So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe someone who is better at photoshop could change that to read 'Just because she's in an elevator doesn't mean she wants to...'

(again - large ;) )
 
Then she started ranting about misogyny and calling for all TRUE feminists to boycott people to soothe her petty ego.

And that was bad. I've already disagreed with it, especially the Dawkins boycott, at length.

But even if she was beating babies with kittens and using their blood to write "Don't be that guy!" her original statement is still valid. Even if she hadn't dumped gasoline on the fire, this argument would have still happened. it's been lurking.
 
Back to the basics - this isn't about all women any more then it is about all men. Watson's original video - everyone at the conference was great, there was just this one guy, he made me feel uncomfortable because of this specific context. Don't be that guy."

Watson's original video was fine. If this had been only about that, we wouldn't have this conversation.

It's grown beyond that, and this has included Watson's profligate and IMO inappropriate accusations of misogyny toward those who do not agree with her position in a lickspittle fashion. There is a demand here that she be treated as the spokeswoman for all women in general.

This does not even include all the things that other people have said, which IMO is the overwhelming bulk.
 
When it is a reasonable request, yes, when it is " Don't ask a women if she wants to have sex." no.

How about, "when I just gave a talk about how I don't like being objectified and sexualized at conventions, don't propose me to an activity that could easily be interpreted for sex in an elevator at 4AM after I just said I was tired and was going to bed"? Sounds reasonable to me, but it's a bit more long-winded. Guess it's easier to just strip down those annoying details so we can beat down on a simplified version of the "request"...

Then she started ranting about misogyny and calling for all TRUE feminists to boycott people to soothe her petty ego.
I do agree that this part was just idiotic. Dawkins was insensitive, perhaps a bit dense, regarding the original video, but Rebecca's reaction to that was just... dare I say, hysterical. Pity, cause I was completely on her side before that.
 
I think its important to add that the use of the word 'True' was not made by Rebecca, in the context of the 'boycott'. Not really that big a deal, but lets not get accused of putting words in her mouth.

ETA: And thanks to whomever it was that point this out to me when we were originally discussing the 'boycott'.
 
everyone at the conference was great, there was just this one guy, he made me feel uncomfortable because of this specific context. Don't be that guy."

With the context being don't hit on me if I don't find you attractive, if she found the guy very attractive, the comfort levels would have been completely different.

From the guy's point of view it can be bad for self esteem to assume women will find you unattractive and is it better he say nothing and avoid a few seconds of discomfort on her part, or to say something to avoid weeks of regret and discomfort on his part and damage to his esteem.
 
I'm not sure that I understand you. My pet projects wouldn't be relevant as they have nothing to do with the skeptical movement.



Oh. My pet projects mostly involve women in developing countries, or those who lack resources closer to home. No consequences to my friends and family. We're already privileged.



Well, to be honest, I don't give a flying **** if women get hit on at a skeptic's conference compared to a 14 year old girl about to give birth to her third child unattended by even a mid-wife, even though it may spare me the horror of being obliged to turn down a proposition myself.



Interesting take on it.

Linda

Maybe it's because I'm involved with a lot of different things but I have a hard time with dismissing smaller for larger (no, really!) Maternal mortality rates in developing countries deserve priority over privileged women in elevators but it doesn't negate the importance of having a discussion about common average sexism within a movement.

At the same time, I have missed any post of yours regarding maternal mortality rates and that is regrettable. Have there been too few of them? bad timing? Do you feel that this is not the place for it? So much of the stuff I do outside this forum, the stuff that I really care about isn't discussed here, maybe tossed into the mix of other conversations and let go. This just isn't the place for it. Maybe feminism is the one of the few subjects that gets a response, even though it is often a negative one.

Great, now I have to go think.
 
How about, "when I just gave a talk about how I don't like being objectified and sexualized at conventions, don't propose me to an activity that could easily be interpreted for sex in an elevator at 4AM after I just said I was tired and was going to bed"?

But that is assuming that he heard the conversation. The thread's gotten pretty big. Have we established that he did ?
 
How about, "when I just gave a talk about how I don't like being objectified and sexualized at conventions, don't propose me to an activity that could easily be interpreted for sex in an elevator at 4AM after I just said I was tired and was going to bed"? Sounds reasonable to me, but it's a bit more long-winded. Guess it's easier to just strip down those annoying details so we can beat down on a simplified version of the "request"...

It's a lot simpler to say, "I'm tired, and I want to go to bed." And then he says "OK."

Apparently, this is what happened.
 
Watson's original video was fine. If this had been only about that, we wouldn't have this conversation.

It's grown beyond that, and this has included Watson's profligate and IMO inappropriate accusations of misogyny toward those who do not agree with her position in a lickspittle fashion. There is a demand here that she be treated as the spokeswoman for all women in general.

This does not even include all the things that other people have said, which IMO is the overwhelming bulk.

Well, it's kinda weird. On the skepchick site there are letters to Dawkins regarding his response from various folk. Everywhere that this has been debated, it's fairly split between those who agree and those who don't. Watson is speaking for quite a lot of people and she recognizes that but I don't think she has ever said that she is speaking for all women.

I wish with all my heart that this discussion had been different in so many ways. But it just doesn't work that way. If there is a problem, there is a lot of very rational discourse for a while and nothing happens. Then something catchy comes along and it blows up. Within the explosion, there's a lot of emotion, hyperbole, generalizations, finger-pointing, jokes and other rhetoric. Then it blows over, there's a last gasp of rational discussion and things change, slightly. Such a tiny bit that the huge mess hardly seems worth it. Until next time.
 
But that is assuming that he heard the conversation. The thread's gotten pretty big. Have we established that he did ?

She was seated on a panel next to Dawkins when she gave her talk. It seems unlikely that someone who paid to be there would miss the key-note speaker.
 
Maybe it's because I'm involved with a lot of different things but I have a hard time with dismissing smaller for larger (no, really!) Maternal mortality rates in developing countries deserve priority over privileged women in elevators but it doesn't negate the importance of having a discussion about common average sexism within a movement.

So what is this "common average sexisim within a movement" you speak of?

I think what a lot of people are questioning is that if the "EG" is the worst of it, can you really quantify that as "common average sexisim within a movement"?

Is it worse? is there something really wrong with people that show up to these things?
 
When it is a reasonable request, yes, when it is " Don't ask a women if she wants to have sex." no.

Even RW flat out said this was not the intent of her statement. You can't always lay out all the specific criteria for being creepy but under these particular circumstances, in their entirety, she is justified in feeling creeped out by the guy.

There is really nothing wrong with looking to hook up with someone, but for the sake of avoiding awkwardness between the both of you, look for some signal that the other person is receptive to your advances before you proposition them.
 
She was seated on a panel next to Dawkins when she gave her talk. It seems unlikely that someone who paid to be there would miss the key-note speaker.

Yeah but who really listens when a woman speaks, their voice is all high and whiny.
 
It's a lot simpler to say, "I'm tired, and I want to go to bed." And then he says "OK."

Apparently, this is what happened.

That's not debatable. On the other hand, if she didn't like the feeling of being propositioned by a stranger in an elevator, is there really anything wrong with making that known publicly, to prevent that moment from happening again?
 
With the context being don't hit on me if I don't find you attractive, if she found the guy very attractive, the comfort levels would have been completely different.

From the guy's point of view it can be bad for self esteem to assume women will find you unattractive and is it better he say nothing and avoid a few seconds of discomfort on her part, or to say something to avoid weeks of regret and discomfort on his part and damage to his esteem.

He is the cause of both the discomfort to her and the damage to his esteem. A guy who can't get past the fact that he didn't hit on a strange woman in an elevator at 4 AM needs to reevaluate his priorities.
 
Even RW flat out said this was not the intent of her statement. You can't always lay out all the specific criteria for being creepy but under these particular circumstances, in their entirety, she is justified in feeling creeped out by the guy.
.

Didn't she turn elevator guy into what is wrong with the skeptic movement though? The EG is the reason women aren't showing up if you will..

(which i would say is bogus.. and hope she isn't trying to make that assertion..)
 
Yes, but I seem to remember someone asking if he was there at all.

Maybe he was just trolling her, mind you.

This thread is now huge but buried somewhere in it is a video of the talk that Rebecca gave at the conference while seated next to Dawkins.

She discussed being an atheist activist while female and how that gave her a slightly different experience than her male colleges, including unique negatives like rape threats.

For the record, these are not always the topics that leave a woman wet and waiting for strange men in elevators. In fact, I will go so far as to say that many times it has the exact opposite effect.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom