So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, that happens. But humans have not perfected reading other people's behavior, especially when they have a strongly desired goal in mind. Explicit consent is no more than "Do you want this?" In scenes where people push the boundaries of sexual experiences, making sure that all parties are aware, informed and willing is the norm.

We have a regular way of gauging consent: if the person says no or stop you should stop. if you ignore them it's non-consensual.

It only gets complex because of the mind crime rubbish that's been embraced.
 
We have a regular way of gauging consent: if the person says no or stop you should stop. if you ignore them it's non-consensual.

It only gets complex because of the mind crime rubbish that's been embraced.

That's sort of backwards, isn't it. No means this has gone too far. Yes means this hasn't gone far enough. Trying to avoid a no seems a bit crude when you can easily check for a yes.

There is a place for no. People should always have the option of stopping something that has gone too far. But a mutually beneficial sexual relationship is about going somewhere together.
 
but now it appears there is a wedge going down of whats "manly", whats "creep" and whats "normal" that apparently trumps our ability to reason and thats what makes me annoyed with this entire thing.

It doesn't have to be that way. Whether or not we 'would have known a priori' EG's choice of interaction creeped at least some people out, can't we simply nod and cross that off thepossibilities list? Nobody can know for sure that something we haven't tried before may creep someone out, of course; but when we have some data that a given approach does so, doesn't it only make sense to reject that one? If the point of striking up a conversation with someone is to initiate congenial interaction, doesn't asserting your right to use whatever method you want and not have to worry about offending people or making them uncomfortable fly in the face of the goal we're trying to achieve?

Honestly, what difference does it make whether the same situation would have made YOU uncomfortable? It makes some people uncomfortable, for whatever reason. So choose a different one. How badly does refraining from asking women for sex while you're alone with her in an elevator at 4am limit one's options for social interaction?
 
Last edited:
Hmmm... I've had occasions when women I've barely met made it perfectly clear what they wanted, and certainly didn't ask me for "explicitly stated consent" first.

Yeah and I've had men I've barely met make it perfectly clear what they wanted, and certainly didn't ask me for "explicitly stated consent" first. That turned into a very negative experience for them.

It's best to check first.
 
I've been tricked and asked to hit the third floor button on the elevator and then I was goosed by many women when I turned my back as I turned and bent to hit the button (I never learn). However, no one ever seemed to take me seriously when I complained just as in this video.

Who can deny the double standard?
 
Yet you hit that SEND key after typing belittling statements...or is your advice only good for vocal exchanges?
Because I get sick and tired of people trying to justify creepy behavior by having some sort social issue.
 
Last edited:
I understand that there are millions of starving children in the world, so why does anyone care about Sylvia Brown? Those children are starving, how does making sure that a few less middle-class people waste money on a bogus psychic help them?

No. What I mean is that if we are so concerned with women's rights that Rebecca's moment of discomfort is worth tearing Richard apart limb from limb (metaphorically of course), are there possibly other ways of demonstrating that concern that would have a tad more pay-off?

Linda
 
Would we universally agree that you are not a creep, or is there a chance that some posters find you creepy?
I'm too socially inept and conservative to ever come close to talking like that. In fact if I was ever propositioned I'm sure I would run away screaming. :(
 
Last edited:
I'm too socially inept and conservative to ever proposition someone like that.

That's really a very specific example though. You said you learned not to be creepy, I asked if you're sure you're 100% successful.

Or, are you in fact saying you learned how to avoid being significant enough of a creep for women not to blog about the experience? Otherwise how would you know?

Legitimate question by the way; self examination is never easy.
 
No. What I mean is that if we are so concerned with women's rights that Rebecca's moment of discomfort is worth tearing Richard apart limb from limb (metaphorically of course), are there possibly other ways of demonstrating that concern that would have a tad more pay-off?

Linda

if you can think of something let me know. I'm glad that this is being discussed. As I mentioned earlier, it has been growing for some time. No other example got quite this amount of interest, so maybe this is what it took. maybe it's timing.
 
I've been tricked and asked to hit the third floor button on the elevator and then I was goosed by many women when I turned my back as I turned and bent to hit the button (I never learn). However, no one ever seemed to take me seriously when I complained just as in this video.

Who can deny the double standard?

And see, there really isn't a double standard. Your history of posting has lead people to believe that you were bragging more than complaining and you weren't taken seriously.
 
I've been tricked and asked to hit the third floor button on the elevator and then I was goosed by many women when I turned my back as I turned and bent to hit the button

So was this a group of women driven mad with lust at the same time, or many separate women unable to resist the hypnotic lure of your bum?
 
I've been tricked and asked to hit the third floor button on the elevator and then I was goosed by many women when I turned my back as I turned and bent to hit the button (I never learn). However, no one ever seemed to take me seriously when I complained just as in this video.

Who can deny the double standard?

Yep. I've been put in really uncomfortable situations by my female co-workers and bosses, and been ignored when I complained.

I imagine that if the sexes of each person in this farce were switched, the tone would be jarring.
 
And see, there really isn't a double standard. Your history of posting has lead people to believe that you were bragging more than complaining and you weren't taken seriously.

If you would bother to read the studies about men being assaulted by women in the elevator you would know many men are too ashamed to admit their bottoms are red and sore by the time they reach the double digit floors where they work on a daily basis. Us abused men victims have learned to be keep our mouths shut and accept the abuse lest we be further mocked.

I bet few who are not in my demographic even believe me reading this.
 
Nobody disagrees that EG handled himself poorly or than Rebecca had reason to be discomforted.

Well, maybe not very many people, but certainly some. Seismosaurus, for one.

I understand that there are millions of starving children in the world, so why does anyone care about Sylvia Brown? Those children are starving, how does making sure that a few less middle-class people waste money on a bogus psychic help them?

Why would anyone care whether someone refers to a child as a Catholic child or a Muslim child? It's all just words.

No. What I mean is that if we are so concerned with women's rights that Rebecca's moment of discomfort is worth tearing Richard apart limb from limb (metaphorically of course), are there possibly other ways of demonstrating that concern that would have a tad more pay-off?

But that really is just a metaphor. No actual physical harm has come to Richard Dawkins. It's all just words.
 
Because I get sick and tired of people trying to justify creepy behavior by having some sort social issue.

Some behaviors are inherited, some are learned. Both could be classified as social issues depending on the paradigm by which you classify them.

With that being said. What exactly are you sick of?

Also, i might add, explaining something through potential social disorders/issues isn't exactly justifying those behaviors.
 
No. What I mean is that if we are so concerned with women's rights that Rebecca's moment of discomfort is worth tearing Richard apart limb from limb (metaphorically of course), are there possibly other ways of demonstrating that concern that would have a tad more pay-off?

Linda

I'm not sure what constitutes "tearing Richard apart limb from limb" metaphorically. It sounds to me like the same kind of thing that Dawkins' critics keep accusing him of doing, all that "militant, angry atheist" nonsense.

If someone believes that Dawkins' comments are stupid, insensitive, and sexist, then pointing that out -- even in strong language, to which RD is no stranger -- and asking him to rethink and apologize seems like a sensible and proportionate response to me.
 
If someone believes that Dawkins' comments are stupid, insensitive, and sexist, then pointing that out -- even in strong language, to which RD is no stranger -- and asking him to rethink and apologize seems like a sensible and proportionate response to me.

Yeah, much better than trying to organise a boycott against him...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom