So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just checking in for my nightly fix and today's body count.

Reading back through the thread, I can't help feeling that there are some pretty creepy posts in here. And given some people (possibly even female people) could be reading the thread alone at 4am, unable to find a way out, I'd just like to ask posters not to do that.
 
But some people have been saying exactly that-- that the appropriate place to proposition Rebecca was in the crowded bar. E.g., this guy:

That's nonsense. Getting a quiet moment alone with Rebecca Watson at a bar after an atheist conference is never going to happen, and "would you like to come back to my room for 'coffee'" is not a question you ask in front of a crowd. EG had two options: ask the question in the privacy of the elevator, or don't ask it at all. He chose poorly.

This highlights the oddness of the defenses of this goofball (setting aside the issue of whether you represented the blog post correctly):

The act of "getting a quiet moment alone with Rebecca Watson" is choice that involves two people. Rebecca gets to choose whether she wants to be alone with this guy, and the way she chooses is by having a conversation with him, or not. Maybe she looks over, checks out his rockin' package, and they walk out together and **** all night without ever saying a word to each other, whatever.

But it involves both people. By waiting until Rebecca was alone and in a situation that drastically limited her free movement, he denied her that choice.

If you can't fight through the crowd to get in a word with Rebecca Watson, so be it. She's, roughly speaking, a celebrity of some sort at these events, that's the way it goes. But just because you have a tough time talking to her at a bar, that doesn't give you the opportunity to behave as he did.

And even with all that in mind, there were still better ways for this person to begin a line of communication with Ms. Watson.
 
Reading back through the thread, I can't help feeling that there are some pretty creepy posts in here. And given some people (possibly even female people) could be reading the thread alone at 4am, unable to find a way out, I'd just like to ask posters not to do that.


Which ones do you find creepy? Hard to ask people not to post in a certain way if you don't provide examples of what you mean, or at least a clearer description beyond "pretty creepy".
 
I suspect a lot of the hoo-ha about this issue has been caused because Rebecca didn't make it entirely clear what she was objecting to. If it was being sexualised as she seems to have claimed, then why does the location make any difference? Is it sexualising someone to proposition them alone, but not sexualising them to proposition them elsewhere? If the real complaint was her feeling uncomfortable, was it uncomfortable as in embarrassing, or uncomfortable as in she feared for her safety? If the former - well embarrassing things happen sometimes and we all have to live with them. And if the latter, she is well within her rights to feel uncomfortable in any situation, but I can't see why the guy asking her back to his room is any greater risk (for being attacked in the elevator) than the guy saying nothing, or the guy making small talk (note the rape in the elevator case linked to a short while back - in which the man made small talk and then attacked the woman)?

So basically, I think rebecca mentioned this before she thought through exactly what it is she is objecting to - which is fair enough, it was a small aside in a much longer video. But given the discussion that occurred afterwards, I think she should have thought it through a bit more and clarified things a bit better. As far as i can see, she only muddied the waters further with the remark about sexualisation.

In summary, people who are well known for blogging about skeptical issues maybe need to think things through better, or be better communicators.
 
Last edited:
Many have claimed that this is a tempest in a teapot and pointless bickering. I disagree and would like to explain why.

My first skeptical gathering was TAM 8, last year. Apparently, from what I heard from speakers and other attendees, there were some issues regarding the male-female balance at TAM 7 and the JREF decided to address that imbalance and aggressively promote more female speakers and do more community reach-out to female skeptics. Most every attendee I spoke with at TAM 8 agreed with this and felt that being more inclusive of females was a very positive step for the whole skeptical movement.

During this last year, I also started to listen to SGU (having first heard about it at TAM 8) and got to know Rebecca through that program. Having listened to about 4 years of podcasts in 4 months, I quickly learned that Rebecca has for most of that time been at the forefront of the push within the movement to include more women in skepticism.

Now comes the Dublin conference and the incident with EG. Rebecca points out that his behavior made her uncomfortable and this is not an isolated incident (perhaps more extreme than others, but not unique). Clearly the incident had some impact on Rebecca, and it is hard to conceive that at some point, she did not question the very goal of including more women into skepticism. However, she chose instead to make this a learning moment and point out how such behavior affects women and is detrimental to the goal of having more women at such conferences.

Whatever you think of what came afterwards, it is not just about how EG behaved and how Rebecca reacted. It is about how much do we truly value women within the movement.

This is why Dawkins' remarks bother me so much. Yes, he is correct, in that what Rebecca experienced is nowhere near as bad as what women in other parts of the world suffer. However, if we truly value what Rebecca and other women do for the skeptical movement overall, then how comfortable they are to come to these events is very important. Dawkin's dismissal of Rebecca was, in my mind, tantamount to him publicly stating that her contribution to the skeptical movement is so minimal that it matters not to him whether she continues to attend skeptical events. I simply cannot agree with that assessment.

In short, if we agree that women are important to the skeptical movement, then it is incumbent upon all of us that they feel comfortable and welcome at skeptical events. If a few outliers don't know how to behave around women in such settings then we need to teach them, not justify or dismiss their behavior as 'awkward' or 'shy'. And we definitely do not want to dismiss the discomfort of those women as 'insignificant in the larger picture' as Dawkins did.
 
Setting everything else aside, that's where I part ways. Yes, people end up in elevators alone all the time. Often just a man and a woman. It was that next step that puts the nail in the coffin:

And that's where the spin (either in my direction or yours) ends. Yes, there is an expectation that this person consider the environment and the nature of his question.

I get that you wouldn't feel uncomfortable in that scenario. Look, we all know the old stories about Native Americans working on sky-scrapers without safety harnasses because they weren't afraid of heights. If I was walking around up there, I would be scared ****-less. That fear would not be irrational, I would be perfectly justified in requesting safety gear.

The lack of fear in other people does not make my perception any less rational or valid, and likewise, the fact that I'm afraid does not mean the others should be. Nevertheless, some amount of danger is present regardless of people's opinions toward it.

I didn't say that Rebecca shouldn't feel uncomfortable because I might not feel uncomfortable or afraid. I said that at least some men will have had the experience of being in an elevator with a women and will have engaged in conversation with them without anything untoward happening. How are they then supposed to reconcile those experiences with suggestions that they should realize this scares women?

Like I have said all along, sure you can offer up an extreme or obvious example which makes the distinction clear. But that's of no help when there is no clear distinction to be made in the situation at hand.

Men should understand how their behavior affects others. EG didn't know what the attitude of the woman in the elevator would be, but there is an obvious implication that was strengthened by the bald proposition.

Because he is alone with a woman in an environment where she has no exit. This is not an appropriate place for a proposition, regardless of how mild it is in construct. Google "sexual assault elevator" and read through some of the cases:

http://host.madison.com/wsj/news/lo...98a-11df-998d-001cc4c03286.html#ixzz1RX5QoNTj

Now, to be clear that is not linked to 1) argue that you should be afraid in an elevator or 2) to argue that this sort of thing is an inevitability.

But men should be able to realize how their behavior is affecting women.

Surely you are not suggesting that it is the presence of small talk that distinguishes any of these cases?! And again, how is any of that supposed to help "that guy" who has already had the experience of engaging in small in talk in elevators without women cowering in the corner begging not to be raped?

I should also point out that the notion that this was a chance encounter that EG sought to capitalize on is contradicted by the, "I think you're really interesting" phrase. Regardless of what he intended, it's very reasonable for Rebecca Watson to be thinking, "who is this guy, has he been following me around, how am I going to get out of here if he gets even weirder..."

I don't want to suggest that it was unreasonable for Rebecca to feel uncomfortable or that I wouldn't have felt the same way. Rebecca doesn't strike me as someone who would over-react or be unnecessarily sensitive. I'm trying to understand how the guy can get some idea of how he comes across, because this is difficult to discover. For example, I do not understand why other people seem to find me approachable (in real life). If I had to guess, I would have thought that I give off a 'prickly' vibe. But that's not how I get treated.

It's not too much to ask to avoid putting women through that thought process, but nothing serious did happen, which is why the request was circumscribed: guys, please don't do that.

I agree that it's reasonable. I don't think the advice which has been given has been useful or helpful for the reasons I outlined. So far, I get the impression that men should picture all women as weak and vulnerable so as to understand their perspective.

Linda
 
cwalner - the thing is that rebecca is making a point about what *she thinks* is something keeping women away from skeptical events. She has no data to back her up, only an anecdote or two. perhaps she or others, if they really want to know why there is a gender imbalance, should try doing some proper research on the matter rather than assuming that their own experiences apply to everyone.

For example is it true that many women have attended such a conference and then never returned because of unpleasant experiences such as she describes? We don't know. Is it true that many women have never attended because they have heard about such experiences and decided not to attend? We don't know. There could be a myriad of factors affecting why women are less well represented at skeptical events, but an anecdote doesn't cut it for me when it comes to evidence.
 
I can assure you that being followed into an elevator at 4:00 AM by a man she has not previously interacted with and being propositioned may not make every single woman on the planet at best uncomfortable, I would bet very serious money that it will make almost every woman at best uncomfortable. That some people refuse to accept this fact both mystifies and saddens me.

-Pieter
What century are you in? As an adult woman, I think I could handle a guy making a pass in such a situation without fear. Someone could join the elevator with said person leaving the chat and at the same time give off vibes one should be concerned about, but to claim this is automatically worrisome is ludicrous. It's a hotel! People use the elevator. Men talk to women they haven't been formally introduced to. The world is just not that scary one should fear every encounter with a guy you haven't met. The proof is in the fact NOTHING BUT ASKING HAPPENED!!

Had this been a simple coincidence, two people going to their rooms at 4 am, are you suggesting a gentleman would wait and take the next elevator car so as to not frighten the vulnerable little female in the elevator? That's rather sexist.
 
cwalner - the thing is that rebecca is making a point about what *she thinks* is something keeping women away from skeptical events. She has no data to back her up, only an anecdote or two. perhaps she or others, if they really want to know why there is a gender imbalance, should try doing some proper research on the matter rather than assuming that their own experiences apply to everyone.

For example is it true that many women have attended such a conference and then never returned because of unpleasant experiences such as she describes? We don't know. Is it true that many women have never attended because they have heard about such experiences and decided not to attend? We don't know. There could be a myriad of factors affecting why women are less well represented at skeptical events, but an anecdote doesn't cut it for me when it comes to evidence.
Exactly.
 
Which ones do you find creepy? Hard to ask people not to post in a certain way if you don't provide examples of what you mean, or at least a clearer description beyond "pretty creepy".

Hint, I smell sarcasm coming from Soapy Sam's post....
 
Whatever you think of what came afterwards, it is not just about how EG behaved and how Rebecca reacted. It is about how much do we truly value women within the movement.

This is why Dawkins' remarks bother me so much. Yes, he is correct, in that what Rebecca experienced is nowhere near as bad as what women in other parts of the world suffer. However, if we truly value what Rebecca and other women do for the skeptical movement overall, then how comfortable they are to come to these events is very important. Dawkin's dismissal of Rebecca was, in my mind, tantamount to him publicly stating that her contribution to the skeptical movement is so minimal that it matters not to him whether she continues to attend skeptical events. I simply cannot agree with that assessment.

In short, if we agree that women are important to the skeptical movement, then it is incumbent upon all of us that they feel comfortable and welcome at skeptical events. If a few outliers don't know how to behave around women in such settings then we need to teach them, not justify or dismiss their behavior as 'awkward' or 'shy'. And we definitely do not want to dismiss the discomfort of those women as 'insignificant in the larger picture' as Dawkins did.

Well, if we assume that RW's intention in all of this was indeed to make it a 'teaching moment' and nothing more, then she has a very odd way of communicating that.

- When the foaming at the mouth posters at www.skepchick.org starting getting their frillies askew (I intend this in the least sexist way possible) and posting excessively aggressive and jingoistic arguments on various blogs, where was she asking people to calm the hell down?

- When Dawkins chimed in with arguments that showed he wasn't 'getting it', where was the reasoned discourse or open letter to RD explaining the error of his way? Instead we have a call for a letter writing campaign to RD (many of which are exceedingly rude and verge on threatening) and a passive-aggressive boycott that apparently isn't really a boycott, its just a bunch of people decided to do what I am doing.

- When the media hype is spiralling out of control, where is RW being the bigger woman in all of this and saying 'Whoa. Listen up all of you. This is NOT what I had in mind'.

I'll tell you why not - because this was about attention/media whoring and not about trying to create a more welcoming environment for women at skeptical/atheist functions.

I'm sorry if the tone of this message is perhaps a little stronger than most of my other posts today, but I'm getting weary of all this, and someone should've poured a bucket of water on this fire way before mainstream media decided to stand around and point fingers at all the crazed atheists & skeptics who can't have a conversation without going bat ****.
 
In short, if we agree that women are important to the skeptical movement, then it is incumbent upon all of us that they feel comfortable and welcome at skeptical events. If a few outliers don't know how to behave around women in such settings then we need to teach them, not justify or dismiss their behavior as 'awkward' or 'shy'. And we definitely do not want to dismiss the discomfort of those women as 'insignificant in the larger picture' as Dawkins did.


Hmm, enforced social norms as a way of being more inclusive. That could work well.

Have you considered making an outreach effort to invite more high school jocks to skeptical events? They seem to know how to deal with the 'awkward' and 'shy' guys whose presence makes the popular girls uncomfortable.
 
Many have claimed that this is a tempest in a teapot and pointless bickering. I disagree and would like to explain why.

My first skeptical gathering was TAM 8, last year. Apparently, from what I heard from speakers and other attendees, there were some issues regarding the male-female balance at TAM 7 and the JREF decided to address that imbalance and aggressively promote more female speakers and do more community reach-out to female skeptics. Most every attendee I spoke with at TAM 8 agreed with this and felt that being more inclusive of females was a very positive step for the whole skeptical movement.

During this last year, I also started to listen to SGU (having first heard about it at TAM 8) and got to know Rebecca through that program. Having listened to about 4 years of podcasts in 4 months, I quickly learned that Rebecca has for most of that time been at the forefront of the push within the movement to include more women in skepticism.

Now comes the Dublin conference and the incident with EG. Rebecca points out that his behavior made her uncomfortable and this is not an isolated incident (perhaps more extreme than others, but not unique). Clearly the incident had some impact on Rebecca, and it is hard to conceive that at some point, she did not question the very goal of including more women into skepticism. However, she chose instead to make this a learning moment and point out how such behavior affects women and is detrimental to the goal of having more women at such conferences.

Whatever you think of what came afterwards, it is not just about how EG behaved and how Rebecca reacted. It is about how much do we truly value women within the movement.

This is why Dawkins' remarks bother me so much. Yes, he is correct, in that what Rebecca experienced is nowhere near as bad as what women in other parts of the world suffer. However, if we truly value what Rebecca and other women do for the skeptical movement overall, then how comfortable they are to come to these events is very important. Dawkin's dismissal of Rebecca was, in my mind, tantamount to him publicly stating that her contribution to the skeptical movement is so minimal that it matters not to him whether she continues to attend skeptical events. I simply cannot agree with that assessment.

In short, if we agree that women are important to the skeptical movement, then it is incumbent upon all of us that they feel comfortable and welcome at skeptical events. If a few outliers don't know how to behave around women in such settings then we need to teach them, not justify or dismiss their behavior as 'awkward' or 'shy'. And we definitely do not want to dismiss the discomfort of those women as 'insignificant in the larger picture' as Dawkins did.
See Linda's reply to TraneWreck above. First one needs to establish the reason for the imbalance with more than an anecdotal impression. And your conclusion about the meaning of Dawkin's comments goes well beyond what the evidence supports.
 
Maybe we should have a women only thread, asking if members have been to a skeptical event or not, and why, and if they have returned or not, and why? A bit of qualitative research that might give us some leads.
Better would be an anonymous randomized survey taken at the end of the upcoming TAM asking about people's expectations and experience. Forum polls don't represent unbiased samples.
 
Better would be an anonymous randomized survey taken at the end of the upcoming TAM asking about people's expectations and experience. Forum polls don't represent unbiased samples.

True, but it doesn't get to the people who might reasonably be expected to be interested in such an event, but have never attended. Not an either/or proposition though.
 
cwalner - the thing is that rebecca is making a point about what *she thinks* is something keeping women away from skeptical events. She has no data to back her up, only an anecdote or two. perhaps she or others, if they really want to know why there is a gender imbalance, should try doing some proper research on the matter rather than assuming that their own experiences apply to everyone.

For example is it true that many women have attended such a conference and then never returned because of unpleasant experiences such as she describes? We don't know. Is it true that many women have never attended because they have heard about such experiences and decided not to attend? We don't know. There could be a myriad of factors affecting why women are less well represented at skeptical events, but an anecdote doesn't cut it for me when it comes to evidence.

You are right, that there is a complete absence of data, one way or the other. This has not been studied. Rebecca formed a hypothesis based on anecdote because there is no other evidence period.

I agree, that where there is evidence, we should follow it. Where there is none, we can only use anecdotes, personal experience and logic to form hypotheses, which is exactly what Rebecca did.

It is just as bad skepticism to dismiss a hypothesis without evidence than it is to accept it as true without any. And that is exactly what Dawkins did.
 
What century are you in? As an adult woman, I think I could handle a guy making a pass in such a situation without fear. Someone could join the elevator with said person leaving the chat and at the same time give off vibes one should be concerned about, but to claim this is automatically worrisome is ludicrous. It's a hotel! People use the elevator. Men talk to women they haven't been formally introduced to. The world is just not that scary one should fear every encounter with a guy you haven't met. The proof is in the fact NOTHING BUT ASKING HAPPENED!!

Had this been a simple coincidence, two people going to their rooms at 4 am, are you suggesting a gentleman would wait and take the next elevator car so as to not frighten the vulnerable little female in the elevator? That's rather sexist.

Sadly it appears ideology is trumping humanity and we all to often forget were only humans.

I'm sure i've looked like a "creeper".. not long ago i was in a bind and needed shot records and i was told it would be 3 days to get them after i scheduled to pick them up. NOt having any sitter or the ability to send my kids to school and missing my first 3 days of work at a new job made me visibly pale. I got emotional and begged for them to release official shot records because i was in a bind.

20 minutes later the young lady came out with the shot records and i insitictively asked her if i could hug her.. i have no freaking clue why, but i did and she accepted.

Today, was that probably the wisest thing to do? i dunno.. but it was completely innocent back then, i was visibly "worried" and fearing the world was giving me another crushing blow to a long chain of crushing blows but she helped me and beyond saying thanks - which i did, the question just popped out.

i don't know the circumstances of the EG.. but there are mine.

Am i a creeper or was i just an emotional dude stuck in a painful part of my life and thrilled to the gills because SOMONE finally helped me?

maybe EG "finally" got his chance.. i dunno..

but now it appears there is a wedge going down of whats "manly", whats "creep" and whats "normal" that apparently trumps our ability to reason and thats what makes me annoyed with this entire thing.
 
Every situation I am ever in that involves another human being is one in which I may be considered threatening. Could you let me know how I differentiate?

Here's a couple of questions you can ask yourself. They are the same questions a woman who has been sexually assaulted is likely to be asking herself when she finds herself alone with a stranger or even an acquaintance that she doesn't know all that well.

Does the woman have the ability to exit quickly and easily? Are there other people (witnesses) around? If the answer to both questions is no, then hold off propositioning her until the answer to one of those is 'yes'. Note that I said don't proposition her, not that you shouldn't talk to her. Striking up a conversation, introducing yourself, etc. is fine.

No, she didn't. Or rather, she did, but then she went on to instruct all men to not "be that guy". And that's my problem - with the attitude that there is to be no discussion at all of whether her fear was reasonable, that it is purely a matter of "you must never act in a way that frightens me, no matter how unreasonable that fear may be."
Do you think her discomfort was unreasonable? Plenty of people have posted that they don't think it's appropriate social behavior. Do you disagree?

Exactly. And my issue here is that many people (not necessarily you) appear to believe that their opinion of what is and is not appropriate social behaviour represent obvious universal truth.
The vast majority of people, even those defending EG, think it's inappropriate social behavior for our common english speaking society. That doesn't mean is it necessarily obvious (clearly plenty of guys never gave it a thought before and it's not like EG is the first guy to ever try that technique). No one has claimed it's universal either. In a culture where women aren't allowed to drive or leave their home unattended by a male relative, Rebecca hanging out in a bar until 4:00 am without a man to keep an eye on her would be inappropriate social behavior. What's appropriate and inappropriate certainly varies, but I must admit, I can't think of any culture on earth where that would considered appropriate. Can you?

I think the arguments are more about how inappropriate it is. Some people seem to think it's inappropriate on the level of farting in the elevator. Others, like myself, think it's an order of magnitude more inappropriate than that.

Because I have extended and received invitations exactly like these from both genders.
You have gone to the hotel room of a person that you never spoken with before he made the request and knew nothing about, not even his name? Frankly, I doubt that. Most likely you had started up the conversation and established that you enjoyed being with them before such an invitation was either extended or accepted. If you actually have done that, you've been lucky and you might want to read up about 'stranger danger'. [/QUOTE]

The problem is that for those of us who want to advise our sons not to be "that guy"...if all he wants is to offer coffee and says that he's not suggesting anything else, he won't recognize that he is "propositioning her".

Linda

I would suggest that first of all you instruct him that being alone in a hotel room with a complete stranger is not a very safe thing to do. Second, you should probably let him know that inviting a woman he just met for the first time to his hotel room for any reason at any time of day is very likely to be interpreted as an request to have sex with her in our society. Finally, I recommend that you give him some instructions on how most women will want to be treated by a man before she'll agree to have sex with him. You know, little things like introducing himself and chatting about other things for at least a minute or two before inviting her to his hotel room.
 
cwalner - the thing is that rebecca is making a point about what *she thinks* is something keeping women away from skeptical events. She has no data to back her up, only an anecdote or two. perhaps she or others, if they really want to know why there is a gender imbalance, should try doing some proper research on the matter rather than assuming that their own experiences apply to everyone.

For example is it true that many women have attended such a conference and then never returned because of unpleasant experiences such as she describes? We don't know. Is it true that many women have never attended because they have heard about such experiences and decided not to attend? We don't know. There could be a myriad of factors affecting why women are less well represented at skeptical events, but an anecdote doesn't cut it for me when it comes to evidence.

The women I've spoken to who have felt a bit uncomfortable only have anecdotes. The comments on the various blogs are only anecdotes. I only have anecdotes.

But this is hardly the first time the issue has come up. There's an excessive reaction not because it's a new idea but because it has been so often repeated. One single throw-away teaching moment has become a huge debate not because there wasn't enough evidence for rational minds to reach a conclusion but because it represents something. in most cases it is either empathy for Watson who had to deal with discomfort, again(!). Or empathy for elevator guy who has been singled out for a mistake that many could, have, will make innocently.

That this debate is so far reaching indicates that there may be a problem. Or that people who self-identify as skeptics get really pissy when one of their own is treated with anything but kid-gloves.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom