So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
One of your pet peeves is a preference shared by close to 50% of the human population, not including those men who also find women with muscle unattractive ? :p It's going to peeve you off for a while ;)

Men find women who look athletic highly attractive.

Athletic = muscular.

:)

Don't get me started on osteoporosis.
 
Men find women who look athletic highly attractive.

Athletic = muscular.

:)

Don't get me started on osteoporosis.

No athletic does not mean muscular. There is muscle tone, then there is visible muscle mass.

Did you mention earlier that you are Bi-sexual? That may tint your view on this a teeny bit. (I may be totally confusing you for the poster earlier who is Bi)
 
I'd go further. I'd say there is cognitive dissonance in insisting there's no reason women should be limited from rough sport or even combat duty in the military, while at the same time expecting exceptionalism.

Either women are fragile flowers deserving the last lifeboat, or else it's every carbon based lifeform for themselves.
There's a fine line between the true limitations based on biology which are real and those which are either self imposed or imposed by society or both. I don't think it's all about eating cake you have.

For example, women police, soldiers and fire fighters exist and do great jobs. Maybe there are things some women can't do in those jobs because of physical limitations, but there are also things they can do better. Female soldiers in Afghanistan, for example, can search Afghan women without being culturally offensive. A female police officer can help change male officer's attitudes about domestic violence and while I'm not saying a male officer could not, having a mixed police force helps officers see women as colleagues and equals. It changes the interaction. Women firefighters might be less scary to a frightened child, or perhaps can get into a smaller space than a larger man.

I'm sure I've had a less common experience than many women. I've never been timid or afraid to try stuff. My personal experience has been that what people are saying in this thread should make a woman feel vulnerable, in my experience hasn't. If I was going to drink in the hotel bar until 4 am, why should I then be intimidated by a guy making a pass in the elevator. The two scenarios fit your cognitive dissonance description if one bothers you and the other doesn't.

And before people jump again, it's not the same as saying, if you do [x] you deserve the consequences if someone hurts or assaults you. Rather it's saying, why would EG bother you? It wasn't a big deal.
 
Last edited:
IMO, what Rebecca and Richard should do is open a public 1-1 discussion on this issue on the Skepchick or RDF website. They could even learn something from each other and it would be a great way to rise above the level of discussion that's raging on many sites at the moment. I'm sure they could handle it pretty nicely.

This was pretty much my email to Dawkins, if you like the idea, why not send a message to Rebecca and Richard as well, it would be interesting.
 
And if you can do that, then you can apply for Randi's million.

Are you really trying to suggest that without mind reading capabilities, you have no way of knowing if someone is into you? It's a miracle people hook up at all.
 
How about "don't ask a woman if she wants to have sex when that's the first thing you've ever said to her in her life"? Not reasonable?
Not in all situations, no, not reasonable.

But I have a different take on this. The world is full of socially inept guys. Why would I expect something different? Isn't it better to be able to deal with such a guy than to ask that no guys act that way? The latter is unrealistic.
 
Not in all situations, no, not reasonable.

But I have a different take on this. The world is full of socially inept guys. Why would I expect something different? Isn't it better to be able to deal with such a guy than to ask that no guys act that way? The latter is unrealistic.

Or even more realistic would be, if you are going to proposition women, as your opening to meeting them, don't be surprised if you piss off a few.
 
IMO, what Rebecca and Richard should do is open a public 1-1 discussion on this issue on the Skepchick or RDF website. They could even learn something from each other and it would be a great way to rise above the level of discussion that's raging on many sites at the moment. I'm sure they could handle it pretty nicely.

This was pretty much my email to Dawkins, if you like the idea, why not send a message to Rebecca and Richard as well, it would be interesting.

Agreed. I should think the problem isn't with the primaries, but everyone else interpreting them.

They should sit together on stage with a moderator to guide the conversation as they share their views.

. . .while having a nice cup of coffee.

"I'm sorry I dismissed your concerns. When compared to the plight of some less fortunate women they are small, but that does not make them any less real or valid. You had a good point to make about being made uncomfortable and I shouldn't have dismissed it. That was thoughtless of me."

"Thank you, Richard. I'm sorry I called for a boycott on your books. I over reacted."

"Think nothing of it. More coffee?"

". . ."
 
Last edited:
IMO, what Rebecca and Richard should do is open a public 1-1 discussion on this issue on the Skepchick or RDF website. They could even learn something from each other and it would be a great way to rise above the level of discussion that's raging on many sites at the moment. I'm sure they could handle it pretty nicely.

This was pretty much my email to Dawkins, if you like the idea, why not send a message to Rebecca and Richard as well, it would be interesting.

I always wonder why the mail to just Dawkins and Rebecca?

Why does PZ get a free pass on his "biggus dickus" complex?

Put Phil, PZ, RD and Watson up on the podium with a moderated debate, then we may see the bottom of this :)
 
Last edited:
I always wonder why the mail to just Dawkins and Rebecca?

Why does PZ get a free pass on his "biggus dickus" complex?

P.Z.'s a great writer and a wonderful promoter of science and reason.

However, what do you expect from a pig but a grunt?
 
Pffffffffffft, 100 lbs is light weight.

Most women underestimate how strong they are, and find having muscles and being strong quite distasteful.

I am being a bit pedantic, but this is one of my pet peeves, women avoiding resistance training because they don't want to build muscle.

Singing to the choir - I'm a book dealer. I can carry two banker boxes of books up a flight of stairs. If I've been sorting a large library, I'll look like Olive Oyl sporting Popeye's arms. But most men with my build (5' 9" and scrawny) would still be able to dead-lift more weight even if they hadn't been hauling 40 pound boxes around for three weeks. I've gone toe-to-toe with guys my weight and my height in the ring. if we weren't playing, I'd be dog meat, even if I was more proficient.

This does not in anyway lessen my contribution to society or make me the lesser person. It is simply an aspect of being born with a specific set of chromosomes.
 
Are you really trying to suggest that without mind reading capabilities, you have no way of knowing if someone is into you? It's a miracle people hook up at all.

There are people who are skilled in this, and there are people who aren't.

Unlike some other cultures (Greek, Italian, French), boys and men are not taught these skills. They are supposed to figure them out for themselves. If they do, they're dogs, and if they don't, they're losers and scum.
 
Agreed. I should think the problem isn't with the primaries, but everyone else interpreting them.

They should sit together on stage with a moderator to guide the conversation as they share their views.

. . .while having a nice cup of coffee.

"I'm sorry I dismissed your concerns. When compared to the plight of some less fortunate women they are small, but that does not make them any less real or valid. You had a good point to make about being made uncomfortable and I shouldn't have dismissed it. That was thoughtless of me."

"Thank you, Richard. I'm sorry I called for a boycott on your books. I over reacted."

"Think nothing of it. More coffee?"

". . ."

This is the best thing I've read all day.
 
Last edited:
Not in all situations, no, not reasonable.

Okay, "anywhere outside of a brothel"...?

No, I'm sure you'll think of some uncommon kind of situation that has no bearing on the circumstances of Watson's complaint. How about "within the context of an international meeting dedicated to intellectual issues, where people of backgrounds and cultures vastly different from yours are in attendance"? Is asking someone not to ambush women they've never met before with thinly-veiled requests for sex at a fracking TAM or atheist gathering reasonable then? If not, why not?

But I have a different take on this. The world is full of socially inept guys. Why would I expect something different? Isn't it better to be able to deal with such a guy than to ask that no guys act that way? The latter is unrealistic.

Why does it have to be? Guys are socially inept because they don't know any better. Usually they don't know that a given scenario is unacceptable until they try it, and the situation crashes and burns all over them. Given that, how is a preemptive warning possibly a bad thing? "Don't do X in situation Y." Noted. Right? They learn the same lesson without the humiliation. What's the downside here?

Besides, there's exactly as much evidence that the guy on the elevator was "socially inept" as there is that he chose to intentionally troll Rebecca after hearing her speech about not wanting to be hit on. In fact, when I saw Watson's video that's actually the first possibility that occurred to me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom