So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
The one thing I am disappointed about in reading this thread is how there is still a completely irrational approach once "sex" becomes involved. For example I could go to TAM and have as one of my goals meeting new people and creating friendships and that is OK, but if one of my goals is to have sex that is not OK. Sex is part of human social interactions to single it out and treat it as taboo or that there has to be set etiquette rules is to me irrational. For goodness sake why can't we just be honest about sex and sexual desires, why does it have to be hidden and camouflaged and controlled by Mr and Mrs Manners on the etiquette steering committee?


Because there's people who do not want sex and/or who feel offended or insulted by being asked by complete or relative strangers. The problem with people who have opinions like yours that I've met is that they either refuse to acknowledge the existence of the aforementioned individuals, or they capriciously presume that the feelings of those persons are irrational or based on faulty reasoning and therefore can or should be ignored in favor of the opinions of those who would like humanity to change so that asking for sex is as common and casual as asking for a conversation.
 
I have been told that if I go to a convention and one of my goals is to get laid then I have serious problems.
Really? Who said that? I must have honestly missed it, but even if someone said that (I disagree), but even the person who said that probably didn't mean, "sex is a nasty dirty thing". Surely you would realize that'd be a misrepresentation of his/her view?

Overlook what? I have seen no evidence that this person had heard whatever it is he was meant to have heard.
But... Didn't Rebecca say that he said, "I find you interesting and want to continue this discussion"? :confused: Or are you suggesting he was lying about having found her talk interesting? But then if he was lying, he actually didn't find her very interesting, and probably did want to get into her pants... no?

There are many, many other interpretations than the one that Rebecca has supplied even if the events unfolded as she claims they did.
Each one as unlikely as the rest, to be honest. I don't know if you are that naive, or if Irish culture is that different than North American culture, or if you're just playing devil's advocate, but I certainly find it exceedingly unlikely that it was not a proposition for sex with all those circumstances combined.

(Never mind that people have not yet explained what is intrinsicly wrong with just wanting sex with someone.)
That might be because no one has claimed that it's intrinsically wrong... hard to give an explanation for a position you don't hold.

What I see is a load of people being very quick to uncritically accept an anecdote as being 100% accurate and being very prescriptive in regards to social interactions that are "sexualised".
If you are saying that Rebecca misrepresented the facts, and have reason to believe that she embellished or omitted stuff, then point taken. I don't know her at all, so I had no reason to disbelieve her version of the story.
 
Bloody hell this is getting ridiculous, singling out someone who some people find creepy and weird - why does he have to change, why can't people deal with him as he is, if you don't like him because you find him creepy then don't interact with him! If he was actually dangerous fair enough but for goodness sake live and let live!.

So, are you going to stop warning, infracting and banning people because they don't abide by the social rules of the forum (the MA), or as Liason, will you continue to do your job and enforce those social rules because they have a purpose and help promote an atmosphere that better allows the free exchange of ideas?

Yes, I agree that the social rules of life are not as clearly laid down as the MA, but they are there and if somebody has such a problem following them that they cause significant problems, then the organizer of the event does have a responsibility (just as you do here on the forum) to enforce those rules and make sure that an atmosphere that allows the open and free exchange of ideas is maintained.
 
I agree with Alison's post, for the record. I think Rebecca was perfectly fine in pointing out the issue, but the sh##storm that followed was completely over-the-top. Dawkins's post was a bit rude and probably missed the point, but the backlash against was blown out of proportion. That follow-up post by Rebecca calling for his boycott and raving against the untr00 feminists is just pure silliness.

I agree. One aspect of the whole thing that I think has been overlooked (to the extent anything has been overlooked as this dead horse has been beaten to pulp) is PZ's role in escalating this from a teachable moment about tact and empathy to the debacle it's become. Rebecca's initial video about "don't be that guy who creeps out women in elevators" was good advice for the EGs and Buzzos of the conference world who need to hear it. Then Myers comes along with his usual white knight schtick:

There is an odd attitude in our culture that it's acceptable for men to proposition women in curious ways — Rebecca Watson recently experienced this in an elevator in Dublin, and I think this encounter Ophelia Benson had reflects the same attitude: women are lower status persons, and we men, as superior beings, get to ask things of them. Also as liberal, enlightened people, of course, we will graciously accede to their desires, and if they ask us to stop hassling them, we will back off, politely. Isn't that nice of us?

It's not enough. Maybe we should also recognize that applying unwanted pressure, no matter how politely phrased, is inappropriate behavior. Maybe we should recognize that when we interact with equals there are different, expected patterns of behavior that many men casually disregard when meeting with women, and it is those subtle signs that let them know what you think of them that really righteously pisses feminist women off.

Of course Dawkins and Rebecca are responsible for their own responses to this-- and neither of them comes out looking good-- but it seems like Dawkins was really responding to PZ's characterization of the issue (which contains a lot of intemperate nonsense-- "ask[ing] things" of women is a sign of subordination, really?), not to what Rebecca had actually said.
 
I think you're rather leaping to conclusions here, Bookitty.

The ONLY report we have to follow in all this, is Rebecca's video. If Rebecca's claim were that monkeys flew out of her butt, then we would be well within our rights to suggest that a short YouTube clip is not necessarily compelling evidence of same.

There are a myriad of speculations both sympathetic to EG and even more damning to EG, that we're probably never going to be able to dispel / investigate because no one seems to remember anything or be willing to talk about it.

That's all.

Rebecca's "claim" was that at a conference where nearly everyone was just great, one guy did something that, because of context, made her feel uncomfortable and oh hey, maybe don't do that.

I hardly think this needs extraordinary evidence.
 
I have only just realized an elevator means a "lift" in British English. That makes more sense... I thought she meant an elevator, which is a kind of moving staircase. :(

cj x
 
The excuses for the Elevator Guy keep piling up. The dude is now a very shy, partially deaf, drunk, aspie-sufferer. A moment of silence, if you will, for the trials and tribulations of Elevator Guy.

:newlol Inorite?

I mean, clearly that's equally likely as the guy just being a run-of-the-mill troll/creep who made a faux pas... >_>
 
The excuses for the Elevator Guy keep piling up. The dude is now a very shy, partially deaf, drunk, aspie-sufferer. A moment of silence, if you will, for the trials and tribulations of Elevator Guy. A man so flawed that he can never be made responsible for his own behavior.

...snip...

What excuses? It is not making excuses to state that given the evidence we have that there are many different interpretations and explanations for the claimed event. Indeed we do not know if there was even any behaviour that needs to even be explained never mind excused. We apparently have an anecdote by someone who we know (if she had been drinking) perception and memory will be less than optimum and we know that even when not being effected by alcohol memory is at best an unreliable tool.

Now I am quite happy to take Rebecca's word for what has happened as a starting point for a discussion (I know her), but I'm not willing to take her interpretation and perception as being gospel.

(And the reason I brought the partially deaf example is that my other half is partially deaf and he struggles in noisy environments especially when many people are talking and I've seen how his behaviour can be misinterpreted by other people.)
 
Last edited:
I have only just realized an elevator means a "lift" in British English. That makes more sense... I thought she meant an elevator, which is a kind of moving staircase. :(

cj x

Those are escalators on this side of The Pond.

so to sum up, in America boxes elevate, stairs escalate.
 
I'm not asking for extraordinary evidence, Boo. I'm just saying that we have only one picture of the context.

At the risk of repeating myself...

If EG deliberately stalked RW after the talk, throughout the evening, and into the bar, never introducing himself or engaging in conversation, and then seeing RW heading for the elevator, decided it was time to attempt to woo her with a one-liner.... ULTRA-creepy. Borderline harrassment / restraining order sort of stuff.

If EG were, for example, DRBuzz0 (someone whom I think is mostly harmless if not a mild annoyance - and known to be socially 'awkward') who was engaged in the conversation at the bar but not participating, and waited to say something until RW was alone in the elevator (particularly because he had been brought to tears at an earlier TAM because of his awkwardness) then the context is a lot different.

RW is OF COURSE allowed to feel 'uncomfortable' by the approach no matter the context - it was her experience, and in her skin. But since we're talking about trying to 'fix people' I really would like to hear a corroborative story, or a second point of view.
 
Yes, I agree that the social rules of life are not as clearly laid down as the MA, but they are there and if somebody has such a problem following them that they cause significant problems, then the organizer of the event does have a responsibility (just as you do here on the forum) to enforce those rules and make sure that an atmosphere that allows the open and free exchange of ideas is maintained.


I don't think anyone is arguing against that. But what does "cause significant problems" mean? Where do you draw the line? Simply asking what to some may sound weird questions or being annoying in some harmless way?

As soon as the behavior does start harming or threatening others, then of course you can take action, but aside from that, we don't agree to certain behavioral or politeness guidelines when we register for TAM.
 
Because there's people who do not want sex and/or who feel offended or insulted by being asked by complete or relative strangers. The problem with people who have opinions like yours that I've met is that they either refuse to acknowledge the existence of the aforementioned individuals, or they capriciously presume that the feelings of those persons are irrational or based on faulty reasoning and therefore can or should be ignored in favor of the opinions of those who would like humanity to change so that asking for sex is as common and casual as asking for a conversation.

This is quick to deal with - I'm not like those other people you mention.
 
My comment was that we don't know who the mysterious Elevator Guy is. No one is talking about it. No one is stepping forward (understandably). The silence is deafening. No one who was talking with Rebecca in the bar noticed this guy? Rebecca herself won't chirp in and say 'The guy looked like 'x' or his name was 'y'

So - to refer back to cwalner's point... I would absolutely be willing to engage in a discussion with elevator guy to give him some Queer eye for the Awkward Straight Elevator Guy 'How not to be a Creep' tips. But I can't.

I can only speak for myself, but I think many on "my side" in this discussion would agree that it's really not about Elevator Guy. He did something that (in my, RW's, and others' opinion) was creepy and showed a lack of sensitivity to the concerns that (many) women live with. Rebecca said, "hey guys, a word to the wise, don't do that please," and that's really as far as it needed to go with respect to EG in my opinion. No need to identify him or berate him or send him to counseling, Queer Eye or otherwise.

What made this issue blow up, in my opinion, was a certain type of response to RW's video blog. I can get people saying, "wow, hadn't thought of that." I can get people saying, "eh, I think this is just some idiosyncratic paranoia of Rebecca's and not a common concern among women," though I think we at least know that a non-trivial number of women in this community do in fact share those concerns. But the number of people whose response was, essentially, "I don't care how it makes women feel, I'm trying to get laid!" is what transformed it from an issue of (being charitable) One Clueless Guy to an issue of a large segment of the community being dismissive of the very idea of taking women's concerns into consideration.
 
What excuses? It is not making excuses to state that given the evidence we have that there are many different interpretations and explanations for the claimed event. Indeed we do not know if there was even any behaviour that needs to even be explained never mind excused. We apparently have an anecdote by someone who we know (if she had been drinking) perception and memory will be less than optimum and we know that even when not being effected by alcohol memory is at best an unreliable tool.

Now I am quite happy to take Rebecca's word for what has happened as a starting point for a discussion (I know her), but I'm not willing to take her interpretation and perception as being gospel.

(And the reason I brought the partially deaf example is that my other half is partially deaf and he struggles in noisy environments especially when many people are talking and I've seen how his behaviour can be misinterpreted by other people.)

Waitaminute - You're willing to consider that EG had some good reason for his behavior but not that RW had good reason to be uncomfortable?

As a skeptic, you might want to lose the idea that people are psychic and that women in uncomfortable circumstances can instinctively tell whether or not someone is a deaf, drunk, shy, aspie sufferer who doesn't mean any harm when the only evidence that woman is given is an offer to go back to a hotel room.
 
...snip... But the number of people whose response was, essentially, "I don't care how it makes women feel, I'm trying to get laid!" is what transformed it from an issue of (being charitable) One Clueless Guy to an issue of a large segment of the community being dismissive of the very idea of taking women's concerns into consideration.

Is this on all these other sites that are discussing this because I've not seen that idea being expressed here? (I have enough trouble keeping up with this thread!)
 
I can only speak for myself, but I think many on "my side" in this discussion...<snip>

To somewhat derail this rather entertaining subtopic of coping with the DrBuzz0s of TAM...

That there is this perception of 'sides' in all of this is the crux of my issue.

The histrionics that have made this debate become so much larger than one unfortunate elevator encounter, is what has my knickers in a twist.

ETA: My I also add that I find it juicily ironic that I'm conversing about a matter of 'sexism' with someone whose avatar is Julian? Try to picture my avatar as Jim Lahey, please.
 
Last edited:
Is this on all these other sites that are discussing this because I've not seen that idea being expressed here? (I have enough trouble keeping up with this thread!)

Gee, isn't it annoying when people misrepresent what you say... my sympathies. ;)
 
Call it the snowball effect. First day, a woman runs into dear old buzzo. "Well" she thinks as she scurries away with alacrity "THAT wasn't very nice." She sees a person that she met earlier and tells them what happened. "Oh, that's just Buzzo, he does it to everyone." And she doesn't want to make a big deal because, seriously TAM is awesome and she's having a really good time but maybe somebody could have warned her?

Between lectures she grabs a book to read back in her room. And lo! The author is there to sign it. Neat! of course Vegas is like 2000 degrees so she's in a T-shirt that isn't quite enough coverage for the super air-conditioned corridor. And the author has noticed this but that's OK because it's TAM and everything is awesome and who knew that people could sign books while staring at your tits instead of the page? Fascinating.

And when she mentions it to the people from her skeptical group, they just laugh. Yep that's how it is and hey, free lunch time! (Not really free it was included with her ticket which cost hundreds of dollars that she has, but not really but it's worth it 'cause it's TAM!)

At lunch, some guy she's never talked to snakes into the seat next to her. He's a little more smooth than BuzzO but a bit perfunctory. Things get around to a gentle no, he gets up and leaves with barely a word. ooookay. That was odd.

And on and on, until by the end of it she's exhausted, walking around with her hands crossed over her chest like she's back in high school (damn air conditioning) and disappointed in a weird undefined way. Like everyone else, she's sad because it's over but she's also a little relieved. The next time TAM rolls around, she starts to get excited but it's kind of expensive and she didn't really have that great a time and you know what, maybe skip it.

I just want to say that I have found your posts in this thread and in the What Feminists Want thread very useful. You clarify the issues with specific and reasonable examples. But I am a bit puzzled by this post. Are you saying that guys don't stare at your tits otherwise? That by avoiding TAM you won't experience sexist remarks and unwanted advances? Is it much worse at TAM? Or did you expect it to be absent?

Linda
 
Waitaminute - You're willing to consider that EG had some good reason for his behavior but not that RW had good reason to be uncomfortable?

Not at all. Again I am not saying what his reasons actually were merely putting forward alternates to the one that Rebecca put forward that still match what she said had occurred to illustrate that we cannot make firm conclusions based on her anecdote about someone's behaviour.

As a skeptic, you might want to lose the idea that people are psychic and that women in uncomfortable circumstances can instinctively tell whether or not someone is a deaf, drunk, shy, aspie sufferer who doesn't mean any harm when the only evidence that woman is given is an offer to go back to a hotel room.

:confused: You have totally lost me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom