Fair enough, she over uses the term. I can certainly understand scrutinizing her use of the term in every case because she seems so generous with it. However, overusing a term, certainly does not equate to never getting it right.
Even a stopped clock is right twice a day.
There are plenty of people on this board that toss out accusations of logical fallacies far more often than fitting but that doesn't mean that they are never correct in identifying one. If you honestly don't feel that it's possible that RD is speaking from a priviledged position, I am more than happy to agree to disagree but simply saying he's not because she over uses the term is not an argument that stands on it's own merrit.
You don't understand me. I don't want to get into the argument at all. I don't think that getting into a discussion about what someone else using a word that Watson used might mean if they said it. It might be perfectly appropriate in some other discussion, but not this one.
Part of such a discussion would be on how lucky Watson is to have been born White in the West, with the wherewithal to maintain a residence in London, and the great fortune of getting her expenses paid (and maybe an honorarium or two) to speak at so many conventions, including one at a really nice and safe hotel in a major European city, not to mention not ever having to work at a job that gave her calluses or shortened her life.
That makes her more privileged than just about everybody on the planet, male or female. It would be at least fair. Would that fly in this discussion?
I don't think so. One of the reasons is that this is all being interpreted in the context of a certain kind of feminism, in which male
versus female is so overriding that it eclipses class, cultural, racial, and national differences.
One could also re-interpret Dawkins' statement to be pointing this out, but that also has not been done much
in this thread, and it also is for another thread (which exists but has not had the legs of this one).
So, I'd prefer to discuss what Watson has actually said and done, and what the meaning of this is within the context of other things she's said and done.
I've been restraining myself from saying a lot about Watson's privilege. However, I could start if you want to talk about Dawkins' privilege, or the privilege of all males. I'm sure I could come up with some really pithy stuff. There was some of this earlier, but I think we've gotten beyond that, and I think the discussion is better for it.
Do you want to go there? I'd just as soon not, as there is plenty else to discuss, even at this late date. However, I am willing to oblige.