So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
No it's a transcript from the original video

Fair enough. I will modify my earlier post to suggest that while Rebecca is certainly entitled to describe her feelings from the event she describes in whatever way she sees fit, that I struggle to see how the invitation as it was described 'sexualized' her. Unless the guy was leering, staring at her cleavage, licking his chops, or had a comically exagerrated gait - then I personally read the scenario as being 'uncomforting' but hardly 'sexualized'.
 
Why is it so terrible, then, to explain things clearly for socially awkward Aspergers super geeks? Isn't that exactly what they need and want?

I have not yet seen an example of a proper way to ask someone if they'd like coffee.

I get nervous enough just saying "hello," so I have to jump to the point of the conversation to get it over with so I can stop shaking.

If I had been there, that might have been me..
 
Perhaps I'm overly shy, but I would not feel comfortable asking to get to know someone better (whether this implied sex or not) in front of a crowd of people who were listening. This would be both for my own sake, but also for the other person; I wouldn't want them to feel awkward by being put on the spot in front of people they may (or may not) know. It may be that's not what you meant when you spoke of being humiliated, but even if it isn't, it's what others seem to have meant. I don't see why being turned down should entail humiliation in front of others; what business is it of anyone else? Just to be clear, I also think that EG went way too far the other direction; asking in a public area with others around, but not in earshot, would have been fine, but the world doesn't need to know unless the person asking does step outside the bounds of politeness, at which point the person being asked can always attract attention to what is happening.

I have a hard time accepting the "shy" explanation, though. I totally get that someone could be so cripplingly shy that he can't even say hello or introduce himself to a woman if a third party is in earshot -- that's sad, but probably not unheard of. But how does that same cripplingly shy person muster up the courage to invite a woman he's never spoken to back to his hotel room for "coffee" at 4 am? I mean, even James Bond does the whole "my name is Bond. James Bond" thing before the bedroom invites start.
 
Now I kind of understand the rather odd reactions I was getting when asking after Rebecca at SkepChickcon last week.

I just wanted to say "Hi" because she was the only name I really knew. I never did get to, this time around.

She just went to the elevator, if you hurry you can still catch her... :D
 
Fair enough. I will modify my earlier post to suggest that while Rebecca is certainly entitled to describe her feelings from the event she describes in whatever way she sees fit, that I struggle to see how the invitation as it was described 'sexualized' her. Unless the guy was leering, staring at her cleavage, licking his chops, or had a comically exagerrated gait - then I personally read the scenario as being 'uncomforting' but hardly 'sexualized'.

That's what I asked in my first post back on page 1. Don't worry. You didn't miss an answer in the intervening 21 pages. :)

Linda
 
I have a hard time accepting the "shy" explanation, though. I totally get that someone could be so cripplingly shy that he can't even say hello or introduce himself to a woman if a third party is in earshot -- that's sad, but probably not unheard of. But how does that same cripplingly shy person muster up the courage to invite a woman he's never spoken to back to his hotel room for "coffee" at 4 am? I mean, even James Bond does the whole "my name is Bond. James Bond" thing before the bedroom invites start.

He couldn't have been that socially inept, "Don't take this the wrong way..." is our first clue that he was aware of it potentially putting her off.
 
Fair enough. I will modify my earlier post to suggest that while Rebecca is certainly entitled to describe her feelings from the event she describes in whatever way she sees fit, that I struggle to see how the invitation as it was described 'sexualized' her. Unless the guy was leering, staring at her cleavage, licking his chops, or had a comically exagerrated gait - then I personally read the scenario as being 'uncomforting' but hardly 'sexualized'.

One of my favorite not-yet-known illustrators, Lili Chin did a very cool campaign for dog bite prevention week. *
http://drsophiayin.com/blog/entry/preventing-dog-bites-by-learning-to-greet-dogs-properly

Many of the "Don'ts" are stuff that people do all the time. For example, sticking their hand out for the dog to sniff. (it's sticking your hand in their face which, to the dog, is aggressive. A lot of people do this. They've never really thought about it, they have done it their whole lives. Maybe the dogs they have met have been ok with it, or maybe the dog really disliked it. became intimidated and the person went away thinking it was an unfriendly dog.

If a person now has that information and they continue to stick their hand in a dog's face because they have never been bitten, they shouldn't be surprised by a negative reaction. If they are defending their right to shove their hand in the dog's face because they've always done it that way, they aren't being very rational.

* Her general doggie stuff is awesomer.

ETA: Sorry, this was supposed to be a response to a different comment, not yours.

To answer your question - Individual social situations among humans are rarely unique. They are informed by previous encounters. An invitation to go to someone's room at 4 AM, no matter how innocent will read as pick-up (therefore sexualized) because previous encounters were propositions.
 
Last edited:
Fair enough. I will modify my earlier post to suggest that while Rebecca is certainly entitled to describe her feelings from the event she describes in whatever way she sees fit, that I struggle to see how the invitation as it was described 'sexualized' her. Unless the guy was leering, staring at her cleavage, licking his chops, or had a comically exagerrated gait - then I personally read the scenario as being 'uncomforting' but hardly 'sexualized'.
That conversation was had back on page 2 or so of this thread (no, I'm not going back to find the actual page number).

Pretty much everyone is okay with "don't do that". It's turning it into misogyny and sexism that caused all this fuss.
 
I have a hard time accepting the "shy" explanation, though. I totally get that someone could be so cripplingly shy that he can't even say hello or introduce himself to a woman if a third party is in earshot -- that's sad, but probably not unheard of. But how does that same cripplingly shy person muster up the courage to invite a woman he's never spoken to back to his hotel room for "coffee" at 4 am? I mean, even James Bond does the whole "my name is Bond. James Bond" thing before the bedroom invites start.

You're missing my point. I'm not saying that what EG did was excusable; I'm not addressing his behaviour at all. I'm saying that some people seem to be saying that the only acceptable behaviour is the complete other extreme, that he should have made any proposition in full view and hearing of everyone else. That's what I'm having trouble accepting.
 
I appreciate that you have presented this in a way which makes it very obvious that he was creepy, so that anyone who cannot see it is too moronic for words. The problem is that for those of us who want to advise our sons not to be "that guy", when they are in that situation, our sons will not be sitting there misrepresenting the events and their intentions, and putting the creepiest possible spin on them, in order to judge whether their own behaviour is acceptable/non-acceptable. That is, the Elevator Guy will not recognize himself as being in the scenario you have painted.

He likely wouldn't recognize himself whether my description was perfectly accurate or not.

If he simply didn't have an opportunity to get close enough to Rebecca to talk to her, he won't recognize that he was "deliberately avoiding conversation for several hours". If he was hanging out with a bunch of like-minded people whose participation in the discussion ranged from a little to a lot (after all, we don't know who else he was talking to while he was there), he won't recognize that his behaviour was "lurking".

Fair enough.

If he happened to leave at the same time as her so he ended up in the elevator with her, he won't recognize she is "isolated and vulnerable" when men and women riding alone in elevators is a common and ordinary event.

Setting everything else aside, that's where I part ways. Yes, people end up in elevators alone all the time. Often just a man and a woman. It was that next step that puts the nail in the coffin:

And finally, if all he wants is to offer coffee and says that he's not suggesting anything else, he won't recognize that he is "propositioning her".

And that's where the spin (either in my direction or yours) ends. Yes, there is an expectation that this person consider the environment and the nature of his question.

I get that you wouldn't feel uncomfortable in that scenario. Look, we all know the old stories about Native Americans working on sky-scrapers without safety harnasses because they weren't afraid of heights. If I was walking around up there, I would be scared ****-less. That fear would not be irrational, I would be perfectly justified in requesting safety gear.

The lack of fear in other people does not make my perception any less rational or valid, and likewise, the fact that I'm afraid does not mean the others should be. Nevertheless, some amount of danger is present regardless of people's opinions toward it.

Men should understand how their behavior affects others. EG didn't know what the attitude of the woman in the elevator would be, but there is an obvious implication that was strengthened by the bald proposition.

Sure, it's good advice if you have accurately represented his perception of his behaviour. But if he's not "lurking" or "propositioning her" in the first place, how's he supposed to realize that he's sleazy?

Because he is alone with a woman in an environment where she has no exit. This is not an appropriate place for a proposition, regardless of how mild it is in construct. Google "sexual assault elevator" and read through some of the cases:

Siva R. Yannam followed the woman into the elevator on Aug. 2 at a building on Bear Claw Way in Madison, made small talk and then grabbed the woman, who was loaded down with groceries, according to a criminal complaint.
http://host.madison.com/wsj/news/lo...98a-11df-998d-001cc4c03286.html#ixzz1RX5QoNTj

Now, to be clear that is not linked to 1) argue that you should be afraid in an elevator or 2) to argue that this sort of thing is an inevitability.

But men should be able to realize how their behavior is affecting women.

I should also point out that the notion that this was a chance encounter that EG sought to capitalize on is contradicted by the, "I think you're really interesting" phrase. Regardless of what he intended, it's very reasonable for Rebecca Watson to be thinking, "who is this guy, has he been following me around, how am I going to get out of here if he gets even weirder..."

It's not too much to ask to avoid putting women through that thought process, but nothing serious did happen, which is why the request was circumscribed: guys, please don't do that.
 
You're missing my point. I'm not saying that what EG did was excusable; I'm not addressing his behaviour at all. I'm saying that some people seem to be saying that the only acceptable behaviour is the complete other extreme, that he should have made any proposition in full view and hearing of everyone else. That's what I'm having trouble accepting.

Sure, that's absurd as well. Fortunately in this modern day of technology people can communicate by text, by e-mail, in a thousand ways that allow them to avoid the initial stress of confronting someone in public.

But the point remains: being uncomfortable in one setting does not give one the right to make someone else uncomfortable in another.
 
I have not yet seen an example of a proper way to ask someone if they'd like coffee.

I get nervous enough just saying "hello," so I have to jump to the point of the conversation to get it over with so I can stop shaking.

If I had been there, that might have been me..

I hear ya. I jump straight to questions sometimes because I'll babble like an idiot if there is any silence at all. There have been times when even I didn't know what I was saying.

I faked being a social animal when I was a bartender (easy because you have a job to do and there is no just standing there.) Some of that still comes in handy.

Introduce yourself if you don't know them, give them a very brief explanation for why you are in this specific space and then ask the same of them. At a party, I'll tell people how I know the host. "Hi, I'm Kitty. Anthony and I were in that band together. So how do you know him?" at TAM it was "I'm here with the IIG. How did you hear about this?" It's a non-threatening question that allows you to find common ground because you have both been drawn to that place. The tricky part is getting into the habit of asking them this (or any innocuous question that they will enjoy answering) instead of blurting out the first thing that comes to mind. I still fail at times.

In general, people are far more kind than expected. They almost never live up to my fear of what they are thinking. Very briefly mention that you have social phobias or that you're very nervous and they will respond with understanding. More often than not with complete empathy. Getting in the habit of acting as if people had already done this took years, an extremely social job, and therapy. It's still an act but often becomes reality.

ETA: After the introductions have been completed and you have found common ground, is a good time to ask for coffee.
 
Last edited:
It is inexcusable behavior which shows the individual's ignorance and total lack of respect. When I am in America I take the sidewalk from the mall the car and stick my shopping in the trunk. There least Rebecca could do in Dublin is call a lift by the right name.
 
You're missing my point. I'm not saying that what EG did was excusable; I'm not addressing his behaviour at all. I'm saying that some people seem to be saying that the only acceptable behaviour is the complete other extreme, that he should have made any proposition in full view and hearing of everyone else. That's what I'm having trouble accepting.

Well no, I don't accept that either. In fact, inviting someone back to your room in front of other people is likely to embarrass both of you as well as deter her from accepting. So if anyone's been suggesting that the "coffee" invitation should have been extended in that situation, I'm in agreement with you.

But I don't think that's what people are really saying. I think the point that is being made is that (1) he could have and should have started "a" conversation, not "that" conversation, in public, (i.e. "Hi, my name's Otis. I really enjoyed your presentation today.") and (2) there's a middle ground for the "coffee invite" between "in the middle of a group conversation" and "alone in an elevator." (Such as "out of earshot of others but where others are present and/or there are easy "escape routes": a less crowded section of the bar, just outside the bar, etc.)

People have been offering these alternatives as an answer to the false dichotomy of the crowd who argues "well, I guess I'm not allowed to talk to women any more!!!!!"

But really, my post wasn't so much intended as a rebuttal to yours; I was just using your post as a reference for the "he's so very shy" theory and explaining my puzzlement. Put aside excusable/inexcusable, rude/not rude, and sexist/not sexist for the moment: I really don't understand how "shy" explains that combination of behaviors.
 
Richard Dawkins said that people who are raped sometimes are making it up.

He's quite an intelligent man, so I doubt he ever said anything so obviously illogical. If you are raped you can not, by definition, make it up.

I suspect what he actually said (stop me if I'm wrong here) is that sometimes, some women, lie about being raped. This is simply a factual statement with irrefutable evidence to back it up.
 
Well no, I don't accept that either. In fact, inviting someone back to your room in front of other people is likely to embarrass both of you as well as deter her from accepting. So if anyone's been suggesting that the "coffee" invitation should have been extended in that situation, I'm in agreement with you.

But I don't think that's what people are really saying. I think the point that is being made is that (1) he could have and should have started "a" conversation, not "that" conversation, in public, (i.e. "Hi, my name's Otis. I really enjoyed your presentation today.") and (2) there's a middle ground for the "coffee invite" between "in the middle of a group conversation" and "alone in an elevator." (Such as "out of earshot of others but where others are present and/or there are easy "escape routes": a less crowded section of the bar, just outside the bar, etc.)

People have been offering these alternatives as an answer to the false dichotomy of the crowd who argues "well, I guess I'm not allowed to talk to women any more!!!!!"

But really, my post wasn't so much intended as a rebuttal to yours; I was just using your post as a reference for the "he's so very shy" theory and explaining my puzzlement. Put aside excusable/inexcusable, rude/not rude, and sexist/not sexist for the moment: I really don't understand how "shy" explains that combination of behaviors.

Poor elevator guy. He's either deaf, shy, and suffering from several severe social disorders or he's the Gilbert Gottfried of elevator rapists.

From the story, it sounds like he's a totally normal guy doing a totally normal thing under very, very unfortunate circumstances. BUT if he is extraordinary, then there is little chance of anyone else making his mistake.
 
He's quite an intelligent man, so I doubt he ever said anything so obviously illogical. If you are raped you can not, by definition, make it up.

I suspect what he actually said (stop me if I'm wrong here) is that sometimes, some women, lie about being raped. This is simply a factual statement with irrefutable evidence to back it up.

And sometimes they aren't lying. No one knows beforehand who will be the one to rape them. This is simply a factual statement with irrefutable evidence to back it up.
 
I suspect what he actually said (stop me if I'm wrong here) is that sometimes, some women, lie about being raped. This is simply a factual statement with irrefutable evidence to back it up.
Nope. Basically he siad that some of the rape accusations that were placed upon the Roman Catholic Church were nothing more than memory artifacts due to False Memory Syndrome. Essentially, these people aren't lying but their memories of the events never actually happened. As I said before i didn't exactly leave out this details to bait people into assuming women but it interestingly turned out that most of you idiotically assumed I was referring to women.
 
Last edited:
But I don't think that's what people are really saying. I think the point that is being made is that (1) he could have and should have started "a" conversation, not "that" conversation, in public, (i.e. "Hi, my name's Otis. I really enjoyed your presentation today.") and (2) there's a middle ground for the "coffee invite" between "in the middle of a group conversation" and "alone in an elevator." (Such as "out of earshot of others but where others are present and/or there are easy "escape routes": a less crowded section of the bar, just outside the bar, etc.)

But some people have been saying exactly that-- that the appropriate place to proposition Rebecca was in the crowded bar. E.g., this guy:
Rebecca Watson spent 6 or 8 hours sitting in this bar that night, freely accessible, having her picture taken by and with folks every other minute literally, and even at 4am the bar was still serving beverages, including coffee. This guy could have done anything from offering coffee to proposing sex or marriage to Rebecca in a non-creepy, normal fashion. The fact that he chose to not do that and instead pass her up in the elevator tells me all I need to know....
That's nonsense. Getting a quiet moment alone with Rebecca Watson at a bar after an atheist conference is never going to happen, and "would you like to come back to my room for 'coffee'" is not a question you ask in front of a crowd. EG had two options: ask the question in the privacy of the elevator, or don't ask it at all. He chose poorly.
 
Meh, normal and 'appropriate' social behaviour.

Some people are socially awkward.

Some people have Aspergers.

Some people are just super geeky.

Some people just get caught up in the moment of how fab their first atheist convention was.

We just don't know.

Yes, I can see why it was uncomfortable, but it wasn't necessary to blog this to the entire world.
I'm sorry but most people usually get made fun of when they invoke this arguments. As I said before socially awkwared is not an excuse for idiocy. You have a brain. You can think two seconds before speaking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom