So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
What I've been trying to say is that there is no way to be certain in advance if an approach is going to make a certain woman feel uncomfortable. Sure, there may be signs, but some people just aren't very good at picking up on them. And some women just aren't very good at giving them.

[ . . . ]

I will admit that the time and place chosen by this guy weren't the wisest, but show me someone who says they're never made a social faux pas and I'll show you a damned liar.

I can assure you that being followed into an elevator at 4:00 AM by a man she has not previously interacted with and being propositioned may not make every single woman on the planet at best uncomfortable, I would bet very serious money that it will make almost every woman at best uncomfortable. That some people refuse to accept this fact both mystifies and saddens me.

-Pieter
 
I can assure you that being followed into an elevator at 4:00 AM by a man she has not previously interacted with and being propositioned may not make every single woman on the planet at best uncomfortable, I would bet very serious money that it will make almost every woman at best uncomfortable. That some people refuse to accept this fact both mystifies and saddens me.

-Pieter

"Not previously interacted with"? The function finished at 10.30pm, the drinks in the bar at 4am.
ETA I am simply not convinced that asking someone to have a coffee is propositioning anything other than having a coffee.
 
Last edited:
Serious question not just directed at DR, if you found out that EG was your son, what would you tell him?
I wouldn't say "attaboy", no. I'd say "I know you didn't do anything wrong, but life isn't always fair and people aren't always reasonable. Chalk it up to experience and get on with your life."
 
I wouldn't say "attaboy", no. I'd say "I know you didn't do anything wrong, but life isn't always fair and people aren't always reasonable. Chalk it up to experience and get on with your life."

I have three sons (four daughters BTW) and would say much the same thing.
 
@Lionking & Seismosaurus

With trepidation...

Firstly, its been discussed ad nauseum that RW alleges that EG had had NO interaction or conversation with her all evening.

So the very first interaction, before introducing himself, before shaking hands and saying 'pleased to meet you'... took place in the elevator. At 4am. And involved an invitation of a personal nature - whether it was for coffee, or coffee plus, it was

STILL.

WEIRD.

One doesn't walk around hotels, waiting until people are in elevators, and prior to at least exchanging names & perhaps discussing the weather, suggest it would be appropriate to retire to a room and share a coffee & a conversation. Whether with or without an innuendo for more.

I'm reluctant to call what happened a 'sexist' act. I'm reluctant to call it anything worse than 'disquieting'. But if you sit and think about the context as it has been reported, and without any other information, the approach clearly was...

Weird.
 
Thanks to the folks who enjoyed the Skeptoid article. I appreciate it. ;)

I will say that I do get 'hit on' more frequently at skeptical conferences than others. For instance, I was once working at a porn conference (as a promoter for a club, not as a porn star or anything), and though I was in a minidress and people assumed I WAS a porn star, I was still hit on with less frequency than at TAM.

The reason I think this is, though, is that as critical thinkers we don't dance around the sex subject. While this does create awkward situations if the attraction is not mutual, I do not think it is indicative of a sexist viewpoint.

I think this a great idea for the next TAM...how much floor space is there in an elevator, and should I bring my own nipple tassels?
 
I can assure you that being followed into an elevator at 4:00 AM by a man she has not previously interacted with and being propositioned may not make every single woman on the planet at best uncomfortable, I would bet very serious money that it will make almost every woman at best uncomfortable. That some people refuse to accept this fact both mystifies and saddens me.

-Pieter


*puts hand up*

I'm not saying there would be no discomfort involved for me, but no more than an unwanted proposition in other locations. Unless he was drunk, leering at me and invading my personal space in the elevator - that would be a bit more uncomfortable.

Guys, don't do that...
 
I can assure you that being followed into an elevator at 4:00 AM by a man she has not previously interacted with and being propositioned may not make every single woman on the planet at best uncomfortable, I would bet very serious money that it will make almost every woman at best uncomfortable. That some people refuse to accept this fact both mystifies and saddens me.

-Pieter


*puts hand up*

I'm not saying there would be no discomfort involved for me, but no more than an unwanted proposition in other locations. Unless he was drunk, leering at me and invading my personal space in the elevator - that would be a bit more uncomfortable.

Guys, don't do that...

ETA: And as to sexual advances at conferences, though I've never been to any skeptical ones, I have a hard job imagining that they are much different to other conferences that I have been to. Definitely a lot of sexual networking goes on. Anyone read the David Lodge novels?

ETA: Not sure why that reposted instead of just editing the original post...
 
@Lionking & Seismosaurus

With trepidation...

Firstly, its been discussed ad nauseum that RW alleges that EG had had NO interaction or conversation with her all evening.

Okay, I haven't followed all the posts on all the blogs devoted to this topic. I have difficulty envisaging someone wandering around a hotel at that hour who had obviously heard what RW had to say that night not having any interaction at all.

I should add that I met Rebecca at TAM OZ, and have nothing against her at all, quite the contrary. I don't see the approach to her as propositioning, much less threatening, as some here have stated.
 
Okay, I haven't followed all the posts on all the blogs devoted to this topic. I have difficulty envisaging someone wandering around a hotel at that hour who had obviously heard what RW had to say that night not having any interaction at all.

I should add that I met Rebecca at TAM OZ, and have nothing against her at all, quite the contrary. I don't see the approach to her as propositioning, much less threatening, as some here have stated.

Perhaps he was in the group that was talking with Rebecca but he didn't say very much, so she didn't really notice him?
 
Let me preface this by disclaiming that I expect other women to feel the same way, have the same experiences, or that EG's actions were perfectly reasonable....but...

This situation doesn't make me uncomfortable. I occasionally, even often, chat with guys in elevators. Sometimes we're alone. Sometimes there is an invitation. If we are leaving late from the same function, we may not have spoken to each other previously, but we can recognize that we had a shared experience. "Hey, that was an interesting conversation back there, wasn't it." When I have received a proposition I want to turn down, I just turn it down. When I was younger and inexperienced, it might have made me uncomfortable because I often mangled my rejection. Now I just make light of it. It's no big deal.

So, unfortunately, there are some guys out there who have learned that chatting with some stranger in an elevator can be pleasant, and maybe throwing out a casual invitation which is subsequently rejected isn't a hate-filled attack on women which should never be repeated.

I first posted in this thread asking for advice so my son wouldn't be "that guy". I suspect that if I discovered he was, my response would be pretty much like Seismosaurus' response above. And based on this thread and everything going on in the blogosphere, I would clearly be wrong. I would like to be able to come up with something better than, "you're screwed", but after 20 pages of discussion, that's still all I've got.

Linda
 
I am a little baffled by this type of post (and it's not just Seismosaurus): You are saying that you don't understand it & you don't know how any guy should be expected to know this, and yet at the same time you are refusing to listen to explanations that would help you understand it.
Actually I'm not doing that last part. Rather, I'm saying that the explanations I've heard don't appear justified to me.

Look, I think - I hope - that it's obvious that some scenarios genuinely would be threatening and justify fear, whilst others would not.

On one end of the scale, if a woman was alone in a dark parking lot at 4 am in a seedy part of town and a guy ran at her naked, waving a meat cleaver and screaming "TIME TO DIE!!!" then yes, obviously she'd be justified in being afraid.

On the other hand if a postman knocks on a woman's door and says "You need to sign for this please," and she screams and runs to hide in a cupboard in fear, I think it's obvious that she has not reacted reasonably.

In this case all that happened is a guy in a lift told a woman she was interesting and invited her to talk over coffee. She said no, and that was the end of it. She says it "sexualized" her, but he said nothing sexual - she simply assumed that he meant something sexual. Others have added things about her being "cornered." This seems dubious to me. An elevator is not a cell, it's a public place whose doors can open at any moment and will do so within tens of seconds at most, quite possibly to reveal other people. I'm curious as to a couple of details - was he between her and the door, or did he deliberately move to be so? Was he between her and the control panel, or did he deliberately move to be so? Did he get up close and in her face? Was his tone aggressive or demanding? Any or all of those things could make it seem much more threatening - but if any of them happened, she didn't say so.

Based purely on what she did say, what he did seems pretty reasonable to me.

If you are in a situation where you may be perceived as threatening but you don't want to be, you find a way to demonstrate that you are not a threat.
On the surface that looks good, but it's missing a vital element - is the perception reasonable?

People's perceptions and feelings are not always reasonable. If we say that a man is automatically wrong whenever a woman perceives a threat, then we hold men hostage to a standard that cannot possibly be met. This is why I said earlier that the real message of that attitude is, never make any kind of approach to any woman at all.

If you want to say "Fellas, if you find yourself in a situation where it's reasonable that a woman will find you threatening, do something about it." This I agree with fully - I've found myself doing it inadvertently before, and took action to try and make the woman feel safer.

But from how Ms Watson described it, I don't see that this man did anything unreasonable.

For any men who are not able to see this from the woman's point of view, this is a good learning experience. This is your chance to get a better understanding of how women (some, although of course not all) may judge risk, so that you can adjust your behavior accordingly (see previous paragraph).
Or alternatively, this is a good learning experience in which women (some, although of course not all) may learn a more reasonable standard of when to be afraid and when not to be.
 
If you are in a situation where you may be perceived as threatening but you don't want to be, you find a way to demonstrate that you are not a threat.

Every situation I am ever in that involves another human being is one in which I may be considered threatening. Could you let me know how I differentiate?
 
I can assure you that being followed into an elevator at 4:00 AM by a man she has not previously interacted with and being propositioned may not make every single woman on the planet at best uncomfortable, I would bet very serious money that it will make almost every woman at best uncomfortable. That some people refuse to accept this fact both mystifies and saddens me.

-Pieter

Now replace the word man with the word 'Muslim' or the word 'Black' and see how well that sits.
 
Rumour has it it's a certain R Dawkins, FRS, FRSL, of New College, Oxford, UK.

LOL

Look, I think - I hope - that it's obvious that some scenarios genuinely would be threatening and justify fear, whilst others would not.

Right, and there's a big area in between. And Ms. Watson didn't mace the guy or call the police -- she just used the situation as an example of something that made her uncomfortable.

On the surface that looks good, but it's missing a vital element - is the perception reasonable?

Who gets to decide that?

And again, her perception was just that he had done a couple of things that made her somewhat uncomfortable. That's not fear, and it seems pretty reasonable to me.

This is why I said earlier that the real message of that attitude is, never make any kind of approach to any woman at all.

Well, to me that seems like more of an over-reaction than anything Ms. Watson said or did.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom