So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
What exactly does that have to do with my post?

She is demonizing a guy for no reason and has a long history of being a caricature of fringe feminism. She has other redeeming qualities, but in regards to her views on men, she is just shy of LLoth.

Demonized him? Where did she demonize him? She said don't do that. Now whether or not she is a caricature of fringe feminism, I can't say because I am not a fan. However, I will even go with what you say for the sake of the argument. If, up until that moment in the elevator, she was a raving feminist, it still doesn't change the fact that she has the right to say exactly what she did; don't do that. Every individual on the planet has a right to set clear boundaries.
 
And none of that changes the fact that she was creeped out by something unreasonable. Heck, some people are creeped out by midgets or the deformed, should we lock them away to avoid this?

I can have sympathy for the fact that she was creeped out, but that is where it ends. Everyone has to deal with stuff they don't like on earth, and the less harmful said stuff is, the more it is expected for you to take steps to mitigate your fear, not the rest of the world.

It's buttons, buttons all the way down.

It's here where we can just agree to disagree and part ways. I find that she has every right to feel creeped out and say, I don't like that approach. There was a specific set of circumstances that I feel validate her position. At the risk of repeating myself; she spoke earlier that night and discussed emails involving rape threats. It would be reasonable for her, considering she is not in a place where she can't just walk away, to entertain the possibility that this stranger, who just made a proposal that she found off putting is one of those who feel that she should be raped.
 
100% agree, and it gives me a springboard to clarify something. ( thank you, lol.)

I am a sexual person, i don't mind random sex, one night stands, <snip>
It is simply not attaching the insane amount of baggage to sex that some people would like to.

<snip>

Sex shouldn't be the crux of a relationship, it shouldn't be the prize at the bottom of the romance box of cereal that fringe feminists want it to be. And i can see why they want it this way. When they keep it as something they are " giving" to men, they keep a huge amount of power, keeping men in the exact position they want them ( no pun intended.).

And it obviously gets under their skin that some of their sisters are more enlightened, and ruining this for them. They realize that sex is just sex, something fun between two people, not a superpower given to them by nature to allow them to make men jump through any hoop they want.

I call false dichotomy.

I also call strawman.

I'm 52 years old and the issues including whether women could get a loan from a bank without getting it co-signed by a male relative, participate in a business conference located in a hotel without being escorted by a male, and work in professional vs clerical job (including after marriage) with widespread acceptance had all been settled by the time I reached adulthood. (And I'm grateful that I didn't have to participate in that fight, the only thing I had to do was reap the benefits.)

So, probably as a result, my experience has been that 99% of the time when someone uses the word "feminism" IRL, its usually by someone who wants to troll and start a stupid argument. The word has had its original meaning hijacked, similarly to the way many Republicans have striven to hijack the word "liberal" of its meaning.
 
Tatyana:

I think this comes down to 2 things.

1) You have a definition of 'muscular' that I do not believe meshes with the common vernacular.

2) You interact with lots of women who are ignorant about female anatomy.


Ask most people to pick out an athletic woman from a stack of photos. Then ask them to pick out a muscular woman. I do not think you'll get much overlap.

You describe naturally muscular women. I have never seen a woman who I would describe that way. Big, stocky, strong women yeah; maybe it's because the natural fat content hides the musculature?

My wife is very strong for a woman, as strong as a small man, but she's not muscular in the way that I understand the term.


Women are not going to build muscle mass by accident. Men have to work hard to build muscle, and we have a distinct biological advantage.

I think you are somehow conflating some women being clueless with exercise, and men pressuring women to be flabby and have osteoporosis.
 
I think you owe it to your readers here to make that sort of detail plain rather than posting what looks exactly like a claim that people here are saying that it women don't want to be groped frequently that they should stay away from skeptical gatherings, and then modifying it when you get called out for it.
I'm sorry my post didn't meet your standards. Here are some quotes from Skepchick:
Female guests as well as attendees have found themselves accosted by other guests and attendees for decades. – Skepchick comments zylla 07.05.2011

Sadly, I stopped attending IRL atheist events quite a while ago, and the hostile atmosphere was part of the reason for that – Skepchick comments smudge 07.05.2011

I stopped going to atheist events because of the discomforts that you describe. There were just so many more fun things to do on a Saturday night than endure “accidental” breast touching and being followed back to my car – Skepchick comments meko 07.05.2011
Perhaps 'groped' was not the right word. Maybe I should have used 'inappropriate touching' or I could have said 'inappropriate propositions'. Forgive me. I was trying to convey a general idea of the picture I have. I think back to my experiences at sci-fi and comic books conventions when I was an attractive women in my early twenties. Groping is how I think of that general type of encounter.

However given that you haven't given us any links, and this is all based on your fuzzy mental picture of the debate rather than any specific people or comments, I'm somewhat skeptical that a significant number of people ever said this.
I hope the above quotes help. It took me about 30 minutes to find them on Skepchick. There were similar comments on at least one of the threads at Pharangula. There were more on at least one of the feminist blogs I read about this on. It's getting a little blurry for me and I'm not going to try and provide any more evidence for this claim. Instead I'm going to bow out of the conversation with this post. I hope it makes up for my inadequate previous one. Please forgive me.

As for why the women I know don't attend Australian Skeptics meetings, it's not because when they did attend they were getting frequently groped. Since I didn't say anything of the sort,you're doing more of that fuzzy-picture guesswork rather than remembering what people actually said if you think what my remark about women avoiding AS "directly contradicted" my skepticism about women being groped with high frequency.
Really? Have you asked them and confirmed that? Could you tell us why they don't like it and choose not to associate with it?
Do you think that Dawkins responds to every feminist opinion that way? Or only to a subset of feminist opinions he thinks are over-precious and irrational?

Remember your claim was that feminist opinions attracted ridicule and rape threats, not just that stupid feminist opinions did so.

I think Dawkins responds to every opinion he thinks is ridiculous, whether feminist or not. Frankly I find his style and vitriol repellent and don't read him or listen to him anymore. If PZ hadn't blogged about his comment, I would never had heard it.

I found it to be a mean-spirited attack on the idea of discussing what is a reasonable expectation for interactions with strangers in our society. I think this discussion is important and it's generated a lot of heat because it's in a very fuzzy part of what is/is not acceptable behavior in public spaces.

I had to take a break from (reading) this thread because I just can't come to grips with the reaction taking place.
I did too.

I know too many women who have been raped. It really messes women up. Among other things, it makes women really skittish about being in a confined space with a man she is not certain she can trust. I mention this along with the statistics that have been quoted here: 1 in 6 women have been raped. 1 in 4 have suffered a sexual assault. That's 25% of the females in our society. Is it really so unreasonable to consider the possibility that the woman you are making the offer to might be one of that 25%? Or might, even without having had that sort of previous experience, find it creepy and unpleasant?

You don't have to wait long, just until the elevator door opens. You're unlikely to find a crowd waiting to come down at 4:00 am. In the meantime, you might make a little small talk. Tell her your name, tell her what you like about her. I think it will, overall, give you better odds of success and you'll avoid coming across as "indistinguishable from creepy" (I like that description of the behavior.)

I honestly can't even see the argument explaining what this guy in the elevator did that was wrong. He hit on her? Seemingly politely so? Am I to understand that I must now remain completely silent when alone with a woman on an elevator? (For the love of god, I understand not to mention cof*e*- shudders).

I figured I must be missing something, but I still can't find it.

I appreciate all the people posting that, no, it's not that unusual or improper a thing to do. I can only say that you have travelled in a very different subculture than I ever have. Biker bars come to mind for me as place where that might happen regularly, but I really don't have a clue. I don't go to bars or hang out at places like race tracks or atheist conventions. I have no experience at all with that sort of subculture or where it is to be found.

Do you think it would be possible to discuss specifics of where those subcultures are so that women who aren't up for that sort of query could avoid them? I think hotel elevators are public spaces where such behavior should be considered inappropriate. You know, kind of like farting in an elevator with a stranger is inappropriate.

Plenty of people have been posting how it's reasonable for a person to be uncomfortable in that situation. I really think percent of people in our common culture that find such propositions to be far worse a faux pas than farting would be sizable enough (likely more than half) and it's really a rather minor inconvenience to those men who feel it imperative that they ask that attractive stranger to their room.

And again, if you are independent enough to get yourself on an elevator, at 4:00am, alone, in a foreign country, then you are independent enough to deal with these (harmless) consequences.
And so she did. She only mentioned, in passing in her video blog, that such behavior made her really uncomfortable. She didn't freak out about it. It was the internet that went ballistic.

Did Watson claim she was assaulted? Has anyone said that?

She was worried about being in an enclosed space alone with a strange man who was propositioning her. This made her uncomfortable. She was uncomfortable because she was at his mercy.

Her apprehension was justified regardless of the content of the statement, but the fact that he was propositioning her increased that stress.

Again, no one is arguing this was a crime, Watson just made the simple request that men be aware of how such behavior could cause a woman discomfort. It's very reasonable.


Sure, there are times when people's apprehension is not legitimate. If that guy had propositioned Watson in the bar, it still would have been bizarre and likely inappropriate, but there would have been no spectre of danger.

Being isolated, trapped, and alone changes the set of reasonable reactions.

He thought he was being polite, it was pointed out why and how the action could reasonably be interpreted differently. The expectation is then on men to realize these basic facts and act accordingly.
This is exactly it!!!!!

I want to thank you TraneWreck. You've done a great job of patiently explaining again and again that she was uncomfortable, not panicked and that feeling of discomfort was perfectly rational for the situation. I appreciate that.

I'm not going to post on this thread again. This discussion has brought up painful memories I thought I had successfully squashed decades ago. I've gotta go deal with them now. You see, I'm one of the women in that 25%.
 
Last edited:
I have a thought, a small one mind you. Just a throw away. But it seems that people react to things like that. Because they are reacting instead of considering, their reply is full of hyperbole best saved for things that are actually revolutionary, and embellished with many flowery phrases. Phrases so pretty that they must be defended for fervor if not content. And thus goes the merry-go-round.

I'll be gone all day. I wont see your reply. There's no need to type quickly or say the first thing that comes to mind and afterward to defend it to the death.

So here goes - I was thinking, if you're going to defend Elevator guy for just wanting a bit of fun and then being misunderstood and objectified, you can't really hold Watson's past against her.
 
So here goes - I was thinking, if you're going to defend Elevator guy for just wanting a bit of fun and then being misunderstood and objectified, you can't really hold Watson's past against her.

Yeah...I think i need to see your thinking behind that statement.
 
Anyone struggling with the EG use of 'coffee' may be interested in this little Steven Pinker analysis of language.

Not making any excuses, personally, but its an interesting, short lecture.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=3-son3EJTrU

Awesome video! That was a great find.

As I have frequently posted, I grew up partially deaf. I got very little help while growing up and that just made learning about any social cues and innuendos conveyed in spoken language that much harder to learn.

I had often complained to my friends and asked why can't hearing people just speak directly and say what they mean? But as Pinker explains, sometimes there is good reason for it.

And in Pinker's example, as long as sex means more than a handshake to a significant number of people, a significant number of people will probably opt to flirt [ETA: , at least initially,] with innuendos instead of directly. And I think that's understandable.
 
Last edited:
So here goes - I was thinking, if you're going to defend Elevator guy for just wanting a bit of fun and then being misunderstood and objectified, you can't really hold Watson's past against her.

<scratches head>

Going to have to wait 'til you're back to walk through that one I think. Not sure I get where you're going with that, nor how you came to that idea.
 
But I wonder why he would say he found her "interesting" if the first time he laid eyes on her was in that elevator.

Indeed, but it might be a way for him to say "attractive". Or he was just at the bar, etc. It's just that the inclusion of Rebecca's speech in the list of things he should've taken into account is premature.
 
I really couldn't tell you. There are competitions for both, men have been weight lifting longer, but there are more equivalent events for women springing up (fitness competitions). My guess is that over time the difference will narrow.

Unfortunately we can't rely on possible future history to make an argument.

Or we can just observe the integration process in every othe subject about which people claimed, "women don't want to do this because they're different."

Let's not forget that they _are_ different, though. Equal, but different.

Why would it be necessary for the exact same percentage to partipate in something? Remember, this is the claim we're discussin:

Well, because if you're disputing that an activity is more attractive to one sex than to the other, and they are both equally distributed... it follows that if the claim is wrong, you'll have just as many people of each gender participating, no ?

The same is true of men. Teaching, nursing, hairdressing, reception, flight attendent, all of these traditionally female professions are occupied by men. Because they were segregated for hundreds of years (depending on the profession, obviously) and have only been seriously integrated for 30-40, I don't think we should expect 100% equal distribution at this point.

Which proves the point, then. If the distribution is unequal, and there's no social reason not to participate, then we can assume that there is something innate making this difference.
 
And yet, not everyone perceived it that way. And his follow up comments confirmed that I read the intent in his first post correctly.

I would say his first comment was more of an unfiltered reaction.

I agree. I didn't say I was going to boycott the man. ;) But that's the disadvantage of having the ability to post anything that the whole world can immediately read: sometimes we don't take much time to think about what we utter.
 
It would be reasonable for her, considering she is not in a place where she can't just walk away, to entertain the possibility that this stranger, who just made a proposal that she found off putting is one of those who feel that she should be raped.
My bolding.

I believe this is a non-sequitur.

Obviously "reasonable" is subjective, but I do not think it follows that because she found his proposal off putting, it is reasonable to think (based solely on this) that he is one that feels she should be raped. It maybe reasonable to think he isn't remarkably polished, but nothing here suggests he wished her harm.

If you accept this premise, then it is apparent that he would have been just as "threatening" as if he had said nothing.
 
I mention this along with the statistics that have been quoted here: 1 in 6 women have been raped. 1 in 4 have suffered a sexual assault.

How skeptical are you about those statistics? I think Heather MacDonald makes a good cause for being wary about those numbers.

Ack. Here's the article I meant to refer to, by Christina Hoff Sommers. MacDonald's essay is a good read too, but more polemic and less convincing.
 
Last edited:
Tatyana:

I think this comes down to 2 things.

1) You have a definition of 'muscular' that I do not believe meshes with the common vernacular.

2) You interact with lots of women who are ignorant about female anatomy.


Ask most people to pick out an athletic woman from a stack of photos. Then ask them to pick out a muscular woman. I do not think you'll get much overlap.

You describe naturally muscular women. I have never seen a woman who I would describe that way. Big, stocky, strong women yeah; maybe it's because the natural fat content hides the musculature?

My wife is very strong for a woman, as strong as a small man, but she's not muscular in the way that I understand the term.


Women are not going to build muscle mass by accident. Men have to work hard to build muscle, and we have a distinct biological advantage.

I think you are somehow conflating some women being clueless with exercise, and men pressuring women to be flabby and have osteoporosis.


Yah, no.
 
Um, body language? That's why talk before the proposition can help avoid sounding creepy.

BS. You can't just look at someone and tell. You just don't want to have to say it.

This reminds me of our supervisor, who thinks we should guess how he wants projects to be develloped, without having to tell us. And it's not hyperbole. He actually told me so.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom