So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Right, and there's a big area in between. And Ms. Watson didn't mace the guy or call the police -- she just used the situation as an example of something that made her uncomfortable.
No, she didn't. Or rather, she did, but then she went on to instruct all men to not "be that guy". And that's my problem - with the attitude that there is to be no discussion at all of whether her fear was reasonable, that it is purely a matter of "you must never act in a way that frightens me, no matter how unreasonable that fear may be."

She didn't SAY that, obviously, but that is the implication of this whole situation.

Who gets to decide that?
As with all judgments of reasonable, each individual must make them. But again, that's the point. Ms Watson is perfectly entitled to her judgment of what is reasonable - but so is EG. My problem is not so much with the fact that she was creeped out as it is with the fact that she and her defenders appear to believe that a man is automatically wrong any time his behaviour creeps out a woman.

Well, to me that seems like more of an over-reaction than anything Ms. Watson said or did.
Could be. And what she did seems like an over reaction to anything EG did.
 
@Seismosaurus.

We have never met.

You have been giving a presentation at a tradeshow, from a podium. I walk up to you, late at night, in an elevator, and blurt out: "I liked your speech, I'd like to talk about it some more. Would you come to my room to continue the conversation & have a coffee". Without any introduction. Without saying 'Hi, my name is xxx' and maybe offering your hand to shake. Without using any of the other hours of the day in a more open and 'normal' setting to engage in the same conversation. It is an AWKWARD and UNCOMFORTABLE scenario.

That someone could be made 'uncomfortable' by that is not in dispute - I would expect most people to at least be standing there scratching their head and thinking 'WTF'?

If you genuinely think this is normal human interaction, then... I guess there is a lacuna of difference between what we feel is appropriate social behaviour.
 
I'm not denying anybody their rights.



That at least I can agree with. Yes, they both suck.

However, I've said this before, and I'll say it again. There are lots of collected stories about men being mean to women and what it says about Male Nature and the Patriarchy and so on and so forth. Hell, there was even a television channel (Lifetime) that did this all the time, though they have toned it down a bit since they were bought by Disney.

Since feminism isn't the subject of this particular thread, what we ultimately have is one particular bad experience that a woman had, comparable to bad experiences that I personally have every week or so (unless they are worse). And so, ultimately, what?

If there weren't an effort (which, again, I do not ascribe to Watson but rather, at least mostly, to third parties) to make this emblematic of some Big Fat Hairy Feminist Deal, there would be much reason to comment about it.

You may not be outwardly denying her right to speak out but you are handwaving it as one individual's experience, when the evidence says otherwise. She puts a view out there, saying she gets objectified at conventions and she has grown intolerant of it. Women responded by saying thank you for bringing that out because I've had the same experience. I can't verbally support Rebecca's experience or that of any women that responed to her, with any certainty because I am not there to see how the conversation went down. I am incapable of telepathically feeling their reaction to the situation, but if they are having a negative reaction to how they are treated, it's not going to change until it's brought out into the open.

Ultimately, if one bad experience turns into a repetitive theme, you have two choices, take it like a champ or do something about it. Rebecca chose the second.

I've stated in this thread that the reactions from all sides have been over the top and I stated in the What Do Feminists Want, thread that the reaction of the radical feminists are doing more harm than good. The last thing I feel is that this proves that all men are pigs or predators, because I don't.

If this somehow drags out sexist terms that serve to reinforce gender roles, that until now, have been spoken, unchallenged, I think it's a good thing. I'm all for eliminating both; "take it like a man," and "crying like a girl." However, you can't deny one side of the claim by saying it happens to the opposite, as well, because my only response is, no one is stopping you from calling it out. If the response is, "your just acting like a whiny bitch," feel free to say, "thanks for proving my point!" I would totally back you.
 
I mean if a guy had made a video blog where he discussed some very objectional behavior by a woman and than said "OK, to the atheist gals, don't be this gal." -- part of me would have been annoyed. If ONE woman had done something seriously objectionable -- why should ALL of the women in the community be given a talking to, so to speak?

I see that Dunstan has run down the series of events, so I'll just add that the generalization is where I start to part ways with Watson. I think her comments were perfectly appropriate up to that point, but EG's behavior is not really evidence of sexism, much less sexism in the atheist community.

What I thought I'd see is a lot of guys arguing that generalization while abandoning EG, as in: Yeah, the guy is a creep, you shouldn't have to put up with that, but he's not representative of how we behave towards women.

