So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well if you insist ... I was not the first or only one to take your post as it was written. So now you are just making things up to insult me. But don't worry, I don't care. :)

Maybe your need to insert the words "STRAW MAN" into my post in multiple spots should be a clue that my posts weren't referring to whatever it is you have decided you need to go on about?

Linda
 
A lot of people have decided that what she said later clarified what she really had meant earlier. Even people I've agreed with have done it.

This might work, but only given the assumption that Watson has a great deal of integrity and honesty as well as a great memory.

I don't do this for a couple of reasons. One of these is an opinion, albeit I think as reasonable as any and better than many. The other is a plain fact.

Opinion: I do not think that Watson has shown much integrity and honesty. I think the idea that her tale grew in the telling, probably because she wanted attention (which she has admitted to), is at least as probable as the idea that what she said later was really what she meant earlier.

Fact: The concern for almost everybody, started with Watson's calling out of McGraw, which was after McGraw made her blog entry. At the time McGraw made her blog entry, none of the subsequent statements had been made yet. Therefore, what Watson originally said is essential to understanding what happened. If Watson had said something different, then perhaps McGraw would have reacted differently. Perhaps this whole brouhaha would not have happened at all, and at least it would have played out very differently.

You can come up with some sort of gestalt idea of what she really meant, and while it might make some sense in retrospect, it does not affect what people were dealing with at the time, and all of the history is based on what people were dealing with at the time.

Yeah I hear you about some of her responses to what she said on the video. And I agree with you that she could have done better with McGraw, etc.

But we don't have to guess what she meant. First we can simply listen to what she said in the video about the elevator event:

"You know, I don't really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I'll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4 AM, in a hotel elevator, with you, just you, and - don't invite me back to your hotel room right after I finish talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner..."


So we can see here clearly that a lot of straw men were being thrown at her. Her point wasn't about guys picking up girls in general, but in that manner.

It wasn't about sexualization in general, but specifically in that manner.

It wasn't about misogamy in general, but sexualizing in that manner.

So all these straw man refutations of her point have to be thrown out, by her own words.

As far as the danger being felt - she said this herself in the comment trail for the video not soon after. I don't think she or anybody forgets uncomfortable events that quickly, and I don't think she was lying, due to I know that she talked previously about getting rape threats. And so it's easy for me to believe this is never far from her mind.

But I totally agree with you: I wish she had handled her response to McGraw, etc. better. And I wish she had eplained the incident and her feelings about it better using better words. That indeed would have thwarted a lot of the negative feedback.
 
Maybe your need to insert the words "STRAW MAN" into my post in multiple spots should be a clue that my posts weren't referring to whatever it is you have decided you need to go on about?

Linda

lol, so now you want to claim you were inserting straw men in your post to BS up the thread and trick me, CaveMonster, Dunstan, and Monkety Ghost into taking you at your face value? Talk about screwing around with a thread.

If that was the case then why did you respond again about it, seriously to Monketey Ghost? Why didn't you just say haha got you? Instead you seriously responded to him and tried to clarify your point:

I totally get the part where she felt uncomfortable.

It didn't seem to form the basis for her complaint, though. Maybe I'm wrong. I just got the impression that it was something about hitting on her which was objectionable. The time and place just made it a bit creepy. Otherwise, why bring all the stuff about sexual attraction vs. objectification?

Linda

Sorry, but it just doesn't wash. It's alright to be wrong sometimes and admit it you know. We are all humans, not Gods. :) Have a good night.

PS But if you want to continue to claim that your first post and your follow up posts (there were more then one) were all a ruse to play a joke on us and you never let us in on it, then I will just apologize and admit I was wrong about your posts. We are all humans, not Gods. I hope you will forgive me. Hope this ends this matter. :)
 
Last edited:
lol, so now you want to claim you were inserting straw men in your post to BS up the thread and trick me, CaveMonster, Dunstan, and Monkety Ghost into taking you at your face value?

No, I'm just claiming that you're going off on something which seems to be different from what I have been talking about.

If that was the case then why did you respond again about it, seriously to Monketey Ghost? Why didn't you just say haha got you? Instead you seriously responded to him and tried to clarify your point:

Because I was enaging in serious conversation and clarifying my points is part of that?

Sorry, but it just doesn't wash. It's alright to be wrong sometimes and admit it you know. We are all humans, not Gods. :) Have a good night.

I'm wrong about what you were saying? Quite possibly. It looked like you were saying that it was reasonable for Watson to be prudent/uncomfortable about going off with a strange man and that was what she was conveying in her statement. But if you say you meant something else, who am I to argue?

I'm wrong about what I was saying? I hope not. That would be kinda weird (but on the other hand, kinda interesting).

Anyways, I'm sure I'm wrong about something (unless I'm wrong about that), if that helps.

Linda
 
So we can see here clearly that a lot of straw men were being thrown at her. Her point wasn't about guys picking up girls in general, but in that manner.

It wasn't about sexualization in general, but specifically in that manner.

It wasn't about misogamy in general, but sexualizing in that manner.

So all these straw man refutations of her point have to be thrown out, by her own words.

I'm not questioning that, at all. There is one assertion that remains and is not a straw men, and that is that she addressed "guys" in general, even though the original vlog was very much of the "one bad apple" variety. This does have some meaning, which I could argue is that if the evidence is that this behavior is rare, then a shotgun approach is probably suboptimal.

Still, you are right. It doesn't support any of these ideas that you have listed.

As an aside, I hope you mean "misogyny" rather than "misogamy." I'm a misogamist, though it would probably be more accurate to say that I'm a mismonogamist. At least, I don't like marriage, but I dislike monogamy more than polygamy. I'm not a misogynist, and if I were, I probably wouldn't be able to tolerate being poly.

As far as the danger being felt - she said this herself in the comment trail for the video not soon after. I don't think she or anybody forgets uncomfortable events that quickly, and I don't think she was lying, due to I know that she talked previously about getting rape threats. And so it's easy for me to believe this is never far from her mind.

See, this is my problem.

Person A criticizes Watson. She therefore applies what Watson subsequently said. She says that Watson really meant "objectification" when she said "sexualization," which is a much stronger and more condemning word, to make it look that Watson was saying something stronger. (This has happened in this thread, and it involved straw men of me, but I won't name names because it was much earlier and I don't want another pointless derail.)

Person B defends Watson. He therefore applies what Watson subsequently said. He says that Watson was really afraid of assault, to make it look that Watson was saying something more defensible.

How can I tell the difference, such that I am compelled to conclude that A has more basis in fact than B, or vice versa? All I can see is that in both cases, mapping what Watson said later onto what Watson said earlier is tactically similar, given the positions. It seems pretty ad hoc to me.

You introduce the idea that B is more real than A because of what Watson previously said about sexism and rape and so on and so forth. This doesn't help me, though, because someone could (and people have) pointed out additional things that Watson has said that were about sexualization, and the fact that she has flagrantly used sexualization to promote herself.

But don't accuse me of making a straw man just yet. There's one thing that you did report that merits attention: in that manner (your bold). OK, but in what matter?

Watson gave us three data: in an elevator, at 4 AM, after the bar, and in a "foreign country."

Well, "in an elevator" doesn't mean much. Watson goes to a lot of conferences. They involve hotels and elevators, and I'm sure a lot happens in those elevators, including women carrying Watson-approved two-foot "angry vaginas," which I guess could make nobody feel uncomfortable.

"4 AM" and "after the bar" also don't mean much. That's where Watson is.

So that leaves "foreign country." Well, is being in Ireland really a lot more "foreign" than being in Las Vegas after the body shots at the Bordello party? Is it really a lot more dangerous? Is this obvious to people? I don't want to have this come down to the idea that the Irish are all green and short and talk like James Joyce.

But I totally agree with you: I wish she had handled her response to McGraw, etc. better. And I wish she had eplained the incident and her feelings about it better using better words. That indeed would have thwarted a lot of the negative feedback.

I wouldn't even go that far. I'm really terrible at telling people what they should do, let alone what they should have done.

But she did it the way she did it, and my point is that is what people are reacting to. The only reason that most people talk about the original incident at all is that there is a small minority who only talk about that, and so it gets talked about. I think I understand why they do this: there is an obvious sophistic advantage to divert attention away from what people really object to in order to paint a picture of the bad penis-weilders oppressing poor Rebecca Watson.
 
I'm not questioning that, at all. There is one assertion that remains and is not a straw men, and that is that she addressed "guys" in general, even though the original vlog was very much of the "one bad apple" variety. This does have some meaning, which I could argue is that if the evidence is that this behavior is rare, then a shotgun approach is probably suboptimal.

Still, you are right. It doesn't support any of these ideas that you have listed.

As an aside, I hope you mean "misogyny" rather than "misogamy." I'm a misogamist, though it would probably be more accurate to say that I'm a mismonogamist. At least, I don't like marriage, but I dislike monogamy more than polygamy. I'm not a misogynist, and if I were, I probably wouldn't be able to tolerate being poly.



See, this is my problem.

Person A criticizes Watson. She therefore applies what Watson subsequently said. She says that Watson really meant "objectification" when she said "sexualization," which is a much stronger and more condemning word, to make it look that Watson was saying something stronger. (This has happened in this thread, and it involved straw men of me, but I won't name names because it was much earlier and I don't want another pointless derail.)

Person B defends Watson. He therefore applies what Watson subsequently said. He says that Watson was really afraid of assault, to make it look that Watson was saying something more defensible.

How can I tell the difference, such that I am compelled to conclude that A has more basis in fact than B, or vice versa? All I can see is that in both cases, mapping what Watson said later onto what Watson said earlier is tactically similar, given the positions. It seems pretty ad hoc to me.

You introduce the idea that B is more real than A because of what Watson previously said about sexism and rape and so on and so forth. This doesn't help me, though, because someone could (and people have) pointed out additional things that Watson has said that were about sexualization, and the fact that she has flagrantly used sexualization to promote herself.

But don't accuse me of making a straw man just yet. There's one thing that you did report that merits attention: in that manner (your bold). OK, but in what matter?

Watson gave us three data: in an elevator, at 4 AM, after the bar, and in a "foreign country."

Well, "in an elevator" doesn't mean much. Watson goes to a lot of conferences. They involve hotels and elevators, and I'm sure a lot happens in those elevators, including women carrying Watson-approved two-foot "angry vaginas," which I guess could make nobody feel uncomfortable.

"4 AM" and "after the bar" also don't mean much. That's where Watson is.

So that leaves "foreign country." Well, is being in Ireland really a lot more "foreign" than being in Las Vegas after the body shots at the Bordello party? Is it really a lot more dangerous? Is this obvious to people? I don't want to have this come down to the idea that the Irish are all green and short and talk like James Joyce.



I wouldn't even go that far. I'm really terrible at telling people what they should do, let alone what they should have done.

But she did it the way she did it, and my point is that is what people are reacting to. The only reason that most people talk about the original incident at all is that there is a small minority who only talk about that, and so it gets talked about. I think I understand why they do this: there is an obvious sophistic advantage to divert attention away from what people really object to in order to paint a picture of the bad penis-weilders oppressing poor Rebecca Watson.

haha lol Sorry, I was wrong. I did mean misogyny. I agree with you about the term sexualization. Is liking to see nude woman sexualization? It's confusing.

I have to disagree with "bad penis-wielders" (I hope you meant wielders lol)

She didn't say that.

She said "don't sexualize me in that manner" meaning in that particular manner she stated earlier. So I must call straw man to those who say that

So what was the manner she specified, and remember it is the accumulation of these elements that make up the manner, not any one particular one.

So elements of the manner that makes her feel uncomfortable accumulatively were:

1. 4 am
2. in an elevator
3. "with you, just you" meaning being alone with you a stranger.

So "don't sexualize me in that manner" means where manner is 1+2+3 =
Alone with stranger man in an elevator at 4am. So that is the essential manner of sexualizing that she finds uncomfortable which seems reasonable. And that is the only manner of sexualizing that she is referring to.

We can't pull one element out and say that is the manner she was referring to. It is the accumulation of the elements that defines the manner. (She did add some others that are not necessary; but it would be splitting hairs to add them. She was just winging it.) But the above mentioned elements of the manner of sexualizing are understandable and it's reasonable to understand her discomfort with this manner.

As far as the danger felt that is from a quote she said recently after the event, not something I made up. But maybe I am wrong about how to interpret it. And she could be for other types of sexualization, but not in that manner.
 
Last edited:
It looked like you were saying that it was reasonable for Watson to be prudent/uncomfortable about going off with a strange man and that was what she was conveying in her statement. Linda

bold mine.

Uh oh. I have to call straw man on you again. I nor Watson ever said that. That set could include going off with a strange man who is a firefighter in a burning building. I or she never said that. That would be ridiculous.

She said "don't sexualize me in that manner" meaning in that particular manner she stated earlier. So I must call straw man on you. You see?

So what was the manner she specified, and remember it is the accumulation of these elements that make up the manner, not any one particular one.

So elements of the manner that makes her feel uncomfortable accumulatively were:

1. 4 am
2. in an elevator
3. "with you, just you" meaning being alone with you a stranger

So "don't sexualize me in that manner" means where manner is 1+2+3 =
Alone with a stranger in an elevator at 4am. So that is the essential manner of sexualizing that she finds uncomfortable which seems reasonable. And that is the only manner of sexualizing that she is referring to.
 
Last edited:
For one thing she presumes to speak for every woman. She presumes that because she perceived sexualization that it was de facto sexualiztion. She doesn't say, "look, I would recommend that men not do that". She says "don't do that". A bit of humility would be nice.

Oh, come on. She was expression her own view after the incident. She was giving advice to people based on her experience. She wasn't declaring anybody who would do it regardless should be shot.

Also, about "EG doing nothing wrong" -- yes, he DID do something wrong. He made her feel uncomfortable and unsafe with a sexual come-on to a perfect stranger at 4AM in an elevator. That's wrong, duh. We all agree it's far more likely EG is a blundering man with no social skills rather than a would-be serial rapist. But nobody says he's a serial rapist!
 
It just occured to me that EG might not have even been consciously sexualizing RW. Some inexperienced men have a very "logical" -- but absurd in the real world -- way of thinking about how to approach women.

It might well be EG, to judge from his blundering approach, was thinking all week what he would say to RW if they get a moment alone. Naturally he could not imagine how to ever achieve this incredible goal of finding a minute to be alone with a woman he likes on his own. Naturally, the possiblity of going to RW and ASKING her to speak to her privately probably never occurred to him, or else he considered it beyond his abilities.

But this didn't stop him from fantasizing. What does one DO when one is attracted to a woman, if by chance this rare beast is somehow cornered? Why, in all those Hollywood movies he tells her how attracted he is to her and she smiles and accepts him. It must work like that in real life, too!

So when he found RW in an elevator at 4 AM, he couldn't believe his luck. Clearly, the fates had determined that they want him to be alone with her -- and they ARE alone in that elevator at 4 in the morning, aren't they? Clearly, a perfectly appropriate situation, since the movies never seem to mention any other preconditions except for the two being alone. Naturally he used his one-and-only chance to fire his one-and-only known pick-up line.

Why she reacted like she did, I am sure he to this day does not understand: he did everything right, just like in the movies, didn't he?
 
Last edited:
Oh, come on. She was expression her own view after the incident. She was giving advice to people based on her experience. She wasn't declaring anybody who would do it regardless should be shot.

Also, about "EG doing nothing wrong" -- yes, he DID do something wrong. He made her feel uncomfortable and unsafe with a sexual come-on to a perfect stranger at 4AM in an elevator. That's wrong, duh. We all agree it's far more likely EG is a blundering man with no social skills rather than a would-be serial rapist. But nobody says he's a serial rapist!
Because asserting something with "oh come on" is some kind of magic rhetoric. Sorry, no. You can't read his mind and you were not there. If you wanted to state it was likely that would be one thing, This is another and completely different.

But you are entitled to an opinion, something you and RW don't feel others are entitled to.
 
It just occured to me that EG might not have even been consciously sexualizing RW. Some inexperienced men have a very "logical" -- but absurd in the real world -- way of thinking about how to approach women.

It might well be EG, to judge from his blundering approach, was thinking all week what he would say to RW if they get a moment alone. Naturally he could not imagine how to ever achieve this incredible goal of finding a minute to be alone with a woman he likes on his own. Naturally, the possiblity of going to RW and ASKING her to speak to her privately probably never occurred to him, or else he considered it beyond his abilities.

But this didn't stop him from fantasizing. What does one DO when one is attracted to a woman, if by chance this rare beast is somehow cornered? Why, in all those Hollywood movies he tells her how attracted he is to her and she smiles and accepts him. It must work like that in real life, too!

So when he found RW in an elevator at 4 AM, he couldn't believe his luck. Clearly, the fates had determined that they want him to be alone with her -- and they ARE alone in that elevator at 4 in the morning, aren't they? Clearly, a perfectly appropriate situation, since the movies never seem to mention any other preconditions except for the two being alone. Naturally he used his one-and-only chance to fire his one-and-only known pick-up line.

Why she reacted like she did, I am sure he to this day does not understand: he did everything right, just like in the movies, didn't he?
You have a gift my friend, You should try out for Randi's $1,000,000 challenge with those abilities, I'm curious, how do you control for bias? Or do you just brow beat everyone because you must be right and it doesn't matter.
 
This argument has been tried and didn't manage to convince a lot of people.

Frankly, the later revelation that EG was in his mid-50s makes me think that he really did just want to talk. Young men can get confused or be shy or awkward or whatever, but by the time of the half century mark, most men either:

1) Have really figured out how to interact with women, in which case they don't do such clumsy approaches in the first place and also know that they can do a lot better than Rebecca Watson, or

2) Really haven't figured out how to interact with women, in which case they'd probably be too scared to follow Watson into the elevator in the first place.

Plus, if a man did have non-sexual attentions, then he wouldn't think of such a behavior as creepy.

Thank you for seriously clearing this up, I now have a different understanding of the issue. Note, that nowhere in the video did she mention any of this. I had assumed that he was a scared kid in his 20s. These are the types of things she needs to divulge in the video. She needed to put more details that would help us understand how weird or creepy the situation was. And more over, she should've demonstrated how he sexualized her. I have no problem with the fact she made this assumption, but originally based on her words; she gave almost no conclusive evidence as to how the event went down. And therefore, everyone had the right to be skeptical of her allegations.
 
It just occured to me that EG might not have even been consciously sexualizing RW. Some inexperienced men have a very "logical" -- but absurd in the real world -- way of thinking about how to approach women.

It might well be EG, to judge from his blundering approach, was thinking all week what he would say to RW if they get a moment alone. Naturally he could not imagine how to ever achieve this incredible goal of finding a minute to be alone with a woman he likes on his own. Naturally, the possiblity of going to RW and ASKING her to speak to her privately probably never occurred to him, or else he considered it beyond his abilities.

But this didn't stop him from fantasizing. What does one DO when one is attracted to a woman, if by chance this rare beast is somehow cornered? Why, in all those Hollywood movies he tells her how attracted he is to her and she smiles and accepts him. It must work like that in real life, too!

So when he found RW in an elevator at 4 AM, he couldn't believe his luck. Clearly, the fates had determined that they want him to be alone with her -- and they ARE alone in that elevator at 4 in the morning, aren't they? Clearly, a perfectly appropriate situation, since the movies never seem to mention any other preconditions except for the two being alone. Naturally he used his one-and-only chance to fire his one-and-only known pick-up line.

Why she reacted like she did, I am sure he to this day does not understand: he did everything right, just like in the movies, didn't he?

Based on what I know now I doubt he wasn't trying to take her back to his place to beat it up. The question is can she demonstrate how he did it? Or at least make a (non-revealing) video blog on the situation to clear it up. If so I'm inclined to believe her allegations.
 
I have to disagree with "bad penis-wielders" (I hope you meant wielders lol)

She didn't say that.

No, Watson didn't say that. I'm sorry if I gave the impression that I was accusing her of this. That's a rather snarky comment about what others have said.

So elements of the manner that makes her feel uncomfortable accumulatively were:

1. 4 am
2. in an elevator
3. "with you, just you" meaning being alone with you a stranger.

So "don't sexualize me in that manner" means where manner is 1+2+3 =
Alone with stranger man in an elevator at 4am. So that is the essential manner of sexualizing that she finds uncomfortable which seems reasonable. And that is the only manner of sexualizing that she is referring to.

Sorry, but switching it to accumulative doesn't really help, though it's been tried. We could play the accumulative game with other thing's too:

1) Buttons about coming on my face.
2) "In my pants" T-shirts.
3) Bordello parties with body shots.
4) Drunk chicks hitting on geek guys.

Etc. and so forth and so on. All of which could as easily be presented as accumulating to the reasonable impression "it's safe to hit on Rebecca Watson even in extreme circumstances that most women wouldn't put up with, without being called out, even anonymously."

Please note that I'm not arguing for this interpretation or even claiming that it's better supported. What I am saying is that I haven't seen any logical or skeptical reason why one interpretation should be preferred over another.

Now, I'd be just as happy if you could come up with one, because that would involve information.

As far as the danger felt that is from a quote she said recently after the event, not something I made up. But maybe I am wrong about how to interpret it. And she could be for other types of sexualization, but not in that manner.

This still doesn't help me understand what that manner is. I mean, surely, I think that we can all agree that EG wasn't a smooth Rule 10 Violation, but beyond that, what, really?
 
bold mine.

Uh oh. I have to call straw man on you again. I nor Watson ever said that. That set could include going off with a strange man who is a firefighter in a burning building. I or she never said that. That would be ridiculous.

I was attempting to briefly re-state what you said. Of course, it would be ridiculous to take a statement about what you have been saying and apply it to something entirely unrelated.

She said "don't sexualize me in that manner" meaning in that particular manner she stated earlier. So I must call straw man on you. You see?

So what was the manner she specified, and remember it is the accumulation of these elements that make up the manner, not any one particular one.

So elements of the manner that makes her feel uncomfortable accumulatively were:

1. 4 am
2. in an elevator
3. "with you, just you" meaning being alone with you a stranger

So "don't sexualize me in that manner" means where manner is 1+2+3 =
Alone with a stranger in an elevator at 4am. So that is the essential manner of sexualizing that she finds uncomfortable which seems reasonable. And that is the only manner of sexualizing that she is referring to.

I agree that Watson also talked about being made uncomfortable by sexualization.

My statement was referring to your earlier statement (the one that prompted this exchange) that your point all along (and the only point you wanted to make) is that Watson can be commended for her good judgement (for not accepting an invite to a hotel room by a stranger). And then the statement you quoted from Watson with respect to the idea of danger ("But regardless, the point I was making was that people need to be aware of how their comments might make someone feel extraordinarily uncomfortable and even feel as though they are in danger.") which you suggested was relevant to your statement about showing good judgement. My statement was simply an attempt to briefly refer to all that.

Linda
 
In the end it doesn't wash. I could simply dismiss the opinions of women because, well, they are women. Only theists could analyse the arguments and claims of theists and non Mormon's would have to keep silent about issues related to Mormonism. Either an argument is logically valid or it is not. Otherwise you are special pleading.

Do you have the capacity to evaluate the validity of an argument or does your gender prevent that?

It doesn't have to be gender specific. Sometimes people can overlook the objections of others, simply because they have not experienced that particular situation. Are you honestly saying that lack of experience has never led you to be wrong on the minor details of someone else's complaint? There are sayings for this, it's not unusual; never judge a person until you've walked a mile in their shoes; or the opposite, the grass is always greener. There's what we think we know about other people and then there's what's real about other people, those two are not always parallel.
 
It doesn't have to be gender specific. Sometimes people can overlook the objections of others, simply because they have not experienced that particular situation. Are you honestly saying that lack of experience has never led you to be wrong on the minor details of someone else's complaint? There are sayings for this, it's not unusual; never judge a person until you've walked a mile in their shoes; or the opposite, the grass is always greener. There's what we think we know about other people and then there's what's real about other people, those two are not always parallel.
In the end an argument is either valid or it is not. Men are capable of evaluating arguments, Even if I lack the experience to understand a situation I can evaluate the argument given certain premises. In the end it's fallacy. The arguments by Dawkins' must stand on their own. Interestingly enough RW then dismisses arguments by women, they just lack RW's experience. Again, theists can just as easily dismiss atheists. Men have no say in the abortion debate. Non Americans cannot criticize American policy. Dems cannot criticize Republican policy. We can always find a reason to dismiss out of hand our opponents. It's called ad hominem.

I understand your point. The key is to formulate arguments that are valid regardless of gender.
 
Interesting, I am left wondering why there were so many pages justifying and criticizing RW for not appreciating that approach. That must have been my imagination. However, RW posts a short personal anecdote, which incites a few people to post comments of their own, the one that stands out in my opinion is McGraw's hyperbole, which deserved to be challenged. I fail to see how:
Um, just a word to wise here, guys, uh, don't do that. You know, I don't really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I'll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4:00 am, in a hotel elevator, with you, just you, and--don't invite me back to your hotel room right after I finish talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner..."
...equates to demonizing men for being sexual beings? What exactly is it about her stating a specific way she does not like being approached that inspired anyone to not only blog about it, but to call her out on things she didn't express. It was other people making a big deal over it that caused it to snowball.
So you don't think RW's comments about McGraw were wrong then?
RW on Skepchick said:
I hear a lot of misogyny from skeptics and atheists, but when ancient anti-woman rhetoric like the above is repeated verbatim by a young woman online, it validates that misogyny in a way that goes above and beyond the validation those men get from one another. It also negatively affects the women who are nervous about being in similar situations. Some of them have been raped or otherwise sexually assaulted, and some just don’t want to be put in that position. And they read these posts and watch these videos and they think, “If something were to happen to me and these women won’t stand up for me, who will?”

Did you ever read McGraw's comments? And you think saying EG didn't seem that bad was hyperbole?
 
In the end an argument is either valid or it is not. Men are capable of evaluating arguments, Even if I lack the experience to understand a situation I can evaluate the argument given certain premises. In the end it's fallacy. The arguments by Dawkins' must stand on their own. Interestingly enough RW then dismisses arguments by women, they just lack RW's experience. Again, theists can just as easily dismiss atheists. Men have no say in the abortion debate. Non Americans cannot criticize American policy. Dems cannot criticize Republican policy. We can always find a reason to dismiss out of hand our opponents. It's called ad hominem.

I understand your point. The key is to formulate arguments that are valid regardless of gender.

The ad hom, in itself, cannot tear down the opponents argument, but if the ad hom is a legitimate questioning as to the perspective of the opponent and not just an attack on the opponent, it is acceptable, even in debates. Which is why I said she had a point, not that she made a valid argument. I really do feel that there is a difference between being made uncomfortable by someone else's attention being directed at you and someone's oblivious existence annoying you. If she had followed through on that aspect of it, I think she could have formulated a much better argument.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom