So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Belz... said:
My impression is that women are generally not very interested in getting their hands oily while working the innards of motorized vehicles. Just like most men don't want to be hair dressers. I don't see a problem with different genders having different interests.
Ah yes, except there seems to be some sort of requirement these days:

equal treatment can only be given when the two entities are identical

So we keep trying to make everyone the same so we can treat them the same. Why we don't just treat them the same I cannot really imagine.

~~ Paul
 
And so we learn that all women are just as safe in their hometowns as they are anywhere else. If you feel threatened anywhere, you really should just stfu because, you see, Ginger would be just fine in that position. Also, it's really bad to speak for all women.

Except that people are speaking for all women all the time here. When they speak for all women as if they all had the sensibilities of Rebecca Watson, they get away with it. So does Rebecca Watson when she says women this and women that.
 
As a coda to your non-sarcastic question about men being dogs are losers, I have to say, this is completely opposite to the truth.

Actually propositioning women, maybe not as an opening but within a few sentences in, doesn't piss them off.

Even taking them in one's arms and kissing them, sometimes with no words exchanged, does not produce negative reactions.

How very odd. I've had strange men grab me and kiss me. As a swift knee to the nuts is not actually easy under such circumstances, they got the sharp heel to the top of the foot. And some yelling about what the f was wrong with them and, on one notable occasion, chased into the street with a cricket bat.

Oh and then there was this one time I was trying to get a very inebriated girl to the bathroom and some random guy blocked our path until we kissed him on the cheek. "C'mon, just a little one, right there." and got a shirtful of vomit. That was actually pretty awesome.

It seems like a negative to me, but maybe that's what they were going for?
 
P.Z.'s a great writer and a wonderful promoter of science and reason.

However, what do you expect from a pig but a grunt?

I'd say he needs to practice on his reason skills a bit... PZ after all is the one who "facilitated" this issue..
 
Last edited:
I am not bisexual.

Athletic does not mean muscular? What does it mean then?

Muscle tone is more or less a useless word, you either have muscle or you don't.

There is no 'tone' to muscle.

Tonicity really only applies to plants.

What most people mean by 'muscle tone' is that there is a lack of fat and muscle present, which means you have to actually have some muscle.

People have really weird ideas about muscle. We start experiencing atrophy around the age of 30, so unless you actually work on maintaining or building muscle, by the age of 60, men have lost 50% of their muscle mass, it is typically worse for women.

Muscle is metabolic currency, it protects against numerous pathologies, including diabetes, heart disease, osteoporosis and falls in the elderly (of which pathological fractures are far more common than most people realise).

Come on, don't hide behind semantics.

When you say the phrase 'muscular women' the vast majority of people do not picture great legs and a dancer's body. They picture Helga the shot putter. That's why we have terms like muscle tone, it doesn't matter if you personally have different views of common language.

Of course women should have some muscle. They can't help but have some muscle, they wouldn't be able to move otherwise. Unless you're talking actual rounded, noticeable musculature then why even mention it at all? It's a given.

When you say 'men find muscular women attractive' you're only right in the most pedantic sense of exacting language.
 
Come on, don't hide behind semantics.

When you say the phrase 'muscular women' the vast majority of people do not picture great legs and a dancer's body. They picture Helga the shot putter. That's why we have terms like muscle tone, it doesn't matter if you personally have different views of common language.

Of course women should have some muscle. They can't help but have some muscle, they wouldn't be able to move otherwise. Unless you're talking actual rounded, noticeable musculature then why even mention it at all? It's a given.

When you say 'men find muscular women attractive' you're only right in the most pedantic sense of exacting language.

It's OK to generalize.

It's not OK to assume.
 
I'd say he needs to practice on his reason skills a bit... PZ after all is the one who "facilitated" this issue..
My impression, flawed as it probably is in this case, is PZ took the position of many of the men in this thread, taking Rebecca's word for it EG was wrong and this kind of thing really did upset most women. It seemed to me PZ didn't think, as a man, he could disagree with a woman about a female issue like this one.

That was the impression I got from his blog, anyway. I'm not claiming is is correct.
 
It seems like a negative to me, but maybe that's what they were going for?

I wouldn't do it to you. I would only do it to a woman when I'm sure that her body language indicates that she wants me to kiss her. Unless she wants me to take off her bra and feel her up on the dance floor, which sometimes happens.

Which means I'm really good at reading body language, which is no surprise, because I spent a lot of years studying body language, so that I could get this stuff right.

I do something they want, and I want, and it's great fun.

That is, in your terms, "a negative." Or, in other words, it makes me a dog. I'm a dog, because I read the body language right. If I didn't get it right, she'd get pissed off, and I'd be a creep or a loser. But because I get it right, and I only give that kind of attention when I am certain it's wanted, that's what makes me a dog.

You will never, ever want to knee or kick a guy with the skills at reading body language that I have. It isn't going to happen. That's because nobody with those skills will approach you in that way, and that's because they can read body language. They are simply going to stay away from you. (That is, if your self-representation is universally accurate. If it isn't, one might kiss you, and you'll think it's OK.) You probably won't ever notice that guys like that even exist.

Therefore, the only guys who will try to kiss you are those whom you do not want to kiss, and who lack the ability to read body language.
 
Sorry if this has been posted already, but have people seen DJ's comments on the situation and the "TAM Code of Conduct" to appear in this year's program?

We want TAM Las Vegas 2011 to be a welcoming experience for everyone who attends . . .

Please respect your fellow attendees by not disparaging them based on unfair grounds such as race, gender, sexual orientation, and disability; and by not making uninvited sexual comments toward others.

If someone asks you to leave them alone or to otherwise stop a behavior that is directed toward them, please do so. Continued unwanted behavior directed toward another person is harassment. People who harass others or cause multiple complaints of disrespectful behavior may be required to leave without a refund.

Problems can be reported to TAM staff or volunteers who will bring it to the attention of JREF management. A warning will be given when appropriate, but there will be zero tolerance for violence, physical intimidation, and unwanted intentional physical contact.

Let’s make TAM fun for everyone!

http://www.randi.org/site/index.php...-the-corner-some-important-announcements.html

(ETA: DJ mentions that this was drafted a couple of months ago--I wonder what drove that?)
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't do it to you. I would only do it to a woman when I'm sure that her body language indicates that she wants me to kiss her. Unless she wants me to take off her bra and feel her up on the dance floor, which sometimes happens.

Which means I'm really good at reading body language, which is no surprise, because I spent a lot of years studying body language, so that I could get this stuff right.

I do something they want, and I want, and it's great fun.

That is, in your terms, "a negative." Or, in other words, it makes me a dog. I'm a dog, because I read the body language right. If I didn't get it right, she'd get pissed off, and I'd be a creep or a loser. But because I get it right, and I only give that kind of attention when I am certain it's wanted, that's what makes me a dog.

You will never, ever want to knee or kick a guy with the skills at reading body language that I have. It isn't going to happen. That's because nobody with those skills will approach you in that way, and that's because they can read body language. They are simply going to stay away from you. (That is, if your self-representation is universally accurate. If it isn't, one might kiss you, and you'll think it's OK.) You probably won't ever notice that guys like that even exist.

Therefore, the only guys who will try to kiss you are those whom you do not want to kiss, and who lack the ability to read body language.

Two of those guys came up behind me or to the side of me. I had no chance to make any opinion of them before they started slobbering on me.

There has never been an example of someone accosting me without consent and getting away with it because I found them attractive. Doing something like that makes them unattractive. The nicest thing I might have thought after calming down was "It's really too bad he's an ass."

Maybe you've got magic body-language reading skills. Maybe the women you accosted didn't want to say anything because they didn't want to seem like a bitch. But do you really think that "Go ahead! Kiss strangers with no other introduction! They like it!" is generally good advice? You're telling people that it's OK to assault their fellow human beings which is, btw, illegal.
 
Ah yes, except there seems to be some sort of requirement these days:

equal treatment can only be given when the two entities are identical

So we keep trying to make everyone the same so we can treat them the same. Why we don't just treat them the same I cannot really imagine.

~~ Paul

Treating them the same would mean some career paths would not be available for a woman and people value equal opportunity.
 
Well I like DJ's comments. But I find the printed warning a bit mind-numbing.

We want TAM Las Vegas 2011 to be a welcoming experience for everyone who attends . . .

Please respect your fellow attendees by not disparaging them based on unfair grounds such as race, gender, sexual orientation, and disability; and by not making uninvited sexual comments toward others.

OK - so to examine the sort of behaviour RW wants to address (being spoken to in elevators at 0400h, with a possible sexual innuendo) - I don't think EG's actions would break this edict. He make an uninvited comment in an elevator. Rebecca felt that was 'sexualized' but I think it would be pretty hard to prove in a court of law.

If someone asks you to leave them alone or to otherwise stop a behavior that is directed toward them, please do so. Continued unwanted behavior directed toward another person is harassment. People who harass others or cause multiple complaints of disrespectful behavior may be required to leave without a refund.

Is this currently a problem with TAM? Has it ever been in the past? Continued, harassing behaviour? Certainly I've never witnessed it, nor been a part of it. If its not a problem, then why are we printing such a warning? It sort of implies that we have this problem in existence today, if we need to publish an admonition in the program.

Problems can be reported to TAM staff or volunteers who will bring it to the attention of JREF management. A warning will be given when appropriate, but there will be zero tolerance for violence, physical intimidation, and unwanted intentional physical contact.

Wow - looks like we're heading down a slippery slope here of a Forum-esque MA for TAM behaviour, what is 'warning' worthy and what is 'booted without refund' worthy. The comments about violence, physical intimidation & unwanted contact - those areas are either all clearly governed by laws, and are broader security / policing issues. Again, printing them seems to send an odd message if some random person picks up one of our programs, and have there been any reported incidents of this kind in previous TAMs? Its one thing to be slightly creeped out by an unwanted leer or question, but what is being cautioned here sounds like things you could actually consider pressing charges.

Let’s make TAM fun for everyone!

Obviously. But it kind of sets a very strange tone that we need to print what should be clearly understood as the right way to conduct yourself when interacting with humans.
 
Well I like DJ's comments. But I find the printed warning a bit mind-numbing.

<snip>

...it kind of sets a very strange tone that we need to print what should be clearly understood as the right way to conduct yourself when interacting with humans.


I agree.
 
Last edited:
He make an uninvited comment in an elevator. Rebecca felt that was 'sexualized' but I think it would be pretty hard to prove in a court of law.

This is one of the things about this thread that I just can't believe, all of you who are pretending to be so naive and surprised that anyone would consider the situation, of a man asking a woman to come alone to his hotel room in the middle of the night, to have any possible sexual connotation.

Is this currently a problem with TAM? Has it ever been in the past? Continued, harassing behaviour? Certainly I've never witnessed it, nor been a part of it. If its not a problem, then why are we printing such a warning?

Ounce of prevention? The situation has come up in discussion; they've taken the initiative to immediately issue a policy. Is it a bad policy?
 
This is one of the things about this thread that I just can't believe, all of you who are pretending to be so naive and surprised that anyone would consider the situation, of a man asking a woman to come alone to his hotel room in the middle of the night, to have any possible sexual connotation.

Perhaps I wasn't clear enough what I meant. Whether or not the comment had a sexual connotation or not, is subjective. Rebecca thought it was and was bothered by it, that is really the crux of the issue. If now the JREF is going to be issuing yellow cards and red cards, and actively getting involved in policing complaints, someone is going to have to be the judge. And, based on the limited evidence (one report, no witnesses) and the actual words used, objectively I would be hard-pressed to say 'That was an univited sexual comment'. He didn't say 'Nice knockers, Becks'. He (perhaps very deliberately) chose words that could be equally sexually interpreted and equally innocuous. The issue is currently such a hot potato and controversial, that I am pretty sure that whoever is going to 'rule' on the complaints when they're brought forward, is very likely going to side with the accuser - because otherwise they know they're going to be lambasted all over the internet & perhaps mainstream media.


Ounce of prevention? The situation has come up in discussion; they've taken the initiative to immediately issue a policy. Is it a bad policy?

Its not a bad policy - to a normal human being, it is an implied policy when you walk out the door. I expect to behave the same way when I go to work, when I go to a restaurant, when I go to the movies. I don't need a written warning thrust at me to remind me to be a good boy. And if I went to an event for the first time, and there on page 1 or the back of the program, there is some weird edict talking about harassment and violence towards others while at a blody conference about science, atheism, and skeptics, I would wonder strongly at the sorts of nutters I was choosing to hang out with.
 
Last edited:
Ounce of prevention? The situation has come up in discussion; they've taken the initiative to immediately issue a policy. Is it a bad policy?


It's not a bad policy in that we would hope everyone does behave in this way. But why does it need to be spelled out in the front of the program? It certainly makes it appear as if people not following these guidelines has been a significant problem in the past, and that it goes much beyond Elevatorgate (otherwise, why say it was drafted back in May?).


ETA: Yeah, what Antiquehunter said.
 
Last edited:
Please respect your fellow attendees by not disparaging them based on unfair grounds such as race, gender, sexual orientation, and disability; and by not making uninvited sexual comments toward others.

I note that its apparently OK to disparage someone on the fair ground of religion, since that isn't mentioned in the 'Eat your Vegetables' warning. There are a number of people who are religious and/or are not atheists that attend TAM. I wonder if any of them are scared by this oversight? And I wonder if any busybody mainstream media type reporting on the nuttiness of skeptics and the downfall of Richard Dawkins will pick up on that?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom