So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
There are two options:

1) He was propositioning her for sex

2) He is the most naive man on the face of the earth
I like H'ethetheth's theory best, myself:

Of course, given the nature of the lecture Watson gave, he may just have been trolling.


The one thing I am disappointed about in reading this thread is how there is still a completely irrational approach once "sex" becomes involved. For example I could go to TAM and have as one of my goals meeting new people and creating friendships and that is OK, but if one of my goals is to have sex that is not OK. Sex is part of human social interactions to single it out and treat it as taboo or that there has to be set etiquette rules is to me irrational. For goodness sake why can't we just be honest about sex and sexual desires, why does it have to be hidden and camouflaged and controlled by Mr and Mrs Manners on the etiquette steering committee?

Has anyone said anything like that? Or perhaps, just perhaps, you shouldn't not-so-subtly proposition sex to someone who just spoke about her dislike of being sexualized at such events?
 
I don't think that's what Morrigan said but, especially dealing with strangers of the opposite sex, having zero history to build your opinion on his/her intent; it's rather risky to take "want to come back to my room for coffee," as purely innocent.
Morrigan said: "asking an unrelated member of the opposite sex for coffee obviously does mean more than just having coffee..." That implies that they thing that the only way someone can really mean coffee is that if they're related [insert humorous geographical exception of choice here]. Obviously the "same sex" bit need not apply, but that's by the by (no pun intended).As someone said earlier - possibly in the other thread - conference/convention night-time culture varies significantly from the "read world," certainly in my experience, and I couldn't count the number of times I've got into deep and totally platonic conversations with people at stupid o'clock, whether it was my room, theirs, hotel lobbies, empty bars, or wherever.
Put it this way, you are at a hotel with your partner (I don't know your sex/sexual preference). Your partner disappears for a few hours. When that person comes back and you inquire where they've been. How would you feel if their response was, "Oh I met <insert name typically associated with the sex that your partner prefers> in the elevator and he/she was really interesting, so we went back to his/her room for coffee and to further the conversation." Would your response honestly be, "Oh well, it was just coffee,"?
LOL! Well, since my wife historically prefers girls, the name thing might not be relevent, but it wouldn't overly concern me. Put it this way, we still go to nightclubs/raves, and we invariably end up separated for extended periods, meeting new people - or old friends (even "old friends") - and neither of us automatically gets green-eyed about it.
 
I seem to have missed the outcome of this story.

Did Rebecca sleep with the guy or not?

Maybe she meant, "Guys, don't do that...because I'm a crazed sexaholic and I can't help myself, plus a girl has gotta sleep some time"."
 
Last edited:
...snip...

Has anyone said anything like that? Or perhaps, just perhaps, you shouldn't not-so-subtly proposition sex to someone who just spoke about her dislike of being sexualized at such events?

Yes they have.

I'd even say you are showing hints of it in your post above in that you seem to be saying that asking someone in a social setting for sex is wrong, because it "sexualises" someone.

This did not happen when Rebecca was on stage and giving a lecture i.e. a non-social setting. What seems to have happened is that in a social setting someone made what others have said is a clear proposition for sex. I don't see why from a rational standpoint (I have already said I know where it comes from in our societies) that should be any different than asking someone for a coffee, for a further discussion and a myriad of other social interactions.
 
No, you don't have to conform. No, there is no one "right way." You have to act and feel the way you're going to act and feel. I have to do the same.

You're not hearing me. What happened to Rebecca has become a huge topic, a big deal issue now. Aside from her mentioning it in the first place, there's no one reason for the big deal it's become; there are many. And part of the resulting fallout is that some are going to make it a subject for humor. You can't control that. I can't, either. I can control only me. Since I don't want to be subjected to that, if I were going to TAM this year, I'd seriously consider not going now, or otherwise altering my usual behavior. I can't require people not to make jokes about it. I can't ask or demand that everyone behave in ways that suit me.

I don't want to be the "bitchy feminazi who can't take a harmless joke."
But I don't see many ways around it, now.

Whether it will be a big thing at TAM or not I don't know. And as I said earlier we don't have any reliable way of knowing if Rebecca's recounting of the event is at all accurate so I would be surprised if a bunch of skeptics and critical thinkers were to form strong conclusions on the evidence so far presented... (yeah you may detect a hint of sarcastic irony in that :) )

To talk about the more general point why couldn't you adopt one the approaches I mention above to bookitty? Why is it an all or nothing approach?
 
I have to go back to saying I feel this particular incident seems to me to be a tempest in a teapot, blown way out of proportion by relatively minor celebrities in the general scheme of things who at least to me appear to be playing to their audiences more than anyone else, and in my view makes the skeptical and atheist communities look pretty silly to anyone looking in from the outside.

Sigh. :(

Its downright embarrassing from the inside. Phil writing he will ignore all responses/feedback, PZ writing calling people "BOZOS" and Watson being privileged herself writing about another privileged man. Its so absolutely mind numbingly silly that if I were the organizers of TAM i would cancel PZ, Watson and Plait appearances and hire a circus as saving grace. At least the circus would be entertaining.

I know we're all human... but man, you would think the pillars of the "skeptic" movement would think twice about trying to be rational before opening their mouths.

This absolutely makes the skeptic movement look nothing more than a pissing match of ego rubbing and publishing rights. sad sad sad
 
Morrigan said: "asking an unrelated member of the opposite sex for coffee obviously does mean more than just having coffee..." That implies that they thing that the only way someone can really mean coffee is that if they're related [insert humorous geographical exception of choice here]. Obviously the "same sex" bit need not apply, but that's by the by (no pun intended).As someone said earlier - possibly in the other thread - conference/convention night-time culture varies significantly from the "read world," certainly in my experience, and I couldn't count the number of times I've got into deep and totally platonic conversations with people at stupid o'clock, whether it was my room, theirs, hotel lobbies, empty bars, or wherever.

Do you knock on random doors and begin conversations with total strangers in their rooms or is there generally some sort of dialogue before you actually end up in their room? I took unrelated to mean "zero relation", as in no prior relation to the individual. That's all I was correcting.

LOL! Well, since my wife historically prefers girls, the name thing might not be relevent, but it wouldn't overly concern me. Put it this way, we still go to nightclubs/raves, and we invariably end up separated for extended periods, meeting new people - or old friends (even "old friends") - and neither of us automatically gets green-eyed about it.

Generally, I am not the type to stay quiet by his side, either. I do find there to be a difference between mingling in a public setting and meeting new people and going to a complete stranger's hotel room. Call me insecure, I would have a problem with the second.
 
Yes they have.

I'd even say you are showing hints of it in your post above in that you seem to be saying that asking someone in a social setting for sex is wrong, because it "sexualises" someone.

This did not happen when Rebecca was on stage and giving a lecture i.e. a non-social setting. What seems to have happened is that in a social setting someone made what others have said is a clear proposition for sex. I don't see why from a rational standpoint (I have already said I know where it comes from in our societies) that should be any different than asking someone for a coffee, for a further discussion and a myriad of other social interactions.

I think it was Morrigan that brought up one of Travis' threads, some posts back. It might just be American culture, in which case I feel really bad for the guy in the elevator. At any rate, Travis said he was invited by a girl, for coffe, and he said he declined because he doesn't drink coffee. If I remember correctly, his thread blew up with replies stating that coffee does not mean coffee. I will be the first to get behind a "say what you mean," movement, in the US. It would be nice to differenciate between when someone really wants just coffee or if they want sex (neither being out of line), if intentions are clear.
 
The only way for this whole **** storm to never have happened is if Rebecca had never mentioned the incident at all.
the only way for this whole **** storm to never have happened is if the incident had never been mentioned.
Not true. It would still be nothing if she had "mentioned" it without turning it into an opportunity to lecture all men as if we would otherwise act like that one did... and then singling out one person who responded to that for public harassment the next time she had a podium.
 
OMG. In the name of all that's funny, please do not invite Rebecca to your room for coffee during TAM or otherwise jokingly proposition her. The joke is *already* tired, and I bet she's had to endure it a dozen times a day for a week. (And will continue to do so for the next six months.)
 
Storm in a teacup.

I once had a woman be very rude to me because I was walking down a street behind her and apparently had caused her stress and fear.
As I was barely aware she was even there, I was more than a little taken aback.

This reminds me of an experience I had one night. I was walking home, some two miles, through town which involves a very complicated route when I heard the click of heels behind me. I'm a bloke, and I saw a young women walking ten paces behind me. I thought nothing of it and kept walking.

A mile later, after many turnings, she was still there. I felt unnerved. I'm not the kind of chap women hit on, being fairly ugly, so I was worried as to why she had followed me so closely, for so far. I took a different turning. She followed.

Finally we drew near my house, so I turned and said "er, can I help?"

"Oh no" said the girl, for she was about seventeen as I now saw, small and utterly unthreatening. "I just saw you walking home and know you live in Tivoli Road a few houses down from me, so I walked back with you as I felt worried out on my own at 1am! I hope you don't mind!" (One wonders how she knew I was going home!)

I did not mind at all, but I had been terrified for that last five minutes, even though I knew she posed no threat to me. If only she had spoken before it would have been so much easier. ;) I think anyone can be creeped out from time to time. I gave her my number and invited her to call me if she ever got stuck in town and scared again, and picked her up a few times after that, and dropped her off by my house when she called. It was a bit of a pain, but I always end up carrying old ladies shopping home and running errands for folk so no worse than usual. :) Twelve years on we are still friends -- but it was not the best start!

As to the Watson and guy in the elevator event, I have no idea. I just wonder how many speakers I have chatted to after events have misconstrued my questions as advances, and will be more wary in future, which is a great shame. :(

cj x
 
Last edited:
OMG. In the name of all that's funny, please do not invite Rebecca to your room for coffee during TAM or otherwise jokingly proposition her. The joke is *already* tired, and I bet she's had to endure it a dozen times a day for a week. (And will continue to do so for the next six months.)

Oh - I wouldn't do that. I might have to buy her a coffee, tho.
 
Its downright embarrassing from the inside. Phil writing he will ignore all responses/feedback, PZ writing calling people "BOZOS" and Watson being privileged herself writing about another privileged man. Its so absolutely mind numbingly silly that if I were the organizers of TAM i would cancel PZ, Watson and Plait appearances and hire a circus as saving grace. At least the circus would be entertaining.

Well, maybe. That's not a quality I've noticed about circuses in the past though.

I was already anticipating some fireworks before this because of Lawrence Krauss' inclusion on the speakers list. Now with this added layer, it might be more tense than Michael Shermer with a corrupted copy of PowerPoint.
 
I just wonder how many speakers I have chatted to after events have misconstrued my questions as advances, and will be more wary in future, which is a great shame. :(

I don't think it's necessarily a shame. What I've gotten from this is simply a reminder to be aware of how you're presenting yourself to other people, and try to align that presentation with the impression you want to give.

EG probably didn't want to creep Rebecca out. I think even Rebecca believes that. But he managed to instill the same sort of wariness you felt with the girl walking behind you, because he was likely unaware of how his clumsy advance would appear in that situation.

It seems like most of the anger's come because Rebecca feels (and I agree, based on my own experiences and conversations) that this sort of thing is a contributing factor to why many women don't want to come to conventions, and said so into a microphone. That has of course mutated into OMG REBEKKKA IS LECTURING MEN TO NOT BE MEN.

But asking people to put themselves in someone else's shoes before doing or saying something personal or intimate doesn't strike me as a burden. Seems more like civilized behavior.
 
Joke will be on you if she jumps your bones right there.

That would be pretty funny. I wonder if Mark would be inspired then to post his displeasure with the outcome on YouTube, inspiring thousands of web postings...
 
That would be pretty funny. I wonder if Mark would be inspired then to post his displeasure with the outcome on YouTube, inspiring thousands of web postings...

And Dawkins will be on the scene. You could get him to dismiss Mark's concerns RIGHT THERE instead of wading through PZ's blog!
 
I do rather hope that no-one at the next conference Rebecca (I've never heard of her before now - maybe being propositioned in an elevator can be a good thing) attends, I hope no one offers to buy her a cup of coffee.

I have visions of some poor, innocent member of the public, unaware of the completely unrwarranted attention this event is receiving, offering a cup of coffe and being dumbfounded at the reaction. :D
 
Last edited:
I don't think it's necessarily a shame. What I've gotten from this is simply a reminder to be aware of how you're presenting yourself to other people, and try to align that presentation with the impression you want to give.

EG probably didn't want to creep Rebecca out. I think even Rebecca believes that. But he managed to instill the same sort of wariness you felt with the girl walking behind you, because he was likely unaware of how his clumsy advance would appear in that situation.

It seems like most of the anger's come because Rebecca feels (and I agree, based on my own experiences and conversations) that this sort of thing is a contributing factor to why many women don't want to come to conventions, and said so into a microphone. That has of course mutated into OMG REBEKKKA IS LECTURING MEN TO NOT BE MEN.

But asking people to put themselves in someone else's shoes before doing or saying something personal or intimate doesn't strike me as a burden. Seems more like civilized behavior.

I like this description, though I would definitely say that not everyone whose feathers were ruffled by those defending Rebecca and her point of view, have the perception you capitalized. In a discussion that gets this big you wind up with some startling propositions (no pun intended) or statements misunderstood to be startling propositions, from all sides.
 
I've learnt that sex is still a nasty dirty thing that is not appropriate to be spoken about in polite society. Instead I've learnt that if you feel sexual attraction towards someone and want to shag them you should lie about your intentions for some undefined period of time before it becomes the appropriate time to stop lying. ETA: Oh and if you want to have a coffee and a chat with someone in the privacy of your room that means you want to shag them.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom