So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
A bathhouse has rules, some posted on the wall and some are well understood social constructs. Acting within those rules assures consent.

Real life doesn't have as many examples of "Hi!" then sex.

No - but they DO exist. So this is always going to require a healthy degree of maturity and subjectivity. A hard and fast rule isn't going to work for what is explicit consent in a casual sex instance, nor as in what is implicitly 'right' or 'wrong' in a 0400h elevator encounter between two people.
 
A bathhouse has rules, some posted on the wall and some are well understood social constructs. Acting within those rules assures consent.
That could be said about just about anything... "as long as you follow the rules, nothing that would be considered a breach of the rules can happen". Way to state the obvious. You didn't actually answer the question though.

Real life doesn't have as many examples of "Hi!" then sex.
Um. Maybe not in your life. Other people have different experiences. You need to stop trying to apply your personal life experiences onto the rest of the world.
 
Of all the elevator rides you've been on in all the hotels you've stayed at going to those engineering conferences, how many times have you felt nervous because you were alone with a lone male in the elevator?
At a conference - never. The only time I have felt nervous because I was alone with a lone male in an elevator was after a total stranger propositioned me. And not as subtly as EG did. This guy, who I had never seen before, just told me he found me attractive and asked if I would to go to bed with him.

To be honest, after I realized he wasn't going to be a problem, it wasn't a big deal to me then. I just said no and he continued talking to put me at ease. Would I kiss him? Would I hug him? Would I shake his hand? There were a couple of other factors that made it less dangerous. It was in a lively college dormitory with people around who would have heard me scream even from in the elevator and even though it was late at night. It was also before I had been sexually assaulted and I wasn't as aware of either the danger or the danger signals then as I am now.
 
Boo - how explicit is explicit?

Are we talking signed & witnessed affadavits?

Or if say... someone is in a bathhouse, makes eye contact, a gesture is made and you step into a cubicle, what happens next may not actually be rape?

This is actually pretty easy to figure out by looking at the laws of the relevant state.
 
A bathhouse has rules, some posted on the wall and some are well understood social constructs. Acting within those rules assures consent.

There used to be rules regarding social interaction between men and women. They all got blasted into smithereens some time during the 1970s. Gee, I wonder why.
 
OK folks - I'm outta here for a bit. Meeting a friend for dinner, and she may have Roofies in her purse. So if I'm not back by midnight reading 25 more pages of mumbo-jumbo and posting terse/amusing comments, please send a search party to The Queen Elizabeth Hotel, Montreal (the one where John & Yoko stayed). Have them check the elevators, and I like my coffee with a splash of 2% milk and no sugar, please & thank you.
 
Um. Maybe not in your life. Other people have different experiences. You need to stop trying to apply your personal life experiences onto the rest of the world.

In my life it's more along the lines of "Why are you wearing pants?" then sex.

Unless it's something like

Someone else: "Have you met D?"
I: "Well, I met the other end."

Then sex.
 
That could be said about just about anything... "as long as you follow the rules, nothing that would be considered a breach of the rules can happen". Way to state the obvious. You didn't actually answer the question though.

Um. Maybe not in your life. Other people have different experiences. You need to stop trying to apply your personal life experiences onto the rest of the world.

I didn't say it didn't happen, I said it wasn't as prevalent as it was at a bathhouse.

Swingers clubs have very careful rules that are preset in order to make sure that everyone has a good time. Some of these are posted, some are understood. As bathhouses operate in a similar fashion (i.e. give space to people who are interested in that scene) and from what friends have told me, I have reason to believe that there are similarities.
 
I realize that I could be wrong, in which case I'll be happy to throw Richard under the bus. :)

Linda

Upon further thought...I'm going to take that back. Even if Richard is just pointing out that some women have it much, much worse so quit yer whining...some women have it much, much worse. Why are we raising such a stink about whether Rebecca should ever have a moment of discomfort?

I get that some of what happens to women in other cultures is so horrific that we need to mentally distance ourselves from them. But how is ensuring that those of us who are privileged live in a fluffy, pink world going to help them?

Linda
 
No, I am saying that sex without explicit consent has a greater possibility of harming one of the participants than sex with explicit consent. This harm is not negligible. Because it is very easy to assure explicit consent and thus reduce the chance of harm, promoting or defending casual or implied consent is callous.

Let's make sure to take this to its logical conclusion -- sex outside of a long-term committed monogomous relationship has a greater possibility of harming one of the participants than sex within such a relationship, and therefore promoting or defending casual sex is callous.

However, "callous" or not, equating extramarital sex or sex with implied consent (both of which are stupid and should never occur) with nonconsensual sex (which is illegal and blatantly unethical) is inappropriate, and honestly I think you know better.
 
Swingers clubs have very careful rules that are preset in order to make sure that everyone has a good time. Some of these are posted, some are understood. As bathhouses operate in a similar fashion (i.e. give space to people who are interested in that scene) and from what friends have told me, I have reason to believe that there are similarities.

The fundamental rule at every swingers' club I've been to has been "stop if someone says no." I'm not sure what more needs to be said, at least so far as consent is concerned (ETA: at least in the context of a sex club). Taking that back to your original point, is it really the case that consent must be explicitly stated in every encounter to be legitimate? How often does anyone pause to say, "Do you hereby consent to proceed with sexual activity with me?," and wait for an affirmative answer? Isn't consent more often than not implied by the other person's behavior rather than expressly stated?
 
Last edited:
Upon further thought...I'm going to take that back. Even if Richard is just pointing out that some women have it much, much worse so quit yer whining...some women have it much, much worse. Why are we raising such a stink about whether Rebecca should ever have a moment of discomfort?

I get that some of what happens to women in other cultures is so horrific that we need to mentally distance ourselves from them. But how is ensuring that those of us who are privileged live in a fluffy, pink world going to help them?

Linda

I understand that there are millions of starving children in the world, so why does anyone care about Sylvia Brown? Those children are starving, how does making sure that a few less middle-class people waste money on a bogus psychic help them?
 
....Real life doesn't have as many examples of "Hi!" then sex. .....
I can't speak for young people today, but I can say in my teens and twenties, real life most certainly did. Clearly era and place make a difference, but where I was then, causal sex was quite the norm.

And if you read about the history of the HIV pandemic, the chapter that deals with the epidemic as it hit the US most definitely included the bathhouse orgy era. I don't think they often bothered with, "Hi". ;)
 
Last edited:
Nobody disagrees that EG handled himself poorly or than Rebecca had reason to be discomforted.

I just don't see why getting to a place where no woman is ever discomforted or no one ever chews gum is something we actually want.

Linda

I think some people disagree. Unless there's been some new information asking her up for coffee at 4AM isn't a proposition. If it's innuendo it's very subtle. I don't think he handled himself poorly, it seems like a polite and friendly invitation to extend the conversation that may have been taken the wrong way.
 
I understand that there are millions of starving children in the world, so why does anyone care about Sylvia Brown? Those children are starving, how does making sure that a few less middle-class people waste money on a bogus psychic help them?

EDIT:

Maybe starving children and disgusting misery milking frauds are both more heinous than a socially awkward man in a lift?

I can see a blog about children being dismembered in the Congo, i can also see one about sports injuries ending careers. A blog about stubbing your toe...
 
Last edited:
Let's make sure to take this to its logical conclusion -- sex outside of a long-term committed monogomous relationship has a greater possibility of harming one of the participants than sex within such a relationship, and therefore promoting or defending casual sex is callous.....
Just to be a contrarian here, I've never been hurt by a one night stand as badly as I've been hurt by a long term relationship. But that's just my personal experience. ;)
 
The fundamental rule at every swingers' club I've been to has been "stop if someone says no." I'm not sure what more needs to be said, at least so far as consent is concerned (ETA: at least in the context of a sex club). Taking that back to your original point, is it really the case that consent must be explicitly stated in every encounter to be legitimate? How often does anyone pause to say, "Do you hereby consent to proceed with sexual activity with me?," and wait for an affirmative answer? Isn't consent more often than not implied by the other person's behavior rather than expressly stated?

Yes, that happens. But humans have not perfected reading other people's behavior, especially when they have a strongly desired goal in mind. Explicit consent is no more than "Do you want this?" In scenes where people push the boundaries of sexual experiences, making sure that all parties are aware, informed and willing is the norm.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom