So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
....

Further, she has done this because she's actively trying to get more women involved in skepticism and atheism. She's saying that here is one reason why some women aren't getting involved and it's in the power of the guys who attend those conferences to make that change. ...

I think that's the status quo that Rebecca is trying to change.
Wow. It's in the power of the guys who attend.

You hit a nerve there. NO IT IS NOT. It's in the power of the women and perpetuating the idea it's in the power of the men only reinforces the deterrent, if one believes this is indeed a deterrent.
 
The ridicule and mockery she was enjoying then was beyond the level of Dawkins's later note contrasting her story with women's treatment in worse parts of the world. She seems to be reacting not to its mocking nature, but just to the fact that it was directed at her this time (from someone she probably thought would only do stuff like that to the opposition).

That's sort of right but misses the point. I agree that she reacted not to its mocking nature -- she's not a tone troll who gasps about people not being nice and polite -- but to the fact that it was directed at a viewpoint that didn't deserve it.

When a creationist makes some stupid joke about "if evolution is true, how come there are still monkeys? Hur hur hur," my objection is not to joking or sarcasm, but to the view that underlies that particular expressing of joking or sarcasm.

BTW, contrary to what some have said here, her monolog was NOT about guys approaching her like Elevator Creep did, nor did she even mention anything like it. She talked about comments she'd gotten from her audiences over the internet.

Again, I think you're partly right and partly wrong. She did not specifically discuss being propositioned at conferences, but I don't agree that she didn't "mention anything like it." After mentioning all the sexist hate mail she gets, mostly from woos but also from skeptics, she did talk about the supposedly supportive comments she gets from skeptics who think it's helpful and supportive to tell her "in graphic detail" all the things they would like to do to her sexually. Yes, that was "over the internet," not in person, but I think the point was clear that she did not find sexual come-ons from strangers flattering.

For those who want to check, that part starts around the 9:00 mark of the following video:

 
Last edited:
All true. However, posing for a sexy calender then complaining that women are sexually objectified? Come on.

If RW's arguing no woman should ever be sexually objectified, I'd say she doesn't have a gam to stand on: about as defensible as our ol pal Mel Gibson's position on fellatio as perq for arson. But she might simply be arguing that appearing in a sexy calendar, where buyers can sexualize her all they want, til it's black and blue and begging for mercy, doesn't imply she wants to be objectified when she appears at an atheist meet-up, which seems to me a reasonable request.

I don't know the full context of her remarks, but I suspect the intent at least, however sloppily they were expressed via v-blog or whatever, is much closer to the latter.
 
Last edited:
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm...................

I had never looked at the whole Skepchick calendar or advertising for their site.





 
if you can think of something let me know.

You want me to pimp my pet projects?

I'm glad that this is being discussed. As I mentioned earlier, it has been growing for some time. No other example got quite this amount of interest, so maybe this is what it took. maybe it's timing.

On the issue of sexism at skepticism/atheism conferences? That's a good point. Another reason to make sure the hype doesn't lead to a backlash among those who would most benefit from the message.

Linda
 
Well, maybe not very many people, but certainly some. Seismosaurus, for one.

I'm not sure. I think he agrees it was awkward, which is mostly what I meant.

But that really is just a metaphor. No actual physical harm has come to Richard Dawkins. It's all just words.

I think this is supposed to be sarcastic, but it misses the mark, since I'm pretty sure that Richard isn't claiming that he has been wounded by this (not even psychologically), whereas women are claiming to be wounded by objectification.

Linda
 
I'm not sure what constitutes "tearing Richard apart limb from limb" metaphorically.

This kind of stuff.

http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2011/07/oh_no_not_againonce_more_unto.php#comment-4309418
http://skepchick.org/2011/07/the-privilege-delusion/
http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/badastronomy/2011/07/05/richard-dawkins-and-male-privilege/

It sounds to me like the same kind of thing that Dawkins' critics keep accusing him of doing, all that "militant, angry atheist" nonsense.

Maybe. Probably. I was sorta counting on that. It was meant as a tongue-in-cheek characterization, in the spirit of the blogosphere, rather than an accurate representation of what I or anyone here seriously believes.

If someone believes that Dawkins' comments are stupid, insensitive, and sexist, then pointing that out -- even in strong language, to which RD is no stranger -- and asking him to rethink and apologize seems like a sensible and proportionate response to me.

Yes.

Linda
 
Calling someone out in a public setting without giving someone a chance to respond is out of order. creeping women out by being a letch is out of order.

Now, can we all be pals again and get back to stopping douchebag homeopathists and stuff?

I don't know. Real skepticism is also about everyday stuff, not just cooky beliefs.
 
But is it a greater or lesser insult than whore by itself? :D

Lesser, since it is used to describe both men and women who indulge in that behavior.

A good argument can be made that Rebecca has objectified and sexualized herself via her skeptichick calendar poses/pics. Not that there's anything wrong with that, I've been a fan of girlie calendars, nude and almost nude, since I was about ten years old. That argument, however, runs along the lines of 'methinks the young lady protesteth too much' and is not invalid.

None of the above warrants calling Rebecca Watson a whore. If anyone did, they'd be way off base.

OK, I'll bite. I watched the ad for the skepchick site.

WTF does "high hatting the monkey" mean?

My guess is something along the lines of wankery .... but some slang doesn't work that way.
 
Last edited:
Again, not trying to speak for anyone else, but there's a lot of difference in how an approach will make someone feel if you do it in a place with a lot of other people around versus doing it in a place with nobody else there.

Well I can certainly understand that a woman would feel a bit creeped out in that particular situation. And I don't know exactly what the man's intentions were. Perhaps it's a case of "both right and both wrong".

What gets me is the "objectified" comment. I think it's exaggerated. I mean, we objectify one another and ourselves all the time. And then there's that calendar...
 
I think you'd better read what I said again. I said *if* people don't advertise casual sex then they probably don't want it.

No, that's not what you said.

You basically said that a woman has to advertise her preferences before a man should consider making an advance. You didn't say "probably".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom