So we can see here clearly that a lot of straw men were being thrown at her. Her point wasn't about guys picking up girls in general, but in that manner.
It wasn't about sexualization in general, but specifically in that manner.
It wasn't about misogamy in general, but sexualizing in that manner.
So all these straw man refutations of her point have to be thrown out, by her own words.
I'm not questioning that, at all. There is one assertion that remains and is not a straw men, and that is that she addressed "guys" in general, even though the original vlog was very much of the "one bad apple" variety. This does have some meaning, which I could argue is that if the evidence is that this behavior is rare, then a shotgun approach is probably suboptimal.
Still, you are right. It doesn't support any of these ideas that you have listed.
As an aside, I hope you mean "misogyny" rather than "misogamy." I'm a misogamist, though it would probably be more accurate to say that I'm a mismonogamist. At least, I don't like marriage, but I dislike monogamy more than polygamy. I'm not a misogynist, and if I were, I probably wouldn't be able to tolerate being poly.
As far as the danger being felt - she said this herself in the comment trail for the video not soon after. I don't think she or anybody forgets uncomfortable events that quickly, and I don't think she was lying, due to I know that she talked previously about getting rape threats. And so it's easy for me to believe this is never far from her mind.
See, this is my problem.
Person A criticizes Watson. She therefore applies what Watson subsequently said. She says that Watson really meant "objectification" when she said "sexualization," which is a much stronger and more condemning word, to make it look that Watson was saying something stronger. (This has happened in this thread, and it involved straw men of me, but I won't name names because it was much earlier and I don't want another pointless derail.)
Person B defends Watson. He therefore applies what Watson subsequently said. He says that Watson was really afraid of assault, to make it look that Watson was saying something more defensible.
How can I tell the difference, such that I am compelled to conclude that A has more basis in fact than B, or
vice versa? All I can see is that in both cases, mapping what Watson said later onto what Watson said earlier is tactically similar, given the positions. It seems pretty
ad hoc to me.
You introduce the idea that B is more real than A because of what Watson previously said about sexism and rape and so on and so forth. This doesn't help me, though, because someone could (and people have) pointed out additional things that Watson has said that were about sexualization, and the fact that she has flagrantly used sexualization to promote herself.
But don't accuse me of making a straw man just yet. There's one thing that you did report that merits attention:
in that manner (your bold). OK, but in what matter?
Watson gave us three data: in an elevator, at 4 AM, after the bar, and in a "foreign country."
Well, "in an elevator" doesn't mean much. Watson goes to a lot of conferences. They involve hotels and elevators, and I'm sure a lot happens in those elevators, including women carrying Watson-approved two-foot "angry vaginas," which I guess could make nobody feel uncomfortable.
"4 AM" and "after the bar" also don't mean much. That's where Watson is.
So that leaves "foreign country." Well, is being in Ireland really a lot more "foreign" than being in Las Vegas after the body shots at the Bordello party? Is it really a lot more dangerous? Is this obvious to people? I don't want to have this come down to the idea that the Irish are all green and short and talk like James Joyce.
But I totally agree with you: I wish she had handled her response to McGraw, etc. better. And I wish she had eplained the incident and her feelings about it better using better words. That indeed would have thwarted a lot of the negative feedback.
I wouldn't even go that far. I'm really terrible at telling people what they should do, let alone what they should have done.
But she did it the way she did it, and my point is
that is what people are reacting to. The only reason that most people talk about the original incident at all is that there is a small minority who only talk about that, and so it gets talked about. I think I understand why they do this: there is an obvious sophistic advantage to divert attention away from what people really object to in order to paint a picture of the bad penis-weilders oppressing poor Rebecca Watson.