We've gotten some of that, but we've also gotten A LOT of defense of that behavior, which is suprising and depressing.

As to the folks who can't see how creepy that guy was or who think that they have the right to approach everyone with innuendos for sex without taking even a few split seconds to size up the situation -- grow up. Really.

It really is that simple.
 
What I've been trying to say is that there is no way to be certain in advance if an approach is going to make a certain woman feel uncomfortable. Sure, there may be signs, but some people just aren't very good at picking up on them. And some women just aren't very good at giving them.

I am surprised you're taking this line of argument. There are grey areas, but please, there are obvious examples, and this is one.

This is not a complicated situation. No, we don't know how women will react when we begin showing interest, but it's really, really, really easy to begin that social interaction in a way that doesn't make them feel uncomfortable and threatened.

If you're an adult and honestly cannot understand the difference between chatting up a woman at a bar vs. lurking in said bar for several hours until the woman you're targeting decides to leave, then following her into an elevator and propositioning her with no prior interaction, there's really no hope for you.

If people are honestly having that much trouble, err on the side of caution.

I do doubt, of course, that 3.14 and most of the posters REALLY have these issues and are wholly baffled by basic social respectfulness. I think this is mostly a construct of people trying to argue a dumb position.
 
Last edited:
Now replace the word man with the word 'Muslim' or the word 'Black' and see how well that sits.

That sits fine with me, I'm not sure how I'd recognise that someone was Muslim, but if a black guy I'd never spoken to before got in a hotel lift with me at 04:00 and asked me to his room for coffe, I'd feel a bit nervous.
 
I wouldn't say "attaboy", no. I'd say "I know you didn't do anything wrong, but life isn't always fair and people aren't always reasonable. Chalk it up to experience and get on with your life."

I have three sons (four daughters BTW) and would say much the same thing.

I mean this very seriously: that worries me greatly.

But I know both of you are too smart to actually believe that. My guess is that what you've done is try to isolate the action of EG down to "talking to a woman on an elevator."

You would seriously be supportive of a son that lurked around in a bar for several hours avoiding conversation with a woman he was interested in until said woman announced she was tired, then following that woman until she was isolated and vulnerable (so he could spare himself the humiliation of being turned down in front of others--again, not adult behavior), and capping off the sleazy, wimpy, cowardly attempt at seduction by using his first words towards this woman to proposition her?

Obviously he did "nothing wrong" in the sense of breaking laws, but Christ, parents have a responsibility to impart basic concepts of dignity and respect for others. If I believed that the two of you were perfectly serious, here, and not constructing a strawman scenario, I would be concerned.
 
@Seismosaurus.

We have never met.

You have been giving a presentation at a tradeshow, from a podium. I walk up to you, late at night, in an elevator, and blurt out: "I liked your speech, I'd like to talk about it some more. Would you come to my room to continue the conversation & have a coffee". Without any introduction. Without saying 'Hi, my name is xxx' and maybe offering your hand to shake. Without using any of the other hours of the day in a more open and 'normal' setting to engage in the same conversation. It is an AWKWARD and UNCOMFORTABLE scenario.

That someone could be made 'uncomfortable' by that is not in dispute - I would expect most people to at least be standing there scratching their head and thinking 'WTF'?

If you genuinely think this is normal human interaction, then... I guess there is a lacuna of difference between what we feel is appropriate social behaviour.


Meh, normal and 'appropriate' social behaviour.

Some people are socially awkward.

Some people have Aspergers.

Some people are just super geeky.

Some people just get caught up in the moment of how fab their first atheist convention was.

We just don't know.

Yes, I can see why it was uncomfortable, but it wasn't necessary to blog this to the entire world.
 
Last edited:
I am surprised you're taking this line of argument. I suppose I admire your bravery at posting such humiliating personal information, but this does not reflect well on you.

You're just using this discussion as an excuse to insult people, aren't you?
 
No, she didn't. Or rather, she did, but then she went on to instruct all men to not "be that guy". And that's my problem - with the attitude that there is to be no discussion at all of whether her fear was reasonable, that it is purely a matter of "you must never act in a way that frightens me, no matter how unreasonable that fear may be."

1) Her fear was perfectly reasonable.
2) Yes, no man should "be that guy." Why do you object to that statement? Do you want to behave that way? Do you behave that way?

She didn't SAY that, obviously, but that is the implication of this whole situation.

Of course that's the implication. That's what makes the scenario concerning. Do I need to post all of the sexual assault statistics from the other thread here? How about just this one:

The U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics (1999) estimated that 91% of U.S. rape victims are female and 9% are male, with 99% of the offenders being male.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_in_the_United_States_of_America


As with all judgments of reasonable, each individual must make them. But again, that's the point. Ms Watson is perfectly entitled to her judgment of what is reasonable - but so is EG.

Haha, there is literally no way you believe that. Really? We all get to decide "reasonable" for ourselves, the effect on others be damned?

We live in a society, our behavior is necessarily circumscribed by the effect it has on others. It is inappropriate too willfully place another in a needless state of aprehension, all things being equal.

I am just surprised to see so much disdain for the basic concepts of dignity and respect.

My problem is not so much with the fact that she was creeped out as it is with the fact that she and her defenders appear to believe that a man is automatically wrong any time his behaviour creeps out a woman.

I would be curious if you provide anyone saying that. People creep out other people, it happens. If this guy had made the same statement in the bar and Watson was still creeped out, so it goes. But the actual dynamic was far more concerning. Regardless of what was going on his head, EG forced a situation where Watson was completely vulnerable, and he took that time to begin a line of conversation that was quite concerning, for obvious reasons. That's a step beyond creepy. Creepy+
 
Last edited:
I wrote a whole reply to this and then the forum hung up and lost it. This is attempt number two.

@Seismosaurus.That someone could be made 'uncomfortable' by that is not in dispute
Absolutely, I am not disputing that what he did made her feel uncomfortable. Clearly it did. But people can be made uncomfortable by pretty much anything.

If you genuinely think this is normal human interaction, then... I guess there is a lacuna of difference between what we feel is appropriate social behaviour.
Exactly. And my issue here is that many people (not necessarily you) appear to believe that their opinion of what is and is not appropriate social behaviour represent obvious universal truth. In many cases they seem oblivious to the idea that there even could be another opinion. Or if there is, that opinion couldn't possibly be valid - it's just that the person holding it is foolish or obtuse.

This is what Ms Watson implicitly does with her "that made me uncomfortable, and therefore men should not behave this way" line - the possibility that his behaviour might be reasonable and her discomfort not doesn't seem to have even occurred to her.

And that's the mild end of the response. Some of the comments I've seen are along the line of "he was deliberately threatening to rape her in order to coerce her into having sex with him."
 
IYou would seriously be supportive of a son that lurked around in a bar for several hours avoiding conversation with a woman he was interested in until said woman announced she was tired, then following that woman until she was isolated and vulnerable (so he could spare himself the humiliation of being turned down in front of others--again, not adult behavior), and capping off the sleazy, wimpy, cowardly attempt at seduction by using his first words towards this woman to proposition her?

It always amazes me how quickly scenarios shift and twist when you're trying to make a judgment on someone else's behavior unambiguous.

I think the only part of that entire description that is something other than unsupported supposition or unreasonable hyperbole is that Watson announced she was tired. Everything else is your attempt to turn an awkward but innocuous interaction into something condemnation-worthy.
 
It always amazes me how quickly scenarios shift and twist when you're trying to make a judgment on someone else's behavior unambiguous.

I think the only part of that entire description that is something other than unsupported supposition or unreasonable hyperbole is that Watson announced she was tired. Everything else is your attempt to turn an awkward but innocuous interaction into something condemnation-worthy.

No, all of that is supported by the facts of the case.

1) EG was at the bar for the last hour or two Watson was there.
2) He never talked to her in the bar.
3) He followed her out of the bar after she left (fine, maybe he was going to bed, too).
4) He chose a moment of isolation, rather than the several hours of available, public time for social interaction, to make his move.
5) He did so in a way that has obviously concerning overtones, regardless of the content of his words. If you want I can link the 50-100 articles I found about women who were sexually assaulted in elevators. "Polite small talk" was the way a sizeable percentage of the assailants began their attack.

I have no respect for this behavior. Set aside the issue of placing her in apprehension of some type of incident, this is not admirable behavior for a man. Boys have that sort of trouble engaging women, not men. He had time to talk to Watson, express his interest, in a setting where she was comfortable. He chose to ignore that opportunity, and waited until she was in a position of vulnerability. At best it's cowardly.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom