So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
....
It seems to me, Watson is berating both men, and any woman who does not attach the appropriate emotional baggage to sex.
That's a good point. To add to that, there is a difference between objectifying women and liking sex for the sake of sex.

Objectifying, in this case, would be when one doesn't think women are good for anything except sex.
 
I would say his first comment was more of an unfiltered reaction.

Which is exactly what PZ wanted wasn't it? Perhaps PZ and Watson set out all along to raise a stink out of Dawkins fully expecting him to point out the smell? This entire thing feels "baited"
 
I can't show that. But I wonder why he would say he found her "interesting" if the first time he laid eyes on her was in that elevator. It at least implies to me that he saw and/or heard her earlier than that, and so might have been party to having heard some of her discourse on a related topic that evening.

I've went on a rant before that i don't find Black men or women attractive. If everyone stopped the second they thought that someone may not be interested, and had to use this " if there is any doubt, don't ask" policy, i wouldn't have dated a very nice looking black gent for 3 years.

Hence why the flat out question is needed, to clarify. People over or under state things, especially to a group, hence a one on one conversation.
 
Or maybe she just made the entire thing up?

It was just a guy tossing out a line like billions of guys before him, and billions after. He knew she prided herself on her intellect, so he said " interesting" , if he knew she prided herself on her appearance , he would have mentioned the hair.
 
Well Dawkins' initial reaction was a bit... insensitive, shall we say ? It's not his first time being so, however.

I'm a woman, and yes, what Dawkins said was insensitive, nothing more. It only seems to be a big deal because he's the god of atheism and we know the reaction some folks get when their gods let them down.
 
Just to be clear:

A lot of men like women in good shape, low body fat, good legs. Lots of men also like girls with curves, fat girls, skinny girls...

Helga the shotputter has as much worth as a human being as the hottest starlet. She doesn't have the broad sex appeal though. I'm sure there are men out there who love pronounced muscles on women though, so she has every chance at a happy love life.

I don't know of any women afraid of resistance training in case it makes them look like a shot putter. Women have to actually try in order to get substantially muscular.


Yes, I know this is anecdotal, but so is 'I don't know any women that are afraid of resistance training'.

I am not sure how much time you spend in the gym, having conversations with the chubby young girls and they sit around waiting for their boyfriends to finish training, but it isn't uncommon for them to comment 'I don't want to bulk up'.

The issue is that they are already quite bulky with the fat. So yes, they are quite delusional.

There is an issue that a lot of female athletes do take steroids for strength, speed and recovery and have androgenised, which does give a lot of people the misconception that putting on muscles means you would look like a man.

I am substantially muscular without doing drugs, and there are some women who are naturally muscular. I think it is the Eastern European gene pool.

I have done some research on the topic, I was working my way through my fourth degree, here is an excerpt from my literature review:

(The full review is on my other half's external hard drive, I can get the full references).




Strength training has been found to provide numerous psychological benefits for women, such as improvement in self-esteem, emotional well-being and body image (Harne and Bixby, 2005) (Henry et al, 2006). Despite these well-documented benefits, less than fifteen percent of women over the age of eighteen participate in strength training (Harne and Bixby, 2005).

In interviews with women, they have stated a number of barriers to strength training, such as time constraint, however, the foremost is that muscularity is perceived as being inappropriate for women (Grogan et al, 2007), and women are concerned about ‘bulking up’. Grogan and Wainwright have reported that in interviews with girls as young as eight years old, they are as fearful of becoming muscular as becoming fat (Grogan et al, 2004). In addition, certain types of gyms and certain areas of the gym and certain sports are considered to be exclusively for men.

According to Krane et al, it is not only the body image of the female athlete that contrasts with the Western ideal, but the behaviour and demeanour is also contradictory to the cultural ideal of femininity. To be successful as athletes, female athletes have to adapt behaviours that are considered to be masculine, such as being assertive, competitive, independent and strong (Krane et al, 2004).

Not all female athletes are perceived as transgressing the ‘feminine’ norm, for example gymnasts, figure skaters, volleyball players, tennis players and swimmers (Krane et al, 2004). However, women that participate in certain sports that result in a muscular physique, such as athletics, or those that participate in ‘male’ sports such as ice hockey, rugby and baseball and ‘fighting’ contravene western cultural femininity. Interviews with these women have revealed that they are very much aware of the cultural ideal for the female body, and that their bodies do not fit this ideal.

“I like the way I feel when I get the muscle…..but yet, in the back of my mind I get scared that I’m gonna get big and people gonna look at me like ‘oh my god’…I get scared of looking too much like a guy, like having too much muscle” (Kramer et al, 2004, page 320).


Women aren't going to look like "Helga" unless they take steroids or work out to Herculean amounts or have polycystic ovary disease.

So this is one more thing that women worry about that won't happen. If they want to worry about it, I guess it's their right, but it's also delusional.

On the other hand, if someone gives me "Helga's" phone number, we'll see what happens. She might be a lot of fun.


As I mentioned, some women are naturally big and muscular, which is why they become Olympic strength athletes.

Yes, they probably take steroids.

You would be surprised at how many men love seriously muscular, roided up female bodybuilders.

You might be interested in googling the term 'schmoe'.
 
One would think.

And that is the problem. And what irks me about fringe feminists.

" We are powerful, we are independent we can do whatever a man can do. We are woman , hear us ROAR!"

" Having to say no to someone in an elevator EEEEK what do i do, i am scared, this man is evil EEEK!"

The fringe feminist reaction to being politely asked for sex ( again, as someone who likes men and women, i have been asked in the same manner, by both sexes, and a good portion of the time, it is people i turn down. No harm no foul, and i have to say, i have had worse attempts than she is describing. ) , seems to be way too similar to the reaction of a stereotypical female circa 1950 or so to a mouse.

The irony astounds me.
 
I think this is where we have to be very cautious. It isn't for us to decide whether or not someone's fears are unfounded. Indeed I think its pretty clear from RW herself that she wasn't scared. She felt 'uncomfortable'.

She is entitled to feeling however she feels from that incident, and only she will be able to articulate how she felt. As a casual observer, we can really only take that at face value.

It may not be how you or I would feel in the same situation, it may not be how other women would feel.

Its a question of being conscious that your actions may cause unfortunate feelings in others, and to be considerate of those actions. And - in context, striking up a conversation in an elevator at 0400h with a lead-in that could easily be interpreted as being a pickup attempt, is not the most considerate action in the world. Particularly when the other person has just been on stage and holding court in the bar talking about why she doesn't want to be 'sexualized & objectified' or whatever.

And the thing is, if the guy said something along the lines of " Give 'em a flap about the lift hon." i could understand. But he politely as possible asked, not demanded, if she would be interested in going back to his room, with the possibility it could be for sex.

This is not objectification. People do not ask objects, objectification is me slapping a woman's butt ( shocker, women are just as bad for stuff as this as men. Especially if they think you are not into women, suddenly you become free reign for groping. But if i were to get this offended at a woman doing the same thing i would be laughed off the net. ) , not me giving a polite open ended request with no intimidation, nor aggressive body language.

The buttons analogy is apt, i can understand someone is afraid of buttons, and i can even have sympathy for that. But when this person is attempting to demand everyone not wear buttons because she is scared of them, then the line is crossed.
 
And that is the problem. And what irks me about fringe feminists.

" We are powerful, we are independent we can do whatever a man can do. We are woman , hear us ROAR!"

" Having to say no to someone in an elevator EEEEK what do i do, i am scared, this man is evil EEEK!"

The fringe feminist reaction to being politely asked for sex ( again, as someone who likes men and women, i have been asked in the same manner, by both sexes, and a good portion of the time, it is people i turn down. No harm no foul, and i have to say, i have had worse attempts than she is describing. ) , seems to be way too similar to the reaction of a stereotypical female circa 1950 or so to a mouse.

The irony astounds me.

Stupid feminists, didn't they realize that they became immune from sexual assault when they got the right to vote?
 
Define "athletic" ?



I asked for statistics either way, because I wasn't aware of such a study. If you don't like to be the one who's asked, on a public forum, then maybe this isn't the place for you.

Think of a track and field athlete.

If you can't be civil, maybe this isn't the place for you.
 
That's a good point. To add to that, there is a difference between objectifying women and liking sex for the sake of sex.

Objectifying, in this case, would be when one doesn't think women are good for anything except sex.

100% agree, and it gives me a springboard to clarify something. ( thank you, lol.)

I am a sexual person, i don't mind random sex, one night stands, among many other things that i am sure watson hates. But this has nothing to do with not caring about someone's other characteristics.

It is simply not attaching the insane amount of baggage to sex that some people would like to. Some of my best relationships, male or female started with random sex. Finding someone attractive, and immediately wanting to have sex, does not mean you don't care about their mind. Heck, at the very least, personally, it is the exact opposite. If i don't find someone mentally interesting , the chances of me going for a second performance, let alone a long term relationship are slim to nil.

Physical attraction is a small thing compared to mental attraction, and should be treated as such. Sex shouldn't be the crux of a relationship, it shouldn't be the prize at the bottom of the romance box of cereal that fringe feminists want it to be. And i can see why they want it this way. When they keep it as something they are " giving" to men, they keep a huge amount of power, keeping men in the exact position they want them ( no pun intended.).

And it obviously gets under their skin that some of their sisters are more enlightened, and ruining this for them. They realize that sex is just sex, something fun between two people, not a superpower given to them by nature to allow them to make men jump through any hoop they want.
 
It's not just the ability to read body language and signals that makes a man a "dog", it's picking up on those signals and then using deception to get what he wants; pretending to be interested in more than casual sex, pretending to be monogamous when he's got multiple women he's lying to; that's a dog. It's hard to say how other's should feel but I find something to the effect of, "Listen, we are both going to be in different cities tomorrow, but I don't want to end the night..." I could respect that.

I was in a very smarmy mood when I wrote that. Please take it as read that I'm saying that he is viewed as a dog. There is the assumption that the man is being deceptive or nefarious or bad in some way, on the basis of no supporting evidence, and I think that has been demonstrated adequately in this thread.

That you bring up deception, however, is interesting, because I see a fair amount of it going around in this discussion. There's the equivocation of "coffee" and "sex." Whether it was intended or not, it's impossible to know, but either way, the function is equivocation.

Men skilled at sexual interaction do not use the word "coffee" to mean "sex." Not buying a woman a drink in a bar is the central theme of Richard Feynman's essay "You Just Ask Them?" I find this essay extremely honest, but it does seem to offend people.
 
Which is exactly what PZ wanted wasn't it? Perhaps PZ and Watson set out all along to raise a stink out of Dawkins fully expecting him to point out the smell? This entire thing feels "baited"

The more i post, the more i am feeling the same way.

I mean honestly, i have read some silly things from Watson, but this just seems so....overblown, oversaturated ( in the sense of how much it is being promoted in an official manner.) , and overemphasized that the more i think of it the more i think it is going to be some kind of " Gotcha" to us all, in regards to cognitive dissonance or something of that nature.

Something about this seems, fake, in the same manner a good trollin attempt may seem legit at first, but more and more little things start to set off some kind of radar.
 
I certainly hope you're right that this is all some big 'gotcha'. Or even that RW & RD decide to turn it into a big 'gotcha'.
 
Stupid feminists, didn't they realize that they became immune from sexual assault when they got the right to vote?

Sexual assault, there was sexual assault here? Really, where?

Again, there would have been a legitimate issue if he said " Lets see the ol panty hamster" and gave a leer, but a man politely asking something in an elevator, going so far as to not mention sex, is EEEKing at the metaphorical mouse.

It would be like me saying someone was threatening me in a bar if they mentioned they happened to be a professional fighter. Sure the person could threaten me, but they weren't. And if i felt that way, that is my own weird issue, not something that everyone else on earth should modify because i am easily scared.

If she is so scared that a guy being polite in an elevator is a threat, and she doesn't feel physically capable of defending herself, maybe she should go armed? I can have sympathy for the fact she gets scared of silly things, but it is her that needs to take steps to remedy this, not the rest of the world.
 
I certainly hope you're right that this is all some big 'gotcha'. Or even that RW & RD decide to turn it into a big 'gotcha'.

I feel like a ct'er , i really do, but something just seems....weird about the whole thing. I sit here and realize that i have actually been having a debate on whether it is okay to ask someone politely, at a respectful distance, in private if they would like to have sex, and not bother them after they have said no.

I mean it is surreal, i would have the same reaction if i just realized i had been debating over whether scratching ones kitten under it's chin is animal abuse, or if i suddenly realized i was in a 30 page thread about whether it was allright that a christian casually stated he was a christian at the workplace.

And even that, doesn't really describe it well enough, essentially this kind of reaction is what people would use in a joke if they were talking about a fringe feminist. It would be like if i found myself in a thread that was all about black people being obsessed with fried chicken, and it started with a quote from Obama about how he is diverting all KFC supplies in his city to his house. Which is to say, it is just such an absurd promotion of a stereotype that i find it hard to accept that there is not something ....oh god, i can't believe i am saying this.... down the rabbit hole.
 
<snip>debating over whether scratching ones kitten under it's chin is animal abuse<snip>.

Aha - well did you consider the kitten's feelings BEFORE you approached it and molested it? Because if you didn't then you might get asked to leave TAM early.
:o
 
Sexual assault, there was sexual assault here? Really, where?

Did Watson claim she was assaulted? Has anyone said that?

She was worried about being in an enclosed space alone with a strange man who was propositioning her. This made her uncomfortable. She was uncomfortable because she was at his mercy.

Regardless of her political beliefs, whether she thinks women make competenet lawyers or not, her fear at that moment was based purely on that vulnerability.

The connection between social, political, and economic liberation and the idea that she should never be apprehensive is just absurd.

Again, there would have been a legitimate issue if he said " Lets see the ol panty hamster" and gave a leer, but a man politely asking something in an elevator, going so far as to not mention sex, is EEEKing at the metaphorical mouse.

That doesn't mean much. Do you think all sexual assailants begin by whipping out their dong and waving it around?

Her apprehension was justified regardless of the content of the statement, but the fact that he was propositioning her increased that stress.

Again, no one is arguing this was a crime, Watson just made the simple request that men be aware of how such behavior could cause a woman discomfort. It's very reasonable.

It would be like me saying someone was threatening me in a bar if they mentioned they happened to be a professional fighter. Sure the person could threaten me, but they weren't. And if i felt that way, that is my own weird issue, not something that everyone else on earth should modify because i am easily scared.

Sure, there are times when people's apprehension is not legitimate. If that guy had propositioned Watson in the bar, it still would have been bizarre and likely inappropriate, but there would have been no spectre of danger.

Being isolated, trapped, and alone changes the set of reasonable reactions.

If she is so scared that a guy being polite in an elevator is a threat, and she doesn't feel physically capable of defending herself, maybe she should go armed? I can have sympathy for the fact she gets scared of silly things, but it is her that needs to take steps to remedy this, not the rest of the world.

He thought he was being polite, it was pointed out why and how the action could reasonably be interpreted differently. The expectation is then on men to realize these basic facts and act accordingly.

The notion that going around armed is a more reasonable expectation is quite amusing.
 
I mean honestly, i have read some silly things from Watson, but this just seems so....overblown, oversaturated ( in the sense of how much it is being promoted in an official manner.) , and overemphasized that the more i think of it the more i think it is going to be some kind of " Gotcha" to us all, in regards to cognitive dissonance or something of that nature.

And by the way, I do agree that a lot of the subsequent discussion has been bizarre and incomprehensible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom