So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I do not accept the premise that nudity or semi-nudity or existing openly as a sexual being deserves objectification in response.
What does this mean? The Skepchick and Skepdude calendars have all been heavy on the sexual innuendo.

As a matter of fact, now that my memory is going back a few years, the initial Skepchick theme was much closer to 'women in science can be sexy' than this new feminism theme.
 
Last edited:
When I read the phrase "the picture I'm getting" or "I'm picking up a vibe here" or "what it seems to me you are saying" I immediately see a giant, metaphorical warning sign saying "Extreme Straw Man Danger Ahead".

In this particular case I think a few different things are going on.
I'm not sure that I understand you here. Did you think what I said was a straw man? That is the picture that reaches my consciousness after have read and discussed this in detail and nothing you said contradicts or contests what I said.
Do I have a solution? No. Asking "How can we get more women into organised skepticism?" seems to me a bit like asking "How can we get more well-groomed, socially adept, high-earning people, especially women, to come to comic book conventions?" Organised skepticism attracts a certain kind of person. I'm not sure you're going to change the kind of person organised skepticism attracts without fundamentally changing the nature of organised skepticism.

Yes. Some of those guys, like Dawkins and PZ and RW, want to see atheism grow more powerful and popular as a social movement. Not being able to attract women (or minorities) is likely to keep it relegated to minority status.

I don't think anybody has a solution yet. But skeptics and atheists are often very smart people who are good at figuring things out. If that's what they choose to do.

It will be interesting to see how this plays out over time. It may well be a pivotal moment for the communities that are springing up.
 
If you would bother to read the studies about men being assaulted by women in the elevator you would know many men are too ashamed to admit their bottoms are red and sore by the time they reach the double digit floors where they work on a daily basis. Us abused men victims have learned to be keep our mouths shut and accept the abuse lest we be further mocked.

You do realize that this mockery is both calloused and cruel? And exactly the sort of crap that keeps the abused silent in the first place?

Not funny; not okay.
 
For the record I put Dawkins in the misogynist camp, and Watkins and Plait in the feminist-irrationalist camp.

Another dynamic we're watching is the personalization of the argument. Instead of the positions being evaluated for their content, we get "Rebecca's argument" or "Dawkins' stance." This is obviously not very productive.

I think Watson was incredibly correct about the concerning aspects of Elevator Guy's behavior and incredibly wrong about almost everything else. Does that put me in her camp or Dawkins (although Dawkins really hasn't said anything that makes sense in this little episode)?

I confess that I'm having a great deal of trouble understanding Watson's objection to "being sexualized in that manner" with respect to having men at atheist conferences hit on her (set aside, for the moment, issues of proper and improper ways to approach a woman) when she seems to enjoy being sexualized (again, I'm not clear on a specific meaning for this word in this context) and promotes herself as such.

Appearing naked in a calendar doesn't mean all guys have a free pass to hit on her whenever and however they want, or that there is some expectation of sex, but clearly she sees no conflict among 1) being a thinking woman, 2) acknowledging human sexuality and 3) acknowledging her own sexuality through her work as a thinking woman. If she can do that, I don't understand why men who listen to her speak can't do the same. What's the problem with thinking, "Wow, that was a great speech. I also find the speaker attractive."?

But that confusion is wholly irrelevant to the question of whether men should understand the impropriety of coldly propositioning a woman in a confined space with no exit.

So, what are the sides? I can't extract a coherent philosophy from any of this. There are certain things some people say that make sense and a whole lot of really dramatic gibberish.

Do I have a solution? No. Asking "How can we get more women into organised skepticism?" seems to me a bit like asking "How can we get more well-groomed, socially adept, high-earning people, especially women, to come to comic book conventions?" Organised skepticism attracts a certain kind of person. I'm not sure you're going to change the kind of person organised skepticism attracts without fundamentally changing the nature of organised skepticism.

In the 70's we asked, "how can we get more women involved in sports?" Specific effort was exerted to creat opportunities for women. As more women took advantage of those opportunities, the social stigma melted away, and now countless women participate in sports on every level (participants, fans, executives...etc.).

I think a similar dynamic is occurring in the Sci-fi, fantasy, comic book world, though the progression isn't as swift (does there need to be a Title IX for Trekkies?).

I don't know that asking the question will necessarily lead to more women participating, but I'm quite sure that ignoring it will guarantee a lot of sausage-fests at atheist conferences.
 
Last edited:
Yes. Some of those guys, like Dawkins and PZ and RW, want to see atheism grow more powerful and popular as a social movement. Not being able to attract women (or minorities) is likely to keep it relegated to minority status.

This doesn't compute.. Atheism is genderless.. Atheism doesn't rely on participation, its actually the lack of participation :)

I don't think anybody has a solution yet. But skeptics and atheists are often very smart people who are good at figuring things out. If that's what they choose to do.

Lots of people have a solution. I'll give a perfect example - The Northern Virginia Ethical Society. Lots of women involved, lots of programs women enjoy and lots of programs that bring in families, men, women and children. They hosted a fantastic "raising free thinkers" event i went to a few years ago and the women to men ration was amazing but it was also amazing to see full families. I think their success is not based on a group of "what were not" but a great group of "What we are"


Perhaps TAM / JREF would be better served by having a family related conference or at least some visible family "chapter" (if you will.. can't think of a better word) to it.
 
What if things like programming and organized skepticism really appeal to males more often than females?

By all means let's not keep any women out or drive them away, but this cult of sameness is not very skeptical.

Not everything is the patriarchy. If you think it is, we have a perfectly good CT forum. I'm sure the heads of the Illuminati are rich old white men.
 
I'm not sure that I understand you here. Did you think what I said was a straw man? That is the picture that reaches my consciousness after have read and discussed this in detail and nothing you said contradicts or contests what I said.

I've marked an awful lot of bad essays in my time written by people who based their opinions on the picture that reached their consciousness after reading about something in detail.

The ones who actually understood what they had read in detail could discuss it in detail. The ones who didn't understand what they had read only had a fuzzy "picture that had reached their consciousness" and were writing based on that fuzzy picture, which is only very slightly better than writing with a totally uninformed opinion.

Misunderstandings and controversies like this grow, not shrink, when people pile in with their fuzzy-picture guesswork because at best the guesser gets details wrong which the other side will nitpick, and more often the guessers create outright straw men which the other side will attack as such.

As for what you actually said, since you asked, yes I do think it was a huge straw man and completely unproductive. Nobody has said that if a woman doesn't care for being groped by complete strangers at a high frequency, she should either not come to skeptical events or bring a male escort. Or at least nobody has said that where I've seen it, and if anyone has aid that then they are a troll or a fringe idiot who is unrepresentative even of the misogynist-skeptics I mentioned earlier.

Similarly while it's true that if a women expresses a feminist opinion some skeptics will make fun of her, mock her, and insult her while others will threaten to rape her these too are trolls or fringe jerks who don't represent the general skeptical community.

I was trying to be more tactful about it but since you asked, there it is.
 
What if things like programming and organized skepticism really appeal to males more often than females?

By all means let's not keep any women out or drive them away, but this cult of sameness is not very skeptical.

Not everything is the patriarchy. If you think it is, we have a perfectly good CT forum. I'm sure the heads of the Illuminati are rich old white men.

Again, they said this about sports for centuries--women just aren't suited for them; they don't like them, anyway; look, here are some women that say they would never dream of getting all sweaty like that...

When effort was taken to involve women in sports, not merely the passive stance that we won't try to push them away, they began participating at incredibly high rate that's continuing to grow.

How about the military? Eliminating forceable rejection is the first step, active recruiting and/or intentional accomodation are also required.
 
Last edited:
Again, they said this about sports for centuries--women just aren't suited for them; they don't like them, anyway; look, here are some women that say they would never dream of getting all sweaty like that...

When effort was taken to involve women in sports, not merely the passive stance that we won't try to push them away, they began participating at incredibly high rate that's continuing to grow.

How about the military? Eliminating forceable rejection is the first step, active recruiting and/or intentional accomodation are also required.

I'd like to say that I'm not advancing any positive thesis that women in general aren't attracted to skepticism or anything like that.

However I think you're making an apples-to-oranges comparison to some extent in that there's money and attention to be had in sport and in military careers so there were incentives to draw people to them even before any intentional accommodations or active recruitment entered the picture.

In those cases there was an attractive pasture with a "Women Keep Out!" sign on the fence. That problem was solved by taking the old sign down and putting up a "Forget That Old Sign, Women Encouraged To Enter Now!" sign. In the case of comic books and skepticism the problem might be with the pasture, not with the sign on the fence. The limited and anecdotal evidence I've been accidentally exposed to is consistent with women hopping the organised-skepticism fence enthusiastically and then finding that the pasture wasn't very nice.
 
Last edited:
But is it a greater or lesser insult than whore by itself? :D
Greater. ;) Nothing wrong with the oldest profession for the most part, if it weren't for the abuse and drug use the women suffer, but that's not insulting the whores.

An attention whore for the most part resorts to shameless things to get attention, like playing up the elevator incident might be construed as. Mind you I don't have enough evidence to judge whether Rebecca is or is not an attention whore and I'm not saying that is what this is about.
 
Again, they said this about sports for centuries--women just aren't suited for them; they don't like them, anyway; look, here are some women that say they would never dream of getting all sweaty like that...

When effort was taken to involve women in sports, not merely the passive stance that we won't try to push them away, they began participating at incredibly high rate that's continuing to grow.

How about the military? Eliminating forceable rejection is the first step, active recruiting and/or intentional accomodation are also required.
Interesting you would make this comment given your perception the world is more dangerous for women because they are so much weaker than men.

Yes, they are, but that's no reason women shouldn't be comfortable moving about the world for the most part. And for the record, some of those rare dangerous places I mentioned were dangerous for both men and women, not just women. Beach camping in HI while white, wandering the side streets of downtown Amsterdam, and wandering the streets outside the main Capitol area of WA DC for example, are not gender specific dangerous.
 
they just locked the SGU thread.
What is SGU?

Richard is being torn apart for doing exactly the same sort of thing to Rebecca that he does regularly to various religious celebrities.
Aron Ra has videos of the original conference in question, when they sat at a table together in front of an audience. He was there with Watson, Dawkins, and a bald guy I don't recognize. (And that guy's monolog segment is cut out, and he apparently said almost nothing in Q&A, unless that was cut out too!)

The theme of Dawkins's segment was that sharp ridicule was a perfectly good and effective way of dealing with some people who believe in religious or other nonsense. He told about an author whose "********" he had fallen for once before and read part of a book review lambasting that person's book, which he says demonstrated the utility of ridicule because it had worked on him and led him to see the error of his ways. She laughed at the same parts of it that everyone else did. When he was done she said her cellphone's ring tone was a clip of Dawins's reading of some of his hate mail from religionuts and she wanted to make sure she'd get a recording of something else Dawkins had just said about religionuts (something like "you're an idiotic retard") to make her new ring tone.

The ridicule and mockery she was enjoying then was beyond the level of Dawkins's later note contrasting her story with women's treatment in worse parts of the world. She seems to be reacting not to its mocking nature, but just to the fact that it was directed at her this time (from someone she probably thought would only do stuff like that to the opposition).

BTW, contrary to what some have said here, her monolog was NOT about guys approaching her like Elevator Creep did, nor did she even mention anything like it. She talked about comments she'd gotten from her audiences over the internet. And either way, we have no sign that Elevator Creep was there at the time, or even that he had anything to do with the atheist event at all. (When a hotel hosts an event, other customers who aren't there for that event still use that hotel and its restaurant/bar at the same time.)

She's saying that here is one reason why some women aren't getting involved and it's in the power of the guys who attend those conferences to make that change.
OK, let's pretend I'm somewhere near her, or at least in the same bar, when she decides to leave. (And I'm one of the good guys.) Exactly what can I do to change what Elevator Creep was going to do but hadn't done yet, at some other place outside the bar I'm sitting at? Should I follow her out so I'll be ready to interfere if he tries it or just hopefully deter him from trying it by my presence? Should I guard the door after she leaves to prevent any other men from leaving for the next several minutes? Should I make a public announcement to the bar's other male customers that a woman is leaving and it would be really creepy if anybody were to go after her? Should I loudly announce that a woman just left by another door or in another direction, so the creepy guys will be diverted on a wild goose chase? Should I shoot her with a light-blue paintball, the universal "out of bounds for a day" sign in Man Code?

Or, suppose I'm not at the bar, but in the hallways between there and the elevators. When she passes by, should I turn to accompany her the rest of the way, or just stop and wait to block any man who happens to come along the same way soon after? Or maybe instead of walking in the hallway, I should just be dedicating my night to riding up and down the elevator so there'll always be a third person in there whenever some creepy guy follows a woman in...
 
Last edited:
Most often, it's a way of calling a woman a whore and "getting away with it."

What tosh.

There are such things as man-whores, just like there are male attention whores.

You seem to have a real mad on for finding reasons to be outraged for women.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom