So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Its not a bad policy - to a normal human being, it is an implied policy when you walk out the door. I expect to behave the same way when I go to work, when I go to a restaurant, when I go to the movies. I don't need a written warning thrust at me to remind me to be a good boy. And if I went to an event for the first time, and there on page 1 or the back of the program, there is some weird edict talking about harassment and violence towards others while at a blody conference about science, atheism, and skeptics, I would wonder strongly at the sorts of nutters I was choosing to hang out with.

And at the same time, they chose to do this long before elevatorgate and prior to this there was some talk of women feeling uncomfortable. So maybe that implied policy hasn't been doing the job? And maybe, some people have found themselves at a conference wondering what sort of nutters they had chosen to hang out with.
 
I note that its apparently OK to disparage someone on the fair ground of religion, since that isn't mentioned in the 'Eat your Vegetables' warning. There are a number of people who are religious and/or are not atheists that attend TAM. I wonder if any of them are scared by this oversight? And I wonder if any busybody mainstream media type reporting on the nuttiness of skeptics and the downfall of Richard Dawkins will pick up on that?

It is also fair game to judge them on being a vegetarian, a republican, having cruddy taste in t-shirts, enjoying model trains as a hobby and a host of other attributes that people have a choice in selecting.
 
And at the same time, they chose to do this long before elevatorgate and prior to this there was some talk of women feeling uncomfortable. So maybe that implied policy hasn't been doing the job? And maybe, some people have found themselves at a conference wondering what sort of nutters they had chosen to hang out with.

Boo - this warning has very little to do with women who may feel uncomfortable. It pretty specifically suggests that we can't behave like caged animals and attack each other violently, harrassingly, or in ways where you could probably get criminally charged.

If the intention is to address the concerns that some female posters have raised in this thread about unwanted leering / pickup attempts - then this isn't the right warning to achieve that.
 
It is also fair game to judge them on being a vegetarian, a republican, having cruddy taste in t-shirts, enjoying model trains as a hobby and a host of other attributes that people have a choice in selecting.

Obviously. However if you compare this warning to other large anti-discriminatory warnings, usually one finds religion mentioned. I don't think the UN suggests model train hobbyists are a relevant subgroup to put in its charters, but they seem to include everyone else the JREF does. Except they add religion.
 
I move that the above warning be struck and replaced with the following:

picture.php
 
Boo - this warning has very little to do with women who may feel uncomfortable. It pretty specifically suggests that we can't behave like caged animals and attack each other violently, harrassingly, or in ways where you could probably get criminally charged.

If the intention is to address the concerns that some female posters have raised in this thread about unwanted leering / pickup attempts - then this isn't the right warning to achieve that.

There are people, in this very thread, who think that propositioning a woman without any other introduction is a time honored tradition that more often leads to sexual satisfaction for both, then dismay or embarrassment to either.

There's a guy, in this thread, just a small ways up saying that it's OK to hug and kiss total strangers if you are good enough at reading their body language.

There are people who didn't think that any woman has any reason to feel uncomfortable in any elevator, ever. Do you think that being in any small enclosed space with someone who is backing away will change their mind?

Oh and then there's Buzzo who has adopted "Hitting on someone isn't rape!" as his rallying cry for TAM 9. In the past people have asked that he be barred for his behavior. Now he's got internet-rage logic on his side.
 
Last edited:
If someone invites you to make a sexual comment can you still do it if they fall asleep?
 
There are people, in this very thread, who think that propositioning a woman without any other introduction is a time honored tradition that more often leads to sexual satisfaction for both, then dismay or embarrassment to either.

I don't remember reading that. Link, please ? Otherwise it smells of straw.
 
There are people, in this very thread, who think that propositioning a woman without any other introduction is a time honored tradition that more often leads to sexual satisfaction for both, then dismay or embarrassment to either.

There's a guy, in this thread, just a small ways up saying that it's OK to hug and kiss total strangers if you are good enough at reading their body language.

There are people who didn't think that any woman has any reason to feel uncomfortable in any elevator, ever. Do you think that being in any small enclosed space with someone who is backing away will change their mind?

Oh and then there's Buzzo who has adopted "Hitting on someone isn't rape!" as his rallying cry for TAM 9. In the past people have asked that he be barred for his behavior. Now he's got internet-rage logic on his side.

Even if all that is the case, please explain to me how the warning, how it is worded, is going to stop any of these highly traumatic situations you describe.

<snip>... and by not making uninvited sexual comments toward others.

If someone asks you to leave them alone or to otherwise stop a behavior that is directed toward them, please do so. Continued unwanted behavior directed toward another person is harassment. People who harass others or cause multiple complaints of disrespectful behavior may be required to leave without a refund.

Problems can be reported to TAM staff or volunteers who will bring it to the attention of JREF management. A warning will be given when appropriate, but there will be zero tolerance for violence, physical intimidation, and unwanted intentional physical contact.

Look - I am not a 'huggy' kind of person, but I often receive hugs from people who are the kind of people who like to give hugs. I grin, bear it, pat them on the back, smile, and deal with it. Now with this warning, the 'huggers' out there are thinking 'Oh noes! Is that 'unwanted intentional physical contact'? Or 'Its just a hug, who could get mad about that?' And now we have a written-down rule saying that you can go to TAM staff/volunteers to complain, who will escalate it to 'JREF Management' and someone will rule whether or not the hugger gets a warning, or gets shown the door. Without any printed rules / guidelines (which now I'm sure there will need to be a subcommittee formed...)

Lovely context for what used to be a fun and somewhat intellectual get together.
 
My point is that your schtick is that we need to actively seek out women to join any area that is lacking in women. I am arguing that some interests are naturally more attractive to one sex over another. Furthermore, there is a tipping point where you change things so much to lure in a new crowd, that the old crowd gets pushed out.

I point I was trying to make specifically about your manga argument was that in Japan they have a healthy sub-industry of manga purely targeted at women. They didn't just twist regular manga until it magically became popular with large sections of the female population.

Men should not cut women out of anything, or purposefully make them feel uncomfortable. However, I don't think it should be purely up to men to bend over backwards to bring women in to male-centric groups.

As skepticism grows more mainstream expect sub-groups to spring up.

While I would not have called Tranewreck's earlier posts "disingenuous" or "convenient", terms which rudely and unjustifiably impute intention to deceive rather than merely having a different point of view, I was going to post a substantially similar comment.

I could be wrong but I don't think that there would be equally large numbers of women at Western comic book conventions geeking out over X-Men and Batman and whatnot if it was not for cultural prejudice specifically against women reading comics. I suspect that for much broader and deeper reasons, which could equally well be biological or cultural, women are less likely to want to geek out over that subject matter.

Organised skepticism is about getting together to mock and/or pick fights with easy targets because they are saying really stupid things. That seems to appeal more to bearded curmudgeons, as I believe one woman put it, than to women.

I think that organised skepticism is important and valuable because those easy targets still deserve to be kicked in, and because large numbers of gullible people still believe in those really stupid things. However being a sewage worker is also important and valuable and that isn't on the top of everyone's list of dream jobs.

Maybe there's a way to get more women, when they find out about why these claims are stupid, to say "I want to hang out with people and talk about why these claims are stupid!" rather than "That's interesting, but now I'll go do something else". I'm not sure what it is though.
 
I didn't mean it to be taking as a direct quote from anyone. It was a concise paraphrasing of the sentiments I've seen expressed by multiple women who were posting about their experiences having attended such conferences and why they won't be going back. Just because you haven't read such comments (they were on the feminist blogs talking about this matter rather the atheist blogs) doesn't mean they aren't out there.

You can conclude that they don't exist or are so uncommon as to be irrelevant to the issue of why more women aren't attending such conferences, but that is pretty much like deciding not to look at evidence that's available. Further, it seems to me to be directly contradicted by what you posted in #1020 What is it that you think those men are doing that that results in those skeptical Australian women wanting nothing to do with their organization?

I think you owe it to your readers here to make that sort of detail plain rather than posting what looks exactly like a claim that people here are saying that it women don't want to be groped frequently that they should stay away from skeptical gatherings, and then modifying it when you get called out for it.

However given that you haven't given us any links, and this is all based on your fuzzy mental picture of the debate rather than any specific people or comments, I'm somewhat skeptical that a significant number of people ever said this.

As for why the women I know don't attend Australian Skeptics meetings, it's not because when they did attend they were getting frequently groped. Since I didn't say anything of the sort,you're doing more of that fuzzy-picture guesswork rather than remembering what people actually said if you think what my remark about women avoiding AS "directly contradicted" my skepticism about women being groped with high frequency.

They may not be the majority, but when they include a major leader of the movement, I think it's a reasonable conclusion that they are representative of a large faction, not a fringe element.

Do you think that Dawkins responds to every feminist opinion that way? Or only to a subset of feminist opinions he thinks are over-precious and irrational?

Remember your claim was that feminist opinions attracted ridicule and rape threats, not just that stupid feminist opinions did so.
 
So how am I supposed to get sex, if I'm not allowed to ask for it?

I have actually found the best way to ask is "Can I **** you" It cuts out all the ambiguity, all the sexism, and all the pseudo sexism.
 
There's also the context: she had just finished speaking about this very issue, and a few minutes later she gets propositioned in an elevator. If I give a speech about how much I hate onions, and on the way to my room someone intercepts me and tries to get me to eat a big heaping plateful of roasted onions, I have a right to conclude that said person doesn't give a crap about what I think or feel -- they just want me to eat their onions.

Or the person didn't hear your speech and is interested in speaking about onions.
 
When you have her cornered in an elevator, at 4am and she's just got done telling a crowd you were a part of not to do things like that.

Context is kinda important here.

Only if the person knows what you just got talking about. Why the hell would you assume they did?
 
I'm coming to this thread/topic a bit late, but it reminded me of a recent event in my own life, so I thought I'd share... and also share my thoughts on the type of incident involved, here.

I had been in the habit of going through the Taco Bell drive through for "lunch" (actually at 9pm, I work 2nd shift) every day. One day, out of the blue, the drive through attendant (the one who had served me more often than not) passed me a note with my receipt. It said something to the tune of "hey, do you have a girlfriend or wife? Just say your answer."

Now, I didn't actually read that note until after I left the drive through... I kind of had the idea of what passing a note might mean, and didn't particularly want to acknowledge it right away, in this case. So, anyway, I didn't answer the note I didn't read, but there was a second note in the bag. In this one she basically gave me her phone number, and asked that I call her.

This was a woman that I had absolutely no interest in. While I'm sure she's probably a nice girl, the only things I know about her is that she outweighs me by about 150 lbs (for reference, I weigh about 200... at 6'4", and not overweight at all for my build), and that she has a tendency to forget to give me a straw when I go through the drive through. Although I do happen to be single and totally available at the moment, I was not interested at all in this case.

Admittedly, she was not asking me for sex... but still, the difference between asking indirectly for sex and trying to "hook up" tends to be fairly small.

My question is, do I now need to talk about how she did something horribly wrong? What if it was someone who I was attracted to who did the same thing? Knowing myself, I am quite certain that her interest in me was not the problem, nor did I have a problem with her methods. The problem was who she was.

Drawing unwanted attention from someone you are not particularly attracted to can be an awkward thing, to say the least. That was the last time I went there for my lunch break... there are other places to get food, and I really don't want to remember the incident every day when I go through her drive through.

...But I don't really feel the need to put her down for improper behavior, either. I don't think that she is sexist in any way, nor do I think it was particularly rude. I am sure that the manager of the place might find it a bit improper, but I don't feel that I have been wronged in any way. If anything, I am flattered that she would take such a risk. Yes, it was strange and awkward, but I don't feel the need to categorize or demonize her for her behavior at all.
 
Rebecca Watson the sceptical attention whore. At it again.



ETA: I think I just got put on a bunch of ignore lists.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom