Surely you are not suggesting that it is the presence of small talk that distinguishes any of these cases?! And again, how is any of that supposed to help "that guy" who has already had the experience of engaging in small in talk in elevators without women cowering in the corner begging not to be raped?
I'm suggesting that just because the verbal content of the statement was seemingly innocuous, that doesn't make Rebecca's apprehension any less valid.
Rebecca wasn't cowering in the corner, she was deeply uncomfortable. The discomfort was heightened by the nature of the converstion and the fact that she was a captive audience.
How do you talk to women in elevators? Certainly not by propositioning them without any prior contact. Asking about business would have been good--where is your next speaking engagement? are you going to TAM...whatever. If she wants to continue the coversation when you leave the elevator, great, if not, let her go.
I really don't think it's that complicated. The content of the coversation doesn't automatically mean your intentions are pure, but the content can certainly cause more apprehension. I doubt very seriously we ever would have heard of "Elavator Guy" if he had said, I enjoyed your talk, are you going to write a book or anything?
I'm trying to understand how the guy can get some idea of how he comes across, because this is difficult to discover.
Have friends, talk to people, listen to what women say. If nothing else, a whole lot of men are now aware of a set of behaviors a good number of women find objectionable. Whether they choose to respect that opinion is up to them.
The issue of proper interpersonal relations is obviously a vastly complicated hornet's nest. That doesn't mean there aren't clear examples. It's hard to explain why propositioning a woman you've had no prior contact with in an enclosed space late at night would cause a good number of women to be uncomfortable other than the ways that have been offered.
I agree that it's reasonable. I don't think the advice which has been given has been useful or helpful for the reasons I outlined. So far, I get the impression that men should picture all women as weak and vulnerable so as to understand their perspective.
That's why the environment is important. Everyone is weak and vulnerable given the proper circumstances. The reality of sexual assault in America in the 21st century causes more women to legitimately fear a wider variety of those circumstances than men.
Notice, however, that the weak and vulnerable ones in this equation are the men. It's so difficult to talk to women in public that we must be allowed confrontation out of the public eye in whatever means we choose.
Here's a basic rule of thumb: Getting two people alone together should involve the willfull choice of both.
Sometimes that happens by chance. In those circumstances, be respectful until both parties are able to freely choose.
Lot's of gray area there, but EG ain't one of them.