So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think Dr BUZZ0 was before my time, as I'm relatively new to the skeptic community. Should I ask what he did? :D

ETA: Don't want to dig up old history, but if it was just one individual...

He was booted from the forum some time ago, but he still goes to TAM. I saw him from a distance at the first TAM London, and then up close at TAM8. Sadly my social skills were inadequate to the task of moving him away from the women he was bothering at the time. I did also see him wandering the corridors late at night, but that's not such an unusual thing in Vegas.
 
If I were going to be there, I know I wouldn't be getting on any elevators with any men, if only so I wouldn't take the chance of being subjected to some misplaced "humor" about it. Some have already bragged that they're going to seek out Rebecca and do this to her.

It's too bad you feel this way, and I hope you're wrong. I think it's a tiny minority of men who would think of doing such a thing, and even fewer who would actually do it than may claim they are planning to on some anonymous internet forum.

I have to add, though, that your statement feels somewhat insulting, to be honest. "I know I wouldn't be getting on any elevators with any men..."

Gee, thanks.
 
It's too bad you feel this way, and I hope you're wrong. I think it's a tiny minority of men who would think of doing such a thing, and even fewer who would actually do it than may claim they are planning to on some anonymous internet forum.

I have to add, though, that your statement feels somewhat insulting, to be honest. "I know I wouldn't be getting on any elevators with any men..."

Gee, thanks.

I don't know you! I don't know who would or wouldn't think it a funny thing to do. I'm not inclined to take the chance. And if I did, and it happened, I'd be blamed for knowing it could happen and doing it anyway.

Once this kind of thing happens, the chilling effect for some of us is total.
Sorry.
 
They separated over a year ago, so who knows how well the immersion into British culture has gone.

I didn't really want this to be a discussion of her private life, but they appeared to still be together at TAM London, which was less than a year ago.
 
I don't know you! I don't know who would or wouldn't think it a funny thing to do. I'm not inclined to take the chance. And if I did, and it happened, I'd be blamed for knowing it could happen and doing it anyway.

Once this kind of thing happens, the chilling effect for some of us is total.
Sorry.

Let me give you an idea of what it can sound like to some. Replace "men" in your statements with "blacks".

It's a very unfair generalization in either case.
 
Let me give you an idea of what it can sound like to some. Replace "men" in your statements with "blacks".

It's a very unfair generalization in either case.

Oh, please. I'm not talking about never getting on an elevator anywhere in the world with any man ever again.

I'm talking about this incident, and the jokes made about it right here, and the suggestion made that someone intends to pull this as a prank at TAM...if you can't see the difference, and understand that I don't choose to be subjected to this, but that since I now know it's possible, at this particular event, that my only choice to avoid it is to not take any elevators there with men I don't know...come on.
 
If I were going to be there, I know I wouldn't be getting on any elevators with any men, if only so I wouldn't take the chance of being subjected to some misplaced "humor" about it. Some have already bragged that they're going to seek out Rebecca and do this to her.

No, I'm glad I can't go. This would make me cancel. Climbing stairs is painful for me, you see.

I think you are blowing this out of proportion. As far as I have seen, only one person has made this claim and in that post, I also specifically referenced that it was in direct contradiction to Phil Plait's advice, so yes, I am well aware that to do so would be a complete Dick Move.

To make things clear, I have no intent on doing so. If I actually knew Rebecca (or more specifically, if she knew me) then I might consider such a comment as a form of humor, seeing as what I do know of her (from listening to SGU) is that she seems to have a similar sense of humor and would likely find such a comment from somebody she already knew as funny.

However, the fact that I am as much a stranger to her as EG is, I am well aware that such an attempt could easily be misconstrued and likely end very badly for me (I also doubt that Ms. Watson would hesitate in any way to introduce her patella to my testicles if she felt threatened - not something I care to subject myself to.)
 
I think you are blowing this out of proportion. As far as I have seen, only one person has made this claim and in that post, I also specifically referenced that it was in direct contradiction to Phil Plait's advice, so yes, I am well aware that to do so would be a complete Dick Move.

To make things clear, I have no intent on doing so. If I actually knew Rebecca (or more specifically, if she knew me) then I might consider such a comment as a form of humor, seeing as what I do know of her (from listening to SGU) is that she seems to have a similar sense of humor and would likely find such a comment from somebody she already knew as funny.

However, the fact that I am as much a stranger to her as EG is, I am well aware that such an attempt could easily be misconstrued and likely end very badly for me (I also doubt that Ms. Watson would hesitate in any way to introduce her patella to my testicles if she felt threatened - not something I care to subject myself to.)


Sorry, but I'm not blowing it out of my proportion. I just wouldn't want to play, and knowing there's a chance I'll be made to play ruins it for me. Even if you had said nothing, you think I didn't already know there's a good chance some wag is going to do it, just for chuckles?

It really does boil down to "shut up, or you'll pay." The only way for this whole **** storm to never have happened is if Rebecca had never mentioned the incident at all. Sometimes you have to open the can of worms anyway, even if you know the slimy little bastards are just going to muck everything up.
 
I'm not going to TAM, am no longer associating with the IIG and my fundraising & activism efforts no longer involve anything related to skepticism or atheism. (with except of church/state separation stuff.) When people ask me what I'm into or doing these days, skepticism no longer comes up. I don't refer people to any blogs or sites related to skepticism that allow comments.

I'm the smallest fish in the pond, no great loss. My opinions and my decisions are my own, I don't speak for anyone else. But, I'm a woman who, after a year of enthusiastic involvement, is now only connected to the skepticism movement through this forum. (And imagine how that must shade my view, eh.)
I assume this somewhat vague description is your anecdote supporting Rebecca's assertion. Still not convincing. My anecdotes counter yours and then some. Come to Seattle. Your complaints have never been voiced at our skeptics' and atheists' groups and I am more than enough involved in both groups to be able to make that assertion.

It appears to me to be manufactured persecution.

I am more than willing to keep an open mind should more substantial evidence be forthcoming.
 
Sorry, but I'm not blowing it out of my proportion. I just wouldn't want to play, and knowing there's a chance I'll be made to play ruins it for me. Even if you had said nothing, you think I didn't already know there's a good chance some wag is going to do it, just for chuckles?

It really does boil down to "shut up, or you'll pay." The only way for this whole **** storm to never have happened is if Rebecca had never mentioned the incident at all. Sometimes you have to open the can of worms anyway, even if you know the slimy little bastards are just going to muck everything up.
And my voicing skepticism is of course, not "shut up, or you'll pay." Heaven forbid I voice my conclusion Rebecca is overreacting.
 
And my voicing skepticism is of course, not "shut up, or you'll pay." Heaven forbid I voice my conclusion Rebecca is overreacting.

Disagreeing with you isn't telling you to shut up.

Still, the only way for this whole **** storm to never have happened is if the incident had never been mentioned.

There's no way for it to be discussed neatly. It's not a tidy subject.
 
Sorry, but I'm not blowing it out of my proportion. I just wouldn't want to play, and knowing there's a chance I'll be made to play ruins it for me. Even if you had said nothing, you think I didn't already know there's a good chance some wag is going to do it, just for chuckles?

This makes little sense to me. Where would be the chuckles in doing this to some random female attendee? Specifically targeting Rebecca with this as a joke would be funny (in bad taste, definitely, but funny). Referencing this incident in a mock proposition to a female that I already knew, also funny.

Making such a comment to a random female attendee that I don't know from Eve and she doesn't know me from Adam. Just plain creepy and not funny.
 
This makes little sense to me. Where would be the chuckles in doing this to some random female attendee? Specifically targeting Rebecca with this as a joke would be funny (in bad taste, definitely, but funny). Referencing this incident in a mock proposition to a female that I already knew, also funny.

Making such a comment to a random female attendee that I don't know from Eve and she doesn't know me from Adam. Just plain creepy and not funny.

It makes little sense to me, too, but I've seen people do it here, in threads, to strangers. Someone says something difficult, personal, and someone else makes a joke about it.

That it doesn't make sense doesn't mean it doesn't happen.
 
...snip...

And if someone made my niece uncomfortable and I complained about it here, how many people would say that she should just suck it up, that's life, that's how guys are and that they didn't think it was such a big deal.

I think the vast number of replies would be entirely be dependent on the exact situation as has been the case in this thread.

I don't recall anyone in this thread (and as others have said it is fast moving so I will have missed some posts for certain) that people should "just stuck it up". To me it seems to me that some folk are arguing from the "personalities" so making comments about the bloggers and commentators outside the exact situation, others have offered different ways at looking at what happened and others (which is the view I take) that we simply do not have the information required to judge the specific instance so all we can talk about is the more general issues raised by the anecdote.
 
Let me give you an idea of what it can sound like to some. Replace "men" in your statements with "blacks".

It's a very unfair generalization in either case.

Wait a minute - Some men at a very specific location might go along with a mob mentality elevator joke that is already in the planning stages and has been mentioned on several different websites = all blacks. how do you figure that?

The jokes will happen. They might be "Hi, not a rapist! Please don't hurt me!" or they might be "Do you want coffee, or should I just rape you right here?" Any woman who doesn't want to deal with that will either avoid the entire situation or just have to suck it up.
 
The one thing I am disappointed about in reading this thread is how there is still a completely irrational approach once "sex" becomes involved. For example I could go to TAM and have as one of my goals meeting new people and creating friendships and that is OK, but if one of my goals is to have sex that is not OK. Sex is part of human social interactions to single it out and treat it as taboo or that there has to be set etiquette rules is to me irrational. For goodness sake why can't we just be honest about sex and sexual desires, why does it have to be hidden and camouflaged and controlled by Mr and Mrs Manners on the etiquette steering committee?
 
Wait a minute - Some men at a very specific location might go along with a mob mentality elevator joke that is already in the planning stages and has been mentioned on several different websites = all blacks. how do you figure that?

The jokes will happen. They might be "Hi, not a rapist! Please don't hurt me!" or they might be "Do you want coffee, or should I just rape you right here?" Any woman who doesn't want to deal with that will either avoid the entire situation or just have to suck it up.

Or (to use the current meme) say "Stop being a dick and grow-up" and assign the folks who made those jokes to your real-life ignore list. Or laugh with them if you also find it funny. Or totally ignore them... Or... There are plenty different ways to respond to such issues than "just suck it up" that are open to women (and men).
 
It makes little sense to me, too, but I've seen people do it here, in threads, to strangers. Someone says something difficult, personal, and someone else makes a joke about it.
That it doesn't make sense doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

But Sling the answer to that has to be "and". No one will be happy with the way everyone responds to anything, others may joke because that is how they are (I know I make jokes in the most dire of situations) and so on. What I don't like is the idea that there is "right way" that everyone should follow, I really rebel against that conformity.
 
But Sling the answer to that has to be "and". No one will be happy with the way everyone responds to anything, others may joke because that is how they are (I know I make jokes in the most dire of situations) and so on. What I don't like is the idea that there is "right way" that everyone should follow, I really rebel against that conformity.

No, you don't have to conform. No, there is no one "right way." You have to act and feel the way you're going to act and feel. I have to do the same.

You're not hearing me. What happened to Rebecca has become a huge topic, a big deal issue now. Aside from her mentioning it in the first place, there's no one reason for the big deal it's become; there are many. And part of the resulting fallout is that some are going to make it a subject for humor. You can't control that. I can't, either. I can control only me. Since I don't want to be subjected to that, if I were going to TAM this year, I'd seriously consider not going now, or otherwise altering my usual behavior. I can't require people not to make jokes about it. I can't ask or demand that everyone behave in ways that suit me.

I don't want to be the "bitchy feminazi who can't take a harmless joke."
But I don't see many ways around it, now.
 
There are two options:

1) He was propositioning her for sex

2) He is the most naive man on the face of the earth
You know, there was all this talk of privilege earlier on. Being socially apt is as much a privilege as being a "rich white old heterosexual man".
Be aware of this privilege, is what I want to say.

I studied on a virtually woman-free engineering campus; I know people who I'd have no trouble believing this could accidentally happen to. Heck, this specific example could not have happened to me, but a lot of things of similar naivety have.

Of course, given the nature of the lecture Watson gave, he may just have been trolling.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom