So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, I think you agree with me, but because of the rule of internet arguing*, you can't admit it.

You know as well as I do that this fellow behaved attrociously. I don't know why anyone tries to defend it, even in the most tepid of ways.

*Whatever position you intially take, you must defend to the death...or until the thread gets burried.

*Seeks +5 Shovel of Excavating ... *
 
HINT.. i have no problem with Watson calling out someone creepy for elevator macking.. where i got annoyed with the hole thing was when PZ Meyers escalated the issue WAYYYYY beyond blip of a blurb on what Watsons youtube video clip made..

But you could have asked that instead of calling people "not real men" if they're not 100% behind skeptchick

Question: did this interaction begin when I responded to your post, or did it begin when you responded to mine?

Go ahead, take your time, scroll up.

Ok, because you responded to my post, it's not encumbent on me to query you for your motivations. I simply dealt with the argument you provided, which was ridiculous.

Now I notice that you're engaging in a rather weak effort at building a strawman out of my position. I did not define "real men" by their percent agreement with Rebecca Watson. I defined that term with respect to their attitude towards the guy in the elevator.

Take Skepchick out of the equation and replace it with a generic female (I think that means Laura Bush*), the argument stands. Whoever that behavior was directed at, it's absolutely pathetic and anyone attempting a defense is making a fool out of themself.



*This is a more amusing way to rile up feminists: describe the "default woman" as Laura Bush.
 
No, I see the weak rationalizations and lame justifications surrounding the issue of EG's behavior.

There are a ton of related issues that Rebecca Watson brought up that I seriously disagree with, but her sensation of being threatened on that elevator by the pathetic, embarassing behavior of a cynical simulacrum of man is absolutely correct.

And i bet if you bothered to read / gauge the responses you would find out most men agree with the original point Watson made and didn't get outraged until it escalated into something much bigger..

Is it convenient to ignore the other elephants in the room so much?

Do I take it that you're no longer trying to defend this idiot's behavior with absurd analogies?

I'm completely a-political at work, i have so much going on to really give 2 squirts about office politics. I only made the mental connection when it was painfully apparent these women have "boob privilege" as they're all directors, managers and the women who sign my time sheet. Ironically the ladies i get along with the most tend to be a little more conservative in their dressing habits.. The attire is corporate business.. If i showed my cleavage i would just be another one of "those creepers".. I never ONCE thought of "privilege" in such regard until the Watson thing blew up
 
Last edited:
Take Skepchick out of the equation and replace it with a generic female (I think that means Laura Bush*), the argument stands. Whoever that behavior was directed at, it's absolutely pathetic and anyone attempting a defense is making a fool out of themself.

Once again. i think you will find most people who are upset about this aren't upset about Watsons original statement. Have you considered your response is maybe barking up the wrong tree?

I'm merely replying to you because you seem to be fixating on a small minority when some people are just disgusted with the actions of the community at large.

For example.. how can one have a rational discourse upon what Watson said if people like you automatically assume everyone but yourself is inept? To make another "parallel" you basically "Richard Dawkenized" my scenario but from my perspective, rightfully so because i agreed with Dawkins in the context os PZ myers post but i also agreed with Watsons oriiginal claim.. figure that out :) PZ nees to stop calling people Bozo's .. thats my 2 cents
 
Last edited:
Well since you bring it up ... I have wondered how much of the blogwar is due to how this issue was expressed.

I mean if a guy had made a video blog where he discussed some very objectional behavior by a woman and than said "OK, to the atheist gals, don't be this gal." -- part of me would have been annoyed. If ONE woman had done something seriously objectionable -- why should ALL of the women in the community be given a talking to, so to speak?

I don't think that has much to do with how the issue has blown up.

First, Watson's video blog specifically said that most of the skeptical men she's spoken to seem to get what she's talking about. EG was depicted as an exception, though not necessarily a rare one.

After Watson's video blog, the next step was McGraw posting her rebuttal, which did not take the line you describe but rather defended Elevator Guy's behavior as totally unobjectional and just part of being a "sexual being."

Watson responded during her speech at a CFI event (which spawned the offshoot argument about whether that was an appropriate thing to do), and then the discussion went to the blogs, most notably at Pharyngula. I'm sure that somewhere in the many threads on this subject, a few people have taken the line that "of course EG behaved badly, but don't lump the rest of us in," but having slogged through a lot of the discussion on various venues, I'm pretty confident that this was a small minority. (There is the "he behaved badly, but it wasn't sexism, it was just rude" position, but I think that's a different issue from what you're describing.)
 
That being said, its a shame that of all the things to report about in the skeptical community, this is what gets reported in the main press. ETA: And a distorted overblown version at that.

It's an interesting point; should skeptics self-censor on this sort of topic as far as the mainstream media go? The two examples I've seen have been the New Statesman and the Gawker pieces, both by people very much inside the skeptical community (for want of a better phrase). Should we be washing our dirty linen so publicly? It wouldn't be so bad if skeptical matters were getting reported regularly, there might be a sense of perspective, but do we want the first thing many people will read about us to be this?
 
Serious answer:

If my son told me about the incident at 0400, and the reaction of Ms Watson, I'd look at him and say something like:

"Son, that's not a great way to meet someone. It's a way to make someone wish not to meet you."

We'd then need to talk about people skills for a while. He'd probably blow me off, being my son, and a college freshman. :cool:

Interesting. It lead to a very odd thought. I kinda see where the people who are all "But, but, but!?" are coming from.

Lets say you're going to TAM and you are (IRL) a slightly awkward person. Like maybe you're the kinda weird one at work, or you're the one who can't tell anyone you're an atheist because you live in the bible belt. So you're getting ready to mix and mingle with 1000 of your very favorite strangers. Ready to let your geek flag fly, stage-dive into the nerd herd and finally not have to worry about what you say.

And maybe, in that giddy purely platonic orgy of fellow freethinkers, there will be someone of the opposite sex who gets you, or at least gets your rocks off. Not because you're a lonely loser but because you're with your own kind and that would just be cool.

Now someone is splashing cold water all over everything and doing it in such a way that there is no real answer and no real guidelines. Sure, even if you can intellectualize why Rebecca may have felt uncomfortable, it's a chilling contrast to past TAMs, pictures of parties and current hopeful expectations.

So what's to be done? Nothing. Some people will be a little more careful, some will be complete asses, and some will emerge as knights in shining armor with various attendants and the look of having had too little sleep.

The free-thought movement, despite it's own fumbling, has gotten larger. TAM sold out, new meetups are popping up all over the place, etc. People will start gravitating to those events that best suit their needs. There won't be any "safe zone" groups but different groups will have different reputations and there will be something there for everyone.
 
Passing thought : After this I for one certainly wouldn't feel comfortable getting into an elevator alone with Ms Watson, or indeed being any place alone with her. And if I found myself so, I'd be quite concerned about it and want to get out as fast as I could.

Ironic.

Even more ironic is that if I find myself alone in an elevator with Ms Watson, I am going to sexually assault her.

:)
 
The mistake made was to assume that she was interested in a commitment free romp with someone she had never met. That is a tactic which will rarely succeeded. Perhaps he will learn form this and next time increase his chances by making clear that he is willing to pay.
 
Oh, I get that this particular set of circumstances creeped this particular woman out. But I don't really get why it would, or how he could possibly have been expected to have known in advance that it would.

I am a little baffled by this type of post (and it's not just Seismosaurus): You are saying that you don't understand it & you don't know how any guy should be expected to know this, and yet at the same time you are refusing to listen to explanations that would help you understand it.

This is very basic social behavior, even for the socially awkward, and not even limited to humans: If you are in a situation where you may be perceived as threatening but you don't want to be, you find a way to demonstrate that you are not a threat. I'm not going to make any analogies or examples, because those always just distract things, but I'm sure you can think of some on your own.

For any men who are not able to see this from the woman's point of view, this is a good learning experience. This is your chance to get a better understanding of how women (some, although of course not all) may judge risk, so that you can adjust your behavior accordingly (see previous paragraph).

And this risk assessment is what women are advised to do. All self-defense information starts with the idea that women should be aware of our surroundings and alert to possible threats. This was not an incredibly threatening situation, nor did Ms. Watson say it was. But it is a situation where any reasonable risk assessment is increased: in the enclosed space of an elevator, alone in the elevator, and at a time of night when there are probably few people around even when you get off the elevator. And with a guy who has already blundered past some cues that should have told him to back off.

Another thing that women are often advised, is to stop worrying so much about hurting someone's feelings. Look out for our own safety first. Some predatory men rely on women to ignore their internal warning bells out of a desire to avoid being rude or causing hurt feelings. So all the posters who feel like the real problem here is the possibility that some men might be feeling hurt, tough.

It's also occurred to me that some men may be oblivious to just how many creepy men there are out there, and how often women may encounter them. Because the creeps leave us alone when you're with us! I've never had a creepy guy approach when I've been out with my dad, my husband, brothers, male friends, etc. So guys, you may not have ever witnessed the sorts of things that can, over the years, cause a woman to become more & more suspicious of any off-putting male behavior. But just because you haven't seen it doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

And all the hand-wringing about "what if the guy was just socially awkward" is making me grumpy. That was the reason that Ms. Watson brought up the topic, is to spell things out for those guys who didn't pick up on it on their own.
 
Waitaminute - You're willing to consider that EG had some good reason for his behavior but not that RW had good reason to be uncomfortable?

As a skeptic, you might want to lose the idea that people are psychic and that women in uncomfortable circumstances can instinctively tell whether or not someone is a deaf, drunk, shy, aspie sufferer who doesn't mean any harm when the only evidence that woman is given is an offer to go back to a hotel room.

As a skeptic, you might want to lose the idea that people are psychic and that men who make women in uncomfortable circumstances can instinctively tell in advance if their approach is going to cause discomfort.

Women are inconsistent!

People are inconsistent!

What I've been trying to say is that there is no way to be certain in advance if an approach is going to make a certain woman feel uncomfortable. Sure, there may be signs, but some people just aren't very good at picking up on them. And some women just aren't very good at giving them.

I really don't think anyone has the right to be offended by an unwanted advance that's withdrawn after rebuttal. If people aren't allowed to proposition anyone that might be offended and if there's no-way to tell who'll be offended in advance then there would be no propositioning going on at all.

I will admit that the time and place chosen by this guy weren't the wisest, but show me someone who says they're never made a social faux pas and I'll show you a damned liar.
 
Thanks to the folks who enjoyed the Skeptoid article. I appreciate it. ;)

I will say that I do get 'hit on' more frequently at skeptical conferences than others. For instance, I was once working at a porn conference (as a promoter for a club, not as a porn star or anything), and though I was in a minidress and people assumed I WAS a porn star, I was still hit on with less frequency than at TAM.

The reason I think this is, though, is that as critical thinkers we don't dance around the sex subject. While this does create awkward situations if the attraction is not mutual, I do not think it is indicative of a sexist viewpoint.
 
I just want to say that I have found your posts in this thread and in the What Feminists Want thread very useful. You clarify the issues with specific and reasonable examples. But I am a bit puzzled by this post. Are you saying that guys don't stare at your tits otherwise? That by avoiding TAM you won't experience sexist remarks and unwanted advances? Is it much worse at TAM? Or did you expect it to be absent?

Linda


I think that the hope is, at an event all about thinking[i/] the expectation might be that the cerebal rather than the testical would take the lead.

Unfortunately men are sexual creatures. We can't help it. People are sexual creatures.

Or to be more accurate, I'm going to speak for myself only and wait to be vilified, I am a sexual creature. It's on my mind a lot, so...



I'm sorry, ladies, I can't help it, I think about sex a lot. If I find you attractive (and that's a really broad church, ) then I'm afraid I am going to sexualise you. I'm not going to think any less of your morals, intellect, physical prowess or any other aspect of you because I'm sexualising you, but I'm going to view you as a sexual creature. If it helps, I really, really don't mind if this is reciprocal, but I understand if it's not.

I'm sorry if I glance at your tits while I think you're not looking (Even though somehow you always know I've done it)

I'm sorry if I check out your arse as you walk away.

I'm sorry if, when I look into your eyes I just occasionally (not always) just think that they're a pretty colour and not think of the shining intellect behind them.

I'm sorry if, after a few drinks I find myself thinking 'she's really pretty' every now and than rather than 'she's really clever' This doesn't mean I don't think you're clever, it just means I think you're pretty too. The fact that you're clever probably makes you seem more pretty, but sometimes it's just about the pretty.

I'm sorry that I do all this, perhaps it makes me a raging pervert, but I rather hope it doesn't. I rather hope that you understand that the fact I view you as a sexual creature doesn't in any way diminish my appreciation of every other aspect of you because it doesn't.

I'm really sorry if, occasionally, I misread signals and make an unwanted pass. I promise I'll back of like a shot when rebuffed, but, not being either perfect or psychic, I am going to make a mistake every now and then. I don't mean to make you uncomfortable.


Perhaps the above makes me a bad man. Perhaps I'm a case of arrested development and, unaware to me, the proper, grown-up chaps are able to switch that part of their minds off while they're engaging in intellectual pursuits, but for me it's there all the time and I'm afraid I'm not going to hate myself for it, but I doni't mind if you do.



(P.S. With all the above given, it's still really stupid to make a pass in an elevator at 4am. not sexist, not criminal, just stupid. We've all done something stupid sometime)
 
It's also occurred to me that some men may be oblivious to just how many creepy men there are out there, and how often women may encounter them. Because the creeps leave us alone when you're with us! I've never had a creepy guy approach when I've been out with my dad, my husband, brothers, male friends, etc. So guys, you may not have ever witnessed the sorts of things that can, over the years, cause a woman to become more & more suspicious of any off-putting male behavior. But just because you haven't seen it doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

To expand on this idea, I want to point out that the creepy behavior is often linked to the pursuit of getting laid. Therefore, unless they happen to be gay, they generally don't display the creepy behavior around other men. So you may actually know some of these creepy guys, but never actually witness the creepy behavior.
 
Thanks to the folks who enjoyed the Skeptoid article. I appreciate it. ;)

I will say that I do get 'hit on' more frequently at skeptical conferences than others. For instance, I was once working at a porn conference (as a promoter for a club, not as a porn star or anything), and though I was in a minidress and people assumed I WAS a porn star, I was still hit on with less frequency than at TAM.

The reason I think this is, though, is that as critical thinkers we don't dance around the sex subject. While this does create awkward situations if the attraction is not mutual, I do not think it is indicative of a sexist viewpoint.

Nail. Head. Hit.

Your blog was spot on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom