So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Indeed. It's weird to have to actually spell it out, like that, especially since many of the described behaviours are clearly illegal.

And also completely disssimilar to the issue in question. Of course it is wrong to harass a woman, of course it is wrong to say " Give 'em a good flap about the room." , but that is a far cry from " Would you like to come back to my room?" with a chaser of acceptance of the answer " No".

It is like saying no begging at tam, because someone asked someone else if they had 4 quarters to get a soda, and they didn't have change.
 
There is nothing wrong with her saying " Listen, for all men in the audience, don't ask me for sex the first time we meet" , a little weird and personal to use your speaking time to do, but not wacky.

But what she is doing si saying " Don't ask any woman" well sorry Lloth, but most women don't mind. Most women can simply deny the request if they want without issue, heck a good portion of women may not. She is taking a personal preference that she is in the minority of having, and demanding people follow it because, obviously, no woman could think differently from her.

If no women thought differently, heck if the majority of women didn't think differently, the " one night stand" would be a rare obscure occurrence. And as any of us knows, it is not.

I don't want to get cornered and accused of assuming that he was, in fact, hitting on her, so I will repeat, again, that his proposition was ambiguous. Your tone in this argument seems that it was a sexual proposition so I am only following your reasoning.

With that said, she has made clear, since the original blog that it's not about hitting on people. Her issue was specifically, in the elevator (the creepy feeling was presumably a situation where she has no means of walking away), propositioning (her assumption was that it was a sexual proposition) her after indicating that he had been listening to her, ignoring the fact that she had just got done saying that being hit on makes her feel uncomfortable. Those are rather specific circumstances. If this was a cautionary tale, I find that there has to be a lot of specifics for all men to be concerned that she was lecturing.
 
The problem is, simply, that the majority of people would not care. People like sex, people like random sex, to modify actions based on the request of one fringe feminist is silly.

It seems to me, Watson is berating both men, and any woman who does not attach the appropriate emotional baggage to sex.

My issues with this statement are as follows

1) Can you cite any thing that indicates that the majority of women appreciate being propositioned, in the first sentence of the introduction, by complete strangers? Can you actually say for certain that women who actually prefer a "get to know you," period, are at the fringes of society?

2) Can you cite anything RW said specifically about random hookups where both parties are willing?
 
And I'm still waiting for someone to show that this guy had knowledge of this.

I can't show that. But I wonder why he would say he found her "interesting" if the first time he laid eyes on her was in that elevator. It at least implies to me that he saw and/or heard her earlier than that, and so might have been party to having heard some of her discourse on a related topic that evening.
 
I don't think we can blame society for every difference between the two. Do you think women would like weightlifting as much as men if it weren't for social training ?

I really couldn't tell you. There are competitions for both, men have been weight lifting longer, but there are more equivalent events for women springing up (fitness competitions). My guess is that over time the difference will narrow.


Let 'em. At this point it's all opinion, and we have no way to tell how it would be if society were different.

Or perhaps we can. But that would require having data on societies in which such ideas weren't there.

Or we can just observe the integration process in every othe subject about which people claimed, "women don't want to do this because they're different."


I didn't say that NO woman would want to do this, Trane. You know this, so why are you arguing against something I haven't said ? It doesn't follow that the SAME proportion of women as that of men would be interested in those activities. And I doubt it's all learned behaviour.

Why would it be necessary for the exact same percentage to partipate in something? Remember, this is the claim we're discussin:

I am arguing that some interests are naturally more attractive to one sex over another.

From the perspective of women, this is a contingent claim that is directly contradicted by the history of professional integration.

The same is true of men. Teaching, nursing, hairdressing, reception, flight attendent, all of these traditionally female professions are occupied by men. Because they were segregated for hundreds of years (depending on the profession, obviously) and have only been seriously integrated for 30-40, I don't think we should expect 100% equal distribution at this point.

The reason the military is interesting is that they actively recruit women. Those women are then put into all sorts of jobs that are traditionally male. The opportunity is provided, and it's taken eagerly.

Car mechanics do not have the same recruitment policy, and though there are a lot of women mechanics and the number is steadily growing, they are less represented in that field. I don't see how this proves anything about genetics.
 
I can't show that. But I wonder why he would say he found her "interesting" if the first time he laid eyes on her was in that elevator. It at least implies to me that he saw and/or heard her earlier than that, and so might have been party to having heard some of her discourse on a related topic that evening.

Or maybe she just made the entire thing up?
 
Last edited:
One of your pet peeves is a preference shared by close to 50% of the human population, not including those men who also find women with muscle unattractive ? :p It's going to peeve you off for a while ;)

Oh yeah, I'm the one claiming to speak for men alright...



Show me where I likewise claimed an absolute for an entire gender.




Here, your hyperbole isn't quite ridiculous enough:

View attachment 22858

It was Belz.

My bad.

What hyperbole?

The US and the UK have an obesity issue.

As well, I do have references/stats for a paper that states that less than 20% of women over the age of twenty participate in any form of resistance training.

It isn't hyperbole.

Women don't do weight training.
 
Last edited:
I've always found that saying quite condescending, although I'm sure it wasn't the intention here.
It was a joke and a reply to the insults (surely you noticed the insults). It came up earlier in the thread. Actually, I never heard the saying before this thread.


Dang, it just donned on me how sexist those insults were. If a woman mentions casual sex isn't wrong, she must be a slut. Very sexist.
 
Last edited:
People aren't dismissing the perspective of women. They're questioning the perspective of certain women. They're supposed to dismiss the perspective of other women. Is that sexist?

This issue was brought up in the context of a specific debate between Skeptic Ginger and me. She is arguing that when I say, "Rebecca Watson was justified in feeling apprehension," I am arguing that all women are weak and should be afraid of elevators.

As for the dismissal of perspectives, anyone's perspective is legitimate or illegitimate to the degree it tracks with reality. Women fearing sexual assault in enclosed spaces without exits from a man propositioning her is a reasonable worry. Notice that Watson didn't freak out or call the cops, she was just uncomfortable. It's reasonable to request that men avoid behaving that way.

The perspective is reasonable, the request is reasonable.

It seems that "we" are supposed to want particularly thin-skinned women, especially if all they do at skeptic conferences is talk about how tough it is to be a woman at a skeptic conference. Could you explain to me why "we" should want that?

I don't have any idea what you're talking about. That's just condescending nonsense. We should have men with thick enough skin at skeptical conferences to accept reasonable requests from women without flipping out and acting like any criticism is an insult to our masculinity.

The men are the wimps, here. That's plainly obvious.

"We" could find plenty of women, for example in churches. Do "we" want that kind of woman? Probably not. It's probably OK not to want a bunch of, say, seriously Methodist women on panels at skeptic conferences. Maybe "we" could make them feel comfortable by putting a lot of crosses around and opening ever day with a prayer to Jesus. Then "we" could get them.

And now you've repeated the oft deployed (in this discussion) mistake of shifting from, "don't proposition me without any prior conversation when I'm alone with you on an elevator at 4am," to, "don't flirt with me under any circumstances at an atheist conference." The two are very different.

Look, I certainly see where Watson and some other bloggers have hinted at this. If she wants 100% immunity from any man showing interest in her beyond purely professional curiosity, that's an impossibility. SHe, like all of us, can deal with people approaching them for whom they hold no interest. As long as the conversation is begun respectfully and with some dignity, nothing wrong is happening.

But that's a massive scope shift from the discussion.

I don't want to "dismiss" Rebecca Watson, but neither do I particularly want to see some absolute template for all women based on her. Skepticism should, of course, be open to women as well as men. Amongst those women, I'd kind of like to see some who are fearless enough to debate people and to go against people's deeply held beliefs, which requires a lot of self-confidence and independence. But that's the sort of woman whom "we" are supposed to get rid of.

That makes little sense, nor does it describe the women involved in skepticism at all. That's an incredibly insulting comment.

You seem to literally be making the point that unless women suck it up and don't complain when some creep inappropriately slobbers on them, they will not be able to make strong philosophical arguments. THis is just a bizarre notion.

The "sort of woman" who is unafraid to point out when men are behaving like idiots and ******** is the exact "sort of woman" who will not be afraid to call out inappropriate political, social and economic behavior.
 
I need to make a confession. It was never my intention for this to snowball into an issue that threatens the cohesion and good reputation of the skeptical community.



I was trying to quit smoking, Richard! I'm sorry!

I didn't mean anything by it!

It kills me that me and dawkins used the same analogy. ( i assure you before posting i did not read this particular bit.) We just hate gum, really hate gum, but we can understand that it is not doing us any real harm, and some people like it, if only others could take the same opinion about harmless, non malicious actions.

And really that is what this is all about, not being an overreacting turd at harmless, non malicious actions. Everyone has things that annoy them, and if we were to set up a social ban on everything that annoys a few people, the world would be a rather boring place. Much better to judge actions based on intent and how they are committed, than to bend over for every person with a hate-on for their pet peeve.
 
It was a joke and a reply to the insults (surely you noticed the insults). It came up earlier in the thread. Actually, I never heard the saying before this thread.


Dang, it just donned on me how sexist those insults were. If a woman mentions casual sex isn't wrong, she must be a slut. Very sexist.

@lionking. About 20 pages back, someone popped in who was pretty obviously trolling/sock-puppeting. I used it in conversing with that person, whose posts had a lot of ****'s in them. Glad to see I've brought a pithy Gold Coastian saying to a wider audience. ;)
 
I don't want to get cornered and accused of assuming that he was, in fact, hitting on her, so I will repeat, again, that his proposition was ambiguous. Your tone in this argument seems that it was a sexual proposition so I am only following your reasoning.

With that said, she has made clear, since the original blog that it's not about hitting on people. Her issue was specifically, in the elevator (the creepy feeling was presumably a situation where she has no means of walking away), propositioning (her assumption was that it was a sexual proposition) her after indicating that he had been listening to her, ignoring the fact that she had just got done saying that being hit on makes her feel uncomfortable. Those are rather specific circumstances. If this was a cautionary tale, I find that there has to be a lot of specifics for all men to be concerned that she was lecturing.

But the problem is, her fears are unfounded. Most sexual offers are done in private, and speakers speak on a variety of topics, if one were to listen to Dawkins talk, i guess they should avoid him at all costs if they happen to be muslim, right?

If she was more up front with her views and said simply in her speech " I hate men, if your a man, don't come near me." and he still did it, maybe i would see your point. This man gave her the benefit of the doubt that she was not an overly paranoid, reactionary that would misconstrue a politely phrased question as a threat of rape. Shame on him for thinking she was a reasonable person.

A comedian said it well, though i forget his name.

" .... there are some women that take everything the wrong way. You see them at a bar and tell them you like their hair, and what they see is some orc masturbating at them, they walk away disgusted as if they are going to have to clean themselves off afterward."

Watson, is decidedly in this category.
 
Well Dawkins' initial reaction was a bit... insensitive, shall we say ? It's not his first time being so, however.....
And yet, not everyone perceived it that way. And his follow up comments confirmed that I read the intent in his first post correctly.

I would say his first comment was more of an unfiltered reaction.
 
My issues with this statement are as follows

1) Can you cite any thing that indicates that the majority of women appreciate being propositioned, in the first sentence of the introduction, by complete strangers? Can you actually say for certain that women who actually prefer a "get to know you," period, are at the fringes of society?

2) Can you cite anything RW said specifically about random hookups where both parties are willing?

1) Real life, go to a bar , dress up nice, and try it. Some things, unfortunately there is not a statistic for. I could show you some videos, but i don't think they are JREF appropriate. Sure your going to get turned down, more often than if you " play the game" a bit, but even then most of the women will do so as politely as you asked them. And a further percentage will admire your Chutzpah, turn down the original offer, but still hang around for the possibility if they find you worthy.

2) How would you know if both parties were not willing, if you didn't ask? This guy rolled the bones and came up snake eyes. Unless we devolve to the point where we can smell if someone wants to have sex, asking is really the only option.
 
But the problem is, her fears are unfounded.<snip>

I think this is where we have to be very cautious. It isn't for us to decide whether or not someone's fears are unfounded. Indeed I think its pretty clear from RW herself that she wasn't scared. She felt 'uncomfortable'.

She is entitled to feeling however she feels from that incident, and only she will be able to articulate how she felt. As a casual observer, we can really only take that at face value.

It may not be how you or I would feel in the same situation, it may not be how other women would feel.

Its a question of being conscious that your actions may cause unfortunate feelings in others, and to be considerate of those actions. And - in context, striking up a conversation in an elevator at 0400h with a lead-in that could easily be interpreted as being a pickup attempt, is not the most considerate action in the world. Particularly when the other person has just been on stage and holding court in the bar talking about why she doesn't want to be 'sexualized & objectified' or whatever.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom