So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's the question that people are disagreeing on the answer to -- not whether or not Watson should have felt uncomfortable, but whether or not the behavior itself was objectionable.

In either case, I don't think disagreeing with someone on the answer to that question is the same as arguing that she shouldn't feel uncomfortable in that situation.

Then I don't think we are reading the same thread because what I've read was that Rebecca overreacts, she's an attention whore, and she needs to get over herself, those are what I feel should be addressed. It's the attitude of, "It doesn't bother me so it shouldn't bother her."

I still haven't heard an answer from you, though. Is following someone into confined quarters (in this case, an elevator) and then propositioning them (notice I did not say hitting on them) to come back to your room, reasonably creepy?
 
Last edited:
Gosh talk about something getting out of hand? I've never seen a more irrational bunch of people than I have in the 'sceptical world' of the internet!
 
Not if the person is interested. And they can be for any number of reasons.

I know a guy who actually succeeded with the pickup line, "You have the nicest set of tits I've ever seen." That doesn't mean that it's one I would recommend using.
 
Look, I don't know or care enough about the infamous elevator encounter to have an opinion on what it means, or what it says about anyone involved, or what all the discussion says about sexism or sexual assault.

What I do know is that I teach Middle School now and the tenor of this discussion fall at approximately the seventh grade level.

Really? Kids these days!
Listen - what you've missed is that before the elevator got to the second floor Rebecca was expounding on how it's hard to tell if the lift is accelerating or being pulled upwards by a gravitational singularity on the roof. It's called the "My opinion is more equivalent than your'n principle."
 
I know a guy who actually succeeded with the pickup line, "You have the nicest set of tits I've ever seen." That doesn't mean that it's one I would recommend using.

I think the all-time award for comedic brass in that department goes to Chico Marx.

This is from a story told by Didck Cavett.

Cavett interviewed Groucho Marx a couple of times and they became friends. Groucho told him a story about Chico Marx, who was evidently a great ladies man. There was a party for Tallulah Bankhead and Chico pleaded with Groucho to take him to the party because he really wanted to meet Bankhead. Groucho warned Chico, “Be a gentleman because she’s a lady, and I stress the word “lady.” Chico assured him, “Hey, I’m a gentleman, don’t worry about it.” So they went to the party and Chico meets Bankhead and says, “I’d like to **** you Miss Bankhead.” And Bankhead replies, “And so you shall, you old-fashioned boy.”
 
Then I don't think we are reading the same thread because what I've read was that Rebecca overreacts, she's an attention whore, and she needs to get over herself, those are what I feel should be addressed. It's the attitude of, "It doesn't bother me so it shouldn't bother her."

Well that isn't my attitude sgtbaker. I do think this has spiralled out of control, and Rebecca has 'gained the most' from all the attention (so far). But my attitude is not that it doesn't bother me, so it shouldn't bother her.

I have been very clear that what happened to her was unfortunate and uncomfortable for her. I don't support harrassing types of behaviour, and the one takeaway from this should be for people to consider appropriate decorum when inviting others for coffee or coffee 'plus'.

People who aren't public figures usually take an unfortunate situation and go home to think about it. Maybe they make it a topic of discussion on an online thread and get some thoughts about it.

When public figures post youtube talking head videos, take the opportunity to use a public speaking forum to carry on the rant, and then fan the flames across multiple internet fora and media sites, calling for essentially public boycotts of other public figures, days before another public appearance where it just so happens most of those other media sites have representatives in attendance and all stand to benefit peripherally, if only from perhaps a few more foum members, facebook friends or twitter followers... methinks the lady doth protest a wee bit too much.

That said - she IS a public figure. If this had happened to Oprah or Paris Hilton I would expect a similar media management strategy.
 
I think the all-time award for comedic brass in that department goes to Chico Marx.

This is from a story told by Didck Cavett.

Cavett interviewed Groucho Marx a couple of times and they became friends. Groucho told him a story about Chico Marx, who was evidently a great ladies man. There was a party for Tallulah Bankhead and Chico pleaded with Groucho to take him to the party because he really wanted to meet Bankhead. Groucho warned Chico, “Be a gentleman because she’s a lady, and I stress the word “lady.” Chico assured him, “Hey, I’m a gentleman, don’t worry about it.” So they went to the party and Chico meets Bankhead and says, “I’d like to **** you Miss Bankhead.” And Bankhead replies, “And so you shall, you old-fashioned boy.”

That is an approach that often works quite well. Talking about it seems to make women uncomfortable. However, it does work.
 
I don't think rebecca's fears in the elevator were 'hysterical', and I don't think it's an unreasonable request that men not hit up women to 'come to their room' in an elevator or similar situation where a woman can't immediately remove herself from the situation for whatever reason she chooses. I think Dawkins' initial cavalier dismissal of Rebecca's concerns and feelings about the situation were thoughtless and his subsequent attempts to claim that his initial response wasn't a cavalier dismissal to be pathetic.

Anything I haven't covered?
 
Skeptic Ginger said:
I see that now.

I'm always amazed when someone picks an odd topic like this one to be motivated to finally speak up after 7 years of mostly quiet.

It seems to be one that arouses surprisingly strong responses from people all across the internet, not just this board.
 
Do you believe him, or not?
If you believe him -- then he wanted to continue the conversation over coffee, and didn't want her to misinterpret his interest as sexual. That is, he wasn't sexualizing her.
If you don't believe him -- then what evidence do you have that he heard her say that she didn't like being sexualized?

Oh come on. If we were to believe him when he said he did hear the conversation, how on earth does one NOT know that asking a woman in an elevator for "coffee" at 4AM is an euphemism for "let's have sex"? Especially after the lady has said she was tired and wanted to go to bed? If he was sincere about just wanting to talk, he would have said "let's discuss this again tomorrow" or something.

I mean, asking an unrelated member of the opposite sex for coffee obviously does mean more than just having coffee, especially at 4AM after being in a bar.

That's why I'm saying it seems like the guy was just trolling her.

But even if he DIDN'T hear her talk, then it means he's lying about wanting to continue the discussion (after all, what discussion would that be?), and so he's not sincere and just wants to get in her pants in a lame and unsubtle way.
 
I mean, asking an unrelated member of the opposite sex for coffee obviously does mean more than just having coffee, especially at 4AM after being in a bar.
So you believe that only "related members of the opposite sex" (or "related members of the same sex" for that matter) are capable of a non-sexual invitation to coffee at 04:00?!
 
Uh, I guess? If your brother, or same-sex friend (assuming heterosexual dynamics here) invites you to his hotel room to talk about stuff around coffee at 4AM, it's probably not a sexual invitation, no. :P Hell, I'd even allow it for a member of the opposite sex if they know each others well, but this guy was a complete stranger.

Are you seriously suggesting that his invitation had no sexual tone? Even if he really wasn't after sex, surely he's not dumb enough to NOT realize it'd be interpreted that way? Come on now.


Unless the guy in question is Travis... :duck:
 
Last edited:
Then I don't think we are reading the same thread because what I've read was that Rebecca overreacts, she's an attention whore, and she needs to get over herself, those are what I feel should be addressed. It's the attitude of, "It doesn't bother me so it shouldn't bother her."

I still haven't heard an answer from you, though. Is following someone into confined quarters (in this case, an elevator) and then propositioning them (notice I did not say hitting on them) to come back to your room, reasonably creepy?

Yes, given that you are smaller, physically weaker, and alone with a larger, stronger, and clearly horny person who wants to do you. Oh, and there is no avenue of escape if things get dicey.

Under similar conditions, I'd be more than a little nervous.

The trouble is that most men don't have this perspective because they've always been on the "hunter" end of things; as such, they have no idea what it is like to be the "prey". Most times, it isn't a good feeling.

AvalonXQ, for a way of relating to how women feel under these circumstances, take a few to read my blog post on the matter. As a man (I assume you're male), it should give you something to think about before you blithely dismiss the concerns of women regarding situations such as these.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom