So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
....
Who has said that one should fear every encounter with a guy you haven't met? ....
Ah, yes. I've exaggerated the same way I've complained about others doing. ;) So let me clarify. There are a number of people posting opinons in this thread who suggest women should/would naturally fear things I don't perceive as inherently dangerous.

Of all the elevator rides you've been on in all the hotels you've stayed at going to those engineering conferences, how many times have you felt nervous because you were alone with a lone male in the elevator? I am purposefully asking for a denominator here. I don't doubt such a scenario would ever feel uncomfortable.

....No. It's been suggested that it's a courteous thing for men to do. Kind of like men opening doors for women. Is that considered sexist these days? Does it even ever come up anymore?

What I've seen recommended (elsewhere, not here) is that a women who gets a 'vibe' that worries her should get off the elevator with the stranger and take the next one. Don't worry about hurting his feelings, the advice is not to get into a confined space with a stranger that makes you uncomfortable. That seems quite sensible to me. Getting off the elevator is something that a women can do for herself, she needn't rely on the courtesy of strangers.
I think it is an unrealistic expectation and I wonder if such an action (deferring to the next elevator car) ever crosses men's minds. I've never heard of such a thing while I have certainly heard about opening doors for women.

I agree with the second comment. If I'm uncomfortable and the guy really hasn't done anything, it is up to me to take responsibility and get off the elevator. Why should the guy? Because he is bigger/stronger? That seems sexist. :)
 
You know what's weird? Dawkins has been a speaker at many conferences. He has probably had some fan approach him and ask to speak to him privately as he is leaving the room. But he didn't use that as an example, he used being on an elevator with someone who is chewing gum.

I am not trying to make a point with this. There is nothing that can come from this observation that has not already been mentioned. It's just a little strange.

Well, I think that there's a fair chance that Dawkins was drunk when he wrote this. It does seem to me to have an alcoholic flavor to it.
 
The problem is making a pass at a woman for whom you are a stranger and are alone with in an elevator at 4 am in the morning. That's uncouth. And obviously could be worrisome That's all the issue is.
 
The problem is making a pass at a woman for whom you are a stranger and are alone with in an elevator at 4 am in the morning. That's uncouth. And obviously could be worrisome That's all the issue is.

I agree completely.
 
If they have both agreed to enjoy sex together for purely physical gratification, neither is objectifying the other. They are two people engaged in a mutually beneficial relationship to which each has consented. Both of their needs have been considered. Even though their needs at the moment can be reduced to "I want to enjoy your body." The example I gave was rape in which one person has been reduced to an object.

ETA: And seriously, what is it with you and consent? Consent isn't a remnant of archaic prudery. It is the most basic form of respect.
Why would you think I said nonconsensual sex?

How do you get consent if you don't ask? Not every woman cares to get to know the guy first, just as not every guy cares to get to know the woman. It is possible to be physically attracted first and get to know the guy second, ... or not.
 
The problem is making a pass at a woman for whom you are a stranger and are alone with in an elevator at 4 am in the morning. That's uncouth. And obviously could be worrisome That's all the issue is.

That is an elegant way of saying that. I think I've wasted 65,000,000 words trying to express that notion.
 
You would seriously be supportive of a son that lurked around in a bar for several hours avoiding conversation with a woman he was interested in until said woman announced she was tired, then following that woman until she was isolated and vulnerable (so he could spare himself the humiliation of being turned down in front of others--again, not adult behavior), and capping off the sleazy, wimpy, cowardly attempt at seduction by using his first words towards this woman to proposition her?

Wow, you really are incredibly judgmental.

Here's an alternate theory: The guy did interact with her at the bar, but she was drunk and checking out another guy (who wasn't interested) all night and didn't really register EG's existence.

EG picks up her vibe and misconstrues who it's meant for (because he's socially inept/has a mental limitation when it comes to empathy) and decides to try his luck.

There, and I have just as much hard evidence this is what happened as you have that EG was a childish creep coward, propositioning a woman by stealth.
 
Why would you think I said nonconsensual sex?

How do you get consent if you don't ask? Not every woman cares to get to know the guy first, just as not every guy cares to get to know the woman. It is possible to be physically attracted first and get to know the guy second, ... or not.

If there is no explicitly stated consent, it is non-consensual. That's what non-consensual means.

There are some people of all genders who don't care to get to know someone before having sex and there have been many circumstances in which this leads to a terrific time for all. There have also been many cases where this was not the case and people of all genders have been hurt.

Promoting casual sex is fine, I'm all for it. Promoting sexual relationships with questionable consent is a bit callous.
 
And sometimes they aren't lying. No one knows beforehand who will be the one to rape them. This is simply a factual statement with irrefutable evidence to back it up.

Congratulations, you met one factual statement with another.

Since no-one was disputing your fact, I must assume you simply felt the need to score a point somehow or have the last word.
 
I'm sorry but most people usually get made fun of when they invoke this arguments. As I said before socially awkwared is not an excuse for idiocy. You have a brain. You can think two seconds before speaking.

Yet you hit that SEND key after typing belittling statements...or is your advice only good for vocal exchanges?
 
If there is no explicitly stated consent, it is non-consensual. That's what non-consensual means.

No; non-consensual means no consent. Sex with implied consent would be consensual sex; that's what "consensual" means.

Are you claiming it's not possible to imply consent, and that all sexual encounters that occur without explicit discussion of sex are nonconsensual? Because if so, I disagree.
 
If there is no explicitly stated consent, it is non-consensual. That's what non-consensual means.

There are some people of all genders who don't care to get to know someone before having sex and there have been many circumstances in which this leads to a terrific time for all. There have also been many cases where this was not the case and people of all genders have been hurt.

Promoting casual sex is fine, I'm all for it. Promoting sexual relationships with questionable consent is a bit callous.
This straw man borders on bizarre.
 
Wow, you really are incredibly judgmental.

Here's an alternate theory: The guy did interact with her at the bar, but she was drunk and checking out another guy (who wasn't interested) all night and didn't really register EG's existence.

Yeah, yeah, and we might just be brains in a vat...

EG picks up her vibe and misconstrues who it's meant for (because he's socially inept/has a mental limitation when it comes to empathy) and decides to try his luck.

That would change nothing about the approach. Whatever was running through EG's head, he handled himself poorly. In society our intent and behavior is constrained by its effect on others. Adults consider this before acting.

There, and I have just as much hard evidence this is what happened as you have that EG was a childish creep coward, propositioning a woman by stealth.

You have a story that makes the fellow slightly more redeemable (though on a second read, your vision is much more depressing than mine), but it really changes nothing about the inappropriateness of the behavior.

If we learn that this person has some kind of serious mental problem, it would make us evaluate him differently. It would not make that behavior acceptable.
 
Boo - how explicit is explicit?

Are we talking signed & witnessed affadavits?

Or if say... someone is in a bathhouse, makes eye contact, a gesture is made and you step into a cubicle, what happens next may not actually be rape?
 
No; non-consensual means no consent. Sex with implied consent would be consensual sex; that's what "consensual" means.

Are you claiming it's not possible to imply consent, and that all sexual encounters that occur without explicit discussion of sex are nonconsensual? Because if so, I disagree.

No, I am saying that sex without explicit consent has a greater possibility of harming one of the participants than sex with explicit consent. This harm is not negligible. Because it is very easy to assure explicit consent and thus reduce the chance of harm, promoting or defending casual or implied consent is callous.
 
Boo - how explicit is explicit?

Are we talking signed & witnessed affadavits?

Or if say... someone is in a bathhouse, makes eye contact, a gesture is made and you step into a cubicle, what happens next may not actually be rape?

A bathhouse has rules, some posted on the wall and some are well understood social constructs. Acting within those rules assures consent.

Real life doesn't have as many examples of "Hi!" then sex.

ETA: It doesn't really take much. For example, I was hanging out with a few people in the bedroom during a party. My buddy was talking to a girl he'd met that night and they were totally hitting it off. Out of the blue he says to her in a beavis accent "Hey, you wanna, heh heh you know, do it?" to which she replied "Yeah! huh huh" like butthead and then they both kicked the rest of us out while screaming about bungholes.

Had she laughed and replied "Hey, I don't even know your name!" I would not have allowed myself to be kicked out.
 
Last edited:
Nobody disagrees that EG handled himself poorly or than Rebecca had reason to be discomforted.

I just don't see why getting to a place where no woman is ever discomforted or no one ever chews gum is something we actually want.

Linda
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom