So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, that's exactly what I'm doing. I'm expressing the position men should take towards EG. Why are people going to such great lengths to excuse and justify his behavior? It's embarassing.

Do all of you really feel that threatened? Do you want to behave that way and are upset that others are criticizing that behavior?

Why on Earth would you try to justify it?

Notice that all of the whining and consternation has focused on poor, irrational Rebecca Watson. Her perception of events is being minimized, scoffed at and ridiculed, silly woman, how dare she call out inappropriate male behavior. She just doesn't see things like we men see things, so her opinion is invalid. There was nothing concerning about that event.

Well, let's look at it from the other perspective, ignore Rebecca Watson, ignore every statement she ever made on this issue, EG's behavior is still childish, immature, disrespectful, and wholly lacking in dignity. Regardless of how the woman will react (and we have at least two examples of women on these forums saying they wouldn't be overly concerned by that incident, that's fine, they are under no obligation to feel any given way), that's not behavior a decent human being engages in.

From the perspective of a man observing the behavior of another man, setting aside completely the opinion of the woman (the chauvinist perspective), EG's behavior should be condemned, yet men are desperately defending that behavior. It's baffling.

Are you seriously telling me that you've never made a social misjudgement that, upon reflection, was a bad idea. Because you're coming across as Mr/Mrs Squeaky clean, never put foot in mouth, never made a bad social call. If you can honetly say that you've never misread a situation, perhaps due to a pint or two or to exuberance, then carry on vilifying a man who made a mistake.

If, however, you're like the rest of us and not perfect, then allow a man a mistake without judging his whole personality on one incident.


This cointinues to be a storm in a teacup.

This continues not to be an issue of sex discrimination.
 
Last edited:
Well, let's look at it from the other perspective, ignore Rebecca Watson, ignore every statement she ever made on this issue, EG's behavior is still childish, immature, disrespectful, and wholly lacking in dignity. Regardless of how the woman will react (and we have at least two examples of women on these forums saying they wouldn't be overly concerned by that incident, that's fine, they are under no obligation to feel any given way), that's not behavior a decent human being engages in.

I haven't yet chimed in TraneWreck on any of your posts, but this snippet caught my eye.

I think that perhaps you are over-sensationalizing the EG-RW incident.

Rebecca herself said it made her feel 'uncomfortable'. That is a pretty innocuous word by all intents & purposes. She didn't use 'harassed, assuaulted, belittled' etc... She didn't even say that she felt 'Objectified or sexualized' - she drew an allusion to this by counterposing that this incident happened after she had discussed these two topics. But she pretty clearly stuck to 'uncomfortable'.

Now - I definitely agree with you that EG behaved in an 'inappropriate' manner in the elevator. As I pointed out, the issues for me are:

- He could've approached her in a much more open and typical environment, and had adequate opportunity to do so.
- He could've opened the conversation with a more typical conversation starter and not gone immediately for the jugular.
- He probably should've used common sense and at 0400h decided that coffee time was over.
- He should've been more aware of his surroundings.

Striking up a usual conversation that started like 'Hey Rebecca - great talk yesterday and it was fun listening to you at the bar with all your ideas. Its late now, but I would really like an opportunity tomorrow to discuss some ideas one on one, if you have time. By the way, my name is x, and here's my card'. For me - by MY PERSONAL standards of 'creepiness' - the aforementioned scenario is not creepy - even if it takes place in an elevator. YMMV. I'm sure there are many other ones we can think of.

To bring this back to your post TraneWreck - I think it is a bit hasty to label the encounter (with the apocryphal detail we know about what really happened) as "childish, immature, disrespectful, and wholly lacking in dignity". It was certainly an ineffective way to communicate, as proven by the results. But to suggest more than merely 'ineffective' and 'causing discomfort' is reading too much into it.
 
Now I kind of understand the rather odd reactions I was getting when asking after Rebecca at SkepChickcon last week.

I just wanted to say "Hi" because she was the only name I really knew. I never did get to, this time around.
 
I don't do casual sex; I never have. I do, however, continue intellectual conversations into the wee hours of the morning. I have continued interactions in private, face-to-face, with members of both genders.

Again, I mean this seriously: do you not see the immeasurable difference between that behavior and EG guy? And I'm not just talking about the issues of casual sex.

I imagine that you have conversations struck up in bars and conferences around the hotel, hell, even in elevators where you're alone with women. And I bet, because you're intelligent and not an *******, that you begin these conversations in a way that quickly eliminates any apprehension and fear a woman might have. You listen to their wishes, and if they say they don't want to talk or want to go to sleep, you let them go.

I would be willing to bet that you have never in your entire life behaved in any way that remotely resembles what EG guy did. I don't understand why you have an interest in defending that activity, I really don't.

Because I have extended and received invitations exactly like these from both genders. We have retired to someone's room and continued conversations or started new ones while drinking caffeine, then eventually retired to our own rooms (or crashed on a floor/couch).

First of all, the male-female dynamic makes your receipt of such invitations not properly analagous, so set that aside.

Do you ever just walk up to someone you haven't talked to before when both of you are alone and invite them back to your room? I don't mean this type of invite, "hey, a bunch of us are going to go hang out in ____'s room, wanna come?"

I would be willing to bet that when it's just you and one other person, quite a bit of prior conversation occurs before you invite them to your room. I would also be willing to bet that you handle that sort of invite differently when talking to a woman vs. a man because of the obvious implications of such an invite.

The very scenario that you seem to find impossible, that the proposition really was innocent, has played out multiple times in my personal experience -- and it is factually incorrect to attribute improper motives to either those who invited me, or me.

No, I think it's highly possible the invite was purely innocent. But because we live in society, we cannot judge a behavior by it's intent alone. We have to understand how our actions will affect others, and if EG could not understand how his possibly innocent request would be interpreted, that's also his problem.

Obviously there are times when people react irrationally to an absolutely proper request, but this is not one of those situations.
 
A lot of your comment saddens me, and if what you express genuinely is how the majority of American women feel today, then aren't we coming up against a much larger issue than this little forum.
Yes, my last post was about a much larger issue. I think that is why this incident has become such a phenomena.
Perhaps I have rose-tinted glasses on. I'm older, I'm in a relationship, I'm homosexual. I wouldn't talk to someone's breasts, as frankly - not interested - at least, not in that way.
I’m in my fifties, so I haven’t had that stuff come up for a long while myself. When I was younger and it did on a more frequent basis, I just ignored it. As I said, it’s an annoyance, not a problem. It’s even an annoyance I no longer have to put up with these days due to my gray hair and current body shape.

Or as some might put it, it’s a first world problem. Unlike poor muslima, I am allowed to drive. I can leave my home without a male member of the household accompanying me. If I were to commit adultery (I never have), I wouldn’t have to worry about being so much as arrested, much less stoned to death.

Women have it better today that we ever have before, so my comments were not a complaint, but an attempt to let others know what women experience, that many don’t like it (many are not bothered or annoyed and some enjoy it). But those who don’t like it will not attend voluntary events where the frequency of such annoyances exceeds the enjoyment they would get out of the activity. Apparently, for some women, atheist/skeptic conferences are among those events not sufficiently rewarding to make the frequency of those types of annoyances worth tolerating.

If you're already limiting social contact in your work setting (by staying in your room) then obviously a lot happens in your day to day life that bothers you.
Not sure where you get that from. I’m not limiting my social contact in my work setting. I’m not at conferences much and the one I regularly attend (I’m a chair) I’ve gotten to know most of the other regulars and frequently go out to dinner with them. I also enjoy spending a quiet evening in my room having dinner delivered to my door and reading uninterrupted. Being a mother, a quiet evening spent reading without interruption is a pleasure I only get when I’m away from home on business. I sometimes turn down dinner invitations from colleagues at conferences in order to do my committee work and enjoy some solitude.

On the other hand, there are certainly women who do limit their social contacts for just that reason. It only takes one bad choice (and sometimes not even that) to end up being on the wrong side of statistics like 1 in 6 women have been raped and 1 in 4 sexually assaulted. Afterward, women no longer trust in their ability to make the right choices. Not wanting to end up in an isolated position with no exit and a man they don’t know well enough to trust not to attack them, they simply avoid going places where they might have to make such judgment calls. I suspect that women who were assaulted by an acquaintance, “friend” or relative have it worse than those assaulted by a stranger in that regard. How could you ever again trust a male friend after being betrayed in that manner?

If making the decision to attend a TAM (or similar) is a holiday decision for you (as I'm sure it is to a degree for lots of us) then I can understand why you may hope for a better experience than 'usual' - but is that fair? It is after all, primarily a conference attended by Americans, in America, and will have a pretty typical cross-section of (largely) American attendees. Maybe if things are that bad, you're better off choosing to go to a conference that caters only to women - or to gay men. Or going on a trip to a foreign country who have a better way of dealing with inter-gender relations?
I wasn’t talking about me. It doesn’t impact my decisions because I go on holiday with my spouse and he doesn’t care much for conferences of any type. We tend to go camping or rent a cabin by the beach where we mostly picnic and read.

What I did was summarize the comments I’ve read by women who have attended such events and posted why they aren’t going again. I haven’t read them all and yes, some women like SG haven’t experienced problems of that nature at all.

I hope this doesn't sound flippant in any way - it saddens me that people feel inclined to lead their lives in this fashion.

It all depends on how you look at it. As I pointed out earlier, we women in today’s western society have more freedom and opportunities than any other generation of woman before us or anywhere else in the world. I’m grateful that I have had the opportunity to work in a profession and industry that a generation before me couldn’t. But women still alter their behavior like this:
About a year ago, a month before our wedding, I was walking with my wife (wife-to-be, I guess) and some friends through New York City. It was a hot, sunny summer day, so she was in a sun dress.
We walked through parks, we met various friends throughout the city, and generally had a good time.
That evening, talking with her mom, she mentioned that she needed to pin the front of her dress, because it showed too much cleavage, and people had been staring at her cleavage whispering crude things to her all day.
http://scienceblogs.com/tfk/2011/07/a_pedestal_is_as_much_a_prison.php
If that makes you sad, well, I can understand that. But I prefer to look at it as how much better things are here and now. This woman isn’t being forced to wear a burka or required to walk outside only in the company of a man. She’s simply adjusting her attire to make herself more comfortable in the human atmosphere she walks around in. That’s a vast improvement over the lot of most of womankind throughout the world and throughout history.
 
There can be oversimplification at either end. At one end, this could be construed as a single incident, one individual's experience. At the other end, this could be construed as all men versus all women.

And part of the reason why the two genders gravitate towards different ends, is simple physical reality. Women are at risk of sexual assault from men, in a way that men are not from women. Any man who thinks that such an obvious truth is all about him and his hurt feelings, needs to get his head out of his ass.

We are also at a significant strength disadvantage. By the time my stepson was 12 or 13, he was able to do strength-based chores (like opening jars or helping move heavy furniture) better than I can. Most healthy males between, say, puberty and 70ish, could probably overpower me if they wanted.

There's simply no way to pretend that isn't the case. And, again, self-defense that is taught to women emphasizes that we need to be aware of that, and aware of our surroundings, and to pay attention to any red flags that someone's behavior raises.

That's just an instinctive awareness that a woman, alone in a confined space with a man, has. And the man probably doesn't, because he doesn't need to.

That doesn't mean that anyone is condemning all men. It just means that, when you are a total stranger, we don't know whether you are okay or not. And it's smart, for women, to err on the side of caution. If some man gets embarrassed because he didn't know he was doing anything wrong, that's sad. But if a woman is too trusting, the risks to her are a lot worse than simple embarrassment.
 
Are you seriously telling me that you've never made a social misjudgement that, uppon reflection, was a bad idea. Because you're coming across as Mr/Mrs Squeaky clean, never put foot in mouth, never made a bad social call. If you can honetly say that you've never misread a situation, perhaps due to a pint or two or to exuberance, then carry on vilifying a man who made a mistake.

No, I've done it quite often. I'll probably continue to do it. In fact, I have no doubt that some of my behavior when I was in college and learning the proper ways to converse with women would look almost exactly like EG's.

But I learned. I learned from male friends who made fun of the stupid stuff I did, I learned because I listened to my female friends describe situations where they were uncomfortable, and I continue to learn.

EG guy isn't a criminal, he's probably not even a bad guy, but there's no way to understand what is appropriate and what isn't unless we talk about it. Rebecca Watson said: this type of behavior made me deeply uncomfortable, guys, don't do that (she also pointed out that this behavior was the exception, not the rule). What I'm arguing against is the notion that it was improper to point out the bad behavior and anyone defending EG not as a guy who made a mistake, but as someone whose behavior was perfectly appropriate.

If, however, you're like the rest of us and not perfect, then allow a man a mistake without judging his whole personality o n one incident.

Well, fair enough. That wasn't my intent, but I can obviously see how what I've written gives that impression. I think EG can recover, and I hope he learned from this. He's probably a perfectly nice guy.
 
Can you agree that there is a gray area between "perfectly innocent" and "extremely dangerous?" Surely you can agree to that? So it's just a disagreement of how gray a given interaction was.
I've said it myself several times in this thread.

Again, RW didn't knee him in the groin or blow on a rape whistle or anything like that. She simply used it as an example of something that, although some men might not realize it, can be perceived as uncomfortable by some women. It's a discussion.
No she didn't, though. She did not say "hey, I found this uncomfortable and so let's explore whether that feeling was reasonable or not." What she said was more like "hey, I found this uncomfortable, so all men should stop doing it." It was not a discussion, it was a command.

It's a normal human interaction...in the world of porn movies. Elsewhere, it's just plain weird.

What you think people "appear to believe" does not always seem to match the text of the conversation here.
Lol, I just love how people in this thread are saying that I'm wrong and then proving me right on the very same thread, and now within the very same post. Classic.

You keep characterizing what is, after all, the other side of an internet debate as if it is oppressing you. Both (many) sides are expressing opinions -- why are you taking it in such an extreme way?
I'm saying that a person shouldn't issue orders to the male gender to conform with her personal view of what is and is not objectionable, and that it's possible for people to have different ideas of what is reasonable. That's "extreme"?

The most extreme thing I've said in this whole discussion was my first post on it, in which my point was that the message I was taking was to play it as safe as possible by not talking to women at all. In retrospect I'll scale that back to women I don't already know.

And yes, before somebody says it, I'm well aware that this isn't any great loss to womankind.

Really? Care to link to those?
I honestly couldn't, it was in the responses to one of the blogs. I had a bash at tracking it down again but there's so many blogs about it now that I couldn't find it.
 
the explanations I've heard don't appear justified to me... some scenarios genuinely would be threatening and justify fear, whilst others would not... what he did seems pretty reasonable to me... On the surface that looks good, but it's missing a vital element - is the perception reasonable? People's perceptions and feelings are not always reasonable... If you want to say "Fellas, if you find yourself in a situation where it's reasonable that a woman will find you threatening, do something about it." This I agree with fully... I don't see that this man did anything unreasonable... a more reasonable standard of when to be afraid and when not to be.
And that's my problem - with the attitude that there is to be no discussion at all of whether her fear was reasonable, that it is purely a matter of "you must never act in a way that frightens me, no matter how unreasonable that fear may be."
This is what Ms Watson implicitly does with her "that made me uncomfortable, and therefore men should not behave this way" line - the possibility that his behaviour might be reasonable and her discomfort not doesn't seem to have even occurred to her.
"Reasonable or not" is irrelevant. What's relevant is what will actually happen. People will have the reactions that they will have, with or without your permission. It's up to you to act not based on how you think they should react, but based on how they actually do.

In this case all that happened is a guy in a lift told a woman she was interesting and invited her to talk over coffee.
...in his hotel room.

the real message of that attitude is, never make any kind of approach to any woman at all.
Again, you can't actually be this stupid, so I don't know why, but your distortion here has to be deliberate. You know as well as everybody else here does that the message is not to make no "approach" at all but simply to not do so in a threatening way or under threatening circumstances. Why pretend to be unable to get that?

No, she didn't. Or rather, she did, but then she went on to instruct all men to not "be that guy".
Yes, but her rampant misandry is a completely separate issue from Elevator Creep's behavior and can't be used to make it more "reasonable". It's about as relevant as my observations of the texture and flavor of some plums I ate a couple of days ago.

(I didn't know until reading this thread that the famous-on-various-sites misandrist Rebecca Watson was the same person as the famous-at-JREF Rebecca The Sock Puppeteer & Mod-Forum Hacker. It's a bit of a surprise; I know both behaviors are childish belligerent trolling, but they're different kinds of childish belligerent trolling. Now I have a much better understanding of how well-rounded she is at being not just rotten scum, but multiple kinds of rotten scum at once. It still has nothing to do with Elevator Creep's violation of obvious, bare-minimal, basic social decency.)

As with all judgments of reasonable, each individual must make them. But again, that's the point. Ms Watson is perfectly entitled to her judgment of what is reasonable - but so is EG.
No, he is not. Taking care to avoid being perceived the wrong way requires considering how the perceiver will perceive things, and nothing else. The instant you consider anything else, like your own "reasonable" judgement of how you should be perceived, you're not really trying to avoid being perceived the wrong way. You're working toward some other goal which might or might not coincide with that.

I am not disputing that what he did made her feel uncomfortable. Clearly it did. But people can be made uncomfortable by pretty much anything.
Not true, but even if it were, that wouldn't mean all stimuli were equally likely to get that response, so it wouldn't justify treating all situations the same.
 
No, I've done it quite often. I'll probably continue to do it. In fact, I have no doubt that some of my behavior when I was in college and learning the proper ways to converse with women would look almost exactly like EG's.

But I learned. I learned from male friends who made fun of the stupid stuff I did, I learned because I listened to my female friends describe situations where they were uncomfortable, and I continue to learn.

EG guy isn't a criminal, he's probably not even a bad guy, but there's no way to understand what is appropriate and what isn't unless we talk about it. Rebecca Watson said: this type of behavior made me deeply uncomfortable, guys, don't do that (she also pointed out that this behavior was the exception, not the rule). What I'm arguing against is the notion that it was improper to point out the bad behavior and anyone defending EG not as a guy who made a mistake, but as someone whose behavior was perfectly appropriate.



Well, fair enough. That wasn't my intent, but I can obviously see how what I've written gives that impression. I think EG can recover, and I hope he learned from this. He's probably a perfectly nice guy.

Thanks for that. :)

Written language, without the meta-language to modify it often comes out the 'wrong' way.

You write it with one intonation, I read it with another and we're suddenly fighting. And of course nearly everyone (myself very much included) around here is in a heap big hurry to disagree with anyone who presents them with an opportunity to do so, just to show how clever they are.

:D
 
I think that perhaps you are over-sensationalizing the EG-RW incident.

That's pretty clearly true.

Rebecca herself said it made her feel 'uncomfortable'. That is a pretty innocuous word by all intents & purposes. She didn't use 'harassed, assuaulted, belittled' etc... She didn't even say that she felt 'Objectified or sexualized' - she drew an allusion to this by counterposing that this incident happened after she had discussed these two topics. But she pretty clearly stuck to 'uncomfortable'.

Right. The discomfort was rooted in being in a vulnerable position and not knowing what was coming. Obviously she wasn't assaulted, harassed..., it was being at the mercy of someone who could have done any of those things that created aprehension.

Now - I definitely agree with you that EG behaved in an 'inappropriate' manner in the elevator. As I pointed out, the issues for me are:

- He could've approached her in a much more open and typical environment, and had adequate opportunity to do so.
- He could've opened the conversation with a more typical conversation starter and not gone immediately for the jugular.
- He probably should've used common sense and at 0400h decided that coffee time was over.
- He should've been more aware of his surroundings.

I agree with all of that.

To bring this back to your post TraneWreck - I think it is a bit hasty to label the encounter (with the apocryphal detail we know about what really happened) as "childish, immature, disrespectful, and wholly lacking in dignity". It was certainly an ineffective way to communicate, as proven by the results. But to suggest more than merely 'ineffective' and 'causing discomfort' is reading too much into it.

Look, I'm certainly going over the top, but again, I'm trying to articulate a male perspective that seems wholly absent. We have some responsibility for setting the standards for ourselves.

What I find interesting is that if I had to imagine the classic chauvinist perspective, people who really don't give a rip about what women think, I still think I would come down on EG. What's interesting is that the disagreement is not between feminists and their usual opponents (chauvinists, religious right...etc.), it's a battle between feminists and some group of men arguing that they should be allowed to behave in a creepy way that would be rejected by traditional notions of manhood (though I doubt the people I've been arguing with will accept this, most of what I wrote was done to advance that perspective to see how they'd respond).

It seems like "maleness" is now defined as, "what we can get away with before some ball-busting chick tells us we're creeps." The pushback against a simple request--"don't coldly proposition me in an isolated, vulnerable environment," is stunning (I do understand clearly the position against the generalization of EG-->all guys in the skeptical community, or however that should be expressed). In the past, that's the sort of behavior that would be regulated from within the male community, but it seems there's little of that going on. I hear the argument that men should respect the femal perception of the world (which I obviously agree with), but I hear very little, "Guys, even if you want to get laid, you shouldn't do this. It makes you look like a wimp."

In other words, if I really just viewed women as sexual objects, it wasn't "Rebecca Watson" in the bar, just some dame I wanted to nail, that traditional notion of how a man should go about his business would still require that I charm her in public so all could admire my masculine prowess. I don't know if this is the result of the Pick-up Artist culture or Jersey Shore, or whatever, but the "game" has become something like, "get laid at any and all costs, there's no such thing as personal dignity, just get some trim." It's weird.
 
Last edited:
Why is it so terrible, then, to explain things clearly for socially awkward Aspergers super geeks? Isn't that exactly what they need and want?

Yes.

My point was we don't know the brain status of elevator guy.

It may have seemed normal to him to approach RW in this manner.
 
We have some responsibility for setting the standards for ourselves.

OK - I agree with the above.

So - the ONLY slack I'm suggesting those of us commenting on the incident should extend to the mysterious EG is...

SINCE we have only RW's report of what happened (and I'm not suggesting it is mistaken - but it IS only one source, without corroboration.)

SINCE we have stated (without evidence) that it would APPEAR that there is a higher than normal quotient of 'awkward' guys at skeptic/atheist conventions.

SINCE we have a number of (anecdotal) statements from women who attend these events that they experience similarly 'uncomfortable' incidents.

That perhaps a more productive way to go around this whole question is to talk about it like adults and come to some ways forward (like a survey of participants for example) RATHER than to go airing our laundry in very public fora, with emotional levels running well into histrionics...???
 
Rebecca herself said it made her feel 'uncomfortable'. That is a pretty innocuous word by all intents & purposes. She didn't use 'harassed, assuaulted, belittled' etc... She didn't even say that she felt 'Objectified or sexualized' - she drew an allusion to this by counterposing that this incident happened after she had discussed these two topics. But she pretty clearly stuck to 'uncomfortable'.

Ahem...
Um, just a word to wise here, guys, uh, don't do that. You know, I don't really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I'll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4:00 am, in a hotel elevator, with you, just you, and—don't invite me back to your hotel room right after I finish talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner.​
​
 
No she didn't, though. She did not say "hey, I found this uncomfortable and so let's explore whether that feeling was reasonable or not."

No, I didn't say it that way. I didn't say she was opening up discussion about whether her feelings were reasonable. I said she was putting the information out there for men who might not know that women may have that reaction.

It was not a discussion, it was a command.

What possible power does this "command" hold over you?

Lol, I just love how people in this thread are saying that I'm wrong and then proving me right on the very same thread, and now within the very same post. Classic.

Sigh. No, there is no one blanket statement of what is or is not appropriate behavior...context matters a lot, and men aren't always aware of the context women live in. So you could say "thanks for the info!" and be aware of context, or you could keep pouting about it.

But...that doesn't mean that EG had a reasonable expectation. Porn movies aside, in real life it generally takes something more than asking a complete stranger "wanna come back to my place?"

I'm saying that a person shouldn't issue orders to the male gender

Really, what power is it that you imagine these "orders" have over you?

The most extreme thing I've said in this whole discussion was my first post on it, in which my point was that the message I was taking was to play it as safe as possible by not talking to women at all. In retrospect I'll scale that back to women I don't already know.

How could you possibly get that message? This is, specifically, about a man who approached a strange woman, in a confined space, and opened up with asking her back to his hotel room. And your takeaway from that, is that you should never talk to women you don't know?

Why not try a different approach...make conversation first? Establish some kind of rapport? Do what someone above suggested and give her a business card, asking if you could meet tomorrow? Something other than blurting out "let's go back to my place" boom chicka wow wow?

And I'm bowing out for now -- inventory is not counting itself.
 
Last edited:

Thanks Ocelot - but that is from a later blog posting after everything started to go mammary-glands-up (so to speak), was it not? My comment was meant to be that the original video post didn't use such language. I could be wrong, and if so I retract.
 
Why is it so terrible, then, to explain things clearly for socially awkward Aspergers super geeks? Isn't that exactly what they need and want?

It's no more terrible than explaining things clearly to women, because that's what they need and want.
 
You would seriously be supportive of a son that lurked around in a bar for several hours avoiding conversation with a woman he was interested in until said woman announced she was tired, then following that woman until she was isolated and vulnerable (so he could spare himself the humiliation of being turned down in front of others--again, not adult behavior), and capping off the sleazy, wimpy, cowardly attempt at seduction by using his first words towards this woman to proposition her?

Obviously he did "nothing wrong" in the sense of breaking laws, but Christ, parents have a responsibility to impart basic concepts of dignity and respect for others. If I believed that the two of you were perfectly serious, here, and not constructing a strawman scenario, I would be concerned.

I appreciate that you have presented this in a way which makes it very obvious that he was creepy, so that anyone who cannot see it is too moronic for words. The problem is that for those of us who want to advise our sons not to be "that guy", when they are in that situation, our sons will not be sitting there misrepresenting the events and their intentions, and putting the creepiest possible spin on them, in order to judge whether their own behaviour is acceptable/non-acceptable. That is, the Elevator Guy will not recognize himself as being in the scenario you have painted. If he simply didn't have an opportunity to get close enough to Rebecca to talk to her, he won't recognize that he was "deliberately avoiding conversation for several hours". If he was hanging out with a bunch of like-minded people whose participation in the discussion ranged from a little to a lot (after all, we don't know who else he was talking to while he was there), he won't recognize that his behaviour was "lurking". If he happened to leave at the same time as her so he ended up in the elevator with her, he won't recognize she is "isolated and vulnerable" when men and women riding alone in elevators is a common and ordinary event. And finally, if all he wants is to offer coffee and says that he's not suggesting anything else, he won't recognize that he is "propositioning her".

Sure, it's good advice if you have accurately represented his perception of his behaviour. But if he's not "lurking" or "propositioning her" in the first place, how's he supposed to realize that he's sleazy?

Linda
 
Thanks Ocelot - but that is from a later blog posting after everything started to go mammary-glands-up (so to speak), was it not? My comment was meant to be that the original video post didn't use such language. I could be wrong, and if so I retract.

No it's a transcript from the original video
 
I have to say that I'm not sure what to think, but am enjoying throughout being swayed, back and forth like a teaspoon in a tempest in a teacup (or coffee stir-stik in a cyclone in a coffee cup... in an elevator at 4 AM in Dublin), by the eloquence employed on both sides and even in the middle -- no-man nor-woman's land -- to argue this rather minor yet rather fascinating point of inter-gender etiquette. It is bizarre that it's got so much attention and so many people talking; but in the long run, once the storm's past, that can't be a bad thing (let's hope). Kudos to all who've notched in with much nimbler thoughts than this klutz is capable of. Very enjoyable, often remarkable, even enlightening, discussion. :clap:
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom