So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
To somewhat derail this rather entertaining subtopic of coping with the DrBuzz0s of TAM...

That there is this perception of 'sides' in all of this is the crux of my issue.

The histrionics that have made this debate become so much larger than one unfortunate elevator encounter, is what has my knickers in a twist.

If the DrBuzzos get enough people saying "Dude, seriously?" they might modify their behavior with time. But if lots of people are just a little more careful to point their libidos at those who welcome it, he will be just a weird but singular event.
 
I just want to say that I have found your posts in this thread and in the What Feminists Want thread very useful. You clarify the issues with specific and reasonable examples. But I am a bit puzzled by this post. Are you saying that guys don't stare at your tits otherwise? That by avoiding TAM you won't experience sexist remarks and unwanted advances? Is it much worse at TAM? Or did you expect it to be absent?

Linda


Well put, and I was wondering about this as well. What I'm getting from some of the posters is that TAM is worse in this regard than some other conference that brings together 1500 people from all over the world. I don't understand why that would be the case.
 
As soon as the behavior does start harming or threatening others, then of course you can take action, but aside from that, we don't agree to certain behavioral or politeness guidelines when we register for TAM.

Actually, we do, and not just as part of TAM, but as being part of society. I have little doubt that if somebody (just one individual) felt threatened enough she (I will assume female here as that is what this thread is about) would be able to have South Point Security detain the individual and possibly remove him (again assuming male here) from the premises. If he were a TAM registrant, then South Point would bring this matter to the attention of the JREF, as the event organizer. They would then have to decide whether to allow the person to register for future events.

This is reality. Fortunately, things have not escalated (or is it elevated ;)) to that point yet at TAM, but I am certain that other events in LV have had to deal with this exact issue. This is part of the social contract of living in/visiting the USA.

My point is that there is nothing aberrant about JREF enforcing even stricter codes of conduct if they so choose. As the organizer of the event, that is well within their rights. How much that should be done is a valid debate, and it comes down to how much value the JREF gets out of the restrictions because the cost is intentionally turning away potential attendees (but they may encourage even more by doing so).

I don't think that we are yet at the point where conference holders need to do this but if they decide that attracting more female attendees becomes a higher priority, we may see that change.
 
Not at all. Again I am not saying what his reasons actually were merely putting forward alternates to the one that Rebecca put forward that still match what she said had occurred to illustrate that we cannot make firm conclusions based on her anecdote about someone's behaviour.



:confused: You have totally lost me.

It doesn't matter what his intention were. His actions made her uncomfortable. You can mull it over from his perspective all you want but none of that will change how RW would have felt at the time. If she were psychic, she might have been able to tell that it was an honest offer to talk, a complete pick-up, or a dork looking for something nice to say and flubbing it. She is not psychic. All she knows is that, after talking about rape threats (Small clue: this doesn't make all women horny) a guy followed her into the elevator and asked her back to her room. This made her justifiably uncomfortable no matter what he was thinking.
 
Actually, we do, and not just as part of TAM, but as being part of society. I have little doubt that if somebody (just one individual) felt threatened enough she (I will assume female here as that is what this thread is about) would be able to have South Point Security detain the individual and possibly remove him (again assuming male here) from the premises.


We don't disagree on that point, if you read my post more carefully:

As soon as the behavior does start harming or threatening others, then of course you can take action, but aside from that, we don't agree to certain behavioral or politeness guidelines when we register for TAM.
 
Last edited:
If the DrBuzzos get enough people saying "Dude, seriously?" they might modify their behavior with time.

Nods. But of course I need to know to whom I should be addressing my 'Dude, seriously' comment. I don't in the case of RW vs EG. I can pretty much assure you I will probably say 'Dude, seriously' to DRBuzz0 at some point in TAM9 about something.

But if lots of people are just a little more careful to point their libidos at those who welcome it, he will be just a weird but singular event.

I'm not quite sure I grok this. You're saying that people should be aware of who would be welcoming of a pass, and therefore the ones that can't figure it out will stand out even more?

That assumes that a) someone knows ahead of time who would be welcoming of an approach.

For me (who is not dating anyways, being in a 17 year long committed & monogamous relationship) I have always thought looking for a wedding ring was a logical starting point. But that of course is not conclusive - so I would say having a conversation and getting to know someone first is the next step. If no vibe then move on. If 'vibe' then a more direct question may follow (back in the day.)

Do you think there is some other way to achieve a) in a different way that I describe?

And it sounds like you're also saying b) that if 90% of people behave more responsibly / better, then the 10% who don't get it will be more obvious.

But is the problem REALLY that bad, and is it REALLY that much worse at a skeptical/atheist event? That would be a really fascinating question to examine. Is attendee behaviour at a TAM more disconcerting to women than say... at a COMIC-CON or at the Consumer Electronic Show?
 
Really? Who said that? I must have honestly missed it, but even if someone said that (I disagree), but even the person who said that probably didn't mean, "sex is a nasty dirty thing". Surely you would realize that'd be a misrepresentation of his/her view?

As I said I used a bit of hyperbole, that means I exaggerated a response to make a point.

But... Didn't Rebecca say that he said, "I find you interesting and want to continue this discussion"? :confused: Or are you suggesting he was lying about having found her talk interesting? But then if he was lying, he actually didn't find her very interesting, and probably did want to get into her pants... no?

I am saying we don't know, we have no way of knowing what actually happened or was actually said and so on.


Each one as unlikely as the rest, to be honest. I don't know if you are that naive, or if Irish culture is that different than North American culture, or if you're just playing devil's advocate, but I certainly find it exceedingly unlikely that it was not a proposition for sex with all those circumstances combined.

And I don't, but for some reason I don't feel a need to place a label on you because I don't agree with you....

...snip...

If you are saying that Rebecca misrepresented the facts, and have reason to believe that she embellished or omitted stuff, then point taken. I don't know her at all, so I had no reason to disbelieve her version of the story.

Then how can you hold apparently firm conclusions about what happened and what it means?
 
The excuses for the Elevator Guy keep piling up. The dude is now a very shy, partially deaf, drunk, aspie-sufferer. A moment of silence, if you will, for the trials and tribulations of Elevator Guy. A man so flawed that he can never be made responsible for his own behavior.

They're speculating on why Elevator Guy did what he did. Just because they aren't assuming the worst like you seem to be implying here does not mean that they are making excuses for him.
 
It doesn't matter what his intention were. His actions made her uncomfortable. ...snip...

How can you know that!
You can mull it over from his perspective all you want but none of that will change how RW would have felt at the time.

But how do you know her feelings were reasonable and based on something rational in the actual circumstances? Feelings are real but they are often at odds with the reality.

If she were psychic, she might have been able to tell that it was an honest offer to talk, a complete pick-up, or a dork looking for something nice to say and flubbing it. She is not psychic. All she knows is that, after talking about rape threats (Small clue: this doesn't make all women horny) a guy followed her into the elevator and asked her back to her room. This made her justifiably uncomfortable no matter what he was thinking.

What a disgusting thing to throw at me, totally uncalled for.
 
I just want to say that I have found your posts in this thread and in the What Feminists Want thread very useful. You clarify the issues with specific and reasonable examples. But I am a bit puzzled by this post. Are you saying that guys don't stare at your tits otherwise? That by avoiding TAM you won't experience sexist remarks and unwanted advances? Is it much worse at TAM? Or did you expect it to be absent?

Linda

All of the above? I enjoy the social aspects of skepticism as a movement because it's a bit intellectual. I'm 45, married and plain. In my 20's, I was proud that I had a scathing comeback for every occasion and of my ability to tackle the battle of the sexes with energy and wit. But I'm tired of it now. I gave as good as I got for 20 years, can't I go to one measly conference on science and rationality without having to revisit those days? Especially now that time has given me cover.

I have social phobias so, like many people, I hide it with overly-energetic interaction as soon as I am uncomfortable. Before I found my TAM buddy (a truly wonderful gentleman who stuck by my side for days.) I was in constant frantic smiley chatty mode. Which makes me look like an idiot (leading to more social phobia stuff. yay me.) and is utterly exhausting after just a few hours.
 
Well put, and I was wondering about this as well. What I'm getting from some of the posters is that TAM is worse in this regard than some other conference that brings together 1500 people from all over the world. I don't understand why that would be the case.

I obviously can't speak to this from the female perspective, but I can say that I attended a couple of TAMs back in 2006 and 2007 and stopped going in part because the socially awkward quotient of the attendees (at least at the time-- it was only ~800 back in those days) was significantly higher than the norm. The thought of being a target of sexual attention from that group-- yeah, I can see how that would be uncomfortable.
 
How can you know that!


But how do you know her feelings were reasonable and based on something rational in the actual circumstances? Feelings are real but they are often at odds with the reality.



What a disgusting thing to throw at me, totally uncalled for.

Oh I am sorry that I asked you to spare Rebecca a bit of the vast empathy you have lavished on the Elevator guy. <---sarcasm.
 
Call it the snowball effect. First day, a woman runs into dear old buzzo. "Well" she thinks as she scurries away with alacrity "THAT wasn't very nice." She sees a person that she met earlier and tells them what happened. "Oh, that's just Buzzo, he does it to everyone." And she doesn't want to make a big deal because, seriously TAM is awesome and she's having a really good time but maybe somebody could have warned her?

Between lectures she grabs a book to read back in her room. And lo! The author is there to sign it. Neat! of course Vegas is like 2000 degrees so she's in a T-shirt that isn't quite enough coverage for the super air-conditioned corridor. And the author has noticed this but that's OK because it's TAM and everything is awesome and who knew that people could sign books while staring at your tits instead of the page? Fascinating.

And when she mentions it to the people from her skeptical group, they just laugh. Yep that's how it is and hey, free lunch time! (Not really free it was included with her ticket which cost hundreds of dollars that she has, but not really but it's worth it 'cause it's TAM!)

At lunch, some guy she's never talked to snakes into the seat next to her. He's a little more smooth than BuzzO but a bit perfunctory. Things get around to a gentle no, he gets up and leaves with barely a word. ooookay. That was odd.

And on and on, until by the end of it she's exhausted, walking around with her hands crossed over her chest like she's back in high school (damn air conditioning) and disappointed in a weird undefined way. Like everyone else, she's sad because it's over but she's also a little relieved. The next time TAM rolls around, she starts to get excited but it's kind of expensive and she didn't really have that great a time and you know what, maybe skip it.


Yes, sadly.

I remember sitting at a book table (not my books) at TAM 4 when a short woman approached and said "You didn't bring it, did you?" I looked up and didn't recognize her face - having never seen it before - but I guessed that it was a poster here named Suez, and I turned out to be right. She was asking for a jar of honey that I'd promised her; I told her it was in my room and that I'd bring it down later.

At some point that day I remember very clearly how she remarked that it was refreshing that when she came to the table, the first thing I looked at was her face, not her chest. In point of fact, I didn't look at her chest at any other point either, but nevermind; the passing comment got me to realize that the ogling and nonchalant (if not entirely blatant) objectification that many women face, even in a place full of what I normally consider to be enlightened people like TAM, is very real and I can understand the sort of weariness of it that would provoke Rebecca's video message. I haven't felt lectured or stereotyped by anything Rebecca has written or said as a part of this recent scrum.
 
I get the impression that this carries on because people (and I'll include myself in that) may be concerned about a portion of the issue that the major parties involved might even agree on, and are frustrated that a few people commenting haven't agreed with.

At a certain point we're taking issue with each other and with hypotheticals and rolling it into the original problem. This really can't be counted as drama seeking by the major parties, and I'm at the point that I hope it draws down, and I'm starting by backing off a bit myself.
 
With regard to Rebecca - her concerns in the elevator were valid, her behavior in the elevator and during her speech (calling out the critic) were just fine.

With regard to her critic (the one mentioned in the speech) - entitled to her opinion but not justified in being upset at being called out publicly after she criticized Rebecca publicly.

With regard to Richard Dawkins - like his writing and speeches that I've heard very much, do not agree with him at all in this situation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom