So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh yay! let's start a moon colony! We can base it around a huge library with so many books and little niche fireplaces and big comfy chairs and robot cleaners. To get to your living quarters, you need to move a certain bunch of books on a specific shelf in an exact fashion but nobody else has the code. (and the library is huuuuuuuge, like moon base big) so when you're in your space, there is no possible way for anyone to reach you unless you want them to.

Oh and robot chefs.

Is coffee available in living quarters?

Because if so, I see a problem...
 
Is coffee available in living quarters?

Because if so, I see a problem...

Coffee pipes! Hot or cold running coffee in every room. Tea will be delivered on silver trays by superfast butler robots with excellent hearing. Alcoholic beverages tucked into many well-placed globes, other options available on demand. It will be sweet.

It's pretty easy to get in. When someone says "Hey, that bugs me." you just have to honestly respond with either "Oh, I'm sorry, I wasn't thinking." or "Oh, I'm not sure about this. Let me think it over and get back to you. In the meantime, please accept my apology."

That outta keep the riff-raff out.
 
Please explain the straw,
This drama queen stuff:
sgtbaker said:
Unless her genitals are being mutilated, don't complain. Really? So by that notion, unless you are being religiously persecuted in a violent manner, don't complain. You don't like the religious dominance in the US, get over it, people are getting their heads cut off in other countries.
I could also have called it a false dichotomy, it was both. Dawkins did not say what you are claiming. He used the example to illustrate how minor was the complaint Rebecca's outrage was based on.


you posted that you agreed with Mr. Dawkins because you met him once and he was a nice enough guy and I explained why I disagreed.
The relevance is that Rebecca called him a rich old white guy implying something about Dawkin's personality I did not see when I met him.


You respond by calling it a straw and then go off on a rant about something else. Did Dawkin or did he not compare the incident in the elevator, which RW herself, originally stated was not a huge issue, to the plight of Muslim women? Okay, I get it, you and RD set the standard for what the rest of us are and are not allowed to feel uncomfortable about but for argument's sake, let's just say that we are actually individuals who have a wide range on what bothers us. If something bother's an individual, are they not supposed to voice a complaint because someone else has it worse?
More straw. RD and I did not conspire to set any standard.


The funny thing is, in her original complaint, she just said, "don't be that guy." She certainly wasn't intending on it becoming this tragedy. It was the response that turned into a tragedy; as if she is not allowed to feel uncomfortable in a situation that might not make everyone uncomfortable. Maybe you don't get hit on like she and those she said wrote in do. That, in no way, means it doesn't happen. It's an odd thing that some women like to feel like what they say is more important than their bra size. I mean really! How dare she.
And another cherry picker ignores the actual issues (whining about men objectifying women and claiming this is what keeps women from attending these events) and only notes the opening incident which by itself was not that remarkable. I thought the first video was rambling and uninteresting, but not much more.


Which brings me to the point of this post. Sheesh, could anything be more blown out of proportion?


Please, someone provide me with evidence besides Rebecca's claims that the atheist community is full of sexists objectifying women. I'm skeptical of this assertion.
 
Last edited:
... I'm not clear on whether or not RW acted as a bully herself, as I wasn't there and I'm not aware of any video of that event. ....

... I also get the impression (perhaps not accurate) that such propositions happen to RW on a regular basis when she speaks at atheist/skeptic conferences.

... I would say that yes, Randi, Dawkins and especially PZ are often bullying those they are criticizing. Frankly, I don't read much of their stuff on specific creationists or others they disapprove of for that very reason.

I think that Dawkins response to RW has been an example of bullying behavior. ....
I'll wait til you post on some of what you've said after you catch up. The main issues were never about a woman's simple advice to guys about incompetent propositions.

The issues: Is hitting on a woman objectifying them? Linda asks how is a guy supposed to know the difference?

Are come-ons so frequent and so bad they keep women from attending atheist and skeptic conferences? That's a bizarre claim as I see it.

As for Rebecca's complaint people angry with her comments say things like, you should be raped, the commenters are idiots. The world is full of them. What else is new? Dawkins and PZ get plenty of bizarre threats. That's the nature of blogging on the Internet.
 
The issues: Is hitting on a woman objectifying them? Linda asks how is a guy supposed to know the difference?

The issue: If you made it clear that you wanted to go to bed alone and nevertheless some male stranger at 4am and tipsy follows you out of the public space into the lift alone to ask you to his room "for coffee" and further discussion when there was coffee at the bar they just left, would you feel this guy is out of line and feel uncomfortable trapped in an elevator now after having turned him down in a world where elevator assaults/rapes are a reality? My answer would be yes. What's yours? I'm pretty sure that's the only issue here. And I'm pretty sure there is no need to vilify her.

From Rebecca Watson herself:
06.20.2011
"There is a small chance that this man meant nothing sexual in his comment, despite the fact that I had clearly indicated my wish to go to bed (alone) and the fact that the bar had coffee and therefore there was absolutely zero reason to go to anyone’s hotel room to have it. Sure. There’s a chance.

But regardless, the point I was making was that people need to be aware of how their comments might make someone feel extraordinarily uncomfortable and even feel as though they are in danger. This person failed to recognize that even though I had been speaking about little else all day long."
http://skepchick.org/2011/06/about-m...ism-and-jokes/

made further clear by a commenter on same blog:
aynsavoy
06.20.2011

"One assumption I am perfectly comfortable making is that, despite Rebecca’s prior assertions to the group that she wanted to go to bed, this individual thought that it would be a good idea to try to change her mind. Even if we decide that he had the best intentions in mind, this decision shows a disregard for Rebecca’s expressed desires.
I imagine that he decided to make his offer in the elevator, alone with her, so that if she rejected the invitation, he could keep his embarrassment to himself. However, it’s also a situation where, if she rejected his invitation and he reacted badly to that rejection, she could not get away. If you have to turn someone down–for anything–would you rather do it in a space where you can easily make your exit, or where you’re then trapped with that person for an indeterminate amount of time?"
 
Please, someone provide me with evidence besides Rebecca's claims that the atheist community is full of sexists objectifying women. I'm skeptical of this assertion.

I'm not going to TAM, am no longer associating with the IIG and my fundraising & activism efforts no longer involve anything related to skepticism or atheism. (with except of church/state separation stuff.) When people ask me what I'm into or doing these days, skepticism no longer comes up. I don't refer people to any blogs or sites related to skepticism that allow comments.

I'm the smallest fish in the pond, no great loss. My opinions and my decisions are my own, I don't speak for anyone else. But, I'm a woman who, after a year of enthusiastic involvement, is now only connected to the skepticism movement through this forum. (And imagine how that must shade my view, eh.)
 
I'm not going to TAM, am no longer associating with the IIG and my fundraising & activism efforts no longer involve anything related to skepticism or atheism. (with except of church/state separation stuff.) When people ask me what I'm into or doing these days, skepticism no longer comes up. I don't refer people to any blogs or sites related to skepticism that allow comments.

I'm the smallest fish in the pond, no great loss. My opinions and my decisions are my own, I don't speak for anyone else. But, I'm a woman who, after a year of enthusiastic involvement, is now only connected to the skepticism movement through this forum. (And imagine how that must shade my view, eh.)


Are you saying that your disassociation with the skeptical/atheist community came about because of all the male sexism that you saw as existing within it?

(ETA: Apologies if you had explained this upthread. It's hard to keep up with a thread moving this quickly.)
 
Last edited:
As relates to this specific incident, this presumes the man in question was propositioning Rebecca for sex. We don't know that for sure. All we do know is this guy was perhaps socially awkward.

It's a little unfair - and unjustified - to cast him in the role of sexual predator looking to jump Rebecca's bones at first opportunity.

There are two options:

1) He was propositioning her for sex

2) He is the most naive man on the face of the earth
 
Are you saying that your disassociation with the skeptical/atheist community came about because of all the male sexism that you saw as existing within it?

(ETA: Apologies if you had explained this upthread. It's hard to keep up with a thread moving this quickly.)

There's never just one reason for no longer hanging out with people you honestly like and admire but sexism was part of it. I no longer recommend site with comments because I was tired of defending people that I didn't know for attitudes I don't share.
 
All I know is that if I run into Rebecca at TAM, I am going to invite her to my room for coffee. Not that I am at all interested in sex with her, but mostly because I have a really hard time following Phil Plait's advice.

When Phil gave his speech, I could swear he was looking at me & Winslow.
 
There's never just one reason for no longer hanging out with people you honestly like and admire but sexism was part of it. I no longer recommend site with comments because I was tired of defending people that I didn't know for attitudes I don't share.


Got it--thanks. I'm still not sure how large a factor sexism has been in turning people off skepticism (or how much sexism is more prevalent among skeptics than among the community at large, which if that is the case, really saddens me). Doesn't help I'm a man, I guess.
 
Got it--thanks. I'm still not sure how large a factor sexism has been in turning people off skepticism (or how much sexism is more prevalent among skeptics than among the community at large, which if that is the case, really saddens me). Doesn't help I'm a man, I guess.

I would honestly be interested in knowing how many women haven't returned to TAM specifically because of Dr BUZZ0
 
I have to go back to saying I feel this particular incident seems to me to be a tempest in a teapot, blown way out of proportion by relatively minor celebrities in the general scheme of things who at least to me appear to be playing to their audiences more than anyone else, and in my view makes the skeptical and atheist communities look pretty silly to anyone looking in from the outside.

Sigh. :(
 
I would honestly be interested in knowing how many women haven't returned to TAM specifically because of Dr BUZZ0


I think Dr BUZZ0 was before my time, as I'm relatively new to the skeptic community. Should I ask what he did? :D

ETA: Don't want to dig up old history, but if it was just one individual...
 
Last edited:
Got it--thanks. I'm still not sure how large a factor sexism has been in turning people off skepticism (or how much sexism is more prevalent among skeptics than among the community at large, which if that is the case, really saddens me). Doesn't help I'm a man, I guess.

Earlier this year, I was trying to talk my sister into letting me take my niece and nephew to TAM. My niece is 15 but has been blessed/cursed with an attractive figure and looks older than her age. Do you think my sister would have let her go after reading this thread?

And if someone made my niece uncomfortable and I complained about it here, how many people would say that she should just suck it up, that's life, that's how guys are and that they didn't think it was such a big deal.
 
Dawkins did not say what you are claiming. He used the example to illustrate how minor was the complaint Rebecca's outrage was based on.

Not exactly.

He used the example to illustrate how minor he thought Rebecca's complaint was.

And yes, I read it. I read what he wrote. So because no one has taken a razor blade to her clitoris, she should suck it up and be quiet.

I've no respect for him anymore. He didn't just minimize Rebecca, but he used Muslim women to do it, in the sense one might use a rag to cover a stain. He belittled both. The things many Muslim women endure, their pain, it isn't to be used like a cudgel to beat other women!

He used the pain of women to belittle another woman.

This is honorable? Respectable? Not being a dick?


Please, someone provide me with evidence besides Rebecca's claims that the atheist community is full of sexists objectifying women. I'm skeptical of this assertion.

Covering your eyes doesn't really make you blind.
 
I have to wonder how this year's TAM will go. Because it could be all out battle of the sexes. Or it could be open season on women because who is going to complain now that it's blown up this big? Elevator guy is still happily anonymous, Rebecca's the one getting the public flogging. (Although some of that is on her for continuing to escalate.)
 
I have to wonder how this year's TAM will go. Because it could be all out battle of the sexes. Or it could be open season on women because who is going to complain now that it's blown up this big? Elevator guy is still happily anonymous, Rebecca's the one getting the public flogging. (Although some of that is on her for continuing to escalate.)


If I were going to be there, I know I wouldn't be getting on any elevators with any men, if only so I wouldn't take the chance of being subjected to some misplaced "humor" about it. Some have already bragged that they're going to seek out Rebecca and do this to her.

No, I'm glad I can't go. This would make me cancel. Climbing stairs is painful for me, you see.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom