So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Except that there is no Skepchick party this year. There is no new skepchick calendar. On a blog post written 5 years ago that objectified two women, Watson has added an apology because it was inappropriate.

People change. They get new information, they have different experiences and this gives them a different outlook on the world. It's a very good thing. I'm not sure the human race could survive if we stopped learning upon reaching physical maturity.

Watson's gone from "I'm smart and I'm sexy." to "OK, enough with the sexy already. Sheesh!" in just a few years. If people have been following her sporadically (the most likely scenario), they wouldn't understand that it is a process and yes, it would seem very hypocritical.

It's as if she was a drunk who became a recovered alcoholic and is now saying "I don't drink anymore." And teh interwebs are replying "But, but there's pictures of you boozing it up all over the internet!! You're a lush!!"

Thanks for that information. I haven't followed skepchick closely.

I can understand how perspectives and attitudes might change, but the internet is fairly unforgiving for things that have gone before.

The majority of images of me on the web are in a bikini from either bodybuilding competitions or art performances/installations, my avatar is one such image, so I can relate to how people might have unusual perceptions based on one or two photographs.
 
Didn't she turn elevator guy into what is wrong with the skeptic movement though? The EG is the reason women aren't showing up if you will..

(which i would say is bogus.. and hope she isn't trying to make that assertion..)

After saying that everyone at the conference was great and that she had a very nice time, she described the elevator incident and added.

"Um, just a word to wise here, guys, uh, don't do that. You know, I don't really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I'll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4:00 am, in a hotel elevator, with you, just you, and -- don't invite me back to your hotel room right after I finish talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner."
 
He is the cause of both the discomfort to her and the damage to his esteem. A guy who can't get past the fact that he didn't hit on a strange woman in an elevator at 4 AM needs to reevaluate his priorities.

It seems that she should take some responsibility for her feelings, I think you are being a bit harsh on pathetic loser men, certainly allowances are made for a whole variety of people with physical and mental disabilities, why not depressed, socially awkward losers.
 
He is the cause of both the discomfort to her and the damage to his esteem. A guy who can't get past the fact that he didn't hit on a strange woman in an elevator at 4 AM needs to reevaluate his priorities.

There really are a lot of credits being given to this guy; maybe he's got social anxiety disorder, maybe he's got aspergers, maybe he's got self esteem issues. If we are going to keep laying out possibilities; how are they any more credible than RW's feeling on the matter and he was just looking to get her in the room and have sex? She was there; we don't know if his body language spoke more about what he was asking for. If it's possible that they guy was a high functioning autistic, it's equally possible that he was a player and planned on high fiving himself on FB announcing that he nailed Rebecca Watson. They are all irrelavent. What we know is that Rebecca said the exchange was not appreciated and she, as an individual, has the right to say, in what ever manner she pleases, "don't do that!"
 
It seems that she should take some responsibility for her feelings, I think you are being a bit harsh on pathetic loser men, certainly allowances are made for a whole variety of people with physical and mental disabilities, why not depressed, socially awkward losers.

My god, the dorks! Won't somebody please, please think of the dorks!

ETA: This is a movement that prides it's self on being more rational than the average human. They hold conferences so that everyone can hang around, listen to incredibly intelligent people, talk to incredibly intelligent people and reaffirm how incredibly smart and rational they all are.

However, if they are socially awkward losers, they are not expected to learn anything from a fairly benign example of behavior that makes their fellow skeptics uncomfortable.
 
Last edited:
Ah that the world was so black and white. That would really make things so much easier. But, of course, it's grey and worse, shades of grey that blur into each other and overlap and have no real boundaries. Annoying, aint it.

All humans are fragile flowers deserving the last lifeboat who are simultaneously fighting tooth and nail to get into it. We tend to forget that this sinking ship actually has enough lifeboats. It will take a bit of compromise in order to get everyone settled.

A smaller percentage of women will be able to lift 100 pounds. A larger percentage of men could do it with ease. A larger percentage of women could handle delicate detail work that needed smaller hands. A smaller percentage of men could do the same work. You can't make a general measure of worth for all people from either the ability to lift 100 pounds or the ability to do detail work.

Shifting the world around to make more women lift 100 pounds or more men do detail work doesn't make sense. Shifting it around to exploit the natural gifts of both sexes is a lot more practical.

Pffffffffffft, 100 lbs is light weight.

Most women underestimate how strong they are, and find having muscles and being strong quite distasteful.

I am being a bit pedantic, but this is one of my pet peeves, women avoiding resistance training because they don't want to build muscle.
 
Women limit themselves when they believe they are limited. Your posts say you perceive women as much more limited than they truly are.

Again, you're desperately trying to broaden my claim. When a single man and a single woman are in an isolated setting, that women is not out of her mind to be apprehensive. Men should be able to realize this and behave appropriately (there is a wide range of appropriate behavior, it's not difficult to figure it out).

That's the extent of my argument on this score.

The rational apprehension is supported by the factual reality of sexual assault statistics. It's a radical stretch to conclude that based on that, I think "women are limited."

A couple of years ago there was a series of robberies at gunpoint in my neighborhood. I walk around at all hours, to bars, to friends' houses, whatever. The little crime spree culminated in a murder. Shortly after that murder, I was walking home from a bar at 2 or 3 in the morning, I noticed two guys were walking behind me. The followed me around a corner. When I glanced back, I became apprehensive, I quickened my pace. When I made my next turn, they kept going, and that was that.

I would say my apprehension in that context wasn't insane. It was a perfectly valid reaction given the circumstances. Does that mean I think men are limited? I could easily have been victimized in that circumstance, and if those two were the gun-point robbers, there wouldn't be a whole hell of a lot I could do.

I honestly have no idea what you're reading in my posts that are causing you to draw the conclusions you are.
 
Back to the basics - this isn't about all women any more then it is about all men. Watson's original video - everyone at the conference was great, there was just this one guy, he made me feel uncomfortable because of this specific context. Don't be that guy."
Except that by definition that's inherently aimed at a) that guy, but also b) every other man who wasn't at the conference (and perhaps some who were). It comes across as a slightly hysterical self-obsessed warning, not well-meaning advice.
 
Sometimes I feel sorry for the dorks.

So do I. It sucks to be socially awkward. I've made people uncomfortable myself. The difference is that I have worked very hard to keep it to a minimum and I have apologized when it's happened.

You don't expect any of that from the dorks.
 
This thread is now huge but buried somewhere in it is a video of the talk that Rebecca gave at the conference while seated next to Dawkins.

She discussed being an atheist activist while female and how that gave her a slightly different experience than her male colleges, including unique negatives like rape threats.

For the record, these are not always the topics that leave a woman wet and waiting for strange men in elevators. In fact, I will go so far as to say that many times it has the exact opposite effect.

But was the bar exclusive access for people from the meeting?

Or could some poor schmuck wander in to the bar, take some minor part in a discussion about religion, and hit on the reasonably attractive gal in the emo glasses afterwards?
 
My point is that your schtick is that we need to actively seek out women to join any area that is lacking in women.

Again, it's a contingent point. IF you want more women around, THEN we have a clear model of how to procede. If you don't, it doesn't matter.

I am arguing that some interests are naturally more attractive to one sex over another.

This you haven't proven. The only example you've brought up expressly rejects that contention.

Furthermore, there is a tipping point where you change things so much to lure in a new crowd, that the old crowd gets pushed out.

Yes, that's an issue I raised in my first post. It might happen. Though an observation of the relative examples would tend to show that including women in an activity doesn't actually cause men to quit.

I point I was trying to make specifically about your manga argument was that in Japan they have a healthy sub-industry of manga purely targeted at women. They didn't just twist regular manga until it magically became popular with large sections of the female population.

Right, but that's my point as well. Comic books are not something that is only attractive to men. When comic books are created with women in mind, they really like them. Then, if you'll notice in Japanese popular culture, a huge number of Manga/Anime that appeals to both genders at the same time start being produced. I'd imagine if you looked at the most popular Japanese products of the last 5-10 years, the majority of them have a fairly evenly distributed fan base.

Men should not cut women out of anything, or purposefully make them feel uncomfortable. However, I don't think it should be purely up to men to bend over backwards to bring women in to male-centric groups.

Again, IF you want more women around, THEN we have models for how to move forward. You're not really arguing against my position. IF you DON'T want women around, keep doing what you're doing. Maybe some will join, but it certainly won't be a quick or sizeable changeover.

In all honesty, I would bet that the vast majority of women in the United States (and probably the rest of the Western world) just don't have any opinion about the skeptical community. It's not a matter of them actively choosing against it, the larger number just hasn't been exposed in any real way.

As skepticism grows more mainstream expect sub-groups to spring up.

Sure, maybe it will happen naturally, but again, if we want to involve women, we have examples of what to do. If you are indifferent, then obviously there's no reason to adopt the methods that have proven themself effective.
 
This thread is now huge but buried somewhere in it is a video of the talk that Rebecca gave at the conference while seated next to Dawkins.

She discussed being an atheist activist while female and how that gave her a slightly different experience than her male colleges, including unique negatives like rape threats.

For the record, these are not always the topics that leave a woman wet and waiting for strange men in elevators. In fact, I will go so far as to say that many times it has the exact opposite effect.

My post was asking you whether this man was actually at the lecture.
 
She discussed being an atheist activist while female and how that gave her a slightly different experience than her male colleges, including unique negatives like rape threats.

In many respects, this is just preaching to the choir. In our own ways we all get threatened because of our actions or beliefs. People who are more visible will have more visible threats. Sam Harris travels with a security details because of death threats.. Richard Dawkins has published and read some of his hat email as well.

Is her circumstances of being a vocal skeptic really what she spoke to the atheist meeting about? Did the entire thing get posted to youtube or just specific segments?

For the record, these are not always the topics that leave a woman wet and waiting for strange men in elevators. In fact, I will go so far as to say that many times it has the exact opposite effect.

This assumes a lot and the assumptions don't really jive up to be a "bad timing guy?"
 
There is really nothing wrong with looking to hook up with someone, but for the sake of avoiding awkwardness between the both of you, look for some signal that the other person is receptive to your advances before you proposition them.

And if you can do that, then you can apply for Randi's million.
 
I am being a bit pedantic, but this is one of my pet peeves, women avoiding resistance training because they don't want to build muscle.

One of your pet peeves is a preference shared by close to 50% of the human population, not including those men who also find women with muscle unattractive ? :p It's going to peeve you off for a while ;)
 
That's not debatable. On the other hand, if she didn't like the feeling of being propositioned by a stranger in an elevator, is there really anything wrong with making that known publicly, to prevent that moment from happening again?

No; there is nothing wrong with that, and as I've said, Watson's original comments were fine, at least as far as I'm concerned.

Now, asking people not to do something might not be very bright. In my experience, if you make a general comment asking people not to do X, it generally attracts people who want to do X.

Still, it isn't wrong or unjustifiable. It might be inaccurate or a bad strategy. It might be a good strategy, but one designed to produce a different kind of social interaction from the one that is generally assumed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom