So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think everyone should just take the stairs.

Healthier for all concerned.

Certainly from a cardiovascular perspective. Being followed up a stairwell by a guy implying he wants himself from sex might be worse than being in the elevator.
 
Yes they have.

I'd even say you are showing hints of it in your post above in that you seem to be saying that asking someone in a social setting for sex is wrong, because it "sexualises" someone.

This did not happen when Rebecca was on stage and giving a lecture i.e. a non-social setting. What seems to have happened is that in a social setting someone made what others have said is a clear proposition for sex. I don't see why from a rational standpoint (I have already said I know where it comes from in our societies) that should be any different than asking someone for a coffee, for a further discussion and a myriad of other social interactions.

To a young woman in a foreign country, an elevator at 4 AM might...just might...not be considered a "social setting."

I believe all Rebecca said about it was that she found it inappropriate and creepy. She apparently reacted differently from the way I'd have reacted.

I'd have been scared, Darat. I've been assaulted before.
Because I've been assaulted, I either wouldn't have gotten on an elevator, at 4 am, already occupied by a strange man or men, or if I had already been on the elevator and a strange man or men joined me, I'd have gotten out as he or they were boarding. Because I've been assaulted, I find myself consciously altering my behaviors to try to prevent a recurrence.

Have you entirely missed the threads we've had lately about women "asking to be raped" by their behaviors and/or dress?
 
And she abused this privilege... how?

As McGraw and others subsequently explained, she abused her privilege as keynote speaker by accusing an audience member of misogyny for disagreeing with her. It was a shocking breech of civility and ethics, and was a very clear attempt to bully Stef into towing the party line by embarrassing her in front of her peers in a format where she didn't have any genuine method of replying.

As other speakers have made clear, no professional would have pulled this crap -- and, in fact, other speakers planning to call out those present in the audience have a) informed them ahead of time, giving them the opportunity to discuss it with the speaker and/or prepare a response, and b) arranged for a panel-type discussion where the person has the genuine opportunity to discuss the issue.

Watson did neither; her purpose was the typical radical "feminist" purpose of shaming a "brainwashed" or "ignorant" woman into agreeing with her. She failed to do so, because these tactics are far less effective among skeptics, and because her bad behavior was identified immediately by attendees.

And by hijacking her speaking opportunity to this petty end, it's unlikely Watson's actual speech will ever have the full, positive impact it might have had.
 
And she abused this privilege... how? By saying that actions like EG's could seem threatening? By mention Stef McGraw's name after McGraw had criticized Rebecca on a public blog? People seem to think that Rebecca went on a 45-minute tirade, but I don't think that was the case.

Maybe the word we need to define isn't "privilege" but "abuse."

If you're allowed to abuse your power, how is that any different from having more privilege?

–noun 1. a right, immunity, or benefit enjoyed only by a person beyond the advantages of most: the privileges of the very rich. 2. a special right, immunity, or ...
 
I've learnt that sex is still a nasty dirty thing that is not appropriate to be spoken about in polite society. Instead I've learnt that if you feel sexual attraction towards someone and want to shag them you should lie about your intentions for some undefined period of time before it becomes the appropriate time to stop lying. ETA: Oh and if you want to have a coffee and a chat with someone in the privacy of your room that means you want to shag them.

There's nowt so queer as straights.
 
Richard Dawkins said that people who are raped sometimes are making it up.


Well, no. He can't have said that, can he? Wouldn't he have said that people who claim to have been raped are sometimes making it up? Because if you have been raped, you wouldn't be making it up; you see the difference?

And yes, some people who claim to have been raped are making it up. So?
 
As McGraw and others subsequently explained, she abused her privilege as keynote speaker by accusing an audience member of misogyny for disagreeing with her. It was a shocking breech of civility and ethics, and was a very clear attempt to bully Stef into towing the party line by embarrassing her in front of her peers in a format where she didn't have any genuine method of replying.

As other speakers have made clear, no professional would have pulled this crap -- and, in fact, other speakers planning to call out those present in the audience have a) informed them ahead of time, giving them the opportunity to discuss it with the speaker and/or prepare a response, and b) arranged for a panel-type discussion where the person has the genuine opportunity to discuss the issue.

Watson did neither; her purpose was the typical radical "feminist" purpose of shaming a "brainwashed" or "ignorant" woman into agreeing with her. She failed to do so, because these tactics are far less effective among skeptics, and because her bad behavior was identified immediately by attendees.

And by hijacking her speaking opportunity to this petty end, it's unlikely Watson's actual speech will ever have the full, positive impact it might have had.

I have read this same comment so many times this last week that I'm starting to wonder if it's cut & pasted from somewhere.

Fine. Rebecca shouldn't have brought it up. I don't actually agree, but I have yet to see anyone shifted from that position. And I suppose criticizing her speaking style or her professionalism is a handy diversion from her radical feminist point of "try not to make people uncomfortable."
 
And I suppose criticizing her speaking style or her professionalism is a handy diversion from her radical feminist point of "try not to make people uncomfortable."

Don't forget the important addendum of, "... and if you disagree with me, you're a misogynist."
 
Not if you're carrying a cup of coffee. Quite hazardous.

Depends on the coffee. If its a privileged coffee (ie from Starbucks) then I agree, 'danger, Will Robinson'!

Funny!

I need to know if there is a code for what different coffee mean? I don't want to find myself making a faux pas because I wanted cappuccino but bought a latte!
 
It makes little sense to me, too, but I've seen people do it here, in threads, to strangers. Someone says something difficult, personal, and someone else makes a joke about it.

That it doesn't make sense doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

Not that it really has anything to do with Rebecca Watson, but...

Sometimes people make jokes to break the tension with respect to something that makes them feel uncomfortable. I see that happen often, here. A typical pattern is about a page of one-liners. Then one of two things happen. Either people get irritated at the jokes, and the thread becomes about the jokes rather than the subject. Or, people ignore the jokes, and the tension is broken, and the discussion is much improved.

Gallows humor is generally about this. Sometimes it works. Sometimes it doesn't.
 
Don't forget the important addendum of, "... and if you disagree with me, you're a misogynist."

And I wouldn't forget that, if that was something she said instead of something you made up.

The entire OMG TIRADE was about two minutes long out of a 60-minute talk. The whole thing about McGraw seems to boil down to whether Rebecca was right to use her name. I think reasonable people can disagree on whether it was good or bad to do that.
 
Well, that's the problem right there. Because from the perspective of the guy, that could be exactly what he did.

...snip...

The problem comes with equating errors with hatred. It makes sense to me that somebody might see it as a mistake, but I am bewildered when someone tells me that it is hatred. T ...snip...

ETA: This goes the other way around, too. These incidents can also be characterized less negatively than they deserve in order to unfairly diminish the seriousness of the issue (whatever that may be - I don't think it has been established, yet).

Linda

Excellent post.
 
Not that it really has anything to do with Rebecca Watson, but...

Sometimes people make jokes to break the tension with respect to something that makes them feel uncomfortable. I see that happen often, here. A typical pattern is about a page of one-liners. Then one of two things happen. Either people get irritated at the jokes, and the thread becomes about the jokes rather than the subject. Or, people ignore the jokes, and the tension is broken, and the discussion is much improved.

Gallows humor is generally about this. Sometimes it works. Sometimes it doesn't.

True, I agree, but sometimes it isn't gallows humor, but a deliberate attempt to cause hurt. There are many permutations of specific behaviors.
I have seen what you're talking about, and agree it does happen. I've also seen what I've mentioned, and hope you can agree that sometimes, it does happen.
 
I'm not really sure this is going anywhere, however I am pretty sure that in the past some people who have accused others of rape, were found to have been making it up.
Aww for ****s sake you just conflated the fact that someone wanted evidence that there are sexist jackasses in the movement with Rebecca. Dawkins said that being raped is better than being religious. Dawkins then backtracked on his website and in the process said that in some cases people are making it up. So yes there are sexist idiots in the movement and one of them is at the forefront of this debate.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom