So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've learnt that sex is still a nasty dirty thing that is not appropriate to be spoken about in polite society. Instead I've learnt that if you feel sexual attraction towards someone and want to shag them you should lie about your intentions for some undefined period of time before it becomes the appropriate time to stop lying. ETA: Oh and if you want to have a coffee and a chat with someone in the privacy of your room that means you want to shag them.
That's pretty much life in the states between the sexes.

I'll share this anecdote - I used to live in Dupont Circle in DC, at the time when it was still a sort of 'haven' for gay people. Not entirely, more than once I've had food thrown at me out of a moving vehicle, people driving by and screaming 'fag', etc. Anyhoo, I was hit on in some form by guys around once a week (and who could blame them, I'm a stunning hunk o' man meat!). In the same time period, my female roommate was propositioned once by a female. And by 'hit on' or propositioned I just mean 'want to grab a bite to eat' or whatever (only once did I get an offer for the guy to stick his tongue up my bung hole). When she related this event to me, I shared that it happened to me weekly, and she was surprised, as it normally didn't happen to her. She shared the event with me because it was out of the norm for her, and I never shared all of my instances because it was just so normal. To put this in perspective, we are both hetero, and this was mostly random street/store interactions.

The moral? I dunno. Just that we have a culture where men do the asking, it seems (I recognize all the assumptions loaded in that sentence, no time to write the dissertation required to tease them all out). I never felt objectified (except perhaps the bunhole comment) - it was just people expressing interest. I have to say it all seems a lot clearer and easier to do it that way than to perform some kind of dance. OTOH, with the exception of one creep, I never had to deal with being followed, cat called, not taking no for an answer, etc. (I'm ignoring the hostile comments as they aren't really the same thing, and I can't say I've lived the experience that women have because of it).
 
Last edited:
To a young woman in a foreign country, an elevator at 4 AM might...just might...not be considered a "social setting."

I believe all Rebecca said about it was that she found it inappropriate and creepy. She apparently reacted differently from the way I'd have reacted.

...snip...

But it was a social setting, Dublin is in a major international style country and is generally considered a very civilized (if broke) place so I really can't see how it can be described as being a particular dangerous place to be in out of the box so to speak.


I'd have been scared, Darat. I've been assaulted before.
Because I've been assaulted, I either wouldn't have gotten on an elevator, at 4 am, already occupied by a strange man or men, or if I had already been on the elevator and a strange man or men joined me, I'd have gotten out as he or they were boarding. Because I've been assaulted, I find myself consciously altering my behaviors to try to prevent a recurrence.

Which is quite understandable. A point I made earlier was if this type of social situation is an indicator of significantly increased risk for women (from harm at the hands of men) then I would all be for looking at trying to do something about it. But so far no one has indicated that it is. All there seems to be is a huge amount of assumptions and speculations with no facts to back it up.
Have you entirely missed the threads we've had lately about women "asking to be raped" by their behaviors and/or dress?

I've read some and probably posted in some but I really don't know what that has to do with this discussion?
 
Last edited:
And she abused this privilege... how? By saying that actions like EG's could seem threatening? By mention Stef McGraw's name after McGraw had criticized Rebecca on a public blog? People seem to think that Rebecca went on a 45-minute tirade, but I don't think that was the case.

Maybe the word we need to define isn't "privilege" but "abuse."

I find your need to defend the actions of Rebecca very telling. You are blinded to the fact that Rebecca put Stef in a much worse situation than Rebecca was in with EG. She actually SOUGHT to go after another person where that person had no real way to correct the situation then and there.

Rebecca acted like a jerk. Don't defend it.
 
Certainly from a cardiovascular perspective. Being followed up a stairwell by a guy implying he wants himself from some[?] sex might be worse than being in the elevator. [edited by a hillbilly]

Implies committment, though, more than just getting on an elevator ever can. Chicks dig that (I hear). I think that's what this whole misunderstanding comes down to: too much irish coffee (is that a leprechaun in your pants, or are you just happy to share an elevator with me?) You can't trust the Irish. They'd do you for a potato. Total lack of committment to all but the most rudimentary understanding of the dangers of starch-based diets. And coffee. Not to mention clumsy passes on elevators.
 
Funny!

I need to know if there is a code for what different coffee mean? I don't want to find myself making a faux pas because I wanted cappuccino but bought a latte!

Oh no, there's no code. if you can't work it out from context, you're ******. Or not, as the case may be.
 
True, I agree, but sometimes it isn't gallows humor, but a deliberate attempt to cause hurt. There are many permutations of specific behaviors.
I have seen what you're talking about, and agree it does happen. I've also seen what I've mentioned, and hope you can agree that sometimes, it does happen.

Totally agree that can be the case; there is always an up- and downside to all these types of things. I've seen on this very forum some posts that were without the context apparently innocuous but were in fact nothing but a coldly calculated attempt to hurt someone in as nasty manner as possible. But I've also seen when someone has taken an actually innocuous comment the totally wrong way. As in all these things it tends to be situational whether something is appropriate or not.
 
Certainly from a cardiovascular perspective. Being followed up a stairwell by a guy implying he wants himself from sex might be worse than being in the elevator.

Yeah, from experience, stairwells are far less populated than elevators. Although, I guess this proposal would change that.

Another random observation - you'd be amazed at how often dirty, poorly-maintained, poorly lit, smelly and disgusting stairwells can be found in fancy hotels.

Linda
 
True, I agree, but sometimes it isn't gallows humor, but a deliberate attempt to cause hurt. There are many permutations of specific behaviors.
I have seen what you're talking about, and agree it does happen. I've also seen what I've mentioned, and hope you can agree that sometimes, it does happen.

Yes, sometimes it is intended to cause hurt, and sometimes it works.

It's all very complex, and one of the lessons from this bruhaha is that social interaction is far from settled, despite the fact that it is possible to oversimplify with pithy quotes. Reasonable people can have differing perceptions.
 
But it was a social setting, Dublin is a major international style country and is generally considered a very civilized (if broke) place so I really can't see how it can be described as being a particular dangerous place to be in out of the box so to speak.

Oh, friend of mine, please see the difference between "being in a public room or an outdoor setting with multiple people present at 4 am," and "being in a closed elevator with a single stranger at 4 am." Please?

In that case, the elevator is not the "social setting."


Which is quite understandable. A point I made earlier was if this type of social situation is an indicator of significantly increased risk for women (from harm at the hands of men) then I would all be for looking at trying to do something about it. But so far no one has indicated that it is. All there seems to be is a huge amount of assumptions and speculations with no facts to back it up.

I believe I'm trying to say that "being asked back to his room for coffee" might be less creepy or disturbing had it happened in the pub/bar. The creepiness factor was multiplied by the elevator. Never mind the fact that she'd just given a talk in which she essentially said, "this behavior can be objectifying."


I've read some and probably posted in some but I really don't know what that has to do with this discussion?

Just to point out that in order to avoid both possible assault, and blame for even my discomfiture, I have to alter my behaviors to avoid situations most people wouldn't think twice about. My assault happened in a very, very public and open place; a mall parking lot.

Rebecca appears to have handled this differently than I would have--and appears to have come far closer to what might be considered an appropriate response. She didn't automatically assume she was about to be assaulted. I'd have had to assume it, given my past experience.
 
Funny!

I need to know if there is a code for what different coffee mean? I don't want to find myself making a faux pas because I wanted cappuccino but bought a latte!

Its the new handkerchief code of the 'tween years. Whatever you do, unless you're into some really kinky stuff, I wouldn't carry around a Java chip frappucino made with soy milk, in your left hand.
 
Aww for ****s sake you just conflated the fact that someone wanted evidence that there are sexist jackasses in the movement with Rebecca. Dawkins said that being raped is better than being religious. Dawkins then backtracked on his website and in the process said that in some cases people are making it up. So yes there are sexist idiots in the movement and one of them is at the forefront of this debate.

Well, I haven't read that post. I don't happen to read Dawkins' website, nor am I member of his foundation for reason or whatever he calls it. If you'd like to link it, then I would be pleased to comment. I don't think I can draw the conclusion that Dawkins is 'sexist' because he drew a comparison between rape, religion, and false rape accusation, particularly without the context.
 
Its the new handkerchief code of the 'tween years. Whatever you do, unless you're into some really kinky stuff, I wouldn't carry around a Java chip frappucino made with soy milk, in your left hand.

LEFT hand?! Darn! No wonder I got such dull offers last time...
 
I believe I'm trying to say that "being asked back to his room for coffee" might be less creepy or disturbing had it happened in the pub/bar. The creepiness factor was multiplied by the elevator. Never mind the fact that she'd just given a talk in which she essentially said, "this behavior can be objectifying."


I don't think anyone really has a problem with ones ability to measure the "creepiness" factor of anything.

The problem i have with this entire fiasco is the insatiable appetite of a few "skeptics" so willing to throw everyone under the bus for nothing other than a little limelight and showmanship.

PZ Could have done a LOT better with his "surfacing" of this issue beyond the walls of skeptchick and that is what is disappointing to me.

Personal opinions are personal opinions. They're not more valid than another as long as you form those opinions on rational claims...

how we got to quantifying creepiness or devaluating humanity to a bunch of horny sloths i dunno
 
Its the new handkerchief code of the 'tween years. Whatever you do, unless you're into some really kinky stuff, I wouldn't carry around a Java chip frappucino made with soy milk, in your left hand.


That's brought back memories - I can remember some blokes walking around with what looked like one of those magicians never ending rope of handkerchiefs - I did used to think "Wouldn't it be quicker to just ask?" oh and "god help the colour blind!"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom