I appreciate that you have presented this in a way which makes it very obvious that he was creepy, so that anyone who cannot see it is too moronic for words. The problem is that for those of us who want to advise our sons not to be "that guy", when they are in that situation, our sons will not be sitting there misrepresenting the events and their intentions, and putting the creepiest possible spin on them, in order to judge whether their own behaviour is acceptable/non-acceptable. That is, the Elevator Guy will not recognize himself as being in the scenario you have painted.
He likely wouldn't recognize himself whether my description was perfectly accurate or not.
If he simply didn't have an opportunity to get close enough to Rebecca to talk to her, he won't recognize that he was "deliberately avoiding conversation for several hours". If he was hanging out with a bunch of like-minded people whose participation in the discussion ranged from a little to a lot (after all, we don't know who else he was talking to while he was there), he won't recognize that his behaviour was "lurking".
Fair enough.
If he happened to leave at the same time as her so he ended up in the elevator with her, he won't recognize she is "isolated and vulnerable" when men and women riding alone in elevators is a common and ordinary event.
Setting everything else aside, that's where I part ways. Yes, people end up in elevators alone all the time. Often just a man and a woman. It was that next step that puts the nail in the coffin:
And finally, if all he wants is to offer coffee and says that he's not suggesting anything else, he won't recognize that he is "propositioning her".
And that's where the spin (either in my direction or yours) ends. Yes, there is an expectation that this person consider the environment and the nature of his question.
I get that you wouldn't feel uncomfortable in that scenario. Look, we all know the old stories about Native Americans working on sky-scrapers without safety harnasses because they weren't afraid of heights. If I was walking around up there, I would be scared ****-less. That fear would not be irrational, I would be perfectly justified in requesting safety gear.
The lack of fear in other people does not make my perception any less rational or valid, and likewise, the fact that I'm afraid does not mean the others should be. Nevertheless, some amount of danger is present regardless of people's opinions toward it.
Men should understand how their behavior affects others. EG didn't know what the attitude of the woman in the elevator would be, but there is an obvious implication that was strengthened by the bald proposition.
Sure, it's good advice if you have accurately represented his perception of his behaviour. But if he's not "lurking" or "propositioning her" in the first place, how's he supposed to realize that he's sleazy?
Because he is alone with a woman in an environment where she has no exit. This is not an appropriate place for a proposition, regardless of how mild it is in construct. Google "sexual assault elevator" and read through some of the cases:
Siva R. Yannam followed the woman into the elevator on Aug. 2 at a building on Bear Claw Way in Madison, made small talk and then grabbed the woman, who was loaded down with groceries, according to a criminal complaint.
http://host.madison.com/wsj/news/lo...98a-11df-998d-001cc4c03286.html#ixzz1RX5QoNTj
Now, to be clear that is not linked to 1) argue that you should be afraid in an elevator or 2) to argue that this sort of thing is an inevitability.
But men should be able to realize how their behavior is affecting women.
I should also point out that the notion that this was a chance encounter that EG sought to capitalize on is contradicted by the, "I think you're really interesting" phrase. Regardless of what he intended, it's very reasonable for Rebecca Watson to be thinking, "who is this guy, has he been following me around, how am I going to get out of here if he gets even weirder..."
It's not too much to ask to avoid putting women through that thought process, but nothing serious did happen, which is why the request was circumscribed: guys, please don't do that.