So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just repeating this guy could have been a rapist is not winning me over.

If the goal is winning you over, this is obviously worthless. You've decided your perception of reality trumps any and all others, so any woman expressing concern in such a situation is just being silly.

I would direct you to the roughly 500 blogs that have been written over the past couple of weeks by women who have actually been abused. I'd suggest that you read their stories and note how similar many of them are to this scenario. But what do they know? Their life experience is worthless compared to yours, so we can probably discount anything they say, and any person who takes their warnings to heart, like Rebecca Watson, is just a fool.

He wasn't, he didn't act in any way a reasonable person, male or female would think was sexually agressive. I mean, lets be honest here.

Using the fact that nothing did happen to argue there was no reason to be afraid in the moment is just worthless. When a car is speeding in your direction, most people experience a moment of apprehension, when it turns away, that doesn't mean the apprehension was irrational.


I am 120 or so ( 130 if i don't really care too much about what i eat.) about as big as the majority of women, if not a bit smaller. So should i be afraid of every person propositioning me? Because i am not some massive brick **** house, should i live in fear of any male or female who chooses to ask me in private if i want to have sex? (And heck, in regards to men, the kind that would go for me are 100% of the time, much larger and more well built than myself. But as a reasonable person i don't have this fear that everyone is out to rape me. )

No one is arguing that you or any woman should be afraid. If you don't experience fear, you don't experience fear. Good for you.

That doesn't mean the people who do experience fear are irrational. This is a situation where different perceptions of the world are equally valid. Sometimes they contradict and we have to argue for one over the other, but this is not such a case. You can be without fear and be perfectly reasonable and Rebecca Watson can describe how she was uncomfortable and be perfectly reasonable.

Of course not, and if i was, this is not something the rest of the world should have to work around. It is a personal issue, that i need to take steps to avoid myself, not demand everyone cater to my wacky view of the world.

The assault statistics show that it is quite a bit more than a personal issue. Women are victims vs. men at a rate of 9 to 1. Your life experience probably isn't a useful guide.

If i have a fear of benches, i don't demand the world get rid of them all, if i hate gum, i don't demand the world stop chewing it. And any reasonable person thinks this way, they can realize certain pet peeves or fears they have are not held by everyone, and that they have to take steps to alleviate their fears not the rest of the world.

This is a rather childish argument. Obviously some fears are rational, others aren't. Being in a confined space with no exits with a strange man trying to proposition a woman would make many, many of them uncomfortable. They are not all crazy. It's a very rational response, and it isn't requesting much of men to ask that they consider the impact of their behavior on others.

I'm a dude. I get laid. I don't need to corner women in elevators.

And your dismissive point in regards to her being armed not being the more rational option stuns me. The vast majority of people, men , women and other, do not find this kind of thing threatening. Maybe a touch annoying, maybe uncouth, but not threatening.

I doubt that very seriously. First of all, yes, most men would not feel any apprehension while being alone in an elevator with a woman, for good reason. That's not a situation of vulnerability for most men.

But substantiate your claim about women. I don't think that's remotely true.

So what makes more sense? The rest of the world stops a practice that only a small , tiny majority seem to be scared of. Or those people that have this fear, buy a 20 dollar combat knife, and download some self defense manuals on how to use it? ( heck if Watson is interested i can give her the titles of some based solely around using a knife to defend against a male attacker that is much larger than a female victim. )

A combat knife wouldn't really help women. Often, self defense tools end up being used against the victim, but whatever.

What makes more sense is for men to consider how their behavior may affect women and not proposition them in enclosed spaces with no exits at 4am when they haven't so much as exchanged names.

That's really a lot easier.

It all comes down to buttons my friend, i can have sympathy for someone afraid of buttons, but i will be damned if i am going to throw out all my buttoned shirts because of it.

I doubt we'd be friends, but again, this statement is wholly disrespectful of a great many women's experience of the world.

Obviosly some people are deeply irrational, we're under no obligation to cater to whims that are impossible to determine. This is not such an occassion. If you're honestly having trouble understanding why a woman would be uncomfortable in that situation, there's nothing I can say to you that will help you understand.

Women experiencing apprehension because they're isolated and vulnerable with a man propositioning them is in no way similar to being afraid of buttons.
 
Which proves the point, then. If the distribution is unequal, and there's no social reason not to participate, then we can assume that there is something innate making this difference.

That's just begging the question. THe very point at issue is whether there's something social at play, and you haven't begun to rule that out.

Just because active legal segregation within a profession has ceased, that doesn't mean societal restrictions are all gone.

On a historical level, the ability of women to participate in all walks of life is incredibly new. I don't know why we would expect centuries of history to wiped out in 50 years. I have seen nothing to indicate a genetic predilection for any particular profession.
 
1 in 6 women have been raped. 1 in 4 have suffered a sexual assault. That's 25% of the females in our society.

:eek: Huh, what ? That many ? That's almost as many women who'll ever get cancer. Do you have a source for that ? I'm a bit... shocked by the magnitude of that statistics.

Is it really so unreasonable to consider the possibility that the woman you are making the offer to might be one of that 25%?

Same question about asking women on a date. I think it _is_ unreasonable.
 
It would seem you are now backpedaling this a tad. I posted the quote in its entirety for context but it's the bolded words which said to me you see women as more vulnerable than I see them.

No, you actually left out the context. That was mostly in reply to the claim that poor old Elevator Guy had to corner Watson in the elevator because it would have been embarassing to try and flirt with her in public.

Read my post again with that argument in mind and you'll see that I haven't backpedaled in the least. You're just imposing an unduly broad application of a very specific argument.

And the attitude that women are fragile vulnerable little things (regardless if your version is much milder than my exaggeration) is part of the discrimination against women. When we are perceived incorrectly as "obviously" vulnerable, rather than correctly as "could be under some circumstances" vulnerable, it reflects an underlying prejudice.

Right, but I am saying "under some circumstances vulnerable." Namely, when trapped in an elevator alone with a man.

Looking over everything you've bolded in my statement, it only applies to a guy who gets on an elevator alone with a single woman and starts propositioning her. Where is this goofy generalization of yours coming from? You certainly have provided no evidence of it in my words.

Your description reflects an attitude that a woman in an elevator in a hotel at 4 am in Dublin if that wasn't your country should automatically be afraid if any man she doesn't know gets on the elevator and heaven forbid, asks her to his room for conversation and coffee.

Look, you keep saying this, I keep explaining to you that it isn't what I'm saying. I've given you plain descriptions, clear analogies, what else can I do? You literally are not reading my words. The words you went back and bolded do not support this claim.

There's really little use in conversing with you if you cannot deal with what I'm writing.

It's your default position here the 'weaker sex' shouldn't be expected to manage such a situation. I'm talking about the situation as described. If there were other reasons to be concerned that's another matter. I expect to be able to manage such a situation as described. Why shouldn't I be?

I don't expect you to be able to fight off an assailant. I don't expect a man in an elevator to be able to fight off an assailant. That's why I tend to not blame victims for their assaults.

As for "manage" the situation, did Rebecca Watson not do that? It seems to me she handled it fine. She then basically said, "that wasn't pleasant, please don't make me have to handle those situations."

That seems reasonable to me. Her apprehension is easily foreseeable, men should abide by that basic level of respect.

Is it smart to take a man up on such an offer? Of course not. But to fear the exchange, or the elevator in a hotel in that setting where mind you, the bar at 4 am wasn't worrisome? No, that is truly "needless" fear.

Really? You cannot see the difference between a public place and an elevator? I think we've long since reached the point where our discussion is useless, but this should cap it off.

It's your assumptions about the vulnerability of women that I've been complaining about. I don't think you understand what it is about your assumption that concerns me. I think your position includes false beliefs about the capability of women to manage a hotel elevator at 4 am.

Well, it certainly didn't help when you bolded a bunch of words in my post that in no way support his absurd interpretation of my argument you've been stuck on.

Again, Rebecca Watson managed the situation. And no, I don't expect her to be able to manage the situation if that guy became sexually aggressive. Why would any person, man or woman, have such an expectation?

That is victim blaming 101: they should have been able to prevent their assault.

It was fortunate it never came to that, but what would you expect a woman (or a man, for that matter) to do in that scenario?

I'd rather you understood where I'm coming from than get mad at me thinking I'm simply criticizing you. To me, what you are saying is women aren't expected to be comfortable in a hotel elevator at 4 am because they are weaker than men.

So no matter how many times I tell you that this is not what I'm saying, you will continue to think this?

How can I say this any clearer: I do not EXPECT a woman to be uncomfortable, the WOMEN WHO ARE UNCOMFORTABLE are not irrational.

Do you see the difference between those two statements?

And I'm telling you that is not true. I'm no less capable of being comfortable in that elevator in that foreign country than you are. In fact, I've been in many elevators in hotels, including late at night and in countries a lot more foreign than Ireland. I assure you it wasn't something my gender meant I should be afraid. The fact men are on average stronger than women on average does not make that elevator any more or less dangerous than the hotel bar was.

Yes, YOU were comfortable. Do you speak for all women. Because you said that, should I ignore all the women that disagree with you?

You could be attacked in the bar, witnesses or not. Someone could put something in your drink. Someone could break into your room. Someone could attack you on the sidewalk. Yes, but none of these circumstances automatically make me afraid because I am a woman.

It's interesting the degree to which you are judging all women by your own experience. Do you think that other people can have a different experience of the world than you and still be rational?
 
So I have to prove a negative, now ?

No, you have to somehow prove that women are genetically predisposed to avoid being car mechanics.

Just observing how many women are car mechanics is not good evidence. Historical fact has shown us this.

In 1940 the argument could have been, "Women are genetically drawn to be nurses, not doctors." We could have checked to see how many female doctors there were. What's that, a lot more men, oh, that must prove it was genetics.

It wasn't, obviously. So the argument from number analysis is not a good one. If that's the only evidence you have, chances are it's not a very good argument.
 
This thread has devolved and one topic is sexual harassment. One point I will stand by and defend is sexual harassment has a double standard. My point is I was easily arguably sexually harassed at the young age of sixteen and I clearly wasn't damaged as a result:rolleyes:

True story. I was 16 and was promoted from dishwasher to busboy at the local Howard Johnsons. The 25 year old (really hot) hostess would literally cup one of my ass cheeks every time she spoke to me. It wasn't a secret. She told all the waitresses she thought my bottom was attractive and as a result it was open season on squeezing, pinching, patting and spanking my bottom while I worked side side with the rest of the (much older) women. The truth was my ass was attractive because drunk customers on Friday and Saturday nights grabbed my ass as well. The truth was it never bothered me when older (and all women are older when you are 16) women grabbed my ass.

However some of the the MILF's I worked with saw how I might have been abused and decided to even the odds. One of them lifted the 25 year old in questions skirt while we were on a break stating she needed to check the aggressive woman's bottom out for some reason or another. The woman in question's face went red but she didn't defend herself. Subsequent to that anytime I was on a break the waitresses I worked with would raise the skirts of other waitresses, coworkers as an inside joke for my benefit because I was a sincere boy scout and teasing me was fun for them. Pantyhose, granny panties and poor visual positioning made the reality of what happened not as sexy as you might picture but the skirt lifting of my coworkers for my benefit was still well worth it and I have the fetish to prove it.

We all have strengths and weaknesses a and I have a strength that I can look in a woman's eye and decide when women don't wish to sleep with me. The 25 year old in question I knew from the first time she grabbed my ass but I felt I need to ask. When I was in my lat 17eens I grabbed her ass which I never did out of the blue. She looked at me and said "Never do that again."

I asked, "Why not, because you grab my ass always."

She said,"That's just the way it is."

I knew she would say that but I felt the need to ask. My point being there is a double standard. Most men realize women are the gatekeepers of sex. Take women out of the equation and we would be screwing in the streets.
 
I'm a woman, and yes, what Dawkins said was insensitive, nothing more.

I disagree; I think his argument wasn't just insensitive, but ridiculous on its face.

Try the same chain of logic on a couple of other issues and see how it works out:

- You shouldn't complain about boards of education trying to force science teachers to teach creationism alongside evolution, because in some countries even suggesting that evolution is possible will get you imprisoned for heresy.

- (A gay person) shouldn't complain about not being able to visit his or her partner in the hospital, because there are some places on Earth where being gay is an executable offense.

- A black person shouldn't complain about being called a name, because it wasn't so long ago that they would've been dragged out and hanged for complaining.


And so on.
 
I disagree; I think his argument wasn't just insensitive, but ridiculous on its face.

Try the same chain of logic on a couple of other issues and see how it works out:

- You shouldn't complain about boards of education trying to force science teachers to teach creationism alongside evolution, because in some countries even suggesting that evolution is possible will get you imprisoned for heresy.

- (A gay person) shouldn't complain about not being able to visit his or her partner in the hospital, because there are some places on Earth where being gay is an executable offense.

- A black person shouldn't complain about being called a name, because it wasn't so long ago that they would've been dragged out and hanged for complaining.


And so on.

Fine - but is that so heinous an act (a poorly structured, illogical & flippant internet blog post) that someone should expect anapology?
 
I knew she would say that but I felt the need to ask. My point being there is a double standard. Most men realize women are the gatekeepers of sex. Take women out of the equation and we would be screwing in the streets.

"When I tease it's in good fun, when you tease it's sexual harassment?"

I know you're not making a moral recommendation, just assessing society, but that's still ********** up.
 
No, you have to somehow prove that women are genetically predisposed to avoid being car mechanics.

Just observing how many women are car mechanics is not good evidence. Historical fact has shown us this.

In 1940 the argument could have been, "Women are genetically drawn to be nurses, not doctors." We could have checked to see how many female doctors there were. What's that, a lot more men, oh, that must prove it was genetics.

It wasn't, obviously. So the argument from number analysis is not a good one. If that's the only evidence you have, chances are it's not a very good argument.

But they didn't have the opportunity, back then. Now they do, and yet they don't seem to display that interest. Maybe you're right. I actually hope you are, but I don't see the evidence.
 
"When I tease it's in good fun, when you tease it's sexual harassment?"

I know you're not making a moral recommendation, just assessing society, but that's still ********** up.

It isn't *** up -- it is the truth. Unless the truth is *** up.


Do you know young males and young females? Young men I know are on their own -- however I will clock a young man who abuses any of my friend's daughters. It's a double standard I was raised with and I bet most men reading this were raised with as well.
 
Fine - but is that so heinous an act (a poorly structured, illogical & flippant internet blog post) that someone should expect anapology?

My guess is that if RD was just an average Joe, most people wouldn't care if he apologized.

But because he's viewed as an educator and perhaps even as someone who's opinion and values carries more weight in setting society's norms -- many people care more about what he says publicly about this particular topic.

It's really a compliment to RD that so much of a fuss is being made over some comments he made on a blog post.

ETA: I don't know Rebecca Watson well enough to say if that is why she cares ... but I'd take a WAG that its the reason that most of the people who would like him to reevaluate his "Muslima" comment care.
 
It isn't *** up -- it is the truth. Unless the truth is *** up.


Do you know young males and young females? Young men I know are on their own -- however I will clock a young man who abuses any of my friend's daughters. It's a double standard I was raised with and I bet most men reading this were raised with as well.

The truth is ********** up.

I've been told by an interviewer that I was not going to get a desk job because I was male.

"We have an all female environment, and we prefer it that way."

Do women face more discrimination than men? Yes. Is discriminating against men ********** up? Yes.
 
My guess is that if RD was just an average Joe, most people wouldn't care if he apologized.

But because he's viewed as an educator and perhaps even as someone who's opinion and values carries more weight in setting society's norms -- many people care more about what he says publicly about this particular topic.

It's really a compliment to RD that so much of a fuss is being made over some comments he made on a blog post.

ETA: I don't know Rebecca Watson well enough to say if that is why she cares ... but I'd take a WAG that its the reason that most of the people who would like him to reevaluate his "Muslima" comment care.

Its a shame when someone you admire & respect reveals himself to have some controversial ideas. Don't get me wrong - I like RD, read his books, watch his stuff. But he's just showing he's human.

At least he hasn't been caught Emailing sexy photos of himself or anything truly apology-worthy.
 
The truth is ********** up.

I've been told by an interviewer that I was not going to get a desk job because I was male.

"We have an all female environment, and we prefer it that way."

Do women face more discrimination than men? Yes. Is discriminating against men ********** up? Yes.

OK, we are looking at this question from two different perspectives. You are looking at it as a job you lost. I'm looking at it as saying if a 25 year old male had his hand on a 16 year old girl's butt who had to answer to him at work that would be considered sexual harassment and evil. I am saying the gender roles were reversed and I considered it a positive experience. When I was 16 I needed to know women found me attractive. It was all good having my ass grabbed. That is where the double standard lies.
 
I disagree; I think his argument wasn't just insensitive, but ridiculous on its face.

Try the same chain of logic on a couple of other issues and see how it works out:

- You shouldn't complain about boards of education trying to force science teachers to teach creationism alongside evolution, because in some countries even suggesting that evolution is possible will get you imprisoned for heresy.

- (A gay person) shouldn't complain about not being able to visit his or her partner in the hospital, because there are some places on Earth where being gay is an executable offense.

- A black person shouldn't complain about being called a name, because it wasn't so long ago that they would've been dragged out and hanged for complaining.


And so on.

That's not what he was arguing though. He was arguing that this didn't seem to be even a mild example of what we complain about. To make it analogous...

- science teachers shouldn't complain that their school offers a comparative religion class...

- gay people shouldn't complain that not all churches will perform a marriage ceremony for them...

- black people shouldn't complain about the name of the NAACP...

Linda
 
Since there has been some confusion/speculation/discussion about the degree of interaction EG may or may not have had with RW prior to the elevator, I'm bringing over a comment by Rebecca Watson from her Skepchick post*:

Excuse me but I had never spoken to that man in my life. He was amongst a larger group that I spoke to for several hours, and at no point did he engage me in any kind of conversation.

It was inappropriate because the subject of my talk AND the conversation at the bar was entirely about how I DO NOT WANT TO BE HIT ON/TOUCHED/********** WITH.

Of course, I'm sure someone will still manage to spin this into RW "leading him on" in some way.

*-- I don't know how (or if it's possible) to direct link to the specific comment on that thread; you'll have to scroll down a lot to find it
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom