So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, all of that is supported by the facts of the case.
Your hyperbolic description is not. Let's just take the first two, shall we?

1) EG was at the bar for the last hour or two Watson was there.
2) He never talked to her in the bar.
I don't believe Watson has never actually confirmed this to be the case, or denied it either way. But assuming those facts to be true, they are obviously not the same as this hyperbole:
...lurked around in a bar for several hours avoiding conversation with a woman he was interested in...
"Lurking", "several hours", "avoiding conversation"? Nothing of the sort.
The rest of your description is equally unsupported and alarmist.
 
You may not be outwardly denying her right to speak out but you are handwaving it as one individual's experience, when the evidence says otherwise.

No; I'm actually not.

In fact, the most interesting thing about this bruhaha is that it seems that a lot of hot buttons have been pushed, and this has gone way beyond one individual's experience.

I just don't want to accede to the idea that it means something universal about Eternal Verities and Battle of the Sexes and so on, or at least that it must uncritically be taken to mean such.

There can be oversimplification at either end. At one end, this could be construed as a single incident, one individual's experience. At the other end, this could be construed as all men versus all women.

I'm more interested in the middle, where things get complicated. Of course, I realize that I'm going to be accused of being at the opposite end. I'm used to that, and when I'm accuses of being at both opposite ends, then I consider it a good heuristic that I'm actually concentrating at the interesting part.
 
I wrote a whole reply to this and then the forum hung up and lost it. This is attempt number two.

That happens to me, a lot. Then when I attempt to rewrite it, I can only remember segments of what I was originally saying and though I remember them being good points, I don't fully remember where I was going with it. I feel that frustration.

Absolutely, I am not disputing that what he did made her feel uncomfortable. Clearly it did. But people can be made uncomfortable by pretty much anything.

Yes, creepy behavior is very subjective. I can't argue that.

Exactly. And my issue here is that many people (not necessarily you) appear to believe that their opinion of what is and is not appropriate social behaviour represent obvious universal truth. In many cases they seem oblivious to the idea that there even could be another opinion. Or if there is, that opinion couldn't possibly be valid - it's just that the person holding it is foolish or obtuse.

I have no idea if I fit in that catagory, but on the chance that I do, perhaps we (meaning anyone who may fit in that catagory) are just talking past each other. I don't feel that it's universal truth, I feel that she has the right to identify what is creepy to her. Considering she travels and meets lot's of new people, I don't feel it's unreasonable for her to say, publicly, "that behavior is creepy." The only area I feel that is being obtuse is the idea that she had some nerve saying what made her feel creepy.

This is what Ms Watson implicitly does with her "that made me uncomfortable, and therefore men should not behave this way" line - the possibility that his behaviour might be reasonable and her discomfort not doesn't seem to have even occurred to her.

I don't get that impression. I see it as her drawing clear boundaries as to what she finds unacceptable. In this case, it's; don't approach and proposition her as your first introduction, in confined quarters.

And that's the mild end of the response. Some of the comments I've seen are along the line of "he was deliberately threatening to rape her in order to coerce her into having sex with him."

I just don't want to snip. I can't argue that, at all.
 
Whats funny is that I could sit here and call you pathetic as well because you apparently feel the need to vocalize your superiority complex and judge a bunch of people you know absolutely nothing about.

Should we call this "Neo-Skepticism" or "Nu-Skepticism"???
This. Although I would have gone for "indignant cock-waving" rather than "superiority complex".....
 
Oh, no, not just that. He's also showing how manly he is.

Yes, that's exactly what I'm doing. I'm expressing the position men should take towards EG. Why are people going to such great lengths to excuse and justify his behavior? It's embarassing.

Do all of you really feel that threatened? Do you want to behave that way and are upset that others are criticizing that behavior?

Why on Earth would you try to justify it?

Notice that all of the whining and consternation has focused on poor, irrational Rebecca Watson. Her perception of events is being minimized, scoffed at and ridiculed, silly woman, how dare she call out inappropriate male behavior. She just doesn't see things like we men see things, so her opinion is invalid. There was nothing concerning about that event.

Well, let's look at it from the other perspective, ignore Rebecca Watson, ignore every statement she ever made on this issue, EG's behavior is still childish, immature, disrespectful, and wholly lacking in dignity. Regardless of how the woman will react (and we have at least two examples of women on these forums saying they wouldn't be overly concerned by that incident, that's fine, they are under no obligation to feel any given way), that's not behavior a decent human being engages in.

From the perspective of a man observing the behavior of another man, setting aside completely the opinion of the woman (the chauvinist perspective), EG's behavior should be condemned, yet men are desperately defending that behavior. It's baffling.
 
Meh, normal and 'appropriate' social behaviour.

Some people are socially awkward.

Some people have Aspergers.

Some people are just super geeky.

Some people just get caught up in the moment of how fab their first atheist convention was.

We just don't know.

Yes, I can see why it was uncomfortable, but it wasn't necessary to blog this to the entire world.

Oh you're preaching to the choir here... The most appalling part of this whole situation is the media circus that has spiralled out of it.

The topic had shifted back to discussing how to behave in elevators - which is in my opinion, a very different topic.
 
My problem is not so much with the fact that she was creeped out as it is with the fact that she and her defenders appear to believe that a man is automatically wrong any time his behaviour creeps out a woman.

Another red herring.

Can you agree that there is a gray area between "perfectly innocent" and "extremely dangerous?" Surely you can agree to that? So it's just a disagreement of how gray a given interaction was. You keep trying to argue that EG was "perfectly polite and reasonable," like no gray at all. All I'm saying, is that while his intentions were probably not dangerous, his behavior could be taken that way, and that a woman who finds it uncomfortable is perfectly within reason to do so. It's gray.

Again, RW didn't knee him in the groin or blow on a rape whistle or anything like that. She simply used it as an example of something that, although some men might not realize it, can be perceived as uncomfortable by some women. It's a discussion. And, even more than that -- it's a discussion in the context of a greater debate about "why don't more women come to these things?" So what if she "instructed" guys "don't be that guy."?? It's just words, after all.

One could imagine guys reacting by saying, "thanks for the information. I never thought of it that way." And some do. Others are all aflutter with how insulted they are.

If you genuinely think this is normal human interaction, then... I guess there is a lacuna of difference between what we feel is appropriate social behaviour.

It's a normal human interaction...in the world of porn movies. Elsewhere, it's just plain weird.

Exactly. And my issue here is that many people (not necessarily you) appear to believe that their opinion of what is and is not appropriate social behaviour represent obvious universal truth.

What you think people "appear to believe" does not always seem to match the text of the conversation here.

In many cases they seem oblivious to the idea that there even could be another opinion. Or if there is, that opinion couldn't possibly be valid - it's just that the person holding it is foolish or obtuse.

You keep characterizing what is, after all, the other side of an internet debate as if it is oppressing you. Both (many) sides are expressing opinions -- why are you taking it in such an extreme way?

This is what Ms Watson implicitly does with her "that made me uncomfortable, and therefore men should not behave this way" line - the possibility that his behaviour might be reasonable and her discomfort not doesn't seem to have even occurred to her.

Again, what you think is implicit isn't there. It is more, "that made me uncomfortable, and that's information that men might want to have if they don't want to come across, unintentionally, as a creep." It's helpful.

And that's the mild end of the response. Some of the comments I've seen are along the line of "he was deliberately threatening to rape her in order to coerce her into having sex with him."

Really? Care to link to those?
 
Last edited:
No; I'm actually not.

In fact, the most interesting thing about this bruhaha is that it seems that a lot of hot buttons have been pushed, and this has gone way beyond one individual's experience.

I just don't want to accede to the idea that it means something universal about Eternal Verities and Battle of the Sexes and so on, or at least that it must uncritically be taken to mean such.

There can be oversimplification at either end. At one end, this could be construed as a single incident, one individual's experience. At the other end, this could be construed as all men versus all women.

I'm more interested in the middle, where things get complicated. Of course, I realize that I'm going to be accused of being at the opposite end. I'm used to that, and when I'm accuses of being at both opposite ends, then I consider it a good heuristic that I'm actually concentrating at the interesting part.

Hey, I will be more than happy to join you in the middle. I certainly can't argue that this is not or should not representative of the battle of the sexes.
 
I'd be inclined to ask what actually happened from his perspective first.

Exactly right. I wouldn't take the memory of a tired, drunk witness with a known feminist axe to grind as though it were recording of the incident.

Also, if he's anything like me, my son would be geeky enough to ask somebody up for coffee and honestly be looking to have coffee... and naive enough to believe that saying "don't take this the wrong way" actually conveys a lack of prurient interest in the encounter.

I don't do late night pick-ups; a son of mine who did would not have my respect for it.
I do do late-night intellectual conversations; a son of mine who asked for one certainly wouldn't get my condemnation until I knew the facts better.
 
I am surprised you're taking this line of argument. There are grey areas, but please, there are obvious examples, and this is one.

This is not a complicated situation. No, we don't know how women will react when we begin showing interest, but it's really, really, really easy to begin that social interaction in a way that doesn't make them feel uncomfortable and threatened.

If you're an adult and honestly cannot understand the difference between chatting up a woman at a bar vs. lurking in said bar for several hours until the woman you're targeting decides to leave, then following her into an elevator and propositioning her with no prior interaction, there's really no hope for you.

If people are honestly having that much trouble, err on the side of caution.

I do doubt, of course, that 3.14 and most of the posters REALLY have these issues and are wholly baffled by basic social respectfulness. I think this is mostly a construct of people trying to argue a dumb position.

Not at all. It's an acknowledgement that it is possible to make a mistake in such a complex and confusing area and I don't think that one man, let alone an entire gender, should be vilified for one mistake.
 
Your hyperbolic description is not. Let's just take the first two, shall we?


I don't believe Watson has never actually confirmed this to be the case, or denied it either way. But assuming those facts to be true, they are obviously not the same as this hyperbole:

"Lurking", "several hours", "avoiding conversation"? Nothing of the sort.
The rest of your description is equally unsupported and alarmist.

He was interested in Watson. He was at her presentation, he was in the bar with her, he never talked to her. He waited until she was out of public and vulnerable to strike up conversation.

Pathetic. Sure, I've added color to the scenario, but let all that drop away. There is no factual analysis of this situation that leads to a conclusion that this man behaved appropriately.

Is this how you talk to women? Waiting until they're alone in a confined space and then propositing them? Why are you so interested in defending this behavior? I ask that in all seriousness. Why do you feel a need to define these actions as proper?
 
But I know both of you are too smart to actually believe that.
And amazingly enough, later you will ask me for examples of where anybody says that the guy is automatically in the wrong because they disagree.

If I believed that the two of you were perfectly serious, here, and not constructing a strawman scenario, I would be concerned.
I have a rule, and it is this : I almost always mean exactly what I say. I freely concede that I may be wrong, but you'd be well advised never to assume that I'm lying.

If my viewpoint concerns you... I seem to recall that the forum has an ignore feature?

1) Her fear was perfectly reasonable.
Thank you for sharing your opinion. Mine differs.

2) Yes, no man should "be that guy." Why do you object to that statement?
It follows on from my opinion that her fear was not in fact reasonable.

Do you want to behave that way? Do you behave that way?
I think it likely that you and I have very different opinions as to what "behave that way" means in this instance.

But for what it's worth, I have no desire to offend women even when the offence is unreasonable. Therefore I was perfectly serious when I said that the message I take from this is "Don't talk to women."

Of course that's the implication. That's what makes the scenario concerning. Do I need to post all of the sexual assault statistics from the other thread here?
I can't imagine the relevance, so no, you don't.

I would be curious if you provide anyone saying that.
Go read your posts in this thread. You've spent a large part of it stating that this man is automatically in the wrong for doing what he did any nobody could possibly believe otherwise. Thus justifying my point whilst denying it.

Haha, there is literally no way you believe that.
And at this point, we're done talking. I see no more reason to concern myself with anything you think, and no reason to respond to anything you have to say. Bye.
 
Last edited:
Some people are socially awkward.

Some people have Aspergers.

Some people are just super geeky.

Why is it so terrible, then, to explain things clearly for socially awkward Aspergers super geeks? Isn't that exactly what they need and want?
 
Not at all. It's an acknowledgement that it is possible to make a mistake in such a complex and confusing area and I don't think that one man, let alone an entire gender, should be vilified for one mistake.

Sure, I agree that the generalization was unwarranted.

I also agree that there are many, many confusing situations. This, however, is not one of them.
 
One thing that has puzzled me in the posts of some commentators, both here and elsewhere. I quote the example below mainly for convenience.
You would seriously be supportive of a son that lurked around in a bar for several hours avoiding conversation with a woman he was interested in until said woman announced she was tired, then following that woman until she was isolated and vulnerable (so he could spare himself the humiliation of being turned down in front of others--again, not adult behavior), and capping off the sleazy, wimpy, cowardly attempt at seduction by using his first words towards this woman to proposition her?

Perhaps I'm overly shy, but I would not feel comfortable asking to get to know someone better (whether this implied sex or not) in front of a crowd of people who were listening. This would be both for my own sake, but also for the other person; I wouldn't want them to feel awkward by being put on the spot in front of people they may (or may not) know. It may be that's not what you meant when you spoke of being humiliated, but even if it isn't, it's what others seem to have meant. I don't see why being turned down should entail humiliation in front of others; what business is it of anyone else? Just to be clear, I also think that EG went way too far the other direction; asking in a public area with others around, but not in earshot, would have been fine, but the world doesn't need to know unless the person asking does step outside the bounds of politeness, at which point the person being asked can always attract attention to what is happening.
 
Is this how you talk to women? Waiting until they're alone in a confined space and then propositing them?
I don't do casual sex; I never have. I do, however, continue intellectual conversations into the wee hours of the morning. I have continued interactions in private, face-to-face, with members of both genders.

Why are you so interested in defending this behavior? I ask that in all seriousness. Why do you feel a need to define these actions as proper?
Because I have extended and received invitations exactly like these from both genders. We have retired to someone's room and continued conversations or started new ones while drinking caffeine, then eventually retired to our own rooms (or crashed on a floor/couch).

The very scenario that you seem to find impossible, that the proposition really was innocent, has played out multiple times in my personal experience -- and it is factually incorrect to attribute improper motives to either those who invited me, or to me.
 
But for what it's worth, I have no desire to offend women even when the offence is unreasonable. Therefore I was perfectly serious when I said that the message I take from this is "Don't talk to women." I rarely do.

I was responding to your post as I read, then I got to this. Yeah, I think we should stop talking to each other.

No rational conversation will take place.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom