So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
There's no mixed message.

Skepchick used sex to sell her website.

Skepchick found that false feminism gained her some popularity, especially if she misrepresented the skeptic position.


Bullcrap. Plain and simple.

Skepchick found that by overstating a perceived "threat" in an elevator, she could garner more attention. When RD responded, she must have thought all her Christmases had come at once.

So, RD calls her on her BS, and suddenly she takes the hardcore feminist line so she can, yep, gain more attention. Im sorry, but the guy asked her for coffee. If this is too much for her, perhaps a panic room in her house would be a better permanent locale.


I call "attention whore" on the whole thing. It angers me, because through her action she diverts attention from the real damn issues women face every day - workplace inequality, domestic violence etc. You know, real things that are really bad and happen to real people.

Someone asked her for coffee. Boo hoo. Cry me a damn river.

Yes. She can shut up now. Her whoring is done.

Bravo!
 
Is there any way that not acting in a manner that makes another person uncomfortable can just be a gesture of goodwill, rather than necessarily "surrendering to feminazism" or somesuch?
 
I'd go further. I'd say there is cognitive dissonance in insisting there's no reason women should be limited from rough sport or even combat duty in the military, while at the same time expecting exceptionalism.

Either women are fragile flowers deserving the last lifeboat, or else it's every carbon based lifeform for themselves.

Ah that the world was so black and white. That would really make things so much easier. But, of course, it's grey and worse, shades of grey that blur into each other and overlap and have no real boundaries. Annoying, aint it.

All humans are fragile flowers deserving the last lifeboat who are simultaneously fighting tooth and nail to get into it. We tend to forget that this sinking ship actually has enough lifeboats. It will take a bit of compromise in order to get everyone settled.

A smaller percentage of women will be able to lift 100 pounds. A larger percentage of men could do it with ease. A larger percentage of women could handle delicate detail work that needed smaller hands. A smaller percentage of men could do the same work. You can't make a general measure of worth for all people from either the ability to lift 100 pounds or the ability to do detail work.

Shifting the world around to make more women lift 100 pounds or more men do detail work doesn't make sense. Shifting it around to exploit the natural gifts of both sexes is a lot more practical.
 
Is there any way that not acting in a manner that makes another person uncomfortable can just be a gesture of goodwill, rather than necessarily "surrendering to feminazism" or somesuch?

When it is a reasonable request, yes, when it is " Don't ask a women if she wants to have sex." no.
 
Except that there is no Skepchick party this year. There is no new skepchick calendar. On a blog post written 5 years ago that objectified two women, Watson has added an apology because it was inappropriate.

People change. They get new information, they have different experiences and this gives them a different outlook on the world. It's a very good thing. I'm not sure the human race could survive if we stopped learning upon reaching physical maturity.

Watson's gone from "I'm smart and I'm sexy." to "OK, enough with the sexy already. Sheesh!" in just a few years. If people have been following her sporadically (the most likely scenario), they wouldn't understand that it is a process and yes, it would seem very hypocritical.

Except that this whole thing has been presented as meaning something emblematic about women, or even "all women." It seems that whatever Rebecca Watson seems to be going through at any one time is being taken as some Great Lesson about women in skepticism. This is not entirely due to the statements of people other than Rebecca Watson.

It's as if she was a drunk who became a recovered alcoholic and is now saying "I don't drink anymore." And teh interwebs are replying "But, but there's pictures of you boozing it up all over the internet!! You're a lush!!"

Which is a really good and important point, especially if she were trying to be an orator about alcohol.

ETA: It would be a bit different if Rebecca Watson were like Skeptic Ginger or Linda or Professor Yaffle. I'm pretty sure that if any of those got on the podium, they would talk about something about skepticism, rather than women this and women that and women women women.
 
Last edited:
When it is a reasonable request, yes, when it is " Don't ask a women if she wants to have sex." no.

How about "don't ask a woman if she wants to have sex when that's the first thing you've ever said to her in her life"? Not reasonable?
 
Except that this whole thing has been presented as meaning something emblematic about women, or even "all women." It seems that whatever Rebecca Watson seems to be going through at any one time is being taken as some Great Lesson about women in skepticism Great Lesson about Womyn in Skepticism. This is not entirely due to the statements of people other than Rebecca Watson.



Which is a really good and important point, especially if she were trying to be an orator about alcohol.

ftfy.
 
By jrefers, i mean people who would support the jref, legitimate posters. Of course someone is going to say " Good on you, screw those christians!" to cause a reaction, but in regards to posters here for reasons other than to bother folks, i would guarantee if i wait until this thread is forgotten and make a thread of that nature, my prediction will come true.

My apologies. I think I misread your post entirely and understood the exact reverse of what you meant ! Disregard my previous post.
 
Except that this whole thing has been presented as meaning something emblematic about women, or even "all women." It seems that whatever Rebecca Watson seems to be going through at any one time is being taken as some Great Lesson about women in skepticism. This is not entirely due to the statements of people other than Rebecca Watson.



Which is a really good and important point, especially if she were trying to be an orator about alcohol.

Back to the basics - this isn't about all women any more then it is about all men. Watson's original video - everyone at the conference was great, there was just this one guy, he made me feel uncomfortable because of this specific context. Don't be that guy."
 
ETA: It would be a bit different if Rebecca Watson were like Skeptic Ginger or Linda or Professor Yaffle. I'm pretty sure that if any of those got on the podium, they would talk about something about skepticism, rather than women this and women that and women women women.

Are you familiar with Watson outside this incident?
 
How about "don't ask a woman if she wants to have sex when that's the first thing you've ever said to her in her life"? Not reasonable?

No, not really. Some women, correct that, some people, have no problems with random sex, one night stands, threesomes, etc. To simply make a rule because one group can't deal with a polite question, is an insane request. As much as extreme feminists hate the fact, some folks actually like sex, and don't attach the 6 tons of emotional and social baggage to it.
 
How about "don't ask a woman if she wants to have sex when that's the first thing you've ever said to her in her life"? Not reasonable?

How about "If you have reason to believe that your request for sex might not be appreciated, don't ask a woman if she wants to have sex when that's the first thing you've ever said to her in her life?"
 
At first I thought her video had gone more viral than I thought, but it's just the same common saying "don't be that guy", not specifically Rebecca's. Your post was misleading! :P
 
Yes, please.

I'm not sure that I understand you. My pet projects wouldn't be relevant as they have nothing to do with the skeptical movement.

Despite the fact that Elevatorgate has now hit the national entertainment-news outlets, this isn't working. Sure there was that small percentage that took a moment to consider and may revamp their style but that probably happened days ago. Now it's just bickering.

Maybe that's just the nature of skepticism as a movement. With other causes and issues, I am directly affected. If it's campaigning for Planned Parenthood, I've used them and probably will again. If it's voting for someone who supports gay marriage, I have friends who have already invited me to their wedding. My niece goes to a school that teaches creationism, I am all for the separation of church and state. Environmental issues often have huge far-reaching impact. Whatever small part I play contributes to tangible personal consequence to myself or the people I love.

Oh. My pet projects mostly involve women in developing countries, or those who lack resources closer to home. No consequences to my friends and family. We're already privileged.

Some people in the skepticism movement are working on issues that have just as much impact - anti-vaxxers and secularism, for example. But many are stuck on pet projects which don't and never would have impacted them personally. They would never spend money on a psychic, they outgrew Bigfoot long ago, dowsing is a quaint custom, ghosts aren't real, homeopathy is silly and so forth. Those who are interested in promoting science have already made real gains and the lack of respect for science annoys them but has no practical repercussion within their lives.

Well, to be honest, I don't give a flying **** if women get hit on at a skeptic's conference compared to a 14 year old girl about to give birth to her third child unattended by even a mid-wife, even though it may spare me the horror of being obliged to turn down a proposition myself.

There is a large sub-group of the movement that runs around telling other people how wrong they are without any personal risk of feeling the results if their advice isn't taken. While many of these do feel empathy for the victims of shysters or CAM or whatever, it's a removed impersonal feeling that is far less satisfying than spewing statistics. They have gotten used to thinking that their views don't affect "real" people.

Interesting take on it.

Linda
 
Back to the basics - this isn't about all women any more then it is about all men. Watson's original video - everyone at the conference was great, there was just this one guy, he made me feel uncomfortable because of this specific context. Don't be that guy."

Then she started ranting about misogyny and calling for all TRUE feminists to boycott people to soothe her petty ego.
 
In related news... Rebecca Watson's 'Don't Be That Guy' is now the anti-date rape slogan that is about to be plastered all over Vancouver pubs & bars.

http://www.cknw.com/Channels/Reg/NewsLocal/Story.aspx?ID=1454814

I don't think that slogan came from this specific incident. it's already been used in the same context for quite awhile. Plus, campaigns take a while to set up. No matter how good a new catch-phrase is, you're going to stick with the one you've already designed the posters for.
 
At first I thought her video had gone more viral than I thought, but it's just the same common saying "don't be that guy", not specifically Rebecca's. Your post was misleading! :P

Yes - it was supposed to be tongue-in-cheek. But amusing that the same 'don't be that guy' meme is out there. I didn't realize it had 'legs'.
 
Back to the basics - this isn't about all women any more then it is about all men. Watson's original video - everyone at the conference was great, there was just this one guy, he made me feel uncomfortable because of this specific context. Don't be that guy."

To me, this discussion isn't really about that initial episode at all. Rather, it's about how the debate somehow, through some logic I really don't understand, almost immediately went from that small episode to pulling out statistics on rape prevalence and shouts of "rape culture."

Yes, what the guy did was tactless and annoying and he shouldn't have done it. But, really, to parade it about as if it was a prime example of misogynism, patriarchal privelege, prevalent sexism in the skeptic movement or whatever? That's just dumb.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom