So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well that isn't my attitude sgtbaker. I do think this has spiralled out of control, and Rebecca has 'gained the most' from all the attention (so far). But my attitude is not that it doesn't bother me, so it shouldn't bother her.

Not that my approval matters in the end but I don't recall taking issue with anything you've said. I didn't mean to imply that that is the only attitude, here, just the ones that I have responded to.

I have been very clear that what happened to her was unfortunate and uncomfortable for her. I don't support harrassing types of behaviour, and the one takeaway from this should be for people to consider appropriate decorum when inviting others for coffee or coffee 'plus'.

That is pretty much the same tone I picked up from RW's original blog about the situation.

People who aren't public figures usually take an unfortunate situation and go home to think about it. Maybe they make it a topic of discussion on an online thread and get some thoughts about it.

When public figures post youtube talking head videos, take the opportunity to use a public speaking forum to carry on the rant, and then fan the flames across multiple internet fora and media sites, calling for essentially public boycotts of other public figures, days before another public appearance where it just so happens most of those other media sites have representatives in attendance and all stand to benefit peripherally, if only from perhaps a few more foum members, facebook friends or twitter followers... methinks the lady doth protest a wee bit too much.

Common nobodies, like myself, would start a thread about it or a light humor laced comment on FB, if a situation bothered me that much. She's a video blogger and despite the fact that I probably come off as a rabbid fan, by the time I even heard of her, I had my fill of video bloggers; the whole lot of them. I can't tolerate any of them because they all sound self important, to me. That being said, I think she felt she had a medium and used a minute or two to address a small situation, and she really did treat it as not a huge issue, at the beginning. I think some of the responses to "don't be that guy," were over the top and I feel that it set her off and it has continued to spiral, completely out of control, from there.
 
Yes, given that you are smaller, physically weaker, and alone with a larger, stronger, and clearly horny person who wants to do you. Oh, and there is no avenue of escape if things get dicey.

Can't be overstated. One may point out that a woman can always say 'no', but the fact that they afterwards are forced to remain in a confined space in intimate proximity to a not-only-larger-stronger-and-horny-but-now-possibly-angry person for an indeterminate amount of time changes the dynamics of the situation drastically.
 
Oh come on. If we were to believe him when he said he did hear the conversation, how on earth does one NOT know that asking a woman in an elevator for "coffee" at 4AM is an euphemism for "let's have sex"?

Before today, I haven't heard a statement that he asked her for "coffee." (Not that I'd assume this was clearly a euphemism in Dublin.) It seems to be something that has arisen.

All I heard was that he said something like, "Don't take this the wrong way, but I find you interesting. Would you like to come to my room to talk more about it?" That's it.

So, now, there was "coffee," which I guess is obviously a demand for sex. But while you're at it, why not go for broke? He's not here to defend himself. Why not say that he said "I threaten you with rape, and I am going to plunge an ice pick into your forehead and dose you with Roofies and have my way with you, you bitch!"

Why not? Maybe that would be a bit too hard to sell. Still, we know that accuracy is not very important, at least to you.
 
Can't be overstated. One may point out that a woman can always say 'no', but the fact that they afterwards are forced to remain in a confined space in intimate proximity to a not-only-larger-stronger-and-horny-but-now-possibly-angry person for an indeterminate amount of time changes the dynamics of the situation drastically.

This ^

If more men had similar uncomfortable experiences, then a lot more understanding would spread, methinks.
 
Before today, I haven't heard a statement that he asked her for "coffee." (Not that I'd assume this was clearly a euphemism in Dublin.) It seems to be something that has arisen.

All I heard was that he said something like, "Don't take this the wrong way, but I find you interesting. Would you like to come to my room to talk more about it?" That's it.

So, now, there was "coffee," which I guess is obviously a demand for sex. But while you're at it, why not go for broke? He's not here to defend himself. Why not say that he said "I threaten you with rape, and I am going to plunge an ice pick into your forehead and dose you with Roofies and have my way with you, you bitch!"

Why not? Maybe that would be a bit too hard to sell. Still, we know that accuracy is not very important, at least to you.

It was mentioned in Watson's original video that started the whole discussion. You know, the video that was referenced in the original post of this thread. The OP of this thread links to one of PZ's posts, which in turn linked to the various background posts and videos.

The fact that you couldn't be bothered to inform yourself is bad enough. That you're accusing another poster of making things up simply because you, in your ignorance, "hadn't heard it before," is disgusting.
 
Uh, I guess? If your brother, or same-sex friend (assuming heterosexual dynamics here) invites you to his hotel room to talk about stuff around coffee at 4AM, it's probably not a sexual invitation, no. :P Hell, I'd even allow it for a member of the opposite sex if they know each others well, but this guy was a complete stranger.

Are you seriously suggesting that his invitation had no sexual tone? Even if he really wasn't after sex, surely he's not dumb enough to NOT realize it'd be interpreted that way? Come on now.


Unless the guy in question is Travis... :duck:
That spoiler is really mean.

I came back to this thread because of a previous post of yours. I was reading another forum and it reminded me of your earlier post. It's here. This is an aspie forum. I'll quote what I find relevant:

I could have written something just like this. No matter how old I am, or what my life situation is, it always seems like other people have some kind of natural connection to each other, and I'm not part of it. Not that I'm trying to be part of it, but sometimes I would like to, and don't know how. If I try to do what I see other people doing, I feel like an intruder. Sometimes I misread a situation and think I am considered a friend by someone, but then when I attempt to do something "friendly", like offer my phone number, I get a response that suggests I'm out of line or I'm doing something strange. Consequently, "friendships" rarely get off the ground at all.

When I was younger, one problem was that I never really knew how to convey the different messages of "I am interested in getting to know you for a possible friendship" and "I am interested in a sexual relationship." People often seemed to think I meant one when I really meant the other, and to this day I don't know what I was doing to give the wrong message. It's less of an issue now, since I'm happily married with kids, and I've got that middle-aged housewife look.

Now, it's absurd to diagnose somebody over the internet based on a second hand story, but what this guy said just drips of what I quoted above. I acknowledge I could be wrong. But yes, there are people in this world that absolutely do not get that coffee can mean 'coffee', or that by explicitly starting out by saying "I don't mean 'coffee"" (which is what the "don't take this the wrong way" meant) can still be taken as "wanna have 'coffee'". Really. Not everyone is wired the same way.

An ex-girlfriend ran a social group that was largely aspie to autistic. The elevator incident seems incredibly mild compared to the mix-ups I saw.

I don't know if this guy is in the ASD spectrum, or hitting on every woman he came across, but to insist that someone cannot make such social errors is mistaken. Labeling this as necessarily misogyny or sexism is equally mistaken. Sure, it could be (if he hits on 20 women a day, knowing he is putting them ill at ease many times). But we don't know that.
 
So you believe that only "related members of the opposite sex" (or "related members of the same sex" for that matter) are capable of a non-sexual invitation to coffee at 04:00?!

I don't think that's what Morrigan said but, especially dealing with strangers of the opposite sex, having zero history to build your opinion on his/her intent; it's rather risky to take "want to come back to my room for coffee," as purely innocent.

Put it this way, you are at a hotel with your partner (I don't know your sex/sexual preference). Your partner disappears for a few hours. When that person comes back and you inquire where they've been. How would you feel if their response was, "Oh I met <insert name typically associated with the sex that your partner prefers> in the elevator and he/she was really interesting, so we went back to his/her room for coffee and to further the conversation." Would your response honestly be, "Oh well, it was just coffee,"?
 
It was mentioned in Watson's original video that started the whole discussion. You know, the video that was referenced in the original post of this thread. The OP of this thread links to one of PZ's posts, which in turn linked to the various background posts and videos.

The fact that you couldn't be bothered to inform yourself is bad enough. That you're accusing another poster of making things up simply because you, in your ignorance, "hadn't heard it before," is disgusting.

Got me there! Hooray for you! I went back and looked at the video, and she did say "for coffee."
 
All I know is that if I run into Rebecca at TAM, I am going to invite her to my room for coffee. Not that I am at all interested in sex with her, but mostly because I have a really hard time following Phil Plait's advice.
 
All I know is that if I run into Rebecca at TAM, I am going to invite her to my room for coffee. Not that I am at all interested in sex with her, but mostly because I have a really hard time following Phil Plait's advice.


One more reason I cannot wait to get off this planet.
 
One more reason I cannot wait to get off this planet.

Oh yay! let's start a moon colony! We can base it around a huge library with so many books and little niche fireplaces and big comfy chairs and robot cleaners. To get to your living quarters, you need to move a certain bunch of books on a specific shelf in an exact fashion but nobody else has the code. (and the library is huuuuuuuge, like moon base big) so when you're in your space, there is no possible way for anyone to reach you unless you want them to.

Oh and robot chefs.
 
Oh yay! let's start a moon colony! We can base it around a huge library with so many books and little niche fireplaces and big comfy chairs and robot cleaners. To get to your living quarters, you need to move a certain bunch of books on a specific shelf in an exact fashion but nobody else has the code. (and the library is huuuuuuuge, like moon base big) so when you're in your space, there is no possible way for anyone to reach you unless you want them to.

Oh and robot chefs.

I'll bring the coffee!!

oh wait..
 
All I know is that if I run into Rebecca at TAM, I am going to invite her to my room for coffee. Not that I am at all interested in sex with her, but mostly because I have a really hard time following Phil Plait's advice.

You are sooooo getting cockblo-... ahem... I mean "coffee"-blocked at TAM.
 
That spoiler is really mean.
I know, sorry. But it's true. He admitted to having been clueless as to the social/sexual meaning behind "going for a coffee", and said that he once refused such an offer from people he would have otherwise hanged out with because he... hates the actual beverage. Everyone was pretty incredulous at his obliviousness.

Still, it was a cheap shot and I kinda feel bad now. :o

I don't know if this guy is in the ASD spectrum, or hitting on every woman he came across, but to insist that someone cannot make such social errors is mistaken. Labeling this as necessarily misogyny or sexism is equally mistaken. Sure, it could be (if he hits on 20 women a day, knowing he is putting them ill at ease many times). But we don't know that.
Oh, I don't really know for sure if he was sexist or misogynist what. Perhaps he really was an Aspie, or hopelessly clueless. Perhaps he hadn't heard her previous talk, but pretended he did when hitting on her, not knowing it'd be particularly offensive in this context. Still, based on the few facts that I have, I find it more likely that he was just an ass.

Still no reason, IMO, to make a big deal out of the whole thing. But that's the memesphere Internet for you. :)

The fact that you couldn't be bothered to inform yourself is bad enough. That you're accusing another poster of making things up simply because you, in your ignorance, "hadn't heard it before," is disgusting.
[...]
Feel free to apologize to Morrigan any time now.
Haha. Thanks man, appreciate it. And yeah it was mentioned all over the thread anyway... kinda hard to miss it.
 
Last edited:
Well, I cant claim to be an expert on culture or euphemisms in Dublin but I do know its not part of the UK !

However as I understand the prevailing mores, from a couple of visits, if a guy asks a woman to join him for coffee at 4 am when there is 'drink' available then he is either weird, a tourist or wants to rob her.

Not sure if this helps to resolve the conundrum.
 
Edited by jhunter1163: 
Edited for Rule 9. Inappropriate for the public section.


My wife read through this and swore she'd never join the forum. :(
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom