture I have. I think back to my experiences at sci-fi and comic books conventions when I was an attractive women in my early twenties. Groping is how I think of that general type of encounter.

Only one person of those three referred to inappropriate touching, did you notice? The other referred to being "accosted" or to a "hostile atmosphere". Even the one who did refer to inappropriate touching talked about “'accidental' breast touching" which carries milder connotations than "groping".

I hope the above quotes help. It took me about 30 minutes to find them on Skepchick.

If it takes half an hour of searching to mine three quotes, only one of which is relevant and which does not quite support the connotations of the original claim, that says to me that being groped with high frequency isn't a common problem.

If it took five minutes to find a thread saying "Oh my God, the annual skeptics convention is like that pit of hands in The Labyrinth, if I died and they dusted me for fingerprints they'd have half the JREF forum membership in prison" and twenty other women responding saying "That's an understatement, I had five hands in my underpants in the first thirty seconds and I was wearing jeans!" that would of course be different.

There were similar comments on at least one of the threads at Pharangula. There were more on at least one of the feminist blogs I read about this on. It's getting a little blurry for me and I'm not going to try and provide any more evidence for this claim. Instead I'm going to bow out of the conversation with this post. I hope it makes up for my inadequate previous one. Please forgive me.

Rather than playing the victim card you could take on board the point that your post was an (innocent) exaggeration and that such posts are not constructive.

The reason why we demand evidence or citations is to stop exactly this kind of effect where stories grow in the telling.

Really? Have you asked them and confirmed that? Could you tell us why they don't like it and choose not to associate with it?

Their complaints, as I recall, were that women were condescended to and not taken seriously, that some sexist remarks were made and that there was at least one annoying climate change denier. No one that I can refer to complained about inappropriate touching, but they all agreed that the atmosphere was not female-friendly.

I think Dawkins responds to every opinion he thinks is ridiculous, whether feminist or not. Frankly I find his style and vitriol repellent and don't read him or listen to him anymore. If PZ hadn't blogged about his comment, I would never had heard it.

I found it to be a mean-spirited attack on the idea of discussing what is a reasonable expectation for interactions with strangers in our society. I think this discussion is important and it's generated a lot of heat because it's in a very fuzzy part of what is/is not acceptable behavior in public spaces.

It seems like we're now agreeing that your original claim, that women attract ridicule and rape threats for expressing feminist ideas around skeptics, was also an inflammatory exaggeration.

I know too many women who have been raped. It really messes women up. Among other things, it makes women really skittish about being in a confined space with a man she is not certain she can trust. I mention this along with the statistics that have been quoted here: 1 in 6 women have been raped. 1 in 4 have suffered a sexual assault. That's 25% of the females in our society. Is it really so unreasonable to consider the possibility that the woman you are making the offer to might be one of that 25%? Or might, even without having had that sort of previous experience, find it creepy and unpleasant?

I think that it is worth bringing back that earlier point about black people in lifts. Should black people not talk to white people in lifts, if n% of people have been robbed or assaulted by black people? Or might, even without having had that sort of previous experience, find it creepy and unpleasant?

I think that in a civilised society there's an expectation that you treat people as individuals, not as members of a "scary" group, at least for as long as they are engaging with you entirely civilly.

I'm not going to post on this thread again. This discussion has brought up painful memories I thought I had successfully squashed decades ago. I've gotta go deal with them now. You see, I'm one of the women in that 25%.

Hang on, can I check that victim card? Hmm. Looks like everything's in order. You are absolved for posting inflammatory nonsense in an already unnecessarily controversial thread and anyone who pointed it out is now officially the bad guy. Have a nice day ma'm, and please do tell us if anyone else around here disagrees with you.
 
That's not what he was arguing though. He was arguing that this didn't seem to be even a mild example of what we complain about.

But Rebecca never claimed or implied that it was supposed to be an example of what 'women' complain about. All of you in this thread who have said something like 'it would have been fine if Rebecca was just speaking for herself instead of trying to speak on behalf of all women' need to watch her first video again and listen very carefully. From the transcript:



Um. Just a word to the wise here, guys: Uhhhh, don’t do that. Um, you know. [laughs] Uh, I don’t really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I’ll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4 am, in a hotel elevator with you, just you, and—don’t invite me back to your hotel room, right after I’ve finished talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner.



I see a lot of 'me' and 'I' in there; nothing claiming or implying that any of it applies to women in general. Richard Dawkins was the first one to make it about women's rights by comparing her personal experience to the plight of other women. He essentially built a strawman and proceeded to make a bad argument against it.
 
Last edited:
Only one person of those three referred to inappropriate touching, did you notice? The other referred to being "accosted" or to a "hostile atmosphere". Even the one who did refer to inappropriate touching talked about “'accidental' breast touching" which carries milder connotations than "groping".



If it takes half an hour of searching to mine three quotes, only one of which is relevant and which does not quite support the connotations of the original claim, that says to me that being groped with high frequency isn't a common problem.

If it took five minutes to find a thread saying "Oh my God, the annual skeptics convention is like that pit of hands in The Labyrinth, if I died and they dusted me for fingerprints they'd have half the JREF forum membership in prison" and twenty other women responding saying "That's an understatement, I had five hands in my underpants in the first thirty seconds and I was wearing jeans!" that would of course be different.



Rather than playing the victim card you could take on board the point that your post was an (innocent) exaggeration and that such posts are not constructive.

The reason why we demand evidence or citations is to stop exactly this kind of effect where stories grow in the telling.



Their complaints, as I recall, were that women were condescended to and not taken seriously, that some sexist remarks were made and that there was at least one annoying climate change denier. No one that I can refer to complained about inappropriate touching, but they all agreed that the atmosphere was not female-friendly.



It seems like we're now agreeing that your original claim, that women attract ridicule and rape threats for expressing feminist ideas around skeptics, was also an inflammatory exaggeration.



I think that it is worth bringing back that earlier point about black people in lifts. Should black people not talk to white people in lifts, if n% of people have been robbed or assaulted by black people? Or might, even without having had that sort of previous experience, find it creepy and unpleasant?

I think that in a civilised society there's an expectation that you treat people as individuals, not as members of a "scary" group, at least for as long as they are engaging with you entirely civilly.



Hang on, can I check that victim card? Hmm. Looks like everything's in order. You are absolved for posting inflammatory nonsense in an already unnecessarily controversial thread and anyone who pointed it out is now officially the bad guy. Have a nice day ma'm, and please do tell us if anyone else around here disagrees with you.


Quick question - Do the examples posted meet your criteria for what might make some women less likely to attended skeptical conferences/meet-ups/, social gatherings?

Quick statement - If someone has been raped, they are a victim of sexual assault. There is no other word for it, they are the victim. If you can't make your case without mocking someone for being raped, perhaps a rewrite is in order.
 
OK, we are looking at this question from two different perspectives. You are looking at it as a job you lost. I'm looking at it as saying if a 25 year old male had his hand on a 16 year old girl's butt who had to answer to him at work that would be considered sexual harassment and evil. I am saying the gender roles were reversed and I considered it a positive experience. When I was 16 I needed to know women found me attractive. It was all good having my ass grabbed. That is where the double standard lies.

Holy unwarranted generalization, Batman.

Just because you, an individual, enjoyed it, that doesn't make it generally right or acceptable.
 
I disagree; I think his argument wasn't just insensitive, but ridiculous on its face.

Try the same chain of logic on a couple of other issues and see how it works out:

- You shouldn't complain about boards of education trying to force science teachers to teach creationism alongside evolution, because in some countries even suggesting that evolution is possible will get you imprisoned for heresy.

- (A gay person) shouldn't complain about not being able to visit his or her partner in the hospital, because there are some places on Earth where being gay is an executable offense.

- A black person shouldn't complain about being called a name, because it wasn't so long ago that they would've been dragged out and hanged for complaining.


And so on.
Is there ever a time when that black or gay person plays their discrimination card when it is not justified? Do we assume it is justified based solely on their perception, meaning if you feel objectified (in this case) is that all the evidence we need to agree you must have been?
 
I'm a woman, and yes, what Dawkins said was insensitive, nothing more.
<snip>

I disagree; I think his argument wasn't just insensitive, but ridiculous on its face.

Try the same chain of logic on a couple of other issues and see how it works out:

- You shouldn't complain about boards of education trying to force science teachers to teach creationism alongside evolution, because in some countries even suggesting that evolution is possible will get you imprisoned for heresy.

- (A gay person) shouldn't complain about not being able to visit his or her partner in the hospital, because there are some places on Earth where being gay is an executable offense.

- A black person shouldn't complain about being called a name, because it wasn't so long ago that they would've been dragged out and hanged for complaining.


And so on.

That's not what he was arguing though. He was arguing that this didn't seem to be even a mild example of what we complain about. To make it analogous...

- science teachers shouldn't complain that their school offers a comparative religion class...

- gay people shouldn't complain that not all churches will perform a marriage ceremony for them...

- black people shouldn't complain about the name of the NAACP...

Linda

IMHO, Checkmite is correct if we take into account context and connotation. FLS is correct if we don't take into account context and connotation, and only regard what happened literally and as if it had occurred at noon in a wide open space just a few feet away from many people.

As a partially deaf person who has struggled with learning how to communicate with hearing people, I can tell you that most of the time one cannot disregard context and connotation.

I vote for Checkmite's interpretation.


--

As a postscript -- I read Kuko 4000's summary of RW's video blog and RW & RD's subsequent comments in post #1286 (great to have now that we are well past 1400 posts) and noticed that RD made a point in his "Muslima" comment of noting that RW identifies herself as a skept "chick".

I don't think that was an extraneous throw away remark -- I think that was significant point to RD. So how about it, does someone who identifies herself as a "chick" have the same right to not get unsolicitated and unwanted propositions as someone who doesn't identify herself as a "chick"?

Regardless of whether one believes that or not, and regardless of what one believes actually happened in the RW/EG case -- this blogwar has obviously resonated with many people. At this point, many people have shown support for the idea that people shouldn't have to deal with being propositioned for casual sex by strangers completely out of the blue when they've done absolutely nothing to show that they wanted it.

This reminds me of the way the public reacted to the first OJ Simpson trial. For some people, the trial was simply about whether OJ Simpson killed his ex-wife and the waiter. But for other people, based on the reactions and comments made at the time, it was about the fact that many people believed (rightly or wrongly) that a black man could not get a fair trial, even if he was wealthy. FWIW, I was not one of those people -- but at the time it made sense to me that regardless of whether the California judicial and police system believed it, it was an important issue for them to address.

So regardless whether one believes that the RW/EG case was an issue of misunderstanding, rudeness, or creepiness -- its obvious that many people believe that unwanted sexual propositions at conferences are an issue for many women. That means whether RW relayed her story accurately or not, and despite being affiliated with an organization that includes "chick" in its name and that she helped organize nude calendars in the past, this is still an issue that would be a good idea to address.
 
Last edited:
But Rebecca never claimed or implied that it was supposed to be an example of what 'women' complain about. All of you in this thread who have said something like 'it would have been fine if Rebecca was just speaking for herself instead of trying to speak on behalf of all women' need to watch her first video again and listen very carefully. From the transcript:



Um. Just a word to the wise here, guys: Uhhhh, don’t do that. Um, you know. [laughs] Uh, I don’t really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I’ll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4 am, in a hotel elevator with you, just you, and—don’t invite me back to your hotel room, right after I’ve finished talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner.
Except she was talking about at least a broad spectrum of women as her follow up blog noted, and not everyone agrees EG did "sexualize" her.
 
This thread has devolved and one topic is sexual harassment. One point I will stand by and defend is sexual harassment has a double standard. My point is I was easily arguably sexually harassed at the young age of sixteen and I clearly wasn't damaged as a result:rolleyes:

True story. I was 16 and was promoted from dishwasher to busboy at the local Howard Johnsons. The 25 year old (really hot) hostess would literally cup one of my ass cheeks every time she spoke to me. It wasn't a secret. She told all the waitresses she thought my bottom was attractive and as a result it was open season on squeezing, pinching, patting and spanking my bottom while I worked side side with the rest of the (much older) women. The truth was my ass was attractive because drunk customers on Friday and Saturday nights grabbed my ass as well. The truth was it never bothered me when older (and all women are older when you are 16) women grabbed my ass.

However some of the the MILF's I worked with saw how I might have been abused and decided to even the odds. One of them lifted the 25 year old in questions skirt while we were on a break stating she needed to check the aggressive woman's bottom out for some reason or another. The woman in question's face went red but she didn't defend herself. Subsequent to that anytime I was on a break the waitresses I worked with would raise the skirts of other waitresses, coworkers as an inside joke for my benefit because I was a sincere boy scout and teasing me was fun for them. Pantyhose, granny panties and poor visual positioning made the reality of what happened not as sexy as you might picture but the skirt lifting of my coworkers for my benefit was still well worth it and I have the fetish to prove it.

We all have strengths and weaknesses a and I have a strength that I can look in a woman's eye and decide when women don't wish to sleep with me. The 25 year old in question I knew from the first time she grabbed my ass but I felt I need to ask. When I was in my lat 17eens I grabbed her ass which I never did out of the blue. She looked at me and said "Never do that again."

I asked, "Why not, because you grab my ass always."

She said,"That's just the way it is."

I knew she would say that but I felt the need to ask. My point being there is a double standard. Most men realize women are the gatekeepers of sex. Take women out of the equation and we would be screwing in the streets.

So someone who knew you well enough to know that you would like to have your ass grabbed, grabbed your ass and all was well. Then other people extended the ass-grab to a skirt flip that you enjoyed well enough to build a fetish around and all was good. It was unorthodox but everyone was having a good time. At no time did you say "Never do that again." Had you said it, even once, it would have stopped.

(ETA: I, personally, think it's a little gross and completely disrespectful to do this to a 16 year old boy. Especially if you're a 25 year old who has more worldly experience and it is a power trip. )

Then you made the ass-grab on someone. You did it to make a point, knowing that it was not welcome. They didn't like. They said "Never do that again." Nobody was having a good time.

You did not do it again but that's when you started complaining.

The difference is not can/can not grab ass, it's does/does not want ass grabbed. She grabbed your ass because she knew that you would like it. It was friendly. You grabbed her ass because you knew that she wouldn't. It was aggressive.

In this case, I don't blame you at all. A 17 year old kid who has been constantly ass-grabbed will grab back. But that doesn't mean that it was right and it doesn't make for a very comprehensive description of ass grabbing in general.
 
Last edited:
Is there ever a time when that black or gay person plays their discrimination card when it is not justified? Do we assume it is justified based solely on their perception, meaning if you feel objectified (in this case) is that all the evidence we need to agree you must have been?

Seriously? Whose perception are you going to base it on? An outsider who has limited experience with the different ways that society reacts to that group? Some random guy on the street who says things like "Well, you know I only use that word about the dirty ones. Hell ,some white people are n-word."

You can't negate someone's experience just because you haven't the empathy to understand it. Well, actually you can and people do it every day. We just call them bigots.
 
Boo - can you please elaborate to me the correlation you drew earlier before you took your break? I don't really get where you're coming from.
 
Is there ever a time when that black or gay person plays their discrimination card when it is not justified?

Of course; but the proper criteria for judging whether a complaint is justified or not, is not "whether there are worse things that happen elsewhere in the world to the same demographic".
 
Last edited:
Of course not; but the proper criteria for judging whether a complaint is justified or not, is not "whether there are worse things that happen elsewhere in the world to the same demographic".

Yes - fine.

So what? Richard has made an error. A hollow argument. What next? Do we take away his 'atheist' card? Make him issue some sort of apology before we'll talk to him again? I mean really - just because he's smart doesn't mean he can't make a mistake. Is it really that important to hear someone say 'mea culpa'?

This really is verging into some sort of unintellectual witch hunt.
 
So someone who knew you well enough to know that you would like to have your ass grabbed, grabbed your ass and all was well. Then other people extended the ass-grab to a skirt flip that you enjoyed well enough to build a fetish around and all was good. It was unorthodox but everyone was having a good time. At no time did you say "Never do that again." Had you said it, even once, it would have stopped.

(ETA: I, personally, think it's a little gross and completely disrespectful to do this to a 16 year old boy. Especially if you're a 25 year old who has more worldly experience and it is a power trip. )

I think its worse than that ... it was sexual harassment of a minor. IMHO, Senex should have had the opportunity to at least get to the age of 18 years without undergoing this.

It doesn't matter that as an adult Senex decided that he liked having his ass grabbed by upper management. He had the right to mature in an environment appropriate for a minor.

Then you made the ass-grab on someone. You did it to make a point, knowing that it was not welcome. They didn't like. They said "Never do that again." Nobody was having a good time.

You did not do it again but that's when you started complaining.

The difference is not can/can not grab ass, it's does/does not want ass grabbed. She grabbed your ass because she knew that you would like it. It was friendly. You grabbed her ass because you knew that she wouldn't. It was aggressive.

In this case, I don't blame you at all. A 17 year old kid who has been constantly ass-grabbed will grab back. But that doesn't mean that it was right and it doesn't make for a very comprehensive description of ass grabbing in general.
 
Last edited:
I for one don't see the RD letter as intending to say that American women shouldn't complain about anything because there are women who have it so much worse.

Rather it seems to me that he was trying to use the horrible experiences of other women to accentuate just how petty he found the event in the elevator.

Laying it on heavy, in that obnoxious way he can do; but not meaning what some people have chosen to see.
 
Boo - can you please elaborate to me the correlation you drew earlier before you took your break? I don't really get where you're coming from.

Oh sorry, my bad. I'm reading backwards from the end and keep getting caught in the morass. (As it would be totally rude and inappropriate to pun that final word in light of Senex' post, I am not going to do that.)

The elevator guy has been objectified. He is no longer a human being but rather a deaf, aspie, shy dork who skips the headline speaker at a atheist conference in favor of laying in wait until 4 AM to stalk woman, follow them into the elevator and refrain, just barely, from raping them.

The reason he is getting such an outpouring of sympathy and empathy from one side is because he was, after all merely looking to hook up with a woman he found attractive and there shouldn't be anything wrong with that. Hooking up, having casual sex or even just flirting with strangers is normal, natural and harmless fun that many people enjoy.

As this tired saga drags on, a new element appears - Watson is a tease! A hussy! A flirt! Here is an example from this forum:
For the new comers on this board(post Rebecca Watson threads) look up her threads. They are full of sexual inuendo and sexual teasing. Including talking about what kind of person she is going to sleep with at TAM.
So I cannot really take her seriously when she talks about being put off by being hit on in an elevator

There are many other examples across many other sites and a few have their own twist but basically they are saying that Watson has given up the right to respect and empathy because she has hooked up, had casual sex or flirted with strangers.

But if EG is getting let off the hook, if the cries for understanding are based on the idea that casual sex and flirting are healthy wonderful activities, why should Watson be penalized for having done so in the past?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom