So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Indeed, it seems like a good place to meet like-minded people. Just as good a place as any, in fact.

Agreed but, the key phrase is like minded. The only way you are going to find out if the other individual is like minded, is through conversation first. Going to a convention and hoping to hook up with that like minded person, chatting up a few people and looking for signals; there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. Following someone into an elevator, after they just announced that they are done and ready for bed, even if your intention is just to find out if you are actually like minded, is rude. You don't pretend to want to hear what a person has to say, after you just blatently ignored what they've just said. In my opinion, that is objectification (while it may not be overtly sexual); you've just ignored the individual's clearly expressed desire, to go to bed because you want something else.
 
I think i found the problem.

The video clearly states "hot chicks get drunk and hit on nerds."

EG thought the opposite was OK. Tsk tsk.
 
I think you'd better read what you said again:



I think my interpretation is accurate. I've known of many and been privileged to meet one or two women in the most innocuous of circumstances who happily engaged in casual sex.

I am assuming that you found out that they were happy to engage in casual sex because one of you approached the other and the first line was, "Let's have sex."
 
Interesting you would make this comment given your perception the world is more dangerous for women because they are so much weaker than men.

Yes, they are, but that's no reason women shouldn't be comfortable moving about the world for the most part.

What on Earth are you talking about? How is that even a response to my post? And why are you up in arms about "my perception" when a sentence later you agree with it?

Look, I've respected a lot of what you've said in the past, but this constant need on your part to grossly mischaracterize my position is becoming absurd.

And for the record, some of those rare dangerous places I mentioned were dangerous for both men and women, not just women. Beach camping in HI while white, wandering the side streets of downtown Amsterdam, and wandering the streets outside the main Capitol area of WA DC for example, are not gender specific dangerous.

Uh, ok. At what point did I say there was no place on Earth dangerous for men?

We have a specific situation: one man, one woman on an elevator. You have continually generated nonsensical positions by generalizing my comments about that encounter to cover all manner of dissimilar scenarios.

It's getting tiresome.
 
Last edited:
I'd like to say that I'm not advancing any positive thesis that women in general aren't attracted to skepticism or anything like that.

However I think you're making an apples-to-oranges comparison to some extent in that there's money and attention to be had in sport and in military careers so there were incentives to draw people to them even before any intentional accommodations or active recruitment entered the picture.

In those cases there was an attractive pasture with a "Women Keep Out!" sign on the fence. That problem was solved by taking the old sign down and putting up a "Forget That Old Sign, Women Encouraged To Enter Now!" sign. In the case of comic books and skepticism the problem might be with the pasture, not with the sign on the fence. The limited and anecdotal evidence I've been accidentally exposed to is consistent with women hopping the organised-skepticism fence enthusiastically and then finding that the pasture wasn't very nice.

Sure, those distinctions are valid. Women have the legal right to participate in the military and school sports in a way they do not at comic book conventions.

Nevertheless, those models of integration are informative. Long-standing social trends (that were MUCH more powerful that "chicks don't dig comic books") were broken down by the act of engaging, rather than simply passively hoping they show up.

I would also point out that women in Japan are HUGE comic book fans, meaning that there's nothing unique about the Y choromosome that draws one to that universe, it's cultural. Culture can be changed in a way biology cannot.

But, of course, it's a contingent proposition: If we want more women, we have models to show the best way of increasing their attendance. Maybe that's not what "we" want, the changes that would have to be made are unfavored enough that we'd rather just roll with dudes (that would be an unfortunate conclusion in my mind).
 
Last edited:
Sure, those distinctions are valid. Women have the legal right to participate in the military and school sports in a way they do not at comic book conventions.

Nevertheless, those models of integration are informative. Long-standing social trends (that were MUCH more powerful that "chicks don't dig comic books") were broken down by the act of engaging, rather than simply passively hoping they show up.

I would also point out that women in Japan are HUGE comic book fans, meaning that there's nothing unique about the Y choromosome that draws one to that universe, it's cultural. Culture can be changed in a way biology cannot.

Conveniently leaving out the fact that they have male and female orientated Manga. There may be an actual limit as to how much you can co-opt western comic books.

But, of course, it's a contingent proposition: If we want more women, we have models to show the best way of increasing their attendance. Maybe that's not what "we" want, the changes that would have to be made are unfavored enough that we'd rather just roll with dudes (that would be an unfortunate conclusion in my mind).

Well there may indeed be a tipping point where you change the community so much that it ceases to recognize itself. I'm all for tweaking to be inclusive, but potentially cutting out existing members to accommodate theoretical members smacks of social engineering.
 
Conveniently leaving out the fact that they have male and female orientated Manga. There may be an actual limit as to how much you can co-opt western comic books.

That's not "conveniently leaving out," that's the point. Japan has a culture where men and women enjoy comic books (often the same ones, by the way, so you're wrong on the notion of segregation). Check out a Japanese comic book convention, lots of men and women of all ages.

Well there may indeed be a tipping point where you change the community so much that it ceases to recognize itself. I'm all for tweaking to be inclusive, but potentially cutting out existing members to accommodate theoretical members smacks of social engineering.

Sure, any specific course of action must be analyzed on its own merits.
 
Last edited:
That's not "conveniently leaving out," that's the point. Japan has a culture where men and women enjoy comic books (often the same ones, by the way, so you're wrong on the notion of segregation). Check out a Japanese comic book convention, lots of men and women of all ages.

They have an entire sub-industry to produce manga specifically targeted to women. Sure you'll get some overlap, you do in the west too.

It can not all be on men to change to include women in the hobby though, women have to want in and carve a place in the industry. They've certainly become a significant minority over the last couple of decades, but I think that comparing the western comics scene to manga is disingenuous.
 
They have an entire sub-industry to produce manga specifically targeted to women. Sure you'll get some overlap, you do in the west too.

It can not all be on men to change to include women in the hobby though, women have to want in and carve a place in the industry. They've certainly become a significant minority over the last couple of decades, but I think that comparing the western comics scene to manga is disingenuous.

I have no idea what you're talking about. Here was my initial claim:

"I would also point out that women in Japan are HUGE comic book fans, meaning that there's nothing unique about the Y choromosome that draws one to that universe, it's cultural."

The fact that there are comic books specifically targeted to women is evidence IN FAVOR of my position. THat's the point: in Japan, comic books are not the sole domain of the male. I'm not comparing the scenes, I'm pointing out an important difference.

You're essentially saying, "Well, you neglected to mention that the only reason women participate in sports in America is because there are sports for women."

Yes, I know. If you want women at comic book conventions, make some goddamn comics for women. This is the best model if integration is your goal.

If your goal is to keep things the way they are and you'll just make do with whatever women show up, fine, that's the way you want to do things. I would find that conclusion to be sad for the "skeptical movement" and probably a bad idea politically, but obviously integration measures wouldn't be preffered if that's the outcome you want.
 
Last edited:
There's been some more information come to light on this incident.

Apparently EG hit the button to go back to his room. They went up a few floors and the cable snapped, as they began to plummet Watson screamed "We're going to die" and ripped off all her clothes "Make me feel like a woman one last time Elevator Guy". EG ripped off his shirt threw it on the ground and said "Pick that up Rebecca"

:boxedin:
 
Indeed. All those gratuitous extreme close up shots of nude elbows, knees, ankles, and forearms just scream out to be objectified.

Come off it. You think people buy these calendars because of the intellect of the models? This thread has become surreal.
 
Indeed. All those gratuitous extreme close up shots of nude elbows, knees, ankles, and forearms just scream out to be objectified.

Maybe you have a grasp of this, I honestly don't, what's the difference between being "objectified" and being "sexualized?"

I would take "objectified" to mean the obviation of any mental characteristics: we don't care about your thoughts, ideas, just your body.

I'm unclear on what "sexualized" means. When Watson said about being propositioned at atheist conferences (not just the elevator issue), "I don't appreciate being sexualized in that manner," how do we distinguish that from sexy calendars?

I'm sort of baffled by it, I really don't understand the way these terms are being used in context.
 
As for what you actually said, since you asked, yes I do think it was a huge straw man and completely unproductive. Nobody has said that if a woman doesn't care for being groped by complete strangers at a high frequency, she should either not come to skeptical events or bring a male escort. Or at least nobody has said that where I've seen it, and if anyone has aid that then they are a troll or a fringe idiot who is unrepresentative even of the misogynist-skeptics I mentioned earlier.
I didn't mean it to be taking as a direct quote from anyone. It was a concise paraphrasing of the sentiments I've seen expressed by multiple women who were posting about their experiences having attended such conferences and why they won't be going back. Just because you haven't read such comments (they were on the feminist blogs talking about this matter rather the atheist blogs) doesn't mean they aren't out there.

You can conclude that they don't exist or are so uncommon as to be irrelevant to the issue of why more women aren't attending such conferences, but that is pretty much like deciding not to look at evidence that's available. Further, it seems to me to be directly contradicted by what you posted in #1020
many male skeptics run the gamut from being completely well-intentioned but painfully socially inept all the way through to outright misogynist jerks. I've met several wonderful, skeptical Australian women who have nothing to do with the Australian Skeptics organisation for exactly that reason.
What is it that you think those men are doing that that results in those skeptical Australian women wanting nothing to do with their organization?
Similarly while it's true that if a women expresses a feminist opinion some skeptics will make fun of her, mock her, and insult her while others will threaten to rape her these too are trolls or fringe jerks who don't represent the general skeptical community.
They may not be the majority, but when they include a major leader of the movement, I think it's a reasonable conclusion that they are representative of a large faction, not a fringe element.

The fact that you focus on "whore" and not "attention" is telling. Why didn't you also ask if it is a, "bigger or lesser insult than calling her a shameless attention-seeker?"
You have to add shameless to make attention-seeker an insult. And it's nowhere near the same level of insult as shameless whore would be.

Wow. It's in the power of the guys who attend.
Yes. Only they can decide to change their behavior towards women who attend.
You hit a nerve there. NO IT IS NOT. It's in the power of the women and perpetuating the idea it's in the power of the men only reinforces the deterrent, if one believes this is indeed a deterrent.

Wow, you really read that the wrong way. I meant that men have the power to make changes that would affect how many women choose to come to such events. It is in their power to change the way women who attend are treated and make it a more attractive place for women to be. This doesn't mean that women don't have power too. They do.
 
Last edited:
If I were going to be there, I know I wouldn't be getting on any elevators with any men, if only so I wouldn't take the chance of being subjected to some misplaced "humor" about it. Some have already bragged that they're going to seek out Rebecca and do this to her.

Gee, I hope not. This has been blown way out of proportions as it is.

And I really do wish _you_ weren't blowing it out of proportions either.
 
In the end, is Rebecca Watson really the best barometer of why women may not be coming to skeptic events? She may have a valid point, but she speaks to it like she owns the point. Maybe that in and of itself scares off women... women who have no interest in feminism.. no interest in "nerds", no interest in being sexual, no interest in associating with her..

Maybe a lot of women want a place where they can be themselves.. be a mother, be a daughter, be a wife, be a grandma.. as far as i can tell TAM does LITTLE to reflect those HUGE demographics and RW does FAR LESS to attract those demographics.

My wife and myself started a group before and when we kept the topics open about specific ideas women showed up. When it became sort of a routine, women stopped showing up. Personal anecdote, i think enough women have enough routine that they don't need another, but they would love to participate if they get something of value or can offer something of value..

perhaps a lot of women simply don't have the same values of RW for us to put her on such a high pedestal of what "women want"

I watch the show "The Universe" and there are a ton of intelligent women on there.. How about getting some of them to speak? Maybe ask them why they wouldn't if they refuse to accept.
 
In the end, is Rebecca Watson really the best barometer of why women may not be coming to skeptic events? She may have a valid point, but she speaks to it like she owns the point. Maybe that in and of itself scares off women... women who have no interest in feminism.. no interest in "nerds", no interest in being sexual, no interest in associating with her..

[...]

I watch the show "The Universe" and there are a ton of intelligent women on there.. How about getting some of them to speak? Maybe ask them why they wouldn't if they refuse to accept.

I agree with you on the family thing. Obviously not every skeptical conference needs to (or should) be family focused, but that's the best way to grow.

And hell, we're the ones who are interested in science. There's nothing a kid geeks out more about than dinosaurs and saber-tooth tigers and all the other really cool **** scientists have learned. It's an easy in. A convention with youth classes that allow the parents to have some time to themselves...it wouldn't be difficult (hell, it may already be done, I really don't know).
 
I have no idea what you're talking about. Here was my initial claim:

"I would also point out that women in Japan are HUGE comic book fans, meaning that there's nothing unique about the Y choromosome that draws one to that universe, it's cultural."

The fact that there are comic books specifically targeted to women is evidence IN FAVOR of my position. THat's the point: in Japan, comic books are not the sole domain of the male. I'm not comparing the scenes, I'm pointing out an important difference.

You're essentially saying, "Well, you neglected to mention that the only reason women participate in sports in America is because there are sports for women."

Yes, I know. If you want women at comic book conventions, make some goddamn comics for women. This is the best model if integration is your goal.

If your goal is to keep things the way they are and you'll just make do with whatever women show up, fine, that's the way you want to do things. I would find that conclusion to be sad for the "skeptical movement" and probably a bad idea politically, but obviously integration measures wouldn't be preffered if that's the outcome you want.

My point is that your schtick is that we need to actively seek out women to join any area that is lacking in women. I am arguing that some interests are naturally more attractive to one sex over another. Furthermore, there is a tipping point where you change things so much to lure in a new crowd, that the old crowd gets pushed out.

I point I was trying to make specifically about your manga argument was that in Japan they have a healthy sub-industry of manga purely targeted at women. They didn't just twist regular manga until it magically became popular with large sections of the female population.

Men should not cut women out of anything, or purposefully make them feel uncomfortable. However, I don't think it should be purely up to men to bend over backwards to bring women in to male-centric groups.

As skepticism grows more mainstream expect sub-groups to spring up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom