So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not true. It would still be nothing if she had "mentioned" it without turning it into an opportunity to lecture all men as if we would otherwise act like that one did... and then singling out one person who responded to that for public harassment the next time she had a podium.

^^^THIS^^^

Rebecca is OK with calling all men out for their privilege, but won't acknowledge she misued hers. Neither will her famous male defenders.
 
Please, someone provide me with evidence besides Rebecca's claims that the atheist community is full of sexists objectifying women. I'm skeptical of this assertion.
Richard Dawkins said that people who are raped sometimes are making it up.
 
Last edited:
I like this description, though I would definitely say that not everyone whose feathers were ruffled by those defending Rebecca and her point of view, have the perception you capitalized. In a discussion that gets this big you wind up with some startling propositions (no pun intended) or statements misunderstood to be startling propositions, from all sides.

Absolutely. I was using an example to illustrate a point, not literally cataloging all the reactions.
 
I've learnt that sex is still a nasty dirty thing that is not appropriate to be spoken about in polite society. Instead I've learnt that if you feel sexual attraction towards someone and want to shag them you should lie about your intentions for some undefined period of time before it becomes the appropriate time to stop lying. ETA: Oh and if you want to have a coffee and a chat with someone in the privacy of your room that means you want to shag them.

Don't forget you've also learned that the best way to pickup a couple of hundred more twitter followers is to wait until a high-profile best-selling author/friend of yours posts a slightly flippant and ill-advised comment on a blog, and to pounce on this fact like a bulldog on a milkbone.
 
^^^THIS^^^

Rebecca is OK with calling all men out for their privilege, but won't acknowledge she misued hers. Neither will her famous male defenders.

We might need to figure out a useful definition for the term "privilege" that applies to both Richard Dawkins and Rebecca, but doesn't actually include everyone in the western world.
 
Richard Dawkins said that people who are raped sometimes are making it up. There that enough evidence for ya.

I'm not really sure this is going anywhere, however I am pretty sure that in the past some people who have accused others of rape, were found to have been making it up.

This does not in any way negate or discredit the fact that rape is a horrific crime. Furthermore, victims of rape deserve sympathy and care.

It does remind all of us that we should be examining claims with an appropriate level of skepticism.

Rebecca was not raped. Rebecca herself states that she never felt physically threatened by the incident in the elevator. She didn't LIKE what happened and it made her uncomfortable.

What happened to Rebecca : Rape

Isn't in the same ballpark, not even in the same league, not even the same sport.
 
I think everyone should just take the stairs.

Healthier for all concerned.
 
This drama queen stuff:I could also have called it a false dichotomy, it was both. Dawkins did not say what you are claiming. He used the example to illustrate how minor was the complaint Rebecca's outrage was based on.

Outrage? She said, "don't be that guy." I hardly call that outrage.

The relevance is that Rebecca called him a rich old white guy implying something about Dawkin's personality I did not see when I met him.

So in the time you met him, his personality told you he was not a rich old white guy? She nailed those qualities perfectly, it was the priviledged that's debatable, which unfortunately, age, wealth, sex, and color does offer some advantages, IMHO.

More straw. RD and I did not conspire to set any standard.

Wow, I've read over and over, what you quoted, looking for somewhere I may have accidentally indicated that it was a conspiracy but I just can't seem to find it. It was a foolish move on my part to assumed that you would recall specifying that you only meet him once, briefly, therefor any conclusion that you and Dawkins are somehow in cohoots would be an outlandish conclusion. My apologies, I should have specified that yours and Dawkins standards for what an individual should feel comfortable with, though independant, do run parallel. Can you answer the question now? Supposing we actually did think as independant people, is that individual allowed to voice a complaint or should they ask Muslima, what her life is like, first?

And another cherry picker ignores the actual issues (whining about men objectifying women and claiming this is what keeps women from attending these events) and only notes the opening incident which by itself was not that remarkable. I thought the first video was rambling and uninteresting, but not much more

I don't know if you are talking about the blog video or the conference, at this point. The conference discusses the issue if her experiences and it was inspired by a person like you dismissing the occurance of it actually happened, simply because that woman hasn't experienced it, so the subject of it actually happening came first. Then in the blog video, she does a brief rehash of the conference and then merely states that she was propositioned in the elevator, right after having a conversation in the bar about what happens to her, as a woman, in conferences. She did not create the issue after the elevator incident.

Which brings me to the point of this post. Sheesh, could anything be more blown out of proportion?

That's an excellent question. I have not seen the likes of this, ever. RW had some nerve vocalized her dislike of an experience.

Please, someone provide me with evidence besides Rebecca's claims that the atheist community is full of sexists objectifying women. I'm skeptical of this assertion.

I will miss you most of all scarecrow. She never said that the community is full of sexists, she actually clearly stated otherwise. Basically, it's part of the experience, not the entirety of the experience. If you want evidence that it actually happens, take the time to read through the comments on her blog and on Plaits blog. It apparently does happen.
 
We might need to figure out a useful definition for the term "privilege" that applies to both Richard Dawkins and Rebecca, but doesn't actually include everyone in the western world.

We already have some -- including white privilege and economic privilege.

But what's specifically being referred to here is status privilege in the specific situation Watson found herself in as the keynote speaker. The fact that she and her defenders seem incapable of realizing how you can abuse someone in a power imbalance like that, says a lot about her as a person. None of it good.
 
Afterwards, in a video post, she discussed an incident that occurred there. She received some dismissive responses. The above link to PZ Myers is supportive (and has links to the above) with Richard Dawkins being dismissive within the comments. PZ Myers weighs in again. Dawkins still doesn't get it...not a total surprise with his rep, but still.

Where?
 
In all fairness, no, the guy wasn't doing doing what has been advised. I know one can miss a post or few as a thead gets longer, but it has been said, before you posted - that ElevatorGuy had not taken the time to get to know Rebecca before propositioning her.

Well, that's the problem right there. Because from the perspective of the guy, that could be exactly what he did.

The problem is that people are generally depending upon confirmation bias to judge whether or not what he did was appropriate. And it turns out not to be particularly useful, as usual.

If I were a guy who wanted to follow the advice which has been given - get to know her before propositioning her - then my behaviour would look like that of the elevator guy. I'm not going to ask her out or ask for sex, because that would be propositioning her. Instead, I'm going to tell her that I'm not trying to proposition her ("don't take this the wrong way") and ask her if I can talk to her some more to get to know her. That is what it would look like if I were a guy who was trying to get to know someone before suggesting sex. It also doesn't occur to me that she might be worried about harm, because I have no intentions of harming her.

Unfortunately, if I were a guy intent on propositioning her, my behaviour would also look like that of the elevator guy, since apparently everyone but me knows that when you say "don't take this the wrong way" you mean "take this the wrong way, wink, wink, nudge, nudge."

Also unfortunately, if I were a guy intent on raping her, my behaviour would also look like that of the elevator guy. At least, initially it would.

If we are thinking about one particular scenario, we tend to ask, "is this what I expect to see if his intentions are <x>?" And the guy is thinking, "these are my intentions so this is the way I should behave”. Neither of us are thinking that much about the total set of behaviours and intentions from which this is drawn.

Instead, what would be useful is an explanation of how to act to distinguish these 3 scenarios a priori. Like 3 point 14 mentioned earlier, whether or not you are "a creep" depends upon whether she is attracted to you. How does a guy know beforehand that you're definitely not attracted to him? If there seems to be a sexual attraction, how does a guy know beforehand when it is acceptable sexual attraction and when that attraction means unacceptable objectification. When is getting into an elevator with a man scary and when is it not? If alone with a man is not scary and talking to a man is not scary, why is talking to a man when alone with him scary? If we are unwilling or unable to give definitive answers to these questions, then at least we can be sensitive to the realization that guys get at these answers through trial and error.

By all accounts, while he was part of the larger group in the bar with Rebecca, he did not talk with her directly at all. He made no attempt to interact with her in the bar, make a suggestive comment with waggled eyebrows or some flirtatious body language to try and just what her response would be.

He jumped straight from watching her from the other side of the crowd to cornering in an enclosed space out of sight from other people and making what most reasonable people would say is a proposition for sex.

I don’t know what to say to that. I’m a person who says what I mean. I realize that this isn’t common, but I also know that I am not alone in this. It’s one of the things which attracts me to my husband.

Like I said, you can put your own spin on how you present this scenario. I’m just saying that from the perspective of someone who doesn’t have those intentions, it would appear more innocuous.

What Rebecca did next was reasonable and useful, I think. She gave feedback that what he did was in error and why. I don’t know if she did so at the time (hard to do when you’re taken aback), but she did so later in a video which had the added benefit of reaching a wider audience of men. Admittedly, it wasn’t clear exactly which behaviour she was objecting to, but it was an effort.

The problem comes with equating errors with hatred. It makes sense to me that somebody might see it as a mistake, but I am bewildered when someone tells me that it is hatred. That is serious business and in that case, I really want to make sure I understand. If you (not “you” singular, but “you” plural) are going to use strongly negative words to characterize my actions, then I want you to be prepared to be specific and direct about what distinguishes thoughtlessness from hatred or sexual attraction from objectification. If I don’t see this, then I would hope that you got carried away and exaggerated – that the strong wording was unwarranted. And I think that was what Dawkins was getting at. He wasn’t telling Rebecca that she shouldn’t complain or that she should suck it up. He was pointing out examples which could clearly be characterized as hatred or subordination in contrast to what happened to her. Calling the elevator incident hatred or subordination diminishes the very real distress that women exposed to hatred and subordination face, just like calling stinky farts “assault and battery”.

ETA: This goes the other way around, too. These incidents can also be characterized less negatively than they deserve in order to unfairly diminish the seriousness of the issue (whatever that may be - I don't think it has been established, yet).

Linda
 
Last edited:
Well, maybe. That's not a quality I've noticed about circuses in the past though.

Some of those small "burlesque" shows are the best little circuses i've ever seen. They're becoming quite popular in the club circuit.. far more entertaining.

I was already anticipating some fireworks before this because of Lawrence Krauss' inclusion on the speakers list. Now with this added layer, it might be more tense than Michael Shermer with a corrupted copy of PowerPoint.

Why would Lawrence Krauss inclusion start fireworks?
 
I am more than willing to keep an open mind should more substantial evidence be forthcoming.

If you'll check out some of the blogs and comments on this incident, particularly those at Skeptchick, there appears to be a multitude of women who have had similar experiences. It would appear that this sort of behavior is common enough that many women have no interest in attending skeptic/atheist conferences in the future and warn their friends not to attend.

A linkfarm is here: http://scienceblogs.com/gregladen/2011/07/elevators_and_privilege_a_lett.php#c4350815

All of this is still anecdotal of course, but I don't think there have been any formal studies done on the experiences of women who attend such conferences. Anecdotal is all we have at the moment. I've never been to such a conference myself.

And my voicing skepticism is of course, not "shut up, or you'll pay." Heaven forbid I voice my conclusion Rebecca is overreacting.

I don't think Rebecca has overreacted to the initial incident. I think the reason it's getting so much attention is that it wasn't an unusual occurrance. Much like the Dominic rape case in New York, while the maid may have been discredited (which doesn't mean her account was false), other women in France have now come forward with similar stories.

The issues: Is hitting on a woman objectifying them? Linda asks how is a guy supposed to know the difference?
Personally, I part company with Rebecca and other feminists here. I don't think that such behavior is always objectification. Or necessarily misogynist. I also think that the way feminists treat dissenters is wrong. I'm not a feminist and that's one reason why.

Are come-ons so frequent and so bad they keep women from attending atheist and skeptic conferences? That's a bizarre claim as I see it.
You may find it bizarre, but judging from the women who have posted stories of frequent come-ons and lots of unwanted touching and groping at such conferences, it is a big enough problem that it does keep women from attending. Particularly single women who don't wanting that sort of attention. I gather women with a spouse or boyfriend attached have a completely different experience.

From http://skepchick.org/2011/07/the-privilege-delusion/

I would make a comment about how there could really be more women in the community, and the responses from my fellow skeptics and atheists ranged from “No, they’re not logical like us,” to “Yes, so we can **** them!” That seemed weird.

...I got messages from women who told me about how they had trouble attending pub gatherings and other events because they felt uncomfortable in a room full of men. They told me about how they were hit on constantly and it drove them away. I didn’t fully get it at the time, because I didn’t mind getting hit on. But I acknowledged their right to feel that way and I started suggesting to the men that maybe they relax a little and not try to get in the pants of every woman who walks through the door. Maybe they could wait for her to make the first move, just in case.

And then, for the past few years as the audience for Skepchick and SGU grew, I’ve had more and more messages from men who tell me what they’d like to do to me, sexually. More and more men touching me without permission at conferences. More and more threats of rape from those who don’t agree with me, even from those who consider themselves skeptics and atheists.


Given that the problem is pervasive enough to cause this sort of ruckus in the on-line community, it's pretty clear that enough of the men who attend such conferences will not stop their behavior, women who don't want to endure it will simply, like Sling indicated, not go. Now, that isn't necessarily a problem - if you can't stand the heat, stay out of the kitchen, right. It's only a problem for people who would like to see the athiest/skeptic movement(?) grow out of it's stereotypical image (male) and attract more women into being active participants.
 
Last edited:
We might need to figure out a useful definition for the term "privilege" that applies to both Richard Dawkins and Rebecca, but doesn't actually include everyone in the western world.

I meant her privilege as a well known person in the community of skeptics, having a widely read blog, and was the keynote speaker at the event I referenced.
 
We already have some -- including white privilege and economic privilege.

But what's specifically being referred to here is status privilege in the specific situation Watson found herself in as the keynote speaker. The fact that she and her defenders seem incapable of realizing how you can abuse someone in a power imbalance like that, says a lot about her as a person. None of it good.

And she abused this privilege... how? By saying that actions like EG's could seem threatening? By mention Stef McGraw's name after McGraw had criticized Rebecca on a public blog? People seem to think that Rebecca went on a 45-minute tirade, but I don't think that was the case.

Maybe the word we need to define isn't "privilege" but "abuse."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom