So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Fixed YT embedding

"Hot chicks get drunk and hit on nerds"...

Okay, while I can make a case for the calendar as a fun side-project and not a general representation of the mores of the group; the other video... they might really, really (I'm talkin' REALLY here) want to re-think how they market themselves and their site. Even if delivered firmly tongue-in-... umm... -cheek, that's sending some seriously mixed messages to poor sods like Elevator Guy. And then to cry "wolf!" [about being hit on too much at cons] and expect to be taken seriously? Sheesh. Got to wonder if their elevator goes all the way to the top. :fg: :boggled::boggled::boggled: :v:

... OK, I'll bite. I watched the ad for the skepchick site.

WTF does "high hatting the monkey" mean?

My guess is something along the lines of wankery .... but some slang doesn't work that way.

Probably a bit before your time. ;) From the 1929 C.B. DeMille silent The Godless Girl (see this thread). "High hatting the monkey" refers to disdaining Darwin (monkey symbol for evolution and godlessness). :monkey2:
 
Last edited:
I still don't think I quite grasp what the complaint is.

Don't hit on people at conventions? (Sexism because men are more likely to do it than women?)

Don't hit on me when I'm tired? (Sexism because men are more likely to do the hitting and therefore more likely to do it when it's not appreciated?)

Don't hit on me in an elevator? (Sexism because a man would not feel as vulnerable in an enclosed space?) Would the story not be told had he asked her outside the bar?

And I don't quite grok the difference between sexual attraction (okay) and sexual objectification (not okay) in this case, as it sounded like he was indicating an attraction to her (if anything). PZ Meyers said something about men thinking it's okay to make proposals which women are obliged to turn down, which would make sense if women never hit on men. But when is it hitting on someone and when is it indicating attraction?

I have to get this straight because I have a son in college and I'm likely to screw it up, otherwise. Just today I made the mistake of suggesting that if he wants to meet people that share his interests he should consider joining a club. I now realize that if he happens to meet a woman there who he was attracted to who shared his interests, he might do something horribly sexist like ask her on a date.

Linda

Sounds to me like the gent just misread some signals. He probably took the " i want to go to bed" as a hint, and gave it a shot. Despite what extreme feminists think, some times comments like that are a signal. This time it wasn't, the guy rolled the bones ( no pun intended) and it came up snake eyes.

I can honestly say i have said the exact phrase " Well i think i am going to bed, i am pretty tired." as a way to indicate to someone that it was a good time to ask to come back to bed with me. Not in an elevator , granted, but at a party, and yes, sometimes with a person i didn't know all that well.

Sex happens, random sex happens, much to the anger of extreme feminists not every women has the attitude that a man has to jump through X number of hoops before even bringing the subject up. Don't want to have sex? Say so, which apparently she did, and he did not try to do anything unpleasant afterward.

I mean really, we are humans, most humans like sex, what is so friggen wrong about asking if another person would like sex? I can understand harassing being wrong, but the simple act of trying to have sex?

It seems to me, that if extreme feminists want to get rid of this "problem" they should take an idea from chris rock, slightly modified. If you want sex, wear a big bright shirt saying " I want sex" with your conditions outlined on it. If you don't, wear a similar shirt with " I don't want sex". ( i believe chris rock spoke of women's skin turning bright green when in the mood.).

Otherwise they are going to have to deal with the absolute horror of a guy actually having the confidence to ask if they would like to have sex.
 
Okay, while I can make a case for the calendar as a fun side-project and not a general representation of the mores of the group; the other video... they might really, really (I'm talkin' REALLY here) want to re-think how they market themselves and their site. Even if delivered firmly tongue-in-... umm... -cheek, that's sending some seriously mixed messages to poor sods like Elevator Guy. And then to cry "wolf!" [about being hit on too much at cons] and expect to be taken seriously? Sheesh. Got to wonder if their elevator goes all the way to the top. :fg: :boggled::boggled::boggled: :v:

There was a time when some woman walking home after dark could be dragged in to an alley and be raped, and asshats would say "that's terrible, but with that outfit/being alone/out at night she was kinda asking for it..." Such people should be whipped through the streets.

However, now it doesn't matter what a woman says, wears or does she has zero culpability in any result. Get drunk, agree to sex, then have second thoughts the next day? That's the guy's problem.

How about we say a victim is always that, and NOTHING a victim does excuses the attacker, but sometimes people set themselves up?

If I go in to a well known soccer pub wearing the colors of a rival team then any kicking i might receive is 100% the fault of the people doing the kicking. I'd have to be pretty stupid to go in there though.

I think we have some vestigial 'weaker sex' BS left over in the western sub-conscious.
 
He was interested in Watson. He was at her presentation, he was in the bar with her, he never talked to her. He waited until she was out of public and vulnerable to strike up conversation.

Pathetic. Sure, I've added color to the scenario, but let all that drop away. There is no factual analysis of this situation that leads to a conclusion that this man behaved appropriately.

Is this how you talk to women? Waiting until they're alone in a confined space and then propositing them? Why are you so interested in defending this behavior? I ask that in all seriousness. Why do you feel a need to define these actions as proper?

Coming from someone who has done the same thing, and is a very sexual person, i can shine some light on this.

What your trying to catagorize as predetory behavior is actually respect on the person's part. While a guy will give his buddies a high five and leave the bar with a girl, women , even when interested in the one night stand thing, tend to not want their friends to know about it. Waiting for a private moment ( usually on the patio of a bar near closing, but an elevator ride is no big stretch.) so they can actually think about it, sans embarassment , or social pressure , is simply the polite thing to do.

Essentially watson wants all women to be treated as if they are completely frigid , and sex is a favor they would give to a man, and it is rude to ask for a favor in an elevator after the bar. Sorry to burst her bubble on this one, but many women are just as, if not more sexual than men. They are going to the bar with the same intent a man is, and are not going to freak out if asked if they would like sex in a polite fashion.

All of this reminds me of straight men that have put off the wrong signals to me ( usually assuming i am straight as well, due to me hitting on females in the same night.) and politely get asked if they are "playing on my team" for lack of a better term. Then get all antsy , paranoid and weird. ( admittedly these are in the minority, though this could be due to my fairly good gaydar) It is a question, it does not indicate someone is going to do anything further, it indicates that someone wanted to make sure you were interested before doing something.

If people can't ask what are they supposed to do? We arn't animals , a quick sniff isn't going to tell us is someone is interested in sex.
 
Indeed. All those gratuitous extreme close up shots of nude elbows, knees, ankles, and forearms just scream out to be objectified.

Skepchick has done some sexualized promotion.

'Do you find smart chicks hot? Do you find smart girls sexy?'.

I can understand why women don't want to be or like being viewed as a sexualized creature, but if you use sex to sell your website and calender, as well as always using sex jokes on a podcast, it might just confuse some people with the mixed messages.





Yes, blah, blah, blah, women should be able to dress any way they want to. I get it.

It still reeks a bit of hypocrisy to me.
 
Difference: JREF members _agree_ to follow those norms.

Also the anonymity of the internet amplifes the bad behavior of people. You see things posted online very few people would dare say in person. So the guidelines are necessary.
 
Lord knows I've tried.

Alas, we do have biological signals that can be detected. However, not always are the signals mutual. I guess some people are disgusted to sense the signals in someone else when they're not giving them themselves.

The signals are still there though.. maybe some people are just good at ignoring them or are actually trained to be disgusted by them for whatever reason.

Sometimes you can't control them either.. sexuality has a lot of instinctual components. While you may be able to shut your mouth, it may be impossibly hard to stop your other biological reactions to being sexually aroused / excited. I'm curious if even this person didn't say anything RW would still be disturbed reading the body language.. in which case i don' think there is any solution to the "problem"

Maturity plays large part of what is missing in this debate :)
 
it might just confuse some people with the mixed messages.

There's no mixed message.

Skepchick used sex to sell her website.

Skepchick found that false feminism gained her some popularity, especially if she misrepresented the skeptic position.
And then I would make a comment about how there could really be more women in the community, and the responses from my fellow skeptics and atheists ranged from “No, they’re not logical like us,” to “Yes, so we can **** them!” That seemed weird.

Bullcrap. Plain and simple.

Skepchick found that by overstating a perceived "threat" in an elevator, she could garner more attention. When RD responded, she must have thought all her Christmases had come at once.

So, RD calls her on her BS, and suddenly she takes the hardcore feminist line so she can, yep, gain more attention. Im sorry, but the guy asked her for coffee. If this is too much for her, perhaps a panic room in her house would be a better permanent locale.


I call "attention whore" on the whole thing. It angers me, because through her action she diverts attention from the real damn issues women face every day - workplace inequality, domestic violence etc. You know, real things that are really bad and happen to real people.

Someone asked her for coffee. Boo hoo. Cry me a damn river.

Yes. She can shut up now. Her whoring is done.
 
There's no mixed message.

Skepchick used sex to sell her website.

Skepchick found that false feminism gained her some popularity, especially if she misrepresented the skeptic position.


Bullcrap. Plain and simple.

Skepchick found that by overstating a perceived "threat" in an elevator, she could garner more attention. When RD responded, she must have thought all her Christmases had come at once.

So, RD calls her on her BS, and suddenly she takes the hardcore feminist line so she can, yep, gain more attention. Im sorry, but the guy asked her for coffee. If this is too much for her, perhaps a panic room in her house would be a better permanent locale.


I call "attention whore" on the whole thing. It angers me, because through her action she diverts attention from the real damn issues women face every day - workplace inequality, domestic violence etc. You know, real things that are really bad and happen to real people.

Someone asked her for coffee. Boo hoo. Cry me a damn river.

Yes. She can shut up now. Her whoring is done.

The thing that bugs me, is that this is so extreme , so very extreme, yet because it is under the banner of feminism, it automatically gets support from some people.

This is the equivalent of an atheist writing an angry blog entry because a person at work mentioned they were a christian. I can guarantee you that all the JREFers here would jump on that person as an idiot, 100%. But change it around to be a women being offended by something that had no offensive content , and suddenly it gets supporters.

I would hate to live in the ******* Drow society that women like skepchick seem to want. And so would a massive number of women, both feminist and non feminist. Sex shouldn't be treated as a favor that a woman gives a man, some annoying request , and thankfully the vast majority of women don't treat it as such. But there is that hardcore of the feminist movement, the women that are to feminism, what skinheads are to punk rock, that feel like this.

It's cool if you want to hold the ridiculous position that a man is being evil if he simply rolls the dice , but you are in the vast minority, your anger and fear is not similar to someone who fears a lion in the jungle, but closer to the talk show guest that fears buttons. Which is to say, i have sympathy your mind works in a very weird way, but you cannot expect the rest of the world to adopt behaviors because something perfectly normal, civil and harmless gives you the jimmies.
 
It angers me, because through her action she diverts attention from the real damn issues women face every day - workplace inequality, domestic violence etc.

Nobody stopped paying attention to workplace inequality and domestic violence because of this incident or the aftermath.
 
This is the equivalent of an atheist writing an angry blog entry because a person at work mentioned they were a christian. I can guarantee you that all the JREFers here would jump on that person as an idiot, 100%.

You are wrong. Guarantee. All JREFers. 100%. Those are not the words of a skeptic.
 
You want me to pimp my pet projects?



On the issue of sexism at skepticism/atheism conferences? That's a good point. Another reason to make sure the hype doesn't lead to a backlash among those who would most benefit from the message.

Linda

Yes, please. Despite the fact that Elevatorgate has now hit the national entertainment-news outlets, this isn't working. Sure there was that small percentage that took a moment to consider and may revamp their style but that probably happened days ago. Now it's just bickering.

Maybe that's just the nature of skepticism as a movement. With other causes and issues, I am directly affected. If it's campaigning for Planned Parenthood, I've used them and probably will again. If it's voting for someone who supports gay marriage, I have friends who have already invited me to their wedding. My niece goes to a school that teaches creationism, I am all for the separation of church and state. Environmental issues often have huge far-reaching impact. Whatever small part I play contributes to tangible personal consequence to myself or the people I love.

Some people in the skepticism movement are working on issues that have just as much impact - anti-vaxxers and secularism, for example. But many are stuck on pet projects which don't and never would have impacted them personally. They would never spend money on a psychic, they outgrew Bigfoot long ago, dowsing is a quaint custom, ghosts aren't real, homeopathy is silly and so forth. Those who are interested in promoting science have already made real gains and the lack of respect for science annoys them but has no practical repercussion within their lives.

There is a large sub-group of the movement that runs around telling other people how wrong they are without any personal risk of feeling the results if their advice isn't taken. While many of these do feel empathy for the victims of shysters or CAM or whatever, it's a removed impersonal feeling that is far less satisfying than spewing statistics. They have gotten used to thinking that their views don't affect "real" people.
 
You are wrong. Guarantee. All JREFers. 100%. Those are not the words of a skeptic.

By jrefers, i mean people who would support the jref, legitimate posters. Of course someone is going to say " Good on you, screw those christians!" to cause a reaction, but in regards to posters here for reasons other than to bother folks, i would guarantee if i wait until this thread is forgotten and make a thread of that nature, my prediction will come true.
 
Skepchick has done some sexualized promotion.

'Do you find smart chicks hot? Do you find smart girls sexy?'.

I can understand why women don't want to be or like being viewed as a sexualized creature, but if you use sex to sell your website and calender, as well as always using sex jokes on a podcast, it might just confuse some people with the mixed messages.





Yes, blah, blah, blah, women should be able to dress any way they want to. I get it.

It still reeks a bit of hypocrisy to me.

Except that there is no Skepchick party this year. There is no new skepchick calendar. On a blog post written 5 years ago that objectified two women, Watson has added an apology because it was inappropriate.

People change. They get new information, they have different experiences and this gives them a different outlook on the world. It's a very good thing. I'm not sure the human race could survive if we stopped learning upon reaching physical maturity.

Watson's gone from "I'm smart and I'm sexy." to "OK, enough with the sexy already. Sheesh!" in just a few years. If people have been following her sporadically (the most likely scenario), they wouldn't understand that it is a process and yes, it would seem very hypocritical.

It's as if she was a drunk who became a recovered alcoholic and is now saying "I don't drink anymore." And teh interwebs are replying "But, but there's pictures of you boozing it up all over the internet!! You're a lush!!"
 
What on Earth are you talking about? How is that even a response to my post? And why are you up in arms about "my perception" when a sentence later you agree with it?

Look, I've respected a lot of what you've said in the past, but this constant need on your part to grossly mischaracterize my position is becoming absurd.



Uh, ok. At what point did I say there was no place on Earth dangerous for men?

We have a specific situation: one man, one woman on an elevator. You have continually generated nonsensical positions by generalizing my comments about that encounter to cover all manner of dissimilar scenarios.

It's getting tiresome.
I'm sorry. I'm not trying to insult you or anything. I'm not trying to demonize your thoughts, only explain to you what it is about your comments that bothers me. The way your comments come across to me, whether you mean them that way or not, reflects one of the things within this whole brouhaha that bothers me, that of perceiving the weaker physical prowess of women as a much greater barrier than it is.

Women limit themselves when they believe they are limited. Your posts say you perceive women as much more limited than they truly are.
 
Except that there is no Skepchick party this year. There is no new skepchick calendar. On a blog post written 5 years ago that objectified two women, Watson has added an apology because it was inappropriate.

People change. They get new information, they have different experiences and this gives them a different outlook on the world. It's a very good thing. I'm not sure the human race could survive if we stopped learning upon reaching physical maturity.

Watson's gone from "I'm smart and I'm sexy." to "OK, enough with the sexy already. Sheesh!" in just a few years. If people have been following her sporadically (the most likely scenario), they wouldn't understand that it is a process and yes, it would seem very hypocritical.

It's as if she was a drunk who became a recovered alcoholic and is now saying "I don't drink anymore." And teh interwebs are replying "But, but there's pictures of you boozing it up all over the internet!! You're a lush!!"

Yeah couldn't possibly be that " Have your cake and eat it too" attitude prevalent among a lot of extreme feminists. Why? Because it is a group you support of course, and as such, they can never do wrong.
 
I'm sorry. I'm not trying to insult you or anything. I'm not trying to demonize your thoughts, only explain to you what it is about your comments that bothers me. The way your comments come across to me, whether you mean them that way or not, reflects one of the things within this whole brouhaha that bothers me, that of perceiving the weaker physical prowess of women as a much greater barrier than it is.

Women limit themselves when they believe they are limited. Your posts say you perceive women as much more limited than they truly are.

I'd go further. I'd say there is cognitive dissonance in insisting there's no reason women should be limited from rough sport or even combat duty in the military, while at the same time expecting exceptionalism.

Either women are fragile flowers deserving the last lifeboat, or else it's every carbon based lifeform for themselves.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom