So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
....

And it obviously gets under their skin that some of their sisters are more enlightened, and ruining this for them. They realize that sex is just sex, something fun between two people, not a superpower given to them by nature to allow them to make men jump through any hoop they want.
Do I detect a little misogyny there? ;)
 
This whole thing is utterly ******* ridiculous and IMO does a disservice to the advancement of equal treatment of women.

Wait till you show up to work on Monday with a tray a coffees and get accused of being a serial rapist.
 
1) Real life, go to a bar , dress up nice, and try it. Some things, unfortunately there is not a statistic for. I could show you some videos, but i don't think they are JREF appropriate. Sure your going to get turned down, more often than if you " play the game" a bit, but even then most of the women will do so as politely as you asked them. And a further percentage will admire your Chutzpah, turn down the original offer, but still hang around for the possibility if they find you worthy.

Real life, I was a bartender in two different types of bars; one was a local bar which mostly consisted of people meeting before they head out to the scene and the other was a live band club. The second, I got to watch a lot of interaction. Most of it consisted of people talking a flirting for a while, before moving in for the kill. So again, feel free to ask, but you might want to make sure the vibe is there first.

2) How would you know if both parties were not willing, if you didn't ask? This guy rolled the bones and came up snake eyes. Unless we devolve to the point where we can smell if someone wants to have sex, asking is really the only option.

Um, body language? That's why talk before the proposition can help avoid sounding creepy.
 
And if I went to an event for the first time, and there on page 1 or the back of the program, there is some weird edict talking about harassment and violence towards others while at a blody conference about science, atheism, and skeptics, I would wonder strongly at the sorts of nutters I was choosing to hang out with.

As opposed to previous TAMs, when you only starting wondering that after the first hour or so....


2) How would you know if both parties were not willing, if you didn't ask? This guy rolled the bones and came up snake eyes. Unless we devolve to the point where we can smell if someone wants to have sex, asking is really the only option.

No, everyone could just take epepke's training in body language reading -- he is a MASTER at it, with 100% accuracy!
 
Did Watson claim she was assaulted? Has anyone said that?

She was worried about being in an enclosed space alone with a strange man who was propositioning her. This made her uncomfortable. She was uncomfortable because she was at his mercy.

Regardless of her political beliefs, whether she thinks women make competenet lawyers or not, her fear at that moment was based purely on that vulnerability.

The connection between social, political, and economic liberation and the idea that she should never be apprehensive is just absurd.



That doesn't mean much. Do you think all sexual assailants begin by whipping out their dong and waving it around?

Her apprehension was justified regardless of the content of the statement, but the fact that he was propositioning her increased that stress.

Again, no one is arguing this was a crime, Watson just made the simple request that men be aware of how such behavior could cause a woman discomfort. It's very reasonable.



Sure, there are times when people's apprehension is not legitimate. If that guy had propositioned Watson in the bar, it still would have been bizarre and likely inappropriate, but there would have been no spectre of danger.

Being isolated, trapped, and alone changes the set of reasonable reactions.



He thought he was being polite, it was pointed out why and how the action could reasonably be interpreted differently. The expectation is then on men to realize these basic facts and act accordingly.

The notion that going around armed is a more reasonable expectation is quite amusing.

Just repeating this guy could have been a rapist is not winning me over.

He wasn't, he didn't act in any way a reasonable person, male or female would think was sexually agressive. I mean, lets be honest here.

I am 120 or so ( 130 if i don't really care too much about what i eat.) about as big as the majority of women, if not a bit smaller. So should i be afraid of every person propositioning me? Because i am not some massive brick **** house, should i live in fear of any male or female who chooses to ask me in private if i want to have sex? (And heck, in regards to men, the kind that would go for me are 100% of the time, much larger and more well built than myself. But as a reasonable person i don't have this fear that everyone is out to rape me. )

Of course not, and if i was, this is not something the rest of the world should have to work around. It is a personal issue, that i need to take steps to avoid myself, not demand everyone cater to my wacky view of the world.

If i have a fear of benches, i don't demand the world get rid of them all, if i hate gum, i don't demand the world stop chewing it. And any reasonable person thinks this way, they can realize certain pet peeves or fears they have are not held by everyone, and that they have to take steps to alleviate their fears not the rest of the world.

And your dismissive point in regards to her being armed not being the more rational option stuns me. The vast majority of people, men , women and other, do not find this kind of thing threatening. Maybe a touch annoying, maybe uncouth, but not threatening.

So what makes more sense? The rest of the world stops a practice that only a small , tiny majority seem to be scared of. Or those people that have this fear, buy a 20 dollar combat knife, and download some self defense manuals on how to use it? ( heck if Watson is interested i can give her the titles of some based solely around using a knife to defend against a male attacker that is much larger than a female victim. )

It all comes down to buttons my friend, i can have sympathy for someone afraid of buttons, but i will be damned if i am going to throw out all my buttoned shirts because of it.
 
As opposed to previous TAMs, when you only starting wondering that after the first hour or so....

I assume you are being tongue in cheek. I've been to 2 TAMs and 2 of the 'Skeptical Cruises'. I was sufficiently untraumatized by the nutter factor to decide to take some time and spend a few $ to go to this one. Its all part of the fun/experience.

ETA: And for all I know, there are people who think I'm one of the 'nutters'. I don't think I've ever traumatized anyone with a pickup line, tho.
 
Real life, I was a bartender in two different types of bars; one was a local bar which mostly consisted of people meeting before they head out to the scene and the other was a live band club. The second, I got to watch a lot of interaction. Most of it consisted of people talking a flirting for a while, before moving in for the kill. So again, feel free to ask, but you might want to make sure the vibe is there first.



Um, body language? That's why talk before the proposition can help avoid sounding creepy.

So your saying one has to learn how to read body language? Really, versus the simple option of using your words like a human friggen being?

Body language can be misinterpreted, " No" and " yes" are very clear. Saying that basing your actions on something that is a soft science, versus a clear answer, would lead to more misinterpretation, not less.

Do you not see how twisted and silly this argument is getting? Your actually saying that body language is a more effective communications method than asking questions. This is just pure insanity. Staring at a person in order to try and determine something is friggen creepy, as many men and women from across a bar have been told by me. Want to know something about me? Ask, i am not an animal who is trying to go through a mating ritual, i am a person, a person with words who communicates not through flipping his tail in the air when he wants sex, but by talking.

Really, just say it out loud " asking someone if they want to have sex is creepy, staring at them to determine this is not. " , say it in public if you really want to get a sense of how just plain wrong this statement is. Heck if you really want to get a sense of this, go to a gay bar if your straight, and tell me who you find less creepy, the guy who asks what team your playing on, or the guy who eye ***** you from his table all night.
 
Do I detect a little misogyny there? ;)

There is vitriol, and it is against women, but a very specific subset, lol.

And to be fair, some men display this as well.

But it is the kind of person that uses sex as a tool, or a weapon. I find it just cheapens the entire concept, and is degrading to the guy, and socially inhibiting to the woman . But the fringe of the feminism movement loves this, they want a guy to have to give a request for sex on robin blue paper, signed at a 45 degree angle, because it gives them power.

And sex shouldn't be about power, whether we are talking about a rapist or a fringe feminist, using sex for power, is just wrong.
 
I was in a very smarmy mood when I wrote that. Please take it as read that I'm saying that he is viewed as a dog. There is the assumption that the man is being deceptive or nefarious or bad in some way, on the basis of no supporting evidence, and I think that has been demonstrated adequately in this thread.

I understand your point. I feel, at least I have maintained that his question was ambiguous. The most I can say is that RW took it to be a sexual proposition. I have not labeled him as anything. At this point, there are so many opinions on the matter and on occassion, they intersect but for the most part, from one person to another, you are going to run into many conflicts. I have done my best to argue specifically from RW's perspective; She goes to a convention and tries to address a topic. Among her topic are discussing emails where she is threatened to be raped. She goes to a bar afterwards and continues to participate in a discussion. She, supposedly tells her companions that getting hit on at conventions makes her uncomfortable. She announces that she is tired and going to bed. Upon entering the elevator, she meets a man who, at least alludes to being interested in what she's saying, then proceeds to invite her to his room. She said this makes her uncomfortable, don't do that. Having absolutely nothing to do with the guy, his intentions or lack thereof, Rebecca, as an individual A) is justified in feeling a little creeped out by the situation and B) has every right to say she doesn't want that.

That you bring up deception, however, is interesting, because I see a fair amount of it going around in this discussion. There's the equivocation of "coffee" and "sex." Whether it was intended or not, it's impossible to know, but either way, the function is equivocation.

I do find suggesting that this guy is a creep and a woman hater, or what have you, is deceptive. What I also find deceptive is suggesting RW has attempted to put an end to casual hookups, that she is attempting to speak for all women, or that anyone else has attempted to say that all women SHOULD feel vulnerable in an elevator, or even that EG has been demonized. Really all she said was don't do that and based on the words she used before and after that, it really does sound like she was speaking from a personal point of view.

Men skilled at sexual interaction do not use the word "coffee" to mean "sex." Not buying a woman a drink in a bar is the central theme of Richard Feynman's essay "You Just Ask Them?" I find this essay extremely honest, but it does seem to offend people.

This is irrelevant if the guy was honestly asking for coffee. None of it changes the fact that his request, whether innocent or not, creeped RW out.
 
100% agree, and it gives me a springboard to clarify something. ( thank you, lol.)

I am a sexual person, i don't mind random sex, one night stands, among many other things that i am sure watson hates. But this has nothing to do with not caring about someone's other characteristics.

It is simply not attaching the insane amount of baggage to sex that some people would like to. Some of my best relationships, male or female started with random sex. Finding someone attractive, and immediately wanting to have sex, does not mean you don't care about their mind. Heck, at the very least, personally, it is the exact opposite. If i don't find someone mentally interesting , the chances of me going for a second performance, let alone a long term relationship are slim to nil.

Physical attraction is a small thing compared to mental attraction, and should be treated as such. Sex shouldn't be the crux of a relationship, it shouldn't be the prize at the bottom of the romance box of cereal that fringe feminists want it to be. And i can see why they want it this way. When they keep it as something they are " giving" to men, they keep a huge amount of power, keeping men in the exact position they want them ( no pun intended.).

And it obviously gets under their skin that some of their sisters are more enlightened, and ruining this for them. They realize that sex is just sex, something fun between two people, not a superpower given to them by nature to allow them to make men jump through any hoop they want.

Wow, you got all of that out of "don't hit on me, in an elevator, after I just got done saying being sexualized makes me uncomfortable, and announced I was tired and going to bed,"? That is impressive. A really far stretch, and in no way relating to what she said, but still impressive.
 
I understand your point. I feel, at least I have maintained that his question was ambiguous. The most I can say is that RW took it to be a sexual proposition. I have not labeled him as anything. At this point, there are so many opinions on the matter and on occassion, they intersect but for the most part, from one person to another, you are going to run into many conflicts. I have done my best to argue specifically from RW's perspective; She goes to a convention and tries to address a topic. Among her topic are discussing emails where she is threatened to be raped. She goes to a bar afterwards and continues to participate in a discussion. She, supposedly tells her companions that getting hit on at conventions makes her uncomfortable. She announces that she is tired and going to bed. Upon entering the elevator, she meets a man who, at least alludes to being interested in what she's saying, then proceeds to invite her to his room. She said this makes her uncomfortable, don't do that. Having absolutely nothing to do with the guy, his intentions or lack thereof, Rebecca, as an individual A) is justified in feeling a little creeped out by the situation and B) has every right to say she doesn't want that.



I do find suggesting that this guy is a creep and a woman hater, or what have you, is deceptive. What I also find deceptive is suggesting RW has attempted to put an end to casual hookups, that she is attempting to speak for all women, or that anyone else has attempted to say that all women SHOULD feel vulnerable in an elevator, or even that EG has been demonized. Really all she said was don't do that and based on the words she used before and after that, it really does sound like she was speaking from a personal point of view.



This is irrelevant if the guy was honestly asking for coffee. None of it changes the fact that his request, whether innocent or not, creeped RW out.

And none of that changes the fact that she was creeped out by something unreasonable. Heck, some people are creeped out by midgets or the deformed, should we lock them away to avoid this?

I can have sympathy for the fact that she was creeped out, but that is where it ends. Everyone has to deal with stuff they don't like on earth, and the less harmful said stuff is, the more it is expected for you to take steps to mitigate your fear, not the rest of the world.

It's buttons, buttons all the way down.
 
Wow, you got all of that out of "don't hit on me, in an elevator, after I just got done saying being sexualized makes me uncomfortable, and announced I was tired and going to bed,"? That is impressive. A really far stretch, and in no way relating to what she said, but still impressive.

What exactly does that have to do with my post?

She is demonizing a guy for no reason and has a long history of being a caricature of fringe feminism. She has other redeeming qualities, but in regards to her views on men, she is just shy of LLoth.
 
Way too many words to be the final word. ;)

LOL! As I was reading I thought "Wow! This is great. And doomed to end up as tl;dr."

Stop dismissing the essays just because they're very long! The have just as much right to be read as pithy little catchphrases! You're all a bunch of magnitudists! :D
 
This issue was brought up in the context of a specific debate between Skeptic Ginger and me. She is arguing that when I say, "Rebecca Watson was justified in feeling apprehension," I am arguing that all women are weak and should be afraid of elevators.....
I apologize for the discussion in the other thread bleeding into this one, and for taking a while to address this again but I had to find the original post I had reacted to:
Maybe if it's a friend or someone you've been previously acquainted with, but getting onto an elevator with a woman at 4:00am and propositioning her is a really aggressive move that would understandably make a lot of women uncomfortable. The content of the person's words were innocuous, but Watson was in an incredibly vulnerable situation with someone she didn't know who then tried to hit on her.

I also think it's odd that you're so baffled over the notion of hooking up with someone you meet in public. This is sort of why people go to bars and night clubs.

If a person can't communicate with a woman in a situation where she isn't vulnerable, then there are some bigger issues there.



No, as opposed to asking her in the bar where they'd been for the last several hours. And the politeness of the request is relatively meaningless. When she's alone in that elevator in a foreign country with a person she doesn't know well, a polite request could just be step 1.

Watson's statement on that count was perfectly reasonable. That act made her feel incredibly uncomfortable and she asserted that men should not do this. They shouldn't.



Honestly, I don't know how to explain to you why the act of propositioning a single woman on an elevator at 4am in a foreign country (for her) is a troubling move. It should be fairly obvious what's wrong with that.

The problem wasn't the come on, it was where it happened. If you can't flirt and converse and generally progress the situation to a hook-up in a bar, you are sort of pathetic. Yes, rejection may be embarrassing, but intimidating and making the woman feel uncomfortable because you're scared of being uncomfortable yourself isn't a very good excuse.

I think Watson generally made a fool of herself throughout this episode, but she is 100% correct to explain what's wrong with that sort of pursuit. This person ignored her statements in the bar that she wanted to go back to her room and sleep, on what grounds could she trust this person to respectfully acknowledge her rejection of him in the elevator?

It's obviously very good that nothing happened, but Ms. Watson did not know that at the time. That was a situation where a foolish man placed a woman in a needless state of concern and stress. It seems like you're reasoning from the fact that nothing did happen to the conclusion that Watson was irrational for thinking something could happen. Again, had an assault taken place, a huge percentage of the very same people wringing their hands over the notion that perhaps this man acted like a fool would be sanctimoniously lecturing everyone on precautions women should take to avoid assault.
(emphasis mine)

It would seem you are now backpedaling this a tad. I posted the quote in its entirety for context but it's the bolded words which said to me you see women as more vulnerable than I see them. And the attitude that women are fragile vulnerable little things (regardless if your version is much milder than my exaggeration) is part of the discrimination against women. When we are perceived incorrectly as "obviously" vulnerable, rather than correctly as "could be under some circumstances" vulnerable, it reflects an underlying prejudice.

Your description reflects an attitude that a woman in an elevator in a hotel at 4 am in Dublin if that wasn't your country should automatically be afraid if any man she doesn't know gets on the elevator and heaven forbid, asks her to his room for conversation and coffee. It's your default position here the 'weaker sex' shouldn't be expected to manage such a situation. I'm talking about the situation as described. If there were other reasons to be concerned that's another matter. I expect to be able to manage such a situation as described. Why shouldn't I be?

Is it smart to take a man up on such an offer? Of course not. But to fear the exchange, or the elevator in a hotel in that setting where mind you, the bar at 4 am wasn't worrisome? No, that is truly "needless" fear.


I don't disagree one could get signals from the exchange that caused valid fear. I wasn't there. I have no problem with RW's claim the exchange made her uncomfortable. There are many non-verbal cues we don't see when RW described EG's words.

It's your assumptions about the vulnerability of women that I've been complaining about. I don't think you understand what it is about your assumption that concerns me. I think your position includes false beliefs about the capability of women to manage a hotel elevator at 4 am.


I'd rather you understood where I'm coming from than get mad at me thinking I'm simply criticizing you. To me, what you are saying is women aren't expected to be comfortable in a hotel elevator at 4 am because they are weaker than men. And I'm telling you that is not true. I'm no less capable of being comfortable in that elevator in that foreign country than you are. In fact, I've been in many elevators in hotels, including late at night and in countries a lot more foreign than Ireland. I assure you it wasn't something my gender meant I should be afraid. The fact men are on average stronger than women on average does not make that elevator any more or less dangerous than the hotel bar was.

You could be attacked in the bar, witnesses or not. Someone could put something in your drink. Someone could break into your room. Someone could attack you on the sidewalk. Yes, but none of these circumstances automatically make me afraid because I am a woman.
 
Last edited:
I assume you are being tongue in cheek. I've been to 2 TAMs and 2 of the 'Skeptical Cruises'. I was sufficiently untraumatized by the nutter factor to decide to take some time and spend a few $ to go to this one. Its all part of the fun/experience.

I've been to three TAMs, and it does bring out some eclectic personality types, but I was mostly kidding. The true nutters are a small portion; in my experience the worst generalization I could make is that it tends to be a quiet, not-very-gregarious lot.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom