Seismosaurus
Philosopher
- Joined
- Mar 15, 2003
- Messages
- 6,092
No, she didn't. Or rather, she did, but then she went on to instruct all men to not "be that guy". And that's my problem - with the attitude that there is to be no discussion at all of whether her fear was reasonable, that it is purely a matter of "you must never act in a way that frightens me, no matter how unreasonable that fear may be."Right, and there's a big area in between. And Ms. Watson didn't mace the guy or call the police -- she just used the situation as an example of something that made her uncomfortable.
She didn't SAY that, obviously, but that is the implication of this whole situation.
As with all judgments of reasonable, each individual must make them. But again, that's the point. Ms Watson is perfectly entitled to her judgment of what is reasonable - but so is EG. My problem is not so much with the fact that she was creeped out as it is with the fact that she and her defenders appear to believe that a man is automatically wrong any time his behaviour creeps out a woman.Who gets to decide that?
Could be. And what she did seems like an over reaction to anything EG did.Well, to me that seems like more of an over-reaction than anything Ms. Watson said or did.