So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nice gross misrepresentation of the furor in the USA Today article. I wonder who was responsible for that?

Linda

Considering this is McNewspaper we're talking about, they did a better job than they usually do. At least they mentioned relevant people like Annie Laurie Gaylor.
 
Considering this is McNewspaper we're talking about, they did a better job than they usually do. At least they mentioned relevant people like Annie Laurie Gaylor.

Yeah, I thought they did a decent job of going on to talk about women in skepticism.

Linda
 
Disappointing. It's unfortunate that the story is spun so narrowly in the USA piece. There is apparently only one way to see the story. And no, the incident is nothing like RW and EG as EG didn't keep it going and then called RW an epithet.

There are similarities discussed--I agree that is a crucial difference.

Taking the conversation out of public eyes. The “interest” in her work that is entirely trumped by the come-on. The idea that a hint of sexuality, once public, trumps a woman’s preference to not be sexual in a particular context, unironically paired with the accusations of prudery. The idea that the unwelcome come-on from a stranger would be welcome from an attractive stranger.
These were definitely here in the RW mess and a good encapsulation of everything I didn't like about the response. Note that there were plenty of criticisms of RW that were better than these--these were just the bad ones.
 
Last edited:
.... Nice gross misrepresentation of the furor in the USA Today article. I wonder who was responsible for that?

Linda
It seemed that the author rearranged a lot of facts to make the story into something it wasn't. She has the women siding with Watson and the men complaining about women whining. And she fails to note the 'rape you' emails had nothing whatsoever to do to with responding to the elevator video blog.
Many women told of receiving unwanted sexual advances at freethinker gatherings. Some men, meanwhile, ridiculed Watson as overly sensitive or worse — or threatened her with rape, mutilation and murder.
She then goes on to say we are now pondering our membership gender imbalance as if no one ever noticed or thought about it before.

I rate the accuracy of the story about a 2 on a scale of 1-10 with 10 being accurate. It's amazing to me how so very different people interpret the same evidence in the same Universe.


I haven't read PZ's blog yet.
 
There are similarities discussed--I agree that is a crucial difference.

These were definitely here in the RW mess and a good encapsulation of everything I didn't like about the response. Note that there were plenty of criticisms of RW that were better than these--these were just the bad ones.

I missed those comparisons, but I agree in response to whoever did that, I wouldn't like it either.

Linda
 
Ironically, the impression I gained of Rebecca when she was a member here was that she frequently sexualized non-sexual situations, and that she manipulated people via sexuality.
 
I could explain where these tweets overlap with the fallout from elevatorgate. I could even explain why some women will respond to reading those screen-caps with immediate, personal, exasperation.

And the reactions will play out the same way- everybody will scramble all over themselves to explain how nobody has any reason to be discomforted. And the irony will make my head asplode.
 
I could explain where these tweets overlap with the fallout from elevatorgate. I could even explain why some women will respond to reading those screen-caps with immediate, personal, exasperation.

And the reactions will play out the same way- everybody will scramble all over themselves to explain how nobody has any reason to be discomforted. And the irony will make my head asplode.
Many of us, myself included, have said RW had every right to feel discomfort and others had every right to agree with her. I know of no one who doesn't feel that way. Further, the individual in the story also has every right to feel discomfort as do others reading the screen caps and everyone has every right to express how they feel.

It's really unfair when you paint with broad brush strokes and create straw men.

I don't understand how we can have such a lengthy discussion and that still is not understood.
 
Last edited:
Many of us, myself included, have said RW had every right to feel discomfort and others had every right to agree with her. I know of no one who doesn't feel that way. Further, the individual in the story also has every right to feel discomfort as do others reading the screen caps and everyone has every right to express how they feel.

It's really unfair when you paint with broad brush strokes and create straw men.

I don't understand how we can have such a lengthy discussion and that still is not understood.

The word used was "reason", it's even italicised for emphasis. So I don't think bookitty's the only one creating strawmen.
 
Many of us, myself included, have said RW had every right to feel discomfort and others had every right to agree with her. I know of no one who doesn't feel that way. Further, the individual in the story also has every right to feel discomfort as do others reading the screen caps and everyone has every right to express how they feel.

It's really unfair when you paint with broad brush strokes and create straw men.

I don't understand how we can have such a lengthy discussion and that still is not understood.

Orly?

You guys have served up over 90 freaking pages about how elevators are safe and therefore Watson had no reason to feel discomforted by EG. With a heaping side of "It doesn't bother me, so it shouldn't bother Watson."
 
Orly?

You guys have served up over 90 freaking pages about how elevators are safe and therefore Watson had no reason to feel discomforted by EG. With a heaping side of "It doesn't bother me, so it shouldn't bother Watson."
Orly?

Well then you will have no problem quoting me then.
 
Orly?

You guys have served up over 90 freaking pages about how elevators are safe and therefore Watson had no reason to feel discomforted by EG. With a heaping side of "It doesn't bother me, so it shouldn't bother Watson."

You've read this entire thread, and that's your understanding of what it's all about? Nothing about assessing the timeline of secondary events, Watson acting the bully and attributing unwitting misogyny to anyone who disagrees with her, whether or not Watson has the right to ask all men not to behave this way toward all women, whether or not EG actually intended a sexual advance, how widespread come-ons are at skeptic conventions, why Watson was banned from this forum, Watson's hypocrisy involving sexualization, the definitions of objectifying and sexualizing... And I could go on.
We have one or two lines of argument about how skeptics are asserting the danger of elevators without evidence, and a line of argument (mostly discredited even by those generally critical of Watson) that Watson's discomfort was unwarranted, and apparently that's all you read here?
You seem to be unwilling to examine any line of discussion that might lead to criticism of Watson or any of the hateful things done by her or her supporters.
 
Randfan said:
Many of us, myself included, have said RW had every right to feel discomfort and others had every right to agree with her. I know of no one who doesn't feel that way. Further, the individual in the story also has every right to feel discomfort as do others reading the screen caps and everyone has every right to express how they feel.
Orly?

You guys have served up over 90 freaking pages about how elevators are safe and therefore Watson had no reason to feel discomforted by EG. With a heaping side of "It doesn't bother me, so it shouldn't bother Watson."

You've spent about the same number of pages refusing to distinguish between a right and a reason (under skepticism).

You, for instance, have the right to believe that shaken water will cure whatever ails you, but it doesn't mean that it's accurate, and it doesn't mean that your belief would be grounded in fact. Some skeptics care about that distinction.
 
You've read this entire thread, and that's your understanding of what it's all about? Nothing about assessing the timeline of secondary events, Watson acting the bully and attributing unwitting misogyny to anyone who disagrees with her, whether or not Watson has the right to ask all men not to behave this way toward all women, whether or not EG actually intended a sexual advance, how widespread come-ons are at skeptic conventions, why Watson was banned from this forum, Watson's hypocrisy involving sexualization, the definitions of objectifying and sexualizing... And I could go on.
We have one or two lines of argument about how skeptics are asserting the danger of elevators without evidence, and a line of argument (mostly discredited even by those generally critical of Watson) that Watson's discomfort was unwarranted, and apparently that's all you read here?
You seem to be unwilling to examine any line of discussion that might lead to criticism of Watson or any of the hateful things done by her or her supporters.

Yes, you do go on.

And, if I were so included, I could bullet point your diatribe but I ask you, with absolutely zero sarcasm, why should I? What will change?
 
Yes, you do go on.

And, if I were so included, I could bullet point your diatribe but I ask you, with absolutely zero sarcasm, why should I? What will change?

They go on? Now there's a pot calling the kettle black.
 
Orly?

Well then you will have no problem quoting me then.

You were the guy who linked to The Culture of Fear, right? Because we all need to get over all of our irrational fears. You know, like elevators...

And if you're asking me to go back over 97 pages for exact quotes, no. Jumping through hoops is icky.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom