So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, you do have the tools. You know what someone looks like when they are really uncomfortable, right? Step in. or if the person you are talking to looks uncomfortable, step back. Or if you wouldn't want someone filming that moment because it might make you look bad, don't do it.

This isn't just about not hitting on people at inopportune times. It could also apply to say, trapping someone to go over every single thought you have ever had about the anti-vax crowd, even though your listener is already informed.

Don't get me wrong, Boo - if I was part of a conversation where I felt that someone was being made to feel uncomfortable by someone else's approaches, I would definitely say/do something. I have done so in the past (not at a TAM). I think that its pretty rare that someone about to make a pass, particularly an awkward one, will do so in the presence of others - but if I see it, I will intervene.

My comment was that we don't know who the mysterious Elevator Guy is. No one is talking about it. No one is stepping forward (understandably). The silence is deafening. No one who was talking with Rebecca in the bar noticed this guy? Rebecca herself won't chirp in and say 'The guy looked like 'x' or his name was 'y'

So - to refer back to cwalner's point... I would absolutely be willing to engage in a discussion with elevator guy to give him some Queer eye for the Awkward Straight Elevator Guy 'How not to be a Creep' tips. But I can't.
 
Don't get me wrong, Boo - if I was part of a conversation where I felt that someone was being made to feel uncomfortable by someone else's approaches, I would definitely say/do something. I have done so in the past (not at a TAM). I think that its pretty rare that someone about to make a pass, particularly an awkward one, will do so in the presence of others - but if I see it, I will intervene.

My comment was that we don't know who the mysterious Elevator Guy is. No one is talking about it. No one is stepping forward (understandably). The silence is deafening. No one who was talking with Rebecca in the bar noticed this guy? Rebecca herself won't chirp in and say 'The guy looked like 'x' or his name was 'y'

So - to refer back to cwalner's point... I would absolutely be willing to engage in a discussion with elevator guy to give him some Queer eye for the Awkward Straight Elevator Guy 'How not to be a Creep' tips. But I can't.

So you think elevator guy is a complete aberration in the skeptical community and that this problem can be solved by giving him, specifically, him, a stern talking to?
 
My comment was that we don't know who the mysterious Elevator Guy is. No one is talking about it. No one is stepping forward (understandably). The silence is deafening. No one who was talking with Rebecca in the bar noticed this guy? Rebecca herself won't chirp in and say 'The guy looked like 'x' or his name was 'y'

So - to refer back to cwalner's point... I would absolutely be willing to engage in a discussion with elevator guy to give him some Queer eye for the Awkward Straight Elevator Guy 'How not to be a Creep' tips. But I can't.

Yes, but many people here know who DrBuzzo is (I don't) and apparently he causes similar problems. The point being, that if somebody is as infamous as apparently DrBuzzo is and nobody has done anything to reign him in, then the discomfort that he causes is everybody's fault, not just his.
 
Yes, but many people here know who DrBuzzo is (I don't) and apparently he causes similar problems. The point being, that if somebody is as infamous as apparently DrBuzzo is and nobody has done anything to reign him in, then the discomfort that he causes is everybody's fault, not just his.


I share most posters' displeasure and frustration that the skeptical community and specifically the group of TAM attendees includes someone like DrBuzzo (whom I also don't know), but there are 1500 people attending TAM. Wouldn't a certain number of creeps be simply unavoidable in any gathering of 1500 people, skeptical or not? Everyone else just needs to try to deal with them as best as possible.
 
Who the hell is this DrBuzz0 commenter guy and why are we giving him any attention? :confused: I feel like I'm missing out on something here.

I'd even say you are showing hints of it in your post above in that you seem to be saying that asking someone in a social setting for sex is wrong, because it "sexualises" someone.
Wot? That's not remotely what I said.

I think that asking someone for sex, who just earlier had specifically talked about how she didn't want to be sexualized in such events, shows a sign of disrespect.

How do you go from that, to me saying "asking for sex in a social setting is always wrong"? Come on, Darat.

I've learnt that sex is still a nasty dirty thing that is not appropriate to be spoken about in polite society. Instead I've learnt that if you feel sexual attraction towards someone and want to shag them you should lie about your intentions for some undefined period of time before it becomes the appropriate time to stop lying. ETA: Oh and if you want to have a coffee and a chat with someone in the privacy of your room that means you want to shag them.
Wow, that's a lot of straw right there... I give up. You're right. People here have said sex is a nasty dirty thing and no one should hit on anyone, ever. That's exactly it. :rolleyes:

I believe I'm trying to say that "being asked back to his room for coffee" might be less creepy or disturbing had it happened in the pub/bar. The creepiness factor was multiplied by the elevator. Never mind the fact that she'd just given a talk in which she essentially said, "this behavior can be objectifying."
Seriously. Why does everyone overlook this part? It seems to be the most significant bit, really, but it's like everyone glosses over it.

I think I'm going to get some coffee now...
 
Yes, but many people here know who DrBuzzo is (I don't) and apparently he causes similar problems. The point being, that if somebody is as infamous as apparently DrBuzzo is and nobody has done anything to reign him in, then the discomfort that he causes is everybody's fault, not just his.

Should he be banned from conventions? That's quite a serious question and if he is to be banned how is the criteria set, whose mores and ideas of appropriate social behaviour is to be used. Will this then become a test applied to all such males? Plus of course as far as I know DrBuzzo has not committed any type of crime.
 
So you think elevator guy is a complete aberration in the skeptical community and that this problem can be solved by giving him, specifically, him, a stern talking to?

Well I never said that I thought he was a complete aberration, did I? I believe I intimated in several earlier posts that actually I thought the 'quirk quotient' of TAM attendees was pretty high.

Until I know more about the specific 'elevator guy' in question, I don't have sufficient evidence to suggest he was deliberately being creepy - as we have already discussed a whole lot. I am certainly willing to give him the benefit of the doubt based on what I know of the conversation as it has been reported, that perhaps he is socially awkward. If I knew who it was, and I could engage in the conversation in a non-threatening way (ie - over a beer) then I absolutely would have no qualms saying 'You know, just as an aside, its a pretty dumb idea to approach someone with a direct line. And its even dumber to do this in an elevator. Some ideas that might work in future are...'

Of course, then I would probably get chastized for being arrogant / creepy / weird, but hey - I would have that conversation, in the right context.
 
I agree with Alison's post, for the record. I think Rebecca was perfectly fine in pointing out the issue, but the ********* that followed was completely over-the-top. Dawkins's post was a bit rude and probably missed the point, but the backlash against was blown out of proportion. That follow-up post by Rebecca calling for his boycott and raving against the untr00 feminists is just pure silliness.

Edited, breach of rule 10. Please do not curse in your posts or mask such words in an attempt to by-pass the auto-censor.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Locknar
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I share most posters' displeasure and frustration that the skeptical community and specifically the group of TAM attendees includes someone like DrBuzzo (whom I also don't know), but there are 1500 people attending TAM. Wouldn't a certain number of creeps be simply unavoidable in any gathering of 1500 people, skeptical or not? Everyone else just needs to try to deal with them as best as possible.

Ding, ding, ding.
 
Yes, but many people here know who DrBuzzo is (I don't) and apparently he causes similar problems. The point being, that if somebody is as infamous as apparently DrBuzzo is and nobody has done anything to reign him in, then the discomfort that he causes is everybody's fault, not just his.

I wouldn't say nobody has done *anything*: last year was my first TAM and I was warned about him in advance (by men) and never had any contact with him. As mentioned, I don't think the guy could be *banned* for being creepy, but the fact that his behavior has been noticed and not condoned by many attendees is a positive sign IMO.
 
Yes, but many people here know who DrBuzzo is (I don't) and apparently he causes similar problems. The point being, that if somebody is as infamous as apparently DrBuzzo is and nobody has done anything to reign him in, then the discomfort that he causes is everybody's fault, not just his.

What can we do? Short of the JREF banning people who creep others out there is nothing that you can do for the real outliers.
There comes a level of social awkwardness and unawareness where a direct statement that you’re creeping someone out will be met with a denial that people feel creeped out and no change in behaviour.

Oh and buzzo is infamous because he used to post here, a lot, and regularly attends TAM, and creeps people out. He may not be the creepest person you’d see in a crowd of 1500.
 
Yes, but many people here know who DrBuzzo is (I don't) and apparently he causes similar problems. The point being, that if somebody is as infamous as apparently DrBuzzo is and nobody has done anything to reign him in, then the discomfort that he causes is everybody's fault, not just his.

DrBuzz0 is an eccentric and odd (former) forum poster. He exhibits to me (not an expert) signs of being somewhere on the Aspy/Autistic spectrum.

I have never observed him being 'inappropriate' around women (or men). I have observed him asking very strange questions at TAM, and hogging the microphone - to the point where people were audibly groaning when he stood up. He has certain mannerisms and a way of speaking that are definitely odd. He is physically a bit large - I don't find him threatening, but as Boo implied, he could be seen as intimidating I suppose because of his size.

I really have no idea if anyone has ever tried to be friendly with him, or given him any constructive feedback. If he is on that aspy/autistic spectrum, then maybe the feedback would be meaningless anyways.

To me - he's just part of the experience of going to a conference of a bunch of people - you're going to meet lots of different folks. However - I am a guy, and I don't think Buzz0 is into guys. So if there is anything creepy from a sexual perspective going on there, I know nothing.
 
...snip....

Wot? That's not remotely what I said.

I think that asking someone for sex, who just earlier had specifically talked about how she didn't want to be sexualized in such events, shows a sign of disrespect.

How do you go from that, to me saying "asking for sex in a social setting is always wrong"? Come on, Darat.

Perhaps because I did not say what you paraphrase me as saying above e.g. "always"? Plus of course I said it has a hint of the Mr & Mrs Manners instructive posts, if you say there was not then of course I'll take your word on that and I apologise if it caused you offence.

...snip....

Wow, that's a lot of straw right there... I give up. You're right. People here have said sex is a nasty dirty thing and no one should hit on anyone, ever. That's exactly it. :rolleyes:

I have been told that if I go to a convention and one of my goals is to get laid then I have serious problems. But there is no problem if I lie to someone about being sexually attracted to them or engage in other wholesome approved social activities. Sorry if you don't like what I conclude from that. (Which of course was presented as hyperbole to make a point... )

...snip....
Seriously. Why does everyone overlook this part? It seems to be the most significant bit, really, but it's like everyone glosses over it.

I think I'm going to get some coffee now...

Overlook what? I have seen no evidence that this person had heard whatever it is he was meant to have heard. Perhaps Rebecca's talk was not very good and he didn't get her message, perhaps he thought asking someone for a coffee and a chat meant what the words say and not code for "I see you as a piece of meat lets shag", perhaps he was a partially deaf person and couldn't join in the noisy discussion in the pub so waited until he was in an environment in which he could communicate with her. There are many, many other interpretations than the one that Rebecca has supplied even if the events unfolded as she claims they did. (Never mind that people have not yet explained what is intrinsicly wrong with just wanting sex with someone.)

What I see is a load of people being very quick to uncritically accept an anecdote as being 100% accurate and being very prescriptive in regards to social interactions that are "sexualised".
 
What can we do? Short of the JREF banning people who creep others out there is nothing that you can do for the real outliers.
There comes a level of social awkwardness and unawareness where a direct statement that you’re creeping someone out will be met with a denial that people feel creeped out and no change in behaviour.

Oh and buzzo is infamous because he used to post here, a lot, and regularly attends TAM, and creeps people out. He may not be the creepest person you’d see in a crowd of 1500.

Just how creepy is Dr. Buzz0? In other circles I've seen really creepy people handled by getting chewed out -- and in public, if the offender is being unbelievably creepy in public. Perhaps that would help get through to Buzz0 and help set the tone of what's acceptable at the conference? :confused:
 
Should he be banned from conventions? That's quite a serious question and if he is to be banned how is the criteria set, whose mores and ideas of appropriate social behaviour is to be used. Will this then become a test applied to all such males? Plus of course as far as I know DrBuzzo has not committed any type of crime.

No, but if his behavior is so obviously beyond social norms that it is making people around him uncomfortable, has anybody even tried to bring this matter to his attention and let him know that it is harmful.

which, I would like to point out is exactly what Rebecca did in her original video that set this whole mess off. She took the time to explain that such behavior was inappropriate and why it was harmful. She did so in the best way she had available after the fact to actually get the message to who needed it most (in her case EG).

And now the discussion brings up an example of another person, who apparently has been behaving similarly for years at TAM, yet nobody seems willing to tell the guy that it is a problem, they just laugh and say 'Oh, that's just DrBuzzo, no big deal'.

Well, the attention that this topic has gotten due to Rebecca addressing the issue with EG indicates that it is a big deal, and maybe this should have been addressed previously.

And Darat, you, of all people should know the value and need of policing inappropriate behavior in a social setting. That is part of your job here on the forum. You do warn, infract and eventually ban people, because their behavior is disruptive and damages the forum's ability to function as a social network for the free exchange of ideas.

If somebody cannot behave themselves at a skeptical conference and that behavior causes potential attendees not to attend, then by all means, the JREF* can and should ban them from the conference. They should of course take less extreme measures to attempt to correct the behavior first and only use banning if nothing else works. It is not something that should be done lightly, but it should remain an option for the JREF* at their own conference.

*ETA: specified JREF because thinking of TAM. substitute appropriate organizer for any other conferences.
 
Last edited:
Bloody hell this is getting ridiculous, singling out someone who some people find creepy and weird - why does he have to change, why can't people deal with him as he is, if you don't like him because you find him creepy then don't interact with him! If he was actually dangerous fair enough but for goodness sake live and let live!

I've been treated badly in my life enough times because according to others I am the weird one, the odd one, the pervert, the "can't be in a lift with him" (because I am gay) to know how that can go way beyond leaving someone feeling uncomfortable.

Being different, not being the same, not conforming to how other people want you to behave does not make someone the "one rotten apple that spoils the whole barrel".
 
DrBuzz0 is an eccentric and odd (former) forum poster. He exhibits to me (not an expert) signs of being somewhere on the Aspy/Autistic spectrum.

I have never observed him being 'inappropriate' around women (or men). I have observed him asking very strange questions at TAM, and hogging the microphone - to the point where people were audibly groaning when he stood up. He has certain mannerisms and a way of speaking that are definitely odd. He is physically a bit large - I don't find him threatening, but as Boo implied, he could be seen as intimidating I suppose because of his size.

I really have no idea if anyone has ever tried to be friendly with him, or given him any constructive feedback. If he is on that aspy/autistic spectrum, then maybe the feedback would be meaningless anyways.

To me - he's just part of the experience of going to a conference of a bunch of people - you're going to meet lots of different folks. However - I am a guy, and I don't think Buzz0 is into guys. So if there is anything creepy from a sexual perspective going on there, I know nothing.

Oh, people have tried to be helpful...

I recall one memorable discussion involving him, Hal, and GeekGoddess. It started out with him being unresponsive and surly, and ended up with him in tears (not just a little bit, but full-on uncontrollable sobbing) when the conversation went to companionship, and it brought back memories of a dog of his that died accidentally a few years before.

I know Toby and Teek also tried with him. I just don't know if he listens.

He is a character, but even still, I think there have been people at TAM who behaved in more offensive manners to female attendees. Dr. Adequate comes to mind...

So is that a trend, people who use "Dr." in their screen names, but aren't in real life, tend to be creepy?
 
Last edited:
Perhaps because I did not say what you paraphrase me as saying above e.g. "always"? Plus of course I said it has a hint of the Mr & Mrs Manners instructive posts, if you say there was not then of course I'll take your word on that and I apologise if it caused you offence.



I have been told that if I go to a convention and one of my goals is to get laid then I have serious problems. But there is no problem if I lie to someone about being sexually attracted to them or engage in other wholesome approved social activities. Sorry if you don't like what I conclude from that. (Which of course was presented as hyperbole to make a point... )



Overlook what? I have seen no evidence that this person had heard whatever it is he was meant to have heard. Perhaps Rebecca's talk was not very good and he didn't get her message, perhaps he thought asking someone for a coffee and a chat meant what the words say and not code for "I see you as a piece of meat lets shag", perhaps he was a partially deaf person and couldn't join in the noisy discussion in the pub so waited until he was in an environment in which he could communicate with her. There are many, many other interpretations than the one that Rebecca has supplied even if the events unfolded as she claims they did. (Never mind that people have not yet explained what is intrinsicly wrong with just wanting sex with someone.)

What I see is a load of people being very quick to uncritically accept an anecdote as being 100% accurate and being very prescriptive in regards to social interactions that are "sexualised".

The excuses for the Elevator Guy keep piling up. The dude is now a very shy, partially deaf, drunk, aspie-sufferer. A moment of silence, if you will, for the trials and tribulations of Elevator Guy. A man so flawed that he can never be made responsible for his own behavior.

Let us all join hands for our bumbling friend in Dublin. *ahem* Elevator guy, we don't know you. We don't know why you decided to board that fateful elevator, or why you blurted out what you did. All we know is that you will never be asked to refrain from such situations again because if you aren't free to follow women into elevators at 4 AM, (especially when they have been talking about rape threats all day because sexy, right?) then none of us are free. And without the freedom to make women a bit uncomfortable, skeptics will never get a date because we too, are just that clueless. And may Rebecca Watson rot in hell (metaphorically, of course. We're far, far too civilized to believe in the real thing) for daring to suggest that a little discomfort is not a woman's place."
 
Bloody hell this is getting ridiculous, singling out someone who some people find creepy and weird - why does he have to change, why can't people deal with him as he is, if you don't like him because you find him creepy then don't interact with him! If he was actually dangerous fair enough but for goodness sake live and let live!

I've been treated badly in my life enough times because according to others I am the weird one, the odd one, the pervert, the "can't be in a lift with him" (because I am gay) to know how that can go way beyond leaving someone feeling uncomfortable.

Being different, not being the same, not conforming to how other people want you to behave does not make someone the "one rotten apple that spoils the whole barrel".

No, because on the internet everyone has the sacred right not to be offended by anything, and to loudly vilify harmless behavior that falls one hair's breadth outside of the norm.

Part of the inherent joy in meeting many different people from all walks of life is making them conform to your expectations through social pressure, Darat!
 
The excuses for the Elevator Guy keep piling up. The dude is now a very shy, partially deaf, drunk, aspie-sufferer. A moment of silence, if you will, for the trials and tribulations of Elevator Guy. A man so flawed that he can never be made responsible for his own behavior.

Let us all join hands for our bumbling friend in Dublin. *ahem* Elevator guy, we don't know you. We don't know why you decided to board that fateful elevator, or why you blurted out what you did. All we know is that you will never be asked to refrain from such situations again because if you aren't free to follow women into elevators at 4 AM, (especially when they have been talking about rape threats all day because sexy, right?) then none of us are free. And without the freedom to make women a bit uncomfortable, skeptics will never get a date because we too, are just that clueless. And may Rebecca Watson rot in hell (metaphorically, of course. We're far, far too civilized to believe in the real thing) for daring to suggest that a little discomfort is not a woman's place."

I think you're rather leaping to conclusions here, Bookitty.

The ONLY report we have to follow in all this, is Rebecca's video. If Rebecca's claim were that monkeys flew out of her butt, then we would be well within our rights to suggest that a short YouTube clip is not necessarily compelling evidence of same.

There are a myriad of speculations both sympathetic to EG and even more damning to EG, that we're probably never going to be able to dispel / investigate because no one seems to remember anything or be willing to talk about it.

That's all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom