So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
If someone believes that Dawkins' comments are stupid, insensitive, and sexist, then pointing that out -- even in strong language, to which RD is no stranger -- and asking him to rethink and apologize seems like a sensible and proportionate response to me.

Doesn't that equally apply to people who believe the same about Rebecca Watson?

Seems like a recipe for a holy war.
 
Yeah, much better than trying to organise a boycott against him...

I don't support a boycott. I can get why Rebecca would, it's just not where I'm prepared to go.

Doesn't that equally apply to people who believe the same about Rebecca Watson?

By all means. I believe people in this thread have demanded that she apologize already; I disagree that she's done anything to require an apology, but I don't think it's some outlandish tactic or "tearing her limb from limb." I think Abbie Smith (of the blog ERV) has declared that she's boycotting any panels involving Watson.

Seems like a recipe for a holy war.

You have a pretty low bar for a holy war. I know that some people just love to analogize anything atheists do to religion (Dawkins is the Atheist Pope, they all follow him slavishly! No, wait, atheists are criticizing Dawkins, it's a Schism that could lead to an Atheist Reformation!), but you're really stretching here.

My prediction is that at some point (are they both at TAM9?) Watson and Dawkins sit down and emerge with a face-saving solution. Dawkins issues a statement saying that he still doesn't see what all the fuss was about, but that all the criticism he's heard has made him aware that there's another perspective he was perhaps too quick to react, so he's going to think about that, and in the meantime, thanks to all those who wrote to him politely, and apologies if he was seen as dismissing a serious concern. Watson will say hey, that's all I really want, boycott over and thanks to everyone for their support. They'll both make a really stupid joke about how they did or didn't drink coffee at their meeting, and there will be much rhapsodizing about how great it is that skeptics all willing to reconsider their positions in response to debate. No one will have truly changed positions: Dawkins will privately think this is all a load of ****, and Watson will still think he's a privileged ****, but the public issue will fizzle out.
 
You have a pretty low bar for a holy war. I know that some people just love to analogize anything atheists do to religion (Dawkins is the Atheist Pope, they all follow him slavishly! No, wait, atheists are criticizing Dawkins, it's a Schism that could lead to an Atheist Reformation!), but you're really stretching here.

Only if you're anal about language. Religious terms are all over the lexicon, I don't put any mystical meaning behind them.

When someone surprises me I often exclaim "Jesus Christ!" I'm not summoning a carpenter.
 
Last edited:
Interesting. It lead to a very odd thought. I kinda see where the people who are all "But, but, but!?" are coming from.

Lets say you're going to TAM and you are (IRL) a slightly awkward person.

I can't go there, bookitty. I may have been shy when I was seven or eight, but not since. That said, I have been a poor fit in some work situations, or in some of the peer groups I stumbled into, but given how I got to where I am, I typically find somebody I fit in with well enough that for me, it's a matter of when not if. Or, I wander of and make a new friend at the next bar I enter. Been doing that for years.

I don't agonize about it. My daughter picked up on the make a new friend at the drop of a hat thing, my son not so much.

I realize not everyone goes along in the same mode as I do, and that for some people, social situations are a minefield. All I can offer is the suggestion to mix it up as best you can, and hope for the best.

There is hope that your following will then occur.
And maybe, in that giddy purely platonic orgy of fellow freethinkers, there will be someone of the opposite sex who gets you, or at least gets your rocks off. Not because you're a lonely loser but because you're with your own kind and that would just be cool.
For those who trip over such good luck, yes, much cool.
Now someone is splashing cold water all over everything and doing it in such a way that there is no real answer and no real guidelines.
You lost me. EG splashed, or Rebecca did?
Sure, even if you can intellectualize why Rebecca may have felt uncomfortable, it's a chilling contrast to past TAMs, pictures of parties and current hopeful expectations.
But doesn't each TAM have its own character, given that different people will come to each one?
So what's to be done? Nothing. Some people will be a little more careful, some will be complete asses, and some will emerge as knights in shining armor with various attendants and the look of having had too little sleep.
Heh.
The free-thought movement, despite it's own fumbling, has gotten larger. TAM sold out, new meetups are popping up all over the place, etc. People will start gravitating to those events that best suit their needs. There won't be any "safe zone" groups but different groups will have different reputations and there will be something there for everyone.
Not sure what safe zone means in this context. If the card carrying credential for TAM arrival requires "socially awkward" (does it?) then it's not any worse than comic cons or war gaming cons.

Caveat Emptor
 
Last edited:
I get sexualized all the time. Oh, that's right. This only occurs in my fantasies. You know, it seems to me that many are still stuck in the 50's with the notion that sex is something men do to women. Unwanted advances? I guess you have to take those along with the wanted ones. Frankly, there are women who want it both ways - men and women are sexually equal, except when a man "sexualizes" a woman. I wasn't there and so can't know what the real deal was. I don't know Rebecca, but from what tiny, little interaction I have had with her in the distant past left me with the impression that she is not completely issue free and you do not want, inadvertently or not, to get on her bad side. Unlike myself, of course.
 
Just to be a contrarian here, I've never been hurt by a one night stand as badly as I've been hurt by a long term relationship. But that's just my personal experience. ;)

I've been hurt by both, and have provided hurt in both. Is that four, or one, data point? :confused:
 
"I demand you stop objectifying women! Now please buy my calendar featuring me semi-nude! I'm the sexy skeptic!" -Rebecca Watson
 
"I demand you stop objectifying women! Now please buy my calendar featuring me semi-nude! I'm the sexy skeptic!" -Rebecca Watson
To repeat my response to you about that on the SGU forum:
NONE of this means she should be followed into an elevator at 4am and hit on without finding that creepy. None of it means people should threaten her with anything. None of it means people should 'joke' about sexually assaulting her. None of it means she, or anyone else, should be objectified.

Sexual innuendo and jokes and calendars are not "Please do whatever you want to me" invitations. Or reasons for people to do things against her will. You're using the same type of arguments that people forcing women to wear burqas are using.
 
To repeat my response to you about that on the SGU forum:

And I still think your misinterpretting what I said.

I wasn't excusing the trolls/social nerds behavior.

I was calling rebecca a hypocrite and an attention whore.

I talk about apples, then you bring in oranges. Stop it.
 
All true. However, posing for a sexy calender then complaining that women are sexually objectified? Come on.
I do not accept the premise that nudity or semi-nudity or existing openly as a sexual being deserves objectification in response.
 
I do not accept the premise that nudity or semi-nudity or existing openly as a sexual being deserves objectification in response.


Posing for a nude or semi-nude calendar is almost always (unless it's some kind of artistic expression, which I don't think most sexy calendars try to be) posing as a sexual object. Whether you accept it or not doesn't make any difference.
 
Last edited:
I do not accept the premise that nudity or semi-nudity or existing openly as a sexual being deserves objectification in response.

I do not accept that this reply is a complete sentence, even though it has all proper grammar in place.
 
appearantly they just locked the SGU thread.

Now I guess I have to backread this entire thread to stay relevant now.
 
No. What I mean is that if we are so concerned with women's rights that Rebecca's moment of discomfort is worth tearing Richard apart limb from limb (metaphorically of course), are there possibly other ways of demonstrating that concern that would have a tad more pay-off?

Linda

Poor Richard isn't being torn apart because we're all so concerned with Rebecca's moment of discomfort. Richard is being torn apart for doing exactly the same sort of thing to Rebecca that he does regularly to various religious celebrities. And the feminists are acting just like any other group defending their own against attack.

What Richard did to Rebecca was likely more painful and discomforting than what EG did. It would certainly have traumatized me more. It also struck me as actually misogynist as opposed to sexual advances, which can be but usually aren't.

I was calling rebecca a hypocrite and an attention whore.

What is with this insult? Is an attention whore a bigger or a lesser insult than just calling her a whore?

I don't agree with everything Rebecca has said, but I think she has guts to put her own experiences out there to be dissected, reviewed, criticized and insulted by unkind strangers and people she once considered her friends, including someone she once admired greatly. Oh, and threats too. I've not been a fan of hers or skeptichick before, but I'm considering hanging out there now.

Further, she has done this because she's actively trying to get more women involved in skepticism and atheism. She's saying that here is one reason why some women aren't getting involved and it's in the power of the guys who attend those conferences to make that change.

This is the picture I'm getting from the many many blog posts and unfolding of events: If a woman doesn't care for certain types of male-female interactions, like getting propositioned or groped by complete strangers at a high frequency, she should either not come or bring a male escort. If you do come, don't bother complaining about that sort of behavior because the men who do such things are just fine with it and see no reason to change. If you do complain, some of them will make fun of you, mock you, and insult you while others will threaten to rape you.

I think that's the status quo that Rebecca is trying to change.
 
Last edited:
And I think that Rebecca is in the wrong in this case.

I mean, I play Starcraft and other video games online. I get tons of threats from people online. Even in mail and stuff, because they don't like it when I beat them and haters gunna hate.

Do you hear me going on a podium complaining about it?

The internet is the internet and I don't think she is going to change the nature of the internet. I mean seriously, you could call it a collective subconscious of our ideas that are repressed from the physical outside platform.

People are gunna say stuff. And people like Rebecca wants to make a big deal about her inbox getting full.


I'm sure Richard Dawkins get lots of hatemail. What does he do? He laughs it off and reads it on a video. What does Rebecca do? She takes them seriously like she is going to get raped tomorrow.

Its really immature on her part and its only furthering the flame war.

That is why I'm calling her an attention whore.
 
This is the picture I'm getting from the many many blog posts and unfolding of events: If a woman doesn't care for certain types of male-female interactions, like getting propositioned or groped by complete strangers at a high frequency, she should either not come or bring a male escort. If you do come, don't bother complaining about that sort of behavior because the men who do such things are just fine with it and see no reason to change. If you do complain, some of them will make fun of you, mock you, and insult you while others will threaten to rape you.

I think that's the status quo that Rebecca is trying to change.

When I read the phrase "the picture I'm getting" or "I'm picking up a vibe here" or "what it seems to me you are saying" I immediately see a giant, metaphorical warning sign saying "Extreme Straw Man Danger Ahead".

In this particular case I think a few different things are going on.

One is that many male skeptics run the gamut from being completely well-intentioned but painfully socially inept all the way through to outright misogynist jerks. I've met several wonderful, skeptical Australian women who have nothing to do with the Australian Skeptics organisation for exactly that reason.

(Much like many other things, skepticism's worthiness as an interest is not necessarily reflected perfectly in the makeup of the people who form clubs about it).

Another is that many skeptics, male and female, endorse various flavours of feminism which are faith-based rather than evidence-based. Human nature being what it is, people who are perfectly capable of taking a rationalist approach to Bigfoot are not capable of doing so competently when it comes to their political convictions.

My take on it is that the reason this argument has caused so much discussion in the skeptical community is that we're seeing the skeptic-misogynist community and the skeptic-feminist-irrationalist community butting heads. Confusing the issue further are the skeptic-feminst-rationalist community who are sticking the boot into both sides, and being mistaken by each side for members of the other.

For the record I put Dawkins in the misogynist camp, and Watson and Plait in the feminist-irrationalist camp.

Do I have a solution? No. Asking "How can we get more women into organised skepticism?" seems to me a bit like asking "How can we get more well-groomed, socially adept, high-earning people, especially women, to come to comic book conventions?" Organised skepticism attracts a certain kind of person. I'm not sure you're going to change the kind of person organised skepticism attracts without fundamentally changing the nature of organised skepticism.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom