My problem is not so much with the fact that she was creeped out as it is with the fact that she and her defenders appear to believe that a man is automatically wrong any time his behaviour creeps out a woman.
Another red herring.
Can you agree that there is a gray area between "perfectly innocent" and "extremely dangerous?" Surely you can agree to that? So it's just a disagreement of how gray a given interaction was. You keep trying to argue that EG was "perfectly polite and reasonable," like no gray at all. All I'm saying, is that while his intentions were probably not dangerous, his behavior
could be taken that way, and that a woman who finds it uncomfortable is perfectly within reason to do so. It's gray.
Again, RW didn't knee him in the groin or blow on a rape whistle or anything like that. She simply used it as an example of something that, although some men might not realize it, can be perceived as uncomfortable by some women. It's a
discussion. And, even more than that -- it's a discussion in the context of a greater debate about "why don't more women come to these things?" So what if she "instructed" guys "don't be that guy."?? It's just words, after all.
One could imagine guys reacting by saying, "thanks for the information. I never thought of it that way." And some do. Others are all aflutter with how insulted they are.
If you genuinely think this is normal human interaction, then... I guess there is a lacuna of difference between what we feel is appropriate social behaviour.
It's a normal human interaction...in the world of porn movies. Elsewhere, it's just plain weird.
Exactly. And my issue here is that many people (not necessarily you) appear to believe that their opinion of what is and is not appropriate social behaviour represent obvious universal truth.
What you think people "appear to believe" does not always seem to match the text of the conversation here.
In many cases they seem oblivious to the idea that there even could be another opinion. Or if there is, that opinion couldn't possibly be valid - it's just that the person holding it is foolish or obtuse.
You keep characterizing what is, after all, the other side of an internet debate as if it is oppressing you. Both (many) sides are expressing opinions -- why are you taking it in such an extreme way?
This is what Ms Watson implicitly does with her "that made me uncomfortable, and therefore men should not behave this way" line - the possibility that his behaviour might be reasonable and her discomfort not doesn't seem to have even occurred to her.
Again, what you think is implicit isn't there. It is more, "that made me uncomfortable, and that's information that men might want to have if they don't want to come across, unintentionally, as a creep." It's
helpful.
And that's the mild end of the response. Some of the comments I've seen are along the line of "he was deliberately threatening to rape her in order to coerce her into having sex with him."
Really? Care to link to those?