So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
So you don't like the guy for even mentioning a bit of truth?

http://www.bing.com/search?q=false+rape+claims+by+women&form=MOZSBR&pc=MOZI

Rape is one of the most evil things in the world, don't get me wrong. But it has been used by both sexes to wage war on each other and its a problem that needs attention and rational discourse.
Hahahah.... Hahahaha.... Let me first ask you a few questions.
A) Why did you assume I was talking about women?
B) Why did you assume that Dawkins or I were saying that they were lying?
I would like to say I did this on purpose to bait people with a sexist bent but I didn't.
 
Last edited:
I find your need to defend the actions of Rebecca very telling. You are blinded to the fact that Rebecca put Stef in a much worse situation than Rebecca was in with EG. She actually SOUGHT to go after another person where that person had no real way to correct the situation then and there.

Rebecca acted like a jerk. Don't defend it.

Saying "blinded to the fact that" on an issue of opinion is also telling.

That Stef was in a worse position is probably true (since we know nothing happened in the elevator and EG probably had no evil intentions), but I doubt Stef ever feared for her safety when Rebecca was criticizing her comments.

And I think you're conflating an attack on Stef's comments with an attack on Stef herself.

If you want to be offended by Rebecca, by all means do so. If you want to ignore Rebecca's main point in your haste to defend some poor helpless girl (hmmm...), go for it. But the implication that your interpretation of events is the only possible or reasonable one is sort of at odds with what I thought skepticism was about.
 
Which appears from the advice in this thread means to lie about it.

This has set me on a train of thought that might have clarified a few issues for me.

Lets say hypotheically speaking that I see someone I'd like to sleep with. Choice number 1: I come straight out with it "hey you i'd like to sleep with you"
Choice number 2: I try to get to know them first. Is this making a lie of omission by not mentioning that I want to sleep with them.

Not necessarily. At that stage for someone like me, I don't actually know that I really do want to sleep with them. For me the earlier statement "I see someone I'd like to sleep with" carries some implied conditionals. Tense is important. It's not "someone I want to sleep with" (present tense) it's "someone I'd like to sleep with" (conditional tense).

If I've already made up my mind that I do want to sleep with them, that's present tense and thats objectification. If the getting to know you part is something to be negotiated in a manner calculated to maximise the probability of sucess. Thats lying and the domain of the pickup artist. You get consent but it's not informed consent becaue you've lied. Creepy huh? This doesn't matter to you because the object is sex. What matters is what you've seen and that alone. If the getting to know you part is to be skipped entirely then were approaching consent issues and getting a tad rapey. Though with consent there's little wrong with nameless no strings attached sex merely for the sake of sex. Though it often means that you've objectified a few people on the way there. There are however clubs, locations and internet sites where people who have less objection to objectification can be found.

The conditional tense is where I imagine most people would be. Recieved wisdom is that this approach leads to a better quality of pairings. Or am I projecting. At this stage there's no lie of omission is failing to say you want to have sex with them because that hasn't yet been established. A number of further conditions have yet to be met. It's I'd want to sleep with you if...
1) I was available (Which as it happens is not the case)
2) Your personality matches up to your physical attractiveness
3) You're available
4) You also find me physically and personally attractive.
5) You're willing
(in no particular order)

Differing people will have diferent conditions and prioritise more of less heavily between then. Once again I don't know if I'm projecting but I imagine the above is relatively common.

If so it seems hardly worth laying this out to each and every person who merely looks like they measure up to your physical requirements. People tend to know when they're physically attractive. It's partly subjective but theres a good deal of agreement out there.

I dunno, have I "got it" yet?

It's long past time for it to make a difference to my behaviour, but I have three young sons to advise when the time comes.
 
Agreed, awesome post by Ms. Smith.
(link included again, just for clarity)

http://skeptoid.com/blog/2011/07/06/take-back-the-elevator/


Bravo.

I do agree that it's a human issue because both sexes are capable of making the same social infraction. I took a few issues with her post, though.

Which is why I think the rape issue was so gladly pounced upon as an excuse for blowing this so far out of proportion that it’s gone beyond caricature. Again – the original issue; the original problem was not rape. It was discomfort. It was lack of tact. Please, keep saying that to yourself.

I think the term "potential sexual assault" was an unfortunate term used by Phil Plait. Maybe I am an apologist, maybe I am trying to read too far into what he said, to justify his use of the term, but to be honest, I wish he didn't use it. The only way I can understand his application is to assume he meant; in Rebecca's mind. Nobody knows the man's intentions in inviting her back to his room, but for anyone outside the elevator, insinuating that his intentions actually go beyond coffee and conversation, is out of line.

With that said, trying to view this threw RW's perspective, it was a situation that turned out not to be an issue of assault, which has nothing to do with the guys actual intentions. If there was a sense of "creepy" in the elevator, it's safe to assume that she experienced a (even if it was very mild) sense of relief, out of the elevator. That was an odd proposal but I am glad that I didn't turn into one of those news stories. She perceived the request to be odd and felt vulnerable. That's all she experienced and that's all she talked about. The responses to that short blurb were extremely hyperbolic on all sides.

However, then she said that the last time she saw Dawkins, she was on a panel speaking about how she had received rape threats in the past. She then posted a screencap of one of the rape threats.

I took it that she was pointing out why she has reason to be a little unnerved by situations where she feels vulnerable. He sat next to her while she talked about emails telling her that she needs to get raped, perhaps she felt he, after hearing what she said earlier that same night, could be a little bit more sympathetic as to why she would feel so vulnerable. She did not know who this guy was, at all. Would it be unreasonable for her to have a fleeting thought that this guy could be trying to sound harmless, while he was actually one of the people attempting to carry out a threat?

I think what is setting a lot of people off is the utter dismissal of what it feels like to be a potential victim. I only wish it wasn't completely hijacked as a feminine issue because that is a human issue. I am not talking about every possible contact between a stronger and a weaker individual, but specific situations where something catches your attention (in this case it was a seemly bizaare proposal from a stranger), and you wonder if you didn't just find yourself in a really bad situation.
 
I assume this somewhat vague description is your anecdote supporting Rebecca's assertion. Still not convincing. My anecdotes counter yours and then some. Come to Seattle. Your complaints have never been voiced at our skeptics' and atheists' groups and I am more than enough involved in both groups to be able to make that assertion.

It appears to me to be manufactured persecution.

I am more than willing to keep an open mind should more substantial evidence be forthcoming.

Did you think I expected anything else from you?
 
I think what is setting a lot of people off is the utter dismissal of what it feels like to be a potential victim. I only wish it wasn't completely hijacked as a feminine issue because that is a human issue.

From my perspective, that's it. I mean your second sentence.

So, she felt uncomfortable in an elevator after a night of drinking. Fine. I felt the same way when a massively breasted woman with black teeth accosted me just last night.

However, that does not warrant turning it into some sort of massive story about Evil Male Beasts and Innocent Women, the Evil Patriarchy and What All Women Experience From All Those Beastly Atheist Anti-Feminist Men.

To be fair, I don't think that Rebecca Watson did very much to promulgate this idea, though she did do some of it. Still, the story has grown legs.

Personally, I think it would probably be better if people dealt with these things on their own without immediately playing the F-card. However, that's what people do, and it ticks people off, and often there is a good reason for them to get ticked off.
 
Do I headdesk, do I laugh? Allow me to share the joke with those few who will be unfortunate enough to get it.

Let us take the oft repeated statement of Elevatorgate:
"Hitting on a woman does not mean you’re a rapist, or even imply it."

Sums it up, right? Ok, now read it in the voice of DrBuzzo with all the arrogant certainty and complete social tone-deafness that he brings. Actually read all the "This is nothing, it's social, it happens everyday." comments in the voice of Drbuzzo.

A little different in tone now, amiright?
 
Last edited:
Do I headdesk, do I laugh? Allow me to share the joke with those few who will be unfortunate enough to get it.

Let us take the oft repeated statement of Elevatorgate:
"Hitting on a woman does not mean you’re a rapist, or even imply it."

Sums it up, right? Ok, now read it in the voice of DrBuzzo with all the arrogant certainty and complete social tone-deafness that he brings. Actually read all the "This is nothing, it social, it happens everyday." comments in the voice of Drbuzzo.

A little different in tone now, amiright?

Well, yes and no. My recollections of DrB again wasn't that he was a potential rape threat, just that he was 'weird'. Very.

Now - maybe there is a different connotation from women - I don't know.

I guess boo - try your fun scenario picturing Tobias (Sorry T. if you're lurking - I'm not picking on you, dude) saying those things. Or me.

If your point is that the context / tone of saying certain things can easily colour interpretation, then you're spot on.
 
Do I headdesk, do I laugh? Allow me to share the joke with those few who will be unfortunate enough to get it.

Let us take the oft repeated statement of Elevatorgate:
"Hitting on a woman does not mean you’re a rapist, or even imply it."

Sums it up, right? Ok, now read it in the voice of DrBuzzo with all the arrogant certainty and complete social tone-deafness that he brings. Actually read all the "This is nothing, it's social, it happens everyday." comments in the voice of Drbuzzo.

A little different in tone now, amiright?

Is DrBuzz0 a barometer we measure everyone against? That's not very rational. If you know Dr. B you wouldn't get in an elevator with him now would you? its not really a comparable situation.

Is skepticism now a measure of a utopian world view? Can i not appreciate Dawkins, Krauss et all because of what they do even though they're not perfect?

Can we not give humanity the benefit of the doubt anymore?
 
Last edited:
Is DrBuzz0 a barometer we measure everyone against? That's not very rational.

Is skepticism now a measure of a utopian world view? Can i not appreciate Dawkins, Krauss et all because of what they do even though they're not perfect?

Can we not give humanity the benefit of the doubt anymore?

Did you miss the phrase "allow me to share the joke."
 
Well, yes and no. My recollections of DrB again wasn't that he was a potential rape threat, just that he was 'weird'. Very.

Now - maybe there is a different connotation from women - I don't know.

I guess boo - try your fun scenario picturing Tobias (Sorry T. if you're lurking - I'm not picking on you, dude) saying those things. Or me.

If your point is that the context / tone of saying certain things can easily colour interpretation, then you're spot on.

Seriously, I just find it funny.

I'm almost 5' 10" and while I may be on the scrawny side, I'm a book dealer and I box for fun. I have decent upper body strength for a woman. I am no shirking violet. Drbuzzo is taller than me and outweighs me by maybe 75 pounds. Who would win in an elevator fight?

Worse, he'd lecture me the entire time like a someone trying to make an internet point but in real life. I can all too easily picture him working "Hitting on you is not rape." into his TAM vocabulary.
 
Seriously, I just find it funny.

I'm almost 5' 10" and while I may be on the scrawny side, I'm a book dealer and I box for fun. I have decent upper body strength for a woman. I am no shirking violet. Drbuzzo is taller than me and outweighs me by maybe 75 pounds. Who would win in an elevator fight?

Worse, he'd lecture me the entire time like a someone trying to make an internet point but in real life. I can all too easily picture him working "Hitting on you is not rape." into his TAM vocabulary.

I'm pretty sure you could take him, Boo. He is physically big, but he looks pretty squooshy & untoned to me. You'd float like a butterfly & sting like a bee all over his khaki-clad behind.

I'm not sure I see the humour, but I can definitely picture him walking up to a woman (inside the 'personal space' zone) and intoning 'You know, hitting on you is not rape.' as his opener, yes. I guess I find it more sad than funny.
 
How many people like him does it take to put women off going to skeptical conventions?

Call it the snowball effect. First day, a woman runs into dear old buzzo. "Well" she thinks as she scurries away with alacrity "THAT wasn't very nice." She sees a person that she met earlier and tells them what happened. "Oh, that's just Buzzo, he does it to everyone." And she doesn't want to make a big deal because, seriously TAM is awesome and she's having a really good time but maybe somebody could have warned her?

Between lectures she grabs a book to read back in her room. And lo! The author is there to sign it. Neat! of course Vegas is like 2000 degrees so she's in a T-shirt that isn't quite enough coverage for the super air-conditioned corridor. And the author has noticed this but that's OK because it's TAM and everything is awesome and who knew that people could sign books while staring at your tits instead of the page? Fascinating.

And when she mentions it to the people from her skeptical group, they just laugh. Yep that's how it is and hey, free lunch time! (Not really free it was included with her ticket which cost hundreds of dollars that she has, but not really but it's worth it 'cause it's TAM!)

At lunch, some guy she's never talked to snakes into the seat next to her. He's a little more smooth than BuzzO but a bit perfunctory. Things get around to a gentle no, he gets up and leaves with barely a word. ooookay. That was odd.

And on and on, until by the end of it she's exhausted, walking around with her hands crossed over her chest like she's back in high school (damn air conditioning) and disappointed in a weird undefined way. Like everyone else, she's sad because it's over but she's also a little relieved. The next time TAM rolls around, she starts to get excited but it's kind of expensive and she didn't really have that great a time and you know what, maybe skip it.
 
Last edited:
Call it the snowball effect. First day, a woman runs into dear old buzzo. "Well" she thinks as she scurries away with alacrity "THAT wasn't very nice." She sees a person that she met earlier and tells them what happened. "Oh, that's just Buzzo, he does it to everyone." And she doesn't want to make a big deal because, seriously TAM is awesome and she's having a really good time but maybe somebody could have warned her?

Between lectures she grabs a book to read back in her room. And lo! The author is there to sign it. Neat! of course Vegas is like 2000 degrees so she's in a T-shirt that isn't quite enough coverage for the super air-conditioned corridor. And the author has noticed this but that's OK because it's TAM and everything is awesome and who knew that people could sign books while staring at your tits instead of the page? Fascinating.

And when she mentions it to the people from her skeptical group, they just laugh. Yep that's how it is and hey, free lunch time! (Not really free it was included with her ticket which cost hundreds of dollars that she has, but not really but it's worth it 'cause it's TAM!)

At lunch, some guy she's never talked to snakes into the seat next to her. He's a little more smooth than BuzzO but a bit perfunctory. Things get around to a gentle no, he gets up and leaves with barely a word. ooookay. That was odd.

And on and on, until by the end of it she's exhausted, walking around with her hands crossed over her chest like she's back in high school (damn air conditioning) and disappointing in a weird undefined way. Like everyone else, she's sad because it's over but she's also a little relieved. The next time TAM rolls around, she starts to get excited but it's kind of expensive and she didn't really have that great a time and you know what, maybe skip it.

Boo - let me fix this for you.

Hang out with gay wingmen.
 
How many people like him does it take to put women off going to skeptical conventions?

Good point. Very few can have a large impact if the larger group does not reign them in.

How often to skeptics (especially in the politics fora) bemoan that rational moderates do not reign in fringe extremists.

We see it w/ respect to Muslims and Islamists
We see it w/ respect to Republicans and Tea Partiers
We see it w/ respect to Christians and Bible Thumpers

I highlighted the last because that is most germane to the entire Skeptical movement. What point is skepticism if we cannot apply it to ourselves.

I guess this can be correlary to the Plait Maxim which would best phrased as Don't let others be Dicks in our name.
 
Good point. Very few can have a large impact if the larger group does not reign them in.

How often to skeptics (especially in the politics fora) bemoan that rational moderates do not reign in fringe extremists.

We see it w/ respect to Muslims and Islamists
We see it w/ respect to Republicans and Tea Partiers
We see it w/ respect to Christians and Bible Thumpers

I highlighted the last because that is most germane to the entire Skeptical movement. What point is skepticism if we cannot apply it to ourselves.

I guess this can be correlary to the Plait Maxim which would best phrased as Don't let others be Dicks in our name.

Fair point - except we don't have the tools in all of this to identify who the guy is who needs to be reigned in.

The only dick(s) we can attempt to corral in all this from my perspective, are those who have turned it into character assassination and a media circus.
 
Boo - let me fix this for you.

Hang out with gay wingmen.

This experience is not mine alone. Unlike many people at TAM, I listen. Also, gays make up 10% of the population and women roughly 50%. Minus all the gays who would rather not play chaperone (because you know, they have their own lives, wants, needs, etc.) and the pool is too small to protect those women who are being gently hassled.

The only reason I am still in this damn conversation is because I know, for a fact, that a lot of the people reading this multi-site mess are kind, considerate and absolutely lovely. There will be elevator jokes this year. There will also be a few people (male & female) who will be a little more watchful and who will step in when things have gone weird. Ditto meetings, meet-ups and drinking skeptically situations.

ETA: And yes, I still hope that some people will get the message to not be that guy.
 
Last edited:
Fair point - except we don't have the tools in all of this to identify who the guy is who needs to be reigned in.

The only dick(s) we can attempt to corral in all this from my perspective, are those who have turned it into character assassination and a media circus.

Yeah, you do have the tools. You know what someone looks like when they are really uncomfortable, right? Step in. or if the person you are talking to looks uncomfortable, step back. Or if you wouldn't want someone filming that moment because it might make you look bad, don't do it.

This isn't just about not hitting on people at inopportune times. It could also apply to say, trapping someone to go over every single thought you have ever had about the anti-vax crowd, even though your listener is already informed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom