Many have claimed that this is a tempest in a teapot and pointless bickering. I disagree and would like to explain why.
My first skeptical gathering was TAM 8, last year. Apparently, from what I heard from speakers and other attendees, there were some issues regarding the male-female balance at TAM 7 and the JREF decided to address that imbalance and aggressively promote more female speakers and do more community reach-out to female skeptics. Most every attendee I spoke with at TAM 8 agreed with this and felt that being more inclusive of females was a very positive step for the whole skeptical movement.
During this last year, I also started to listen to SGU (having first heard about it at TAM 8) and got to know Rebecca through that program. Having listened to about 4 years of podcasts in 4 months, I quickly learned that Rebecca has for most of that time been at the forefront of the push within the movement to include more women in skepticism.
Now comes the Dublin conference and the incident with EG. Rebecca points out that his behavior made her uncomfortable and this is not an isolated incident (perhaps more extreme than others, but not unique). Clearly the incident had some impact on Rebecca, and it is hard to conceive that at some point, she did not question the very goal of including more women into skepticism. However, she chose instead to make this a learning moment and point out how such behavior affects women and is detrimental to the goal of having more women at such conferences.
Whatever you think of what came afterwards, it is not just about how EG behaved and how Rebecca reacted. It is about how much do we truly value women within the movement.
This is why Dawkins' remarks bother me so much. Yes, he is correct, in that what Rebecca experienced is nowhere near as bad as what women in other parts of the world suffer. However, if we truly value what Rebecca and other women do for the skeptical movement overall, then how comfortable they are to come to these events is very important. Dawkin's dismissal of Rebecca was, in my mind, tantamount to him publicly stating that her contribution to the skeptical movement is so minimal that it matters not to him whether she continues to attend skeptical events. I simply cannot agree with that assessment.
In short, if we agree that women are important to the skeptical movement, then it is incumbent upon all of us that they feel comfortable and welcome at skeptical events. If a few outliers don't know how to behave around women in such settings then we need to teach them, not justify or dismiss their behavior as 'awkward' or 'shy'. And we definitely do not want to dismiss the discomfort of those women as 'insignificant in the larger picture' as Dawkins did.