So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
It just occured to me that EG might not have even been consciously sexualizing RW. Some inexperienced men have a very "logical" -- but absurd in the real world -- way of thinking about how to approach women.

It might well be EG, to judge from his blundering approach, was thinking all week what he would say to RW if they get a moment alone. Naturally he could not imagine how to ever achieve this incredible goal of finding a minute to be alone with a woman he likes on his own. Naturally, the possiblity of going to RW and ASKING her to speak to her privately probably never occurred to him, or else he considered it beyond his abilities.

But this didn't stop him from fantasizing. What does one DO when one is attracted to a woman, if by chance this rare beast is somehow cornered? Why, in all those Hollywood movies he tells her how attracted he is to her and she smiles and accepts him. It must work like that in real life, too!

So when he found RW in an elevator at 4 AM, he couldn't believe his luck. Clearly, the fates had determined that they want him to be alone with her -- and they ARE alone in that elevator at 4 in the morning, aren't they? Clearly, a perfectly appropriate situation, since the movies never seem to mention any other preconditions except for the two being alone. Naturally he used his one-and-only chance to fire his one-and-only known pick-up line.

Why she reacted like she did, I am sure he to this day does not understand: he did everything right, just like in the movies, didn't he?

That's lovely. Here's another scenario:

Knowing Watson by reputation only he decides that reputation implies a very casual attitude toward sex and a tendency towards binge drinking. So EG waited until Watson was (hopefully) drunk enough to sleep with him and then followed her into the elevator in order to get her into his hotel room for sex while she was incapacitated by alcohol.

I'm not saying that's what happened or that I have any evidence for that. Only that it is as possible as your scenario. We have no reason to assume that EG was just a poor bumbling fool when there is equal evidence that he was a polite opportunist. The truth is probably something else entirely.
 
Last edited:
So you don't think RW's comments about McGraw were wrong then?

Did you ever read McGraw's comments? And you think saying EG didn't seem that bad was hyperbole?

No but why the loaded question? It wasn't EG didn't seem that bad, it was

My concern is that she takes issue with a man showing interest in her.

Really? A good question would be; in what manner? She gave that criteria with excludes all situations where a man takes interest in her. Why is McGraw even concerned with how or when RW prefers to be hit on? Even if RW said no one hit on me ever again; why is that a concern for McGraw?

How on earth does that justify him as creepy?

She didn't call him creepy, she said it creeps her out and makes her uncomfortable when men sexualize her in that manner. Saying a particular behavior creeps you out is not the same as calling someone creepy.

Someone who truly abides by feminist principles would, in my view, have to react in the same manner were the situation reversed; if a woman were to engage a man in the same way, she would probably be creeping him out and making him uncomfortable and unfairly sexualizing him, right? But of course no one ever makes that claim, which is why I see Watson's comment as so hypocritical.

She states that RW would probably not have a problem if the situation was reversed (meaning she doesn't really know for sure if RW would or wouldn't have a problem) and then says that it's the reason she sees RWs comments as hypocritical? Sorry, that does not follow.

If you really want social equality for women, which is what feminism is, why not apply the same standards to men and women, and stop demonizing men for being sexual beings?

Where did she demonize men for being sexual beings?
 
The ad hom, in itself, cannot tear down the opponents argument, but if the ad hom is a legitimate questioning as to the perspective of the opponent and not just an attack on the opponent, it is acceptable, even in debates. Which is why I said she had a point, not that she made a valid argument. I really do feel that there is a difference between being made uncomfortable by someone else's attention being directed at you and someone's oblivious existence annoying you. If she had followed through on that aspect of it, I think she could have formulated a much better argument.
Thanks but I'm going to have to disagree. I'm not saying it's never appropriate but I think at best it is rarely appropriate and I honestly find it very disappointing in this context. But I'm happy to agree to disagree. If you are going to use ad hominem I'd suggest you do it rarely (which I surmise by your post you would agree with). :)
 
Thank you for seriously clearing this up, I now have a different understanding of the issue. Note, that nowhere in the video did she mention any of this.

Understandable. It is one of the most difficult things about discussing this. Information has only slowly come out. It is rather difficult to keep track of all the relevant points, which is why I published the timeline. I built it first as a tool for me to keep track and then figured out that it would be useful for others.

Note that this is why people who have been in the thread for a long time lose patience with newcomers. There's all this stuff that we've hashed and rehashed already.

There are two, opposite dangers:

1) Not applying subsequent statements enough.
2) Applying subsequent statements too much.

It's tricky to get right. I try to argue against both, which can also be confusing.

I have no problem with the fact she made this assumption, but originally based on her words; she gave almost no conclusive evidence as to how the event went down. And therefore, everyone had the right to be skeptical of her allegations.

That's correct, and I think that this significantly affects how McGraw and st Clair originally reacted.

I also have to note that amongst us old-timers, nearly everybody has developed an opinion of Watson almost entirely on the basis of these subsequent events. The original incident is about as important to that as the species of apple tree in Newton's garden is to his law of gravitation. The only reason we're talking about the original incident is that newcomers are talking about it, so it's either respond to that or do not participate at all.
 
I do, however think she had a point with her "privileged" accusation. It is easy for RD to be dismissive because he will probably never have that type of experience. I doubt he has to worry much, about being overpowered and sexually assaulted.

That's a strange assertion, and I've been scratching my head over it. Perhaps you have forgotten that previously, Watson had made the same "privilege" accusation toward Paula Kirby, who is not a man.

It seems to me much more likely that "privilege" is just some word that Watson uses in lieu of argumentation.
 
That's a strange assertion, and I've been scratching my head over it. Perhaps you have forgotten that previously, Watson had made the same "privilege" accusation toward Paula Kirby, who is not a man.

It seems to me much more likely that "privilege" is just some word that Watson uses in lieu of argumentation.

I thought she accused Kirby of using an argument from ignorance; I've never experienced it so it didn't happen. Am I remembering that wrong?
 
Thanks but I'm going to have to disagree. I'm not saying it's never appropriate but I think at best it is rarely appropriate and I honestly find it very disappointing in this context. But I'm happy to agree to disagree. If you are going to use ad hominem I'd suggest you do it rarely (which I surmise by your post you would agree with). :)

When discussing how something feels to one in a situation, it isn't an ad-hom to note that some will have different experiences than others. Now how valid a formal argument holds up is different. It doesn't depend on the experiences of the advocate and must stand on it's own. I think that is where some of the disconnect lies.
 
I thought she accused Kirby of using an argument from ignorance; I've never experienced it so it didn't happen. Am I remembering that wrong?

She said "In skepticism, we call that the argument from ignorance, and in feminism, we call that the argument from privilege." This is from memory, so I may have gotten some of the connecting words wrong, but she definitely mentioned both the arguments from ignorance and privilege.

If Kirby has privileges, then they are probably the same kinds of privileges that Watson herself enjoys. They are probably quantitatively less, in fact. Watson seems to enjoy greater popularity with less talent than Kirby.

In any event, Watson's shotgun use of the accusation seems to me far too indiscriminate to interpret it as a point, as she uses the term. I suppose that someone could make a point about real privilege (of which Watson has a great deal), but not Watson, and to find a point in that particular blather seems rather overgenerous to her.

Similarly, I don't react very strongly when she uses terms like "misogynist," nor do I try to find a point, because I know it has nothing to do with misogyny. I learned that during the 1980s and 1990s. Whiny, naive feminist calls people misogynists. Film at eleven.
 
Of course, you are not alone. We seem to regularly get passerbys who come in to tell us that they don't see why anyone is making such a fuss over her actions that night, or over her video blog on the matter. And we patiently explain that none of the complaints or discussion here centred around those actions, which we all seem to agree weren't particularly remarkable. It does get a tad tedious to have to do this over and over again.

Linda
There is only one thing I know of that isn't tedious to do over and over again ... come to think of it, that's what the skepchick site thought it was using as nerd bait. :p
 
Based on what I know now I doubt he wasn't trying to take her back to his place to beat it up.
Does "beat it up" mean "try to slide salami into the slot" or something else? Modern jargon is often lost on me. :confused:
I agree that Watson also talked about being made uncomfortable by sexualization.
Odd, I hear Jeff Goldblum is making another film, this one called "Skepchicks are Easy" which will hit Net Flicks sooner than it will an Oscar red carpet. :p
I for one will not let the terrorists win. If my way of life is threatened and I need to walk in the elevator and say "nice calves" I'll do it. I'm a good citizen.
I shall raise a flag for you tomorrow morning, since Sept 13 is international "I love shapely calves" day.
Knowing Watson by reputation only he decides that reputation implies a very casual attitude toward sex and a tendency towards binge drinking. So EG waited until Watson was (hopefully) drunk enough to sleep with him and then followed her into the elevator in order to get her into his hotel room for sex while she was incapacitated by alcohol.
Could be. If that was the case, he fumbled the ball, and turned it over to the other team. Too bad. He and Tony Romo may have gone to the same college.

DR
 
This just out. Watson thinks that the Church executed Galileo: ---


In Watson's defence, although it's true Galileo wasn't executed, he was placed under house arrest for the last eight years of his life, which at times must have felt like execution (since we must never minimize how anyone feels, feeling like you've been executed is effectively the same as being executed; thus, when Watson says Galileo was executed, she may be wrong as a matter of fact, but, less trivially, as a matter of feeling, she couldn't be righter). Moreover, it's said towards the end of his life the great scientist suffered from several ailments, including, one imagines, constipation: recall his lament: "E pur si no muove." Poor Galileo. Whole days on the toilet seat without movement, so miserable he might have wished he had been executed, whence another source of the false belief he was executed. Historians of science refer to those having this false belief, like Watson, as suffering from the privy ledge delusion. :boxedin:
 
In Watson's defence, although it's true Galileo wasn't executed, he was placed under house arrest for the last eight years of his life, which at times must have felt like execution (since we must never minimize how anyone feels, feeling like you've been executed is effectively the same as being executed; thus, when Watson says Galileo was executed, she may be wrong as a matter of fact, but, less trivially, as a matter of feeling, she couldn't be righter). Moreover, it's said towards the end of his life the great scientist suffered from several ailments, including, one imagines, constipation: recall his lament: "E pur si no muove." Poor Galileo. Whole days on the toilet seat without movement, so miserable he might have wished he had been executed, whence another source of the false belief he was executed. Historians of science refer to those having this false belief, like Watson, as suffering from the privy ledge delusion. :boxedin:
In her defense? Puhleese.

If you want to defend her ignorance at least do it by defending the point she was making. That was legit and well worth the comments she made. Perry has recently been accused by the arson investigator, who was replaced by Perry, of replacing him because he (the arson investigator) found sloppy science in the conviction of the executed man. Perry had the opportunity to say the science is not correct, we cannot execute a man based on totally discredited forensic science. Instead, Perry chose to have the chief investigator replaced. Can you imagine, covering up the fact an innocent man was executed for political reasons?

I would have more respect for Watson had she video blogged about an injustice that scientific evidence exposed. Instead, she video blogged about herself, name dropping, and milking her attendance at Dragoncon. That part of the video simply reinforced my negative opinion of her.
 
In her defense? Puhleese. ...


Yes, thahaaank you, in her defence. :mad:

People often confuse feelings with fact. It's more common than one might think, largely because it can go for years without proper diagnosis and treatment.

This video reveals in no uncertain terms that Watson is suffering from the privy ledge delusion. Rather than quibbling over minor facts like whether she is or not, I feel it behooves us as a community to rally round and support her in her time of need.
 
In her defense? Puhleese.

If you want to defend her ignorance at least do it by defending the point she was making. That was legit and well worth the comments she made. Perry has recently been accused by the arson investigator, who was replaced by Perry, of replacing him because he (the arson investigator) found sloppy science in the conviction of the executed man. Perry had the opportunity to say the science is not correct, we cannot execute a man based on totally discredited forensic science. Instead, Perry chose to have the chief investigator replaced. Can you imagine, covering up the fact an innocent man was executed for political reasons?

I would have more respect for Watson had she video blogged about an injustice that scientific evidence exposed. Instead, she video blogged about herself, name dropping, and milking her attendance at Dragoncon. That part of the video simply reinforced my negative opinion of her.


Joke































Your head​


:D
 

Not to mention difficulty distinguishing between these two guys:

galileo.jpg


art.vert.willingham.face.jpg


because they both have beards, maybe.
 
Does "beat it up" mean "try to slide salami into the slot" or something else? Modern jargon is often lost on me. :confused:

It means to give someone really rough and pleasurable intercourse. It was developed in the African American community during the late 80s/ early 90s after streams of our R n B and hip hop artists coined the term and used it.
 
It means to give someone really rough and pleasurable intercourse. It was developed in the African American community during the late 80s/ early 90s after streams of our R n B and hip hop artists coined the term and used it.

Cool. I learned something new. Not sure I'm going to be able to use it in casual conversation, though...

Linda
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom