So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
No athletic does not mean muscular. There is muscle tone, then there is visible muscle mass.

Did you mention earlier that you are Bi-sexual? That may tint your view on this a teeny bit. (I may be totally confusing you for the poster earlier who is Bi)


I am not bisexual.

Athletic does not mean muscular? What does it mean then?

Muscle tone is more or less a useless word, you either have muscle or you don't.

There is no 'tone' to muscle.

Tonicity really only applies to plants.

What most people mean by 'muscle tone' is that there is a lack of fat and muscle present, which means you have to actually have some muscle.

People have really weird ideas about muscle. We start experiencing atrophy around the age of 30, so unless you actually work on maintaining or building muscle, by the age of 60, men have lost 50% of their muscle mass, it is typically worse for women.

Muscle is metabolic currency, it protects against numerous pathologies, including diabetes, heart disease, osteoporosis and falls in the elderly (of which pathological fractures are far more common than most people realise).
 
Last edited:
Didn't she turn elevator guy into what is wrong with the skeptic movement though? The EG is the reason women aren't showing up if you will..

(which i would say is bogus.. and hope she isn't trying to make that assertion..)

No, I can safely say she didn't do that. That was an issue she had been trying to address before the elevator incident. If anything, the response has proven her point.
 
Singing to the choir - I'm a book dealer. I can carry two banker boxes of books up a flight of stairs. If I've been sorting a large library, I'll look like Olive Oyl sporting Popeye's arms. But most men with my build (5' 9" and scrawny) would still be able to dead-lift more weight even if they hadn't been hauling 40 pound boxes around for three weeks. I've gone toe-to-toe with guys my weight and my height in the ring. if we weren't playing, I'd be dog meat, even if I was more proficient.

This does not in anyway lessen my contribution to society or make me the lesser person. It is simply an aspect of being born with a specific set of chromosomes.

Upper body strength, yes, chromosomes matter.

Lower body strength, there really isn't that much of a difference on average.
 
There are people who are skilled in this, and there are people who aren't.

Unlike some other cultures (Greek, Italian, French), boys and men are not taught these skills. They are supposed to figure them out for themselves. If they do, they're dogs, and if they don't, they're losers and scum.

I am not trying to be sarcastic, I don't get what your saying. If they figure out how to read body language and subtle signals, they're dogs?
 
Maybe it's because I'm involved with a lot of different things but I have a hard time with dismissing smaller for larger (no, really!) Maternal mortality rates in developing countries deserve priority over privileged women in elevators but it doesn't negate the importance of having a discussion about common average sexism within a movement.

I agree. That's probably when it does have to effect me personally - when I see the problem as relatively trivial. I just hadn't previously seen that Skepchick video and it has made me more than a little annoyed about Rebecca's complaints.

At the same time, I have missed any post of yours regarding maternal mortality rates and that is regrettable. Have there been too few of them? bad timing? Do you feel that this is not the place for it? So much of the stuff I do outside this forum, the stuff that I really care about isn't discussed here, maybe tossed into the mix of other conversations and let go. This just isn't the place for it. Maybe feminism is the one of the few subjects that gets a response, even though it is often a negative one.

I never thought about that before. It hadn't occurred to me to bring this stuff up here. I think it's because I came to a lot of it because I am involved in weaving and spinning, rather than something which was an offshoot of science or skepticism. Sure, if the subject of health in developing countries comes up in some other thread, I'll post something. But I haven't started a thread on Lesotho mohair, for example. Maybe I don't want to see something important to me trampled under someone else's political dogmatism. :)

Linda
 
Rationality alert!

Back to the basics - this isn't about all women any more then it is about all men. "

Exactly. There has been so much binary thinking -- make that "knee-jerk reaction" -- about this that I have a hard time believing that this is a forum for people who supposedly value critical thinking.
 
Again, you're desperately trying to broaden my claim. When a single man and a single woman are in an isolated setting, that women is not out of her mind to be apprehensive. Men should be able to realize this and behave appropriately (there is a wide range of appropriate behavior, it's not difficult to figure it out).

That's the extent of my argument on this score.

The rational apprehension is supported by the factual reality of sexual assault statistics. It's a radical stretch to conclude that based on that, I think "women are limited."

A couple of years ago there was a series of robberies at gunpoint in my neighborhood. I walk around at all hours, to bars, to friends' houses, whatever. The little crime spree culminated in a murder. Shortly after that murder, I was walking home from a bar at 2 or 3 in the morning, I noticed two guys were walking behind me. The followed me around a corner. When I glanced back, I became apprehensive, I quickened my pace. When I made my next turn, they kept going, and that was that.

I would say my apprehension in that context wasn't insane. It was a perfectly valid reaction given the circumstances. Does that mean I think men are limited? I could easily have been victimized in that circumstance, and if those two were the gun-point robbers, there wouldn't be a whole hell of a lot I could do.

I honestly have no idea what you're reading in my posts that are causing you to draw the conclusions you are.
I'm not trying to broaden your claim. But you do seem to be unable to see things from my perspective. I wouldn't fear a hotel elevator at 4 am, especially if I had just left the hotel bar where I was having a conversation with a group of people. If I was comfortable in that bar, chances are I'd feel comfortable in the rest of the hotel.

I get it you disagree. That's fine. But I would like you to recognize that your perception that women should fear a guy in an elevator at 4 am given the relevant scenario says to me you think women are more vulnerable than I think they are. I'm telling the women reading this post, don't believe it. I've been in hundreds of hotel elevators in foreign countries and it is not something to fear. TraneWreck is wrong.

You may be trying to soft-pedal your initial comment, or even emphasize the isolated encounter over the scary hotel elevators. But the bottom line remains, you have a perception of how dangerous the world is for women that I'm telling you is inconsistent with my experience. You aren't the only one with your perception. Lots of women think the world is scarier than it is as well.

As a matter of fact, lots of people view the world as a much scarier place than it actually is. The news tells us about rapes and murders and we get the idea these things are common when they are actually rare. I've been to the city and I've seen the elephants, and nothing bad happened. A woman traveling alone in foreign countries is for the most part just as safe as a woman traveling alone in their own country.


We just disagree about how vulnerable women should feel. Of course there are specific scenarios anyone is right to feel nervous about. But you keep insisting a hotel elevator at 4 am is one of those scenarios and it isn't. Could it be? Sure. As could a particular encounter with a scary guy. But you said dangerous was the default position. I don't agree.
 
I am not trying to be sarcastic, I don't get what your saying. If they figure out how to read body language and subtle signals, they're dogs?

I won't take it as sarcasm. But yes, basically, because men who can do that are successful with women, and being successful with woman makes a man a dog. It's like the madonna/whore complex, except for men.
 
Okay, "anywhere outside of a brothel"...?

No, I'm sure you'll think of some uncommon kind of situation that has no bearing on the circumstances of Watson's complaint.
It's cultural, Checkmite. Such a request would have been perfectly acceptable at Woodstock, for example. It wouldn't have raised an eyebrow in the culture I spent my young adulthood in. Casual sex was the norm.



How about "within the context of an international meeting dedicated to intellectual issues, where people of backgrounds and cultures vastly different from yours are in attendance"? Is asking someone not to ambush women they've never met before with thinly-veiled requests for sex at a fracking TAM or atheist gathering reasonable then? If not, why not?
I've already answered this, as have other people. EG's request seemed polite enough. Rebecca's expectation he shouldn't have asked was unrealistic. End of story.

The rest was even more unsupportable. There's no evidence EG was "objectifying" Rebecca. There's only been a couple anecdotal testaments that such men are the reason more women don't attend atheist and skeptical events.

Rebecca could use the incident to teach men about approaching her. I'm not sure she was right to claim this applied to all men approaching all women in hotel elevators at 4 am. Guys can ask. I can say no. That seems more fair to me.
 
Rebecca could use the incident to teach men about approaching her. I'm not sure she was right to claim this applied to all men approaching all women in hotel elevators at 4 am. Guys can ask. I can say no. That seems more fair to me.

Please edit her statement to reflect the above paragraph.

"Um, just a word to wise here, guys, uh, don't do that. You know, I don't really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I'll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4:00 am, in a hotel elevator, with you, just you, and -- don't invite me back to your hotel room right after I finish talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner."
 
http://www.ivoindia.org/story/25511/the-lady-mechanic-initiative-nigeria

Is the lack of female car mechanics a feature of genetics, of "nature?" Or is it a social stigma, like women serving in the military, playing sports, being lawyers, being CEO's, owning homes, voting, working out of the home, being scientists, going to medical school...

My impression is that women are generally not very interested in getting their hands oily while working the innards of motorized vehicles. Just like most men don't want to be hair dressers. I don't see a problem with different genders having different interests.
 
Are you really trying to suggest that without mind reading capabilities, you have no way of knowing if someone is into you? It's a miracle people hook up at all.

I didn't insult you. I don't see why you see the need to insult me.

My point was that people don't wear their intent on their sleeves. Without actually conversing with someone, it's nigh impossible to tell at all, much less tell reliably. So asking seems like the reasonable thing to do.
 
I'm not trying to broaden your claim. But you do seem to be unable to see things from my perspective. I wouldn't fear a hotel elevator at 4 am, especially if I had just left the hotel bar where I was having a conversation with a group of people. If I was comfortable in that bar, chances are I'd feel comfortable in the rest of the hotel.

I get it you disagree. That's fine. But I would like you to recognize that your perception that women should fear a guy in an elevator at 4 am given the relevant scenario says to me you think women are more vulnerable than I think they are. I'm telling the women reading this post, don't believe it. I've been in hundreds of hotel elevators in foreign countries and it is not something to fear. TraneWreck is wrong.

You may be trying to soft-pedal your initial comment, or even emphasize the isolated encounter over the scary hotel elevators. But the bottom line remains, you have a perception of how dangerous the world is for women that I'm telling you is inconsistent with my experience. You aren't the only one with your perception. Lots of women think the world is scarier than it is as well.

As a matter of fact, lots of people view the world as a much scarier place than it actually is. The news tells us about rapes and murders and we get the idea these things are common when they are actually rare. I've been to the city and I've seen the elephants, and nothing bad happened. A woman traveling alone in foreign countries is for the most part just as safe as a woman traveling alone in their own country.


We just disagree about how vulnerable women should feel. Of course there are specific scenarios anyone is right to feel nervous about. But you keep insisting a hotel elevator at 4 am is one of those scenarios and it isn't. Could it be? Sure. As could a particular encounter with a scary guy. But you said dangerous was the default position. I don't agree.

And so we learn that all women are just as safe in their hometowns as they are anywhere else. If you feel threatened anywhere, you really should just stfu because, you see, Ginger would be just fine in that position. Also, it's really bad to speak for all women.
 
Or even more realistic would be, if you are going to proposition women, as your opening to meeting them, don't be surprised if you piss off a few.

As a coda to your non-sarcastic question about men being dogs are losers, I have to say, this is completely opposite to the truth.

Actually propositioning women, maybe not as an opening but within a few sentences in, doesn't piss them off.

Even taking them in one's arms and kissing them, sometimes with no words exchanged, does not produce negative reactions.
 
Agreed. I should think the problem isn't with the primaries, but everyone else interpreting them.

They should sit together on stage with a moderator to guide the conversation as they share their views.

. . .while having a nice cup of coffee.

"I'm sorry I dismissed your concerns. When compared to the plight of some less fortunate women they are small, but that does not make them any less real or valid. You had a good point to make about being made uncomfortable and I shouldn't have dismissed it. That was thoughtless of me."

"Thank you, Richard. I'm sorry I called for a boycott on your books. I over reacted."

"Think nothing of it. More coffee?"

". . ."

Coffee or "coffee" ? Damn. It's a vicious circle.
 
ImaginalDisc said:
They should sit together on stage with a moderator to guide the conversation as they share their views.

. . .while having a nice cup of coffee.

"I'm sorry I dismissed your concerns. When compared to the plight of some less fortunate women they are small, but that does not make them any less real or valid. You had a good point to make about being made uncomfortable and I shouldn't have dismissed it. That was thoughtless of me."

"Thank you, Richard. I'm sorry I called for a boycott on your books. I over reacted."

"Think nothing of it. More coffee?"
Imaginal! Good to see you.

Could this happen at TAM? Maybe so. PZ is there, too.

~~ Paul
 
It's cultural, Checkmite. Such a request would have been perfectly acceptable at Woodstock, for example. It wouldn't have raised an eyebrow in the culture I spent my young adulthood in. Casual sex was the norm.

...however, armed ahead of time with the knowledge that people of different cultures, some of which you know for a fact don't jive on that sort of thing, are around you wouldn't you rather alter your behavior just a little, for the sake of making friends rather than scaring someone off?

I've already answered this, as have other people. EG's request seemed polite enough. Rebecca's expectation he shouldn't have asked was unrealistic. End of story.

I think you're wrong.

The rest was even more unsupportable. There's no evidence EG was "objectifying" Rebecca. There's only been a couple anecdotal testaments that such men are the reason more women don't attend atheist and skeptical events.

And dammit, creeping those few disregardable, "unreasonable" women out and making them not want to be around you is a perfectly acceptable risk for men when there's some sex to be had at the skeptic conference, huh? I mean, at least you can filter the ones that you know won't put out from your Possible Bang List.

Rebecca could use the incident to teach men about approaching her. I'm not sure she was right to claim this applied to all men approaching all women in hotel elevators at 4 am. Guys can ask. I can say no. That seems more fair to me.

If the quote in post #1 in this thread is an accurate excerpt, then I'd say the video was Rebecca talking about her.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